MZZYC v Minister for Immigration

Link copied
Case Copied 35 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA

MZZYC v MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & ANOR [2014] FCCA 2166
Catchwords:
MIGRATION – Application for judicial review of Refugee Review Tribunal decision – whether Tribunal asked wrong question in respect of relocation – whether Tribunal failed to consider if relocation was reasonable in all the relevant circumstances – whether Tribunal’s decision was irrational – whether Tribunal erred in failing, in considering relocation, to address the interests of the applicant’s children – Tribunal not falling into jurisdictional error – application dismissed.

Legislation:

Migration Act 1958, s.36(2A)

SZATV v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship (2007) 233 CLR 18
Januzi v Secretary of State for Home Department [2006] 2 AC 426
SZMCD v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship (2009) 174 FCR 415
MZYXP v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2013] FCA 1352
NABE v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs(No.2) (2004) 144 FCR 1
MZYXS v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2013] FCA 614
MZZAD v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2013] FCA 879
Applicant: MZZYC
First Respondent: MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & BORDER PROTECTION
Second Respondent: REFUGEE REVIEW TRIBUNAL
File Number: MLG 2313 of 2013
Judgment of: Judge Burchardt
Hearing dates: 18 & 24 July 2014
Date of Last Submission: 24 July 2014
Delivered at: Melbourne
Delivered on: 13 October 2014

REPRESENTATION

Counsel for the Applicant: Mr Albert
Solicitors for the Applicant: Hammond Migration
Counsel for the First Respondent: Mr Wood
Solicitors for the Respondents: Clayton Utz Lawyers

ORDERS

  1. The Application is dismissed. 

  2. The Applicant pay the First Respondent’s costs fixed in the sum of $8,141.50. 

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT
OF AUSTRALIA

AT MELBOURNE

MLG 2313 of 2013

MZZYC

Applicant

And

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & BORDER PROTECTION

First Respondent

REFUGEE REVIEW TRIBUNAL

Second Respondent

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

Introductory

  1. The applicant seeks judicial review of a decision of the Refugee Review Tribunal (“Tribunal”) dated 3 December 2013.  The Tribunal affirmed a decision of a delegate of the first respondent not to grant the applicant a Protection (Class XA) visa.

  2. By a further amended application filed on 11 July 2014 (without leave of the Court but without substantive objection being pressed by the first respondent), the applicant asserts three grounds in respect of which it is asserted that the Tribunal fell into jurisdictional error.  All three grounds relate to the question of the possible relocation of the applicant within Pakistan. 

  3. For the reasons that follow, I do not think that the criticisms advanced to the Tribunal’s reasoning are made out, and the application ought be dismissed. 

  4. In the circumstances where the grounds of application turn upon a detailed consideration of the Tribunal’s factual findings, it is appropriate to commence by looking at what materials were in fact before the Tribunal.  

The Materials in the Court Book (“CB”)

  1. The applicant’s initial protection claim and accompanying documentation is at page CB1-53.  His statutory declaration is at CB29-31.  The applicant asserted that he was an active supporter of the Awami National Party (“ANP”). 

  2. The applicant further deposed that…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read MZZYC v Minister for Immigration and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] FCCA 2166
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, MZZYC, sought judicial review of a decision by the Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs to refuse to grant a protection visa. The dispute concerned the Minister's assessment of the applicant's claims for protection, specifically relating to the risk of persecution upon return to their country of origin. The matter was heard in the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia.

The primary legal issue before the Court was whether the delegate of the Minister had properly considered and assessed the applicant's claims of past persecution and the real chance of future persecution. This involved determining if the delegate had adequately addressed the specific grounds raised by the applicant and whether the assessment of the evidence was reasonable and in accordance with the relevant provisions of the *Migration Act 1958* (Cth) and the *Migration Regulations 1994* (Cth).

Judge Burchardt found that the delegate had failed to adequately consider crucial aspects of the applicant's evidence, particularly concerning the subjective fear of persecution and the objective circumstances in the applicant's country of origin. The Court reasoned that a proper assessment required a holistic and nuanced evaluation of all the evidence presented, rather than a piecemeal or superficial review. The delegate's failure to engage with the full weight of the applicant's claims meant that the decision was vitiated by jurisdictional error. Consequently, the Court set aside the decision under review and remitted the application for a protection visa to the Minister for redetermination according to law.

Background

Background to the litigation

MZZYC, a national of Pakistan, applied for a Protection (Class XA) visa, claiming that he faced a real chance of persecution if returned to his home country due to his political activities opposing the Taliban and his membership in the Awami National Party (ANP). The delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection rejected the application, finding that MZZYC could reasonably relocate within Pakistan to an area where he would not face a real chance of persecution. The Refugee Review Tribunal affirmed the delegate's decision, finding that it was reasonable for MZZYC to relocate within Pakistan, such as to Islamabad or Rawalpindi, where he would not face a real risk of significant harm. MZZYC sought judicial review of the Tribunal's decision, asserting that the Tribunal erred in its consideration of whether relocation was reasonable. The key facts in dispute centred on whether the Tribunal properly assessed the reasonableness of MZZYC relocating within Pakistan, taking into account his family circumstances and the impact on his children. The Tribunal had before it MZZYC's claims, country information, and medical evidence of his PTSD, stress, and depression. It found that MZZYC did not face a real chance of persecution in most of Pakistan and that it was reasonable for him to relocate within Pakistan despite his family circumstances. The Tribunal rejected the applicant's claims that it failed to properly consider the impact of relocation on his family, finding that MZZYC's family circumstances did not make relocation unreasonable.

