MZZYC v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

MZZYC v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2015] FCA 1426

Citation: MZZYC v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2015] FCA 1426
Appeal from: Application for extension of time: MZZYC v Minister for Immigration & Anor [2014] FCCA 2166
Parties: MZZYC v MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND BORDER PROTECTION and ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL
File number: VID 433 of 2015
Judge: DAVIES J
Date of judgment: 17 December 2015
Catchwords: MIGRATION – appeal from decision of Federal Circuit Court of Australia – application for extension of time – merit of proposed appeal – application dismissed
Legislation: Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) r 36.03
Cases cited: Daniel v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2004] FCA 21
Hunter Valley Developments Pty Ltd v Cohen (1984) 3 FCR 344; [1984] FCA 176
M211 of 2003 v Refugee Review Tribunal [2004] FCAFC 293
Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v SZSCA [2014] HCA 45
MZZQV v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2015] FCA 533
MZZZA v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2015] FCA 594
NABE v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs (No 2) (2004) 144 FCR 1; [2004] FCAFC 263
SZATV v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship (2007) 233 CLR 18; [2007] HCA 40
Vella v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2015] HCA 42
Date of hearing: 27 November 2015
Place: Melbourne
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 32
Counsel for the Applicant: M Albert
Solicitor for the Applicant: Hammond Migration
Counsel for the First Respondent: N Wood
Solicitor for the First Respondent: Clayton Utz
Counsel for the Second Respondent: The Second Respondent entered a submitting appearance, save as to costs

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

VID 433 of 2015

BETWEEN:

MZZYC
Applicant

AND:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND BORDER PROTECTION
First Respondent

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL
Second Respondent

JUDGE:

DAVIES J

DATE OF ORDER:

17 DECEMBER 2015

WHERE MADE:

MELBOURNE

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The application be dismissed.

2.The applicant pay the first respondent’s costs of the application.

Note:    Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

VID 433 of 2015

BETWEEN:

MZZYC
Applicant

AND:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND BORDER PROTECTION
First Respondent

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL
Second Respondent

JUDGE:

DAVIES J

DATE:

17 DECEMBER 2015

PLACE:

MELBOURNE

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

INTRODUCTION

  1. The Applicant has applied for an extension of time in which to file a notice of appeal against a decision of the Federal Circuit Court (“the FCC”) dismissing the Applicant’s application for judicial review of a decision of the Second Respondent (“the Tribunal”). The Tribunal had affirmed a decision of a delegate of the First Respondent (“the Minister”) not to grant the Applicant a protection visa. For the reasons that follow, the extension of time should be refused.

    REASON FOR THE DELAY

  2. The proposed notice of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read MZZYC v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] FCA 1426
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of MZZYC v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection, the applicant, a citizen of Pakistan, appealed against a decision of the Federal Circuit Court of Australia (FCC) which dismissed his application for an extension of time to lodge an appeal against the Federal Court's dismissal of his application for judicial review of the decision of the Migration Review Tribunal (MRT). The applicant sought a review of the MRT’s decision that he did not have a well-founded fear of persecution if he returned to Pakistan, on the basis that it was unreasonable for him to relocate within Pakistan. The FCC found that the applicant's appeal was barred by time and dismissed his application for an extension of time. The applicant sought to appeal this decision to the High Court.

The key legal issues before the court were whether the Tribunal's decision that it was reasonable for the applicant to relocate within Pakistan was irrational and whether the applicant was entitled to the benefit of the doubt in light of MZZQV v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection. The court noted that the applicant had not raised the issue of generalised risk from terrorism to his family in Islamabad or Rawalpindi, nor had he clearly made a claim that his family would suffer harm if he relocated within Pakistan. The court found that the Tribunal's decision that it was reasonable for the applicant to relocate within Pakistan was open to it, and that the applicant had not demonstrated that the Tribunal's decision was irrational. The court also found that the applicant was not entitled to the benefit of the doubt in light of MZZQV, as the facts of this case were different.

The court dismissed the applicant's appeal and ordered that the application be dismissed and that the applicant pay the first respondent's costs of the application. The court found that the applicant's employment history as a farmer and merchant seaman did not necessarily preclude him from finding work in Islamabad or Rawalpindi, and that the Tribunal had considered the applicant's health difficulties and concluded that they did not make it unreasonable for him to return to Pakistan. The court held that the applicant had not demonstrated that the Tribunal's decision was irrational, and that the applicant's failure to raise the issue of generalised risk from terrorism to his family in Islamabad or Rawalpindi or to clearly make a claim that his family would suffer harm if he relocated within Pakistan meant that he was not entitled to the benefit of the doubt in light of MZZQV.

In conclusion, the court found that the Tribunal's decision that it was reasonable for the applicant to relocate within Pakistan was open to it and that the applicant had not demonstrated that the Tribunal's decision was irrational. The court also found that the applicant was not entitled to the benefit of the doubt in light of MZZQV, as the facts of this case were different. The court dismissed the applicant's appeal and ordered that the application be dismissed and that the applicant pay the first respondent's costs of the application.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application be dismissed.

2. The applicant pay the first respondent’s costs of the application.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Applicant, a Pakistani national, applied for refugee status in Australia. The Tribunal determined that the Applicant did not hold a well-founded fear of persecution if he returned to Pakistan, as it was reasonable for him to relocate within the country. The Applicant contested this decision in the Federal Circuit Court of Australia (FCC), arguing that the Tribunal had erred in its assessment of the reasonableness of relocating to Islamabad or Rawalpindi. The Applicant also raised concerns about potential harm to his family from generalised violence in those cities. The FCC dismissed the Applicant's appeal, finding that the Tribunal's decision was not irrational.

