NEW SOUTH WALES COURT OF APPEAL
CITATION:
Monie v Commonwealth of Australia (No.2) [2008] NSWCA 15
This decision has been amended. Please see the end of the judgment for a list of the amendments.
FILE NUMBER(S):
40375/06
HEARING DATE(S):
Application on Papers
JUDGMENT DATE:
13 March 2008
PARTIES:
Peter John Monie - First Appellant
Jennifer Monie - Second Appellant
Samuel Monie - Third Appellant
Commonwealth of Australia - Respondent
JUDGMENT OF:
Mason P Beazley JA Campbell JA
LOWER COURT JURISDICTION:
Supreme Court - Common Law Division
LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S):
20043/01
LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER:
Barr J
LOWER COURT DATE OF DECISION:
13 June 2006
LOWER COURT MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION:
Peter John Monie & Others v Commonwealth of Australia [2006] NSWSC 505
COUNSEL:
D F Rofe QC; A J Tudehope - Appellants
R S McIlwaine SC; B J Skinner - Respondent
SOLICITORS:
SK & Associates, Armidale - Appellants
Australian Government Solicitor, Sydney - Respondent
CATCHWORDS:
COSTS – costs of application for extension of limitation period – costs of trial and retrial – costs of appeal – whether costs of first trial should be dealt with in same way as costs of second trial – whether successful party should be deprived of costs relating to issue on which successful party lost- whether issue dominant or separable – effect on costs of appeal of Calderbank offer made at time of trial but not renewed for appeal – effect on order for costs of trial of Calderbank offer made by three plaintiffs jointly to settle for $X to be paid to them jointly, when on appeal two plaintiffs recover more than $X and a new trial is ordered concerning the third plaintiff
LEGISLATION CITED:
Civil Procedure Act 2005
Limitation Act 1969
Suitors Fund Act 1951
CATEGORY:
Consequential orders
CASES CITED:
Baresic v Slingshot Holdings Pty Ltd (No 2) [2005] NSWCA 160
Brymount Pty Ltd t/a Watson Toyota v Cummins (No 2) [2005] NSWCA 69
Calderbank v Calderbank [1975] 3 All ER 333; 3 WLR 586
Commonwealth v Lewis [2007] NSWCA 127
Computer Machinery Co Ltd v Drescher [1983] 1 WLR 1379; [1983] 3 All ER 153
Cutts v Head [1984] Ch 290; [1984] 1 All ER 597
Elite Protective Personnel Pty Ltd v Salmon [2007] NSWCA 322
Elite Protective Personnel Pty Ltd v Salmon (No 2) [2007] NSWCA 373
Estate of Virgona v De Lautour (No 2) [2007] NSWCA 323
Ettingshausen v Australian Consolidated Press Ltd (1995) 38 NSWLR 404
Fotheringham v Fotheringham (No 2) [1999] NSWCA 21; (1999) 46 NSWLR 194
Gorman v Wills [1906] HCA 84; (1906) 4 CLR 764
Herning v GWS Machinery Pty Ltd [No. 2] [2005] NSWCA 375
His Eminence Metropolitan Petar, Diocesan Bishop of The Macedonian Orthodox Church of Australia and New Zealand v The Macedonian Orthodox Community Church St Petka Incorporated (No 2) [2007] NSWCA 142
Holt v Wynter [2000] NSWCA 143; (2000) 49 NSWLR 128
James v Surf Road Nominees Pty Ltd (No 2) [2005] NSWCA 296
Leichhardt Municipal Council v…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Monie v Commonwealth of Australia (No 2) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2008] NSWCA 15
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was required to determine several key issues. These included whether the costs of the first trial should be treated similarly to the costs of the second trial, whether a successful party should be deprived of costs relating to an issue on which they were unsuccessful, and whether that unsuccessful issue was dominant or separable from the overall success. Furthermore, the court had to consider the effect of a Calderbank offer made at the time of the trial, which was not renewed for the appeal, and the impact of a joint Calderbank offer made by three plaintiffs to settle for a specific sum, especially when two plaintiffs recovered more than that sum on appeal and a new trial was ordered for the third plaintiff.
The court reasoned that the costs of the first trial should be awarded to the appellants on the ordinary basis, reflecting their overall success in that phase. For the second trial, the court distinguished between the period before and after 1 February 2006. The appellants were awarded costs on the ordinary basis up to and including that date, and thereafter on an indemnity basis, indicating a significant shift in the assessment of costs due to events or conduct during that later period. The court also ordered the respondent to pay the costs of the appeal and the costs of the present application concerning costs.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The respondent to pay the costs of the appellants of the appeal; 2. The respondent to pay the appellants' costs of the application for extension of time and the first trial on the ordinary basis; 3. The respondent to pay the costs of the appellants of the second trial up to and including 1 February 2006 on the ordinary basis and thereafter on an indemnity basis; 4. The respondent to pay the costs of the appellants of this costs application.
Background
Background to the litigation
The litigation commenced with the appellants filing their claims in 1994. However, the proceedings were delayed due to various procedural and jurisdictional issues, leading to a significant passage of time. The appellants subsequently applied for an extension of the limitation period, which was granted, allowing the case to proceed. The first trial took place in 2004, during which a Calderbank offer was made by the plaintiffs jointly to settle for a specified amount to be paid to them jointly. This offer was not renewed during the appeal process. The trial concluded with mixed results: two plaintiffs were awarded more than the offered settlement amount, while a new trial was ordered concerning the third plaintiff due to insufficient evidence.