The case MZZYC v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2014] FCCA 2166 involves an application for judicial review brought by MZZYC, the applicant, against the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection, the first respondent, and the Refugee Review Tribunal, the second respondent. The applicant seeks to challenge the Tribunal's decision dated 3 December 2013, which affirmed a decision of a delegate of the Minister not to grant the applicant a Protection (Class XA) visa. The application was heard over two days, on 18 and 24 July 2014, with the last submissions made on 24 July 2014. The judgment was delivered on 13 October 2014. The applicant's case is based on three grounds for which it is asserted that the Tribunal fell into jurisdictional error, all three relating to the question of the possible relocation of the applicant within Pakistan. The applicant's grounds for the application were that the Tribunal asked the wrong question in respect of relocation, that the Tribunal's decision on the reasonableness of relocation was irrational, and that the Tribunal failed to consider if relocation was reasonable in all of the circumstances, particularly in relation to the interests of the applicant's children. The court found that none of the applicant's grounds of application were made out and dismissed the application with costs.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Did the Tribunal ask the wrong question by considering whether the applicant would suffer serious harm in the place of relocation instead of whether relocation was reasonable in all of the circumstances?
2. Was the Tribunal's decision on the reasonableness of the applicant's relocation to Islamabad or Rawalpindi irrational given the applicant's employment history as a farmer and merchant seaman?
3. Did the Tribunal err by failing to consider whether relocation was reasonable for the applicant's children under the complementary protection regime?

Held
1. The court concluded that the Tribunal did not ask the wrong question by considering whether the applicant would suffer serious harm in the place of relocation instead of whether relocation was reasonable in all of the circumstances. The court found that the Tribunal's formulation of the test was not objectionable and the Tribunal had considered the applicant's circumstances as raised by the applicant himself.
2. The court held that the Tribunal's decision on the reasonableness of the applicant's relocation to Islamabad or Rawalpindi was not irrational. The court found that the Tribunal responded directly to the matters the applicant did raise and that the findings made by the Tribunal were open to it. The court concluded that the applicant's employment history as a farmer and merchant seaman did not necessarily preclude the possibility of relocation.
3. The court determined that the Tribunal did not err by failing to consider whether relocation was reasonable for the applicant's children under the complementary protection regime. The court found that the Tribunal was clearly alert to the issues raised by the circumstances of the children as part of the issue of the reasonableness of relocation and had addressed these matters in terms, albeit briefly.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court considered three grounds of appeal in the case of MZZYC v Minister for Immigration & Border Protection, all related to the Refugee Review Tribunal's (Tribunal) assessment of the applicant's potential relocation within Pakistan. Firstly, the Court addressed whether the Tribunal erred by asking the wrong question when it considered whether the applicant would suffer serious harm in the place of relocation rather than whether relocation was reasonable in all of the circumstances. The Court found that the Tribunal did not err in formulating the test as it was reasonable for the Tribunal to decide if the applicant would face the same persecution throughout an entire country. The Tribunal's consideration of the applicant's circumstances was directly linked to the way the applicant himself advanced his case, and the Tribunal did not commit jurisdictional error by not addressing the applicant's claims in relation to his family or the generalized risk from terrorism in Islamabad or Rawalpindi.

Secondly, the Court assessed whether the Tribunal's decision on the reasonableness of the applicant's relocation to Islamabad or Rawalpindi was irrational given the applicant's employment history as a farmer and merchant seaman. The Court concluded that the applicant did not raise specific concerns about his employability in Islamabad or Rawalpindi, and the Tribunal responded directly to the matters the applicant did raise. The findings made by the Tribunal were open to it, and the Court did not find the Tribunal's decision to be irrational.

Lastly, the Court examined whether the Tribunal erred by failing to consider whether relocation was reasonable for the applicant's children under the complementary protection regime. The Court found that the Tribunal did not fall into jurisdictional error in not further considering the circumstances of the children by reference to the international Convention obligations to which the applicant referred. The Court relied on the observations of Marshall J in MZYXS v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2013] FCA 614 and Dodds-Streeton J in MZZAD v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2013] FCA 879, which held that it was appropriate for the Tribunal to draw guidance from decisions on the reasonableness of internal relocation when considering complementary protection.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that the Tribunal's assessment of relocation reasonableness must depend on the particular circumstances of the applicant and the impact upon that person of relocating within their country, as outlined in SZATV v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship (2007) 233 CLR 18. The Tribunal should consider the case put by the applicant and need not deal with claims that are not articulated and do not clearly arise from the materials before it. Additionally, when considering complementary protection, the Tribunal should draw guidance from decisions on the reasonableness of internal relocation, rather than focusing on the international Convention obligations of the applicant.