MZYXP v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection

Link copied
Case Copied 64 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

MZYXP v Minister for Immigration & Border Protection [2013] FCA 1352

Citation: MZYXP v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2013] FCA 1352
Appeal from: MZYXP v Minister for Immigration & Anor [2012] FMCA 960
Parties: MZYXP v MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND BORDER PROTECTION and REFUGEE REVIEW TRIBUNAL
File number: VID 909 of 2012
Judge: KENNY J
Date of judgment: 12 December 2013
Catchwords: MIGRATION – Appeal from decision of Federal Magistrate upholding decision of the Refugee Review Tribunal to refuse a protection visa – No jurisdictional error disclosed – Appeal dismissed
Legislation: Migration Act 1958 (Cth)
Convention relating to the Status of Refugees (done at Geneva on 28 July 1951, 189 UNTS 137)
Protocol relating to the Status of Refugees (done at New York on 31 January 1967, 606 UNTS 267)
Cases cited: SZMCD v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship (2009) 174 FCR 415
Randhawav Minister for Immigration, Local Government and Ethnic Affairs (1994) 52 FCR 437
Plaintiff M13/2011 v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship (2011) 277 ALR 667
NAHI v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2004] FCAFC 10
Hot Holdings Pty Ltd v Creasy (2002) 210 CLR 438 SZFDE v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship (2007) 232 CLR 189
Muin v Refugee Review Tribunal & Ors (2002) 190 ALR 601
Lie v Refugee Review Tribunal & Ors (2002) 190 ALR 601
SZATV v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship (2007) 233 CLR 18
NAIZ v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs and Indigenous Affairs [2005] FCAFC 37
Franco-Buitrago v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (2000) FCA 1525
Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs v Wu Shan Liang (1996) 185 CLR 259
Abebe v Commonwealth of Australia (1999) 197 CLR 510
Lee v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2005] FCA 464
Tefonu Pty Ltd v Insurance and Superannuation Commissioner (1993) 44 FCR 361
SZJTQ v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship (2008) 172 FCR 563
Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v MZYTS [2013] FCAFC 114
Re Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs; Ex parte Durairajasingham (2000) 58 ALD 609
SZQFS v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2011] FCA 1244
Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs v SCAR (2003) 128 FCR 553
Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v SZNVW (2010) 183 FCR 575
SZQFS v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2011] FCA 1244
Kioa v West (1985) 159 CLR 550
Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Cho (1999) 92 FCR 315
Dranichnikov v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (2003) 197 ALR 389
SZBEL v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs (2006) CLR 152
Date of hearing: 26 March 2013
Date of last submissions: 24 April 2013
Place: Melbourne
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 128
The Appellant appeared in person with the assistance of an interpreter
Counsel for the First Respondent: W Mosley
Solicitor for First the Respondent: Sparke Helmore
The second respondent submitted to any order the Court might have,…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read MZYXP v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] FCA 1352
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appellant, a citizen of Pakistan, appealed against the decision of the Federal Magistrate who upheld the Refugee Review Tribunal's (RRT) refusal to grant him a protection visa. The appellant had arrived in Australia in 2008 on a student visa and applied for a protection visa in 2010, claiming he faced persecution by militant extremist groups due to his liberal values, family connections to the Pakistani army, and his mother’s previous work. The Tribunal reviewed the appellant's claims and documentary evidence, but ultimately affirmed the delegate's decision to refuse the visa, concluding that the appellant could reasonably relocate within Pakistan.

The court was required to decide whether the Tribunal's decision was legally sound, particularly whether the Tribunal had properly considered the appellant's objections to relocation and if it had erred in law. The appellant argued that the Tribunal had not adequately considered his objections to relocating within Pakistan, particularly his financial constraints and the impracticality of such relocation given his familial responsibilities. The court found that the Tribunal had not only considered these objections but had also provided detailed reasoning for rejecting them, concluding that relocation was reasonable in the circumstances. The court found no jurisdictional error in the Tribunal's decision and held that the Tribunal had appropriately exercised its discretion.