The matter began with the Applicant applying for refugee status in Australia. Following a decision by the Tribunal that the Applicant did not have a well-founded fear of persecution if he returned to Pakistan, the Applicant appealed this decision to the FCC. The FCC reviewed the appeal and considered the Applicant's grounds for challenging the Tribunal's decision. Ultimately, the FCC dismissed the appeal and upheld the Tribunal's decision.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Having made that finding, the Tribunal went on to consider whether it would be reasonable for the Applicant to relocate to Islamabad or Rawalpindi. The Tribunal relevantly noted that the Applicant did not wish to relocate his young family (a wife and six children) within Pakistan. However, the Tribunal did not accept that the Applicant’s family circumstances made it unreasonable for him to relocate to one of those cities. The Tribunal considered but did not accept the Applicant’s claim that he would be discriminated against by non-Pashtun people who would assume that he was a terrorist, therefore making it difficult for him to rent a house or find work. In this context the Tribunal noted that the Applicant had lived in Karachi for 12 months prior to departing Pakistan in 2012. The Tribunal accepted that the Applicant suffered from certain mental health problems but considered that the available medical evidence did not suggest that his mental health would deteriorate if he were unable to access particular treatment in Pakistan. Therefore, the Tribunal did not accept, on the evidence before it, that the Applicant’s mental health problems made it unreasonable for him to relocate. Finally, the Tribunal took into account the Applicant’s attributes and capacities. It noted that he is a 43-year-old man who had completed his schooling and who spoke both Urdu and Pashto, and noted that he had been employed as a merchant seaman since 2006. The Tribunal stated that “in all of the circumstances” it did not accept that the Applicant would be unable to earn a living or access accommodation in Islamabad or Rawalpindi. The Tribunal also stated that “for the reasons set out above” the Tribunal had not accepted that the Applicant would be targeted for harm in Islamabad or Rawalpindi on the basis of his Pashtun ethnicity or his past opposition to the Taliban. The Tribunal concluded at [64]:However the Tribunal finds that it is reasonable for the applicant to relocate within Pakistan and that the applicant’s chance of being harmed by the Taliban or other extremist groups outside of Khatyar and the Swat region in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa is remote and, accordingly, not well-founded. The Tribunal therefore finds that that (sic) the applicant does not hold a well-founded fear of persecution if he returns to Pakistan, now or in the reasonably foreseeable future.The FCC decision The grounds advanced by the Applicant in his judicial review application included that:The [Tribunal] erred by asking itself the wrong question, namely would the Applicant suffer serious harm in the place of relocation? Alternatively, the [Tribunal] failed to ask the right question, namely was the relocation reasonable in all the circumstances? The Applicant argued in the FCC that the Tribunal had asked itself the wrong question by: (a)assessing whether the Applicant’s relocation would be reasonable by asking whether he would be the subject of Convention-based harm in Islamabad or Rawalpindi; (b)failing to consider the generalised risk from terrorism to the Applicant’s family in Islamabad or Rawalpindi; and(c)failing to consider the impact that any of the potential harms or difficulties for the Applicant would have on his family.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

There is one further aspect of the submissions for the Applicant that should be dealt with. It was submitted that, based upon MZZQV v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2015] FCA 533, the Applicant is “entitled to the benefit of the doubt” where the question of whether a claim was raised is “finely balanced”. The view taken by Barker J in MZZQV, on the facts before his Honour in that case, that the appellant should have “the benefit of the doubt” does not assist the Applicant in this case where, for the reasons already given, a claim to fear harm from generalised violence was neither expressly made nor did it clearly arise on the material.Was the decision of the Tribunal irrational? The FCC dealt with this ground at [70]–[72] as follows:70.As advanced in both written and oral submissions the applicant’s complaint here is essentially to the effect that the Tribunal’s decision as to relocation was irrational because the applicant’s employment history as a farmer and merchant seaman could not reasonably support the proposition that he could relocate to Islamabad or Rawalpindi, both of which are a very long way from the sea and might reasonably be thought not to have any opportunities for farming. A detailed analysis of the Tribunal’s observations are set out at paragraph 25 of the applicant’s written submissions and in particular at paragraph d thereof. These criticisms were advanced in oral submissions also. It was put that there was a complete mismatch in the relocation cities as a result of the applicant’s prior work experience. It was submitted the applicant would not be able to return to his work as a seaman because he deserted ship. It was put that the Tribunal accepted the state of the applicant’s mental health and that the findings that he could therefore find work in Rawalpindi or Islamabad were plainly such that no reasonable, rational person could reach them.71.Counsel for the first respondent noted, as was in fact agreed by the applicant, that the bar for finding of irrationality is very high. It was submitted that the Tribunal responded to the matters that the applicant raised and that the issues now raised about the applicant’s skills as a seaman or farmer were simply not agitated by him. It was further submitted that the Tribunal consider the medical evidence in the context of a question of practicability of relocation.72.My conclusion can be put shortly. In my opinion the applicant simply did not articulate the specific matters as to his employability in Islamabad or Rawalpindi that are now stressed. The Tribunal responded directly to the matters the applicant did raise and in my view the findings made by the Tribunal were open to it. The Tribunal expressly turned its mind to the applicant’s health difficulties (paragraph 53, CB285) but concluded on the evidence that the applicant’s health did not make it unreasonable for him to return to Pakistan. Minds could readily differ as to whether this was so or not but to suggest that such a finding was one that no rational person could arrive at is not in fact in my opinion made out.