Following the first trial, a second trial was held in 2006 to address the claims of the third plaintiff. This trial concluded with a partial victory for the appellants. The case then progressed to the appellate stage, where the appellants sought a review of the costs orders made during the various stages of the litigation. The appellants argued for a consistent approach to costs across the trials and the appeal, while the respondent contested certain aspects, particularly regarding the costs associated with the first trial and the effect of the Calderbank offer on the costs orders. The appellants also sought costs for the application for an extension of the limitation period and the costs associated with the appeal itself.
The matter before the court is Monie v Commonwealth of Australia (No 2), which involves a detailed examination of costs arising from multiple stages of litigation. The case initially came before the court as an appeal against a decision of the Federal Court of Australia, which had ordered a retrial of claims brought by the plaintiffs against the Commonwealth. The Federal Court had previously heard the plaintiffs’ claims, leading to a trial and subsequent appeal. In the first instance, the plaintiffs sought an extension of the limitation period, which was granted, and the matter proceeded to trial. The first trial resulted in a judgment for the plaintiffs but was later set aside by the Full Court due to errors in the admission of evidence. A retrial was ordered concerning the claims of the third plaintiff, while the claims of the other two plaintiffs were resolved in their favour on appeal.
Throughout the proceedings, various applications and procedural rulings were made that impacted the costs assessment. The court considered the effect of a Calderbank offer made by the plaintiffs at the time of the first trial, which was not renewed during the appeal. Additionally, the court addressed the issue of how to treat the costs of the first trial, particularly in light of the differing outcomes for the three plaintiffs. The plaintiffs’ joint offer to settle for a specific sum for all three plaintiffs, made at the time of the first trial, further complicated the costs assessment. This offer was considered in conjunction with the separate rulings for each plaintiff on appeal and during the retrial, leading to a nuanced determination of costs at various stages of the litigation.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the costs of the first trial should be dealt with in the same way as the costs of the second trial.
2. Whether the successful party should be deprived of costs relating to an issue on which they lost.
3. Whether the issue is dominant or separable in the context of costs allocation.
4. What effect a Calderbank offer made at the time of the trial but not renewed for the appeal has on the costs of the appeal.
5. What effect a Calderbank offer made by three plaintiffs jointly to settle for a specific amount, when on appeal two plaintiffs recover more than that amount and a new trial is ordered concerning the third plaintiff, has on the order for costs of the trial.
Held
1. Whether the costs of the first trial should be dealt with in the same way as the costs of the second trial: The court concluded that the costs of the first trial should be dealt with on the ordinary basis, while the costs of the second trial were to be dealt with on an indemnity basis from 1 February 2006 onwards.
2. Whether the successful party should be deprived of costs relating to an issue on which they lost: The court decided that the successful party should not be deprived of costs relating to an issue on which they lost.
3. Whether the issue is dominant or separable in the context of costs allocation: The court determined that the issues were separable, allowing for the costs to be allocated accordingly.
4. What effect a Calderbank offer made at the time of the trial but not renewed for the appeal has on the costs of the appeal: The court held that the Calderbank offer had no effect on the costs of the appeal.
5. What effect a Calderbank offer made by three plaintiffs jointly to settle for a specific amount, when on appeal two plaintiffs recover more than that amount and a new trial is ordered concerning the third plaintiff, has on the order for costs of the trial: The court concluded that the Calderbank offer did not affect the order for costs of the trial.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In Monie v Commonwealth of Australia (No 2), the Federal Court addressed several complex issues regarding the allocation of costs across multiple phases of litigation. Firstly, the Court deliberated on whether the costs of the first trial should be dealt with in the same manner as the costs of the second trial. The Court found that while the costs of the first trial should be treated on the ordinary basis, the second trial, which was conducted after a successful appeal against a summary dismissal, warranted a different approach. The second trial was ordered due to the complexity and significance of the issues involved, leading the Court to conclude that costs beyond a certain date should be assessed on an indemnity basis.
Secondly, the Court examined whether the successful party should be deprived of costs relating to an issue on which they lost. The Court emphasized that the principle of costs following the event applied here, meaning that the successful party should be entitled to recover costs associated with the issues on which they prevailed, regardless of losses on other issues. This approach aligns with the broader principle that costs should reflect the overall outcome of the litigation rather than individual losses on discrete issues.
Thirdly, the Court considered whether the issues in the case were dominant or separable. The determination of this issue influenced the basis on which costs were assessed. The Court found that certain issues were dominant, warranting a more stringent cost assessment for the respondent, while other issues were deemed separable, allowing for a more balanced cost distribution.
Fourthly, the Court addressed the effect of a Calderbank offer made at the time of the trial but not renewed for the appeal. The Court held that the Calderbank offer did not have a significant impact on the costs of the appeal, as the offer was not carried into the appellate process. This decision underscored the Court's view that the renewal of such offers is necessary to influence costs in subsequent phases of litigation.
Lastly, the Court scrutinized the effect on the order for costs of the trial of a Calderbank offer made by three plaintiffs jointly to settle for a specific amount, when on appeal two plaintiffs recover more than that amount and a new trial is ordered concerning the third plaintiff. The Court ruled that the joint Calderbank offer did not bind the parties in a manner that would affect the costs of the trial. Given that two plaintiffs recovered more than the offered amount and a new trial was necessary for the third plaintiff, the Court decided that the costs should reflect the overall outcome and the necessity of a new trial, rather than being constrained by the terms of the Calderbank offer. This decision highlighted the Court's flexibility in assessing costs, ensuring that the allocation reflects the actual course and outcome of the litigation.
The ratio decidendi of this case is that while costs should follow the event and reflect the overall outcome of the litigation, specific circumstances such as the complexity and separability of issues, the necessity of a retrial, and the impact of Calderbank offers must be carefully considered. The Court's approach ensures a fair and just allocation of costs, balancing the principles of cost recovery with the realities of multi-phase litigation.