In light of the above, the court dismissed the appeal and ordered that the costs of the appeal be paid by the appellant to the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection. The court also amended the title of the first respondent to reflect the current ministerial designation.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The title of the first respondent to this appeal be amended from Minister for Immigration and Citizenship to Minister for Immigration and Border Protection.

2. The appeal be dismissed.

3. The appellant pay the first respondent’s costs of the appeal.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons stated below, I would dismiss the appeal.BACKGROUND The following facts are derived from the Tribunal’s statement of reasons. The appellant is a citizen of Pakistan. He arrived in Australia in July 2008 as the holder of a Student (Class TU subclass 572) visa. He applied for a protection visa in September 2010. In his protection visa application, which was supported by various documents, the appellant indicated that he had left Pakistan to pursue a ‘Western’ education and that he feared persecution by militant extremist groups, such as the Taliban, if he were to return. The appellant claimed that, by reason of his and his family’s liberal values and connection to the army, he feared being tortured or killed in a show of strength by a militant extremist group, or being forced to join such a group against his will. The appellant said that his liberal values and earlier study at a military college would make him a target wherever he lived in Pakistan. The appellant also said that terrorist organisations were aware of the nature of some of his mother’s previous work; and that he feared that, to hurt her, these groups might kill him. In this regard, he said that his mother had already received threats of violence against him. The appellant said that the authorities in Pakistan would be unable to protect him. On 28 June 2011, the appellant was interviewed by a delegate of the Minister (‘the delegate’). The appellant provided documentary evidence, including evidence in support of a further claim concerning extremist responses to his mother’s employment. On 5 July 2011, the delegate decided to refuse to grant the appellant a protection visa. The appellant applied to the Tribunal for a review of this decision on 22 July 2011.THE TRIBUNAL DECISION The appellant appeared before the Tribunal in January 2012, where he was assisted by a migration agent and an interpreter. At the Tribunal hearing, the appellant provided a number of media reports and internet articles in support of his claims. Following the hearing, his migration agent made further submissions in an email to the Tribunal, and attached further media reports and internet articles. Before the Tribunal, the appellant confirmed that everything he had stated in his application and in his interview with the delegate was true. The appellant claimed that his family was vocal in its support of the Government of Pakistan, condemned the Taliban and advocated women’s education openly. He indicated that his deceased father and relatives had served, or were serving, in the Pakistani army. The appellant stated that his mother had received telephone calls from people threatening to harm him if he returned, unless she ceased working and remained indoors. He added that, whenever he travelled outside the army cantonment in which he lived in Pakistan, he was accompanied by a military guard in civilian dress arranged by one of his brothers-in-law. He claimed that a neighbour’s son had been abducted and killed and that bombings had occurred near his family home, including one at a near-by bakery. He also claimed that, when he was preparing for his military entrance exam, two men had approached the gatekeeper at his hostel and asked questions about him.

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 5 July 2011, the delegate decided to refuse to grant the appellant a protection visa. The appellant applied to the Tribunal for a review of this decision on 22 July 2011.THE TRIBUNAL DECISION The appellant appeared before the Tribunal in January 2012, where he was assisted by a migration agent and an interpreter. At the Tribunal hearing, the appellant provided a number of media reports and internet articles in support of his claims. Following the hearing, his migration agent made further submissions in an email to the Tribunal, and attached further media reports and internet articles. Before the Tribunal, the appellant confirmed that everything he had stated in his application and in his interview with the delegate was true. The appellant claimed that his family was vocal in its support of the Government of Pakistan, condemned the Taliban and advocated women’s education openly. He indicated that his deceased father and relatives had served, or were serving, in the Pakistani army. The appellant stated that his mother had received telephone calls from people threatening to harm him if he returned, unless she ceased working and remained indoors. He added that, whenever he travelled outside the army cantonment in which he lived in Pakistan, he was accompanied by a military guard in civilian dress arranged by one of his brothers-in-law. He claimed that a neighbour’s son had been abducted and killed and that bombings had occurred near his family home, including one at a near-by bakery. He also claimed that, when he was preparing for his military entrance exam, two men had approached the gatekeeper at his hostel and asked questions about him. The Tribunal questioned the appellant about various aspects of his claims. Among other matters, the Tribunal asked why he had delayed in applying for a protection visa after reaching Australia; why the two men had not tried to contact him at his home in the 14 months prior to his departure for Australia; why a letter from the army school, which the appellant provided, was not on letterhead and did not name the author; and whether it was reasonable for the appellant to relocate elsewhere in Pakistan. On 22 March 2012, the Tribunal decided to affirm the delegate’s decision. It notified the appellant’s migration agent of this decision the following day. The Tribunal accepted that “members of the family of members of the army”, “individuals who have been educated at army schools” and “individuals who have resided and been educated in Western countries” were each distinct social groups, identifiable by a common characteristic beyond any shared fear of persecution; and that the appellant was a member of each of these groups. The Tribunal did not accept that “membership of a wealthy family” amounted to membership of a particular social group. The Tribunal largely accepted the appellant’s evidence about his circumstances before coming to Australia, including his residence in army cantonments and his family’s connections to the Pakistani army. Despite concerns about the authenticity and impartiality of some documentary evidence provided by the appellant, the Tribunal accepted that the appellant’s mother’s employment at a school had become a source of controversy until she was forced to resign as a result of threats from extremist militant groups. The Tribunal also accepted that his mother received a letter threatening to harm her and the appellant if she did not change her lifestyle and that she was present at the bombing, referred to above, at a local bakery.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Likewise, in Franco-Buitrago, Tamberlin J held (at [17]) that:[I]n reaching a conclusion on this question the RRT must not fall into an error of law by excluding from consideration matters which are central to a determination of that issue. The reasoning in Randhawa makes it clear that the circumstances to be taken into account are wide ranging, with strong emphasis on the practical realities of an applicant's position such that the cultural problems of relocation can be taken into account. In the present case the issue of Juan's health was specifically raised by the applicant as a matter for consideration. The medical condition of the child could reasonably be considered to bear on the question whether relocation is reasonable, or feasible in a practical sense. For example, it may be considered that it is not reasonable to expect the family to relocate in a “safe area” remote from those medical and hospital services and facilities for Juan which are normally found in a large city. The need for medical treatment for the child may also require the parents to visit Pereira where they could experience a real danger of persecution. These practical considerations arising from the child's predicament could limit the number and type of places suitable for relocation and carry weight in determining the question whether relocation in the country is reasonable in the circumstances of any particular case.(Emphasis added) The Tribunal considered and rejected the appellant’s objections to relocation (as stated both at the hearing and in post-hearing submissions) in more than a “summary way”. The Tribunal detailed the appellant’s objections in its statement of reasons ([85]-[91], [99]). It considered and rejected them ([138]-[143]), as it was open to the Tribunal to do. The appellant’s objections were variously that:·The Taliban were “everywhere” and that it would be easy for them to trace someone like him anywhere in Pakistan (at [85]). ·Even if he lived outside an army cantonment his social circle was made up of military people and he would, as a result, remain identifiable as supporting the military (at [85]). ·He would always remain connected to the army and that army families do not live outside cantonments because it is too dangerous (at [87]) and that all military families and all cantonments are under threat, such that it is only “luck if people are not harmed” (at [86]). ·If he had to go and live in another part of Pakistan while outside an army cantonment he would have to take his mother with him. This presented numerous practical difficulties for him including that he did not have the financial resources to buy a house for himself and his mother, and that the family property was tied up in the army cantonments (at [88]). His migration agent later also submitted that, since the appellant was his mother’s only son, he would be expected to look after her on his return; and that this meant that, given his poor financial situation, his proximity to his mother needed to be taken into account in assessing the reasonableness of relocation (at [91]). ·He would be easily identified as being westernised and did not want to change his life to appear otherwise (at [88]).·He was at risk of harm because he would be assumed to be financially well off because he had been westernised and living in a Western country for several years (at [91]).·He lacked the qualifications and financial resources to be able to relocate to any other part of Pakistan (at [99]).