Peter John Monie v Commonwealth of Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 84 min read
CITATION: Peter John Monie & Others v Commonwealth of Australia [2006] NSWSC 505
This decision has been amended. Please see the end of the judgment for a list of the amendments.
HEARING DATE(S): 31 January 2006 - 16 February 2006, 24 March 2006, 7 June 2006
 
JUDGMENT DATE : 

13 June 2006
JUDGMENT OF: Barr J at 1
DECISION: Direct the entry of a verdict and judgment for the defendant. Order the plaintiffs to pay the defendant’s costs of the retrial on an indemnity basis. No order made as to the costs of the first trial. Plaintiffs granted a certificate under the Suitors’ Fund Act 1951 for the costs of the first trial.
PARTIES: Peter John Monie, Jennifer Ann Monie, Samuel Monie, Commonwealth of Australia
FILE NUMBER(S): SC 20043/2001
COUNSEL: DF Rofe QC and AJ Tudehope
RS McIlwaine SC and B Skinner
SOLICITORS:

SK & Associates
Australian Government Solicitior



      IN THE SUPREME COURT
      OF NEW SOUTH WALES
      COMMON LAW DIVISION

      GRAHAM BARR J

      13 JUNE 2006

      20043/2001 PETER JOHN MONIE & OTHERS v COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA

      JUDGMENT

1 HIS HONOUR: The plaintiffs, Peter John Monie (Mr P Monie), Jennifer Ann Monie (Mrs Monie) and Samuel Monie (Mr S Monie) seek an award of damages against the Commonwealth of Australia in the right of the Commonwealth Employment Service (CES). Mr P and Mrs Monie are husband and wife. Mr S Monie is their eldest son. Mr P Monie and PJ Monie & Co Pty Limited carried on the business, under the name Thornleigh & Co, of a cattle and sheep farming property at Thornleigh about 32 kilometres from Bingara. Mr P and Mrs Monie were the Directors of PJ Monie & Co Pty Limited and at all material times its shareholders were Mr P and Mrs Monie and their children, including Mr S Monie.

2 Thornleigh & Co used to take on labour from time to time and dealt on occasions with the Inverell office of the CES. In March 1993 further labour was needed and Mr S Monie, on behalf of Thornleigh & Co, spoke about it to an officer of CES. As a result, a labourer, Darren Winsor, went to the property for an interview. He spoke to Mr P Monie. The details are controversial and I shall defer consideration of them. On 22 or 23 March 1993, having interviewed Mr Winsor, Mr P Monie offered him the job and told him that he and his wife could move into the labourer’s cottage, which was situated a short distance from the homestead. Mr Winsor accepted and it was agreed that he and his wife should move into the cottage on 23 March and that he should start work on 24 March. That is what happened. On 1 April 1993 Mr P Monie and Mr Winsor signed an agreement which recorded, inter alia, the commencement of employment on 24 March.

3 There was in 1993 a scheme called Jobstart, administered by CES, one aim of which was to encourage and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Peter John Monie v Commonwealth of Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] NSWSC 505
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The plaintiffs, Peter John Monie, Jennifer Ann Monie, and Samuel Monie, sought damages against the Commonwealth of Australia in the right of the Commonwealth Employment Service (CES), alleging negligence in the referral of Darren Winsor for employment. The case revolved around whether CES owed a duty of care to the plaintiffs to exercise reasonable skill and care in referring Winsor for employment, particularly given his criminal history. The plaintiffs argued that if they had known about Winsor's criminal record, they would not have hired him, and CES had a duty to disclose such information. The court had to decide if CES knew or should have known about Winsor's criminal history and if it breached any duty owed to the plaintiffs.

The court found that CES was aware of Winsor's criminal history and assessed him as an ex-offender, thereby knowing he had been in prison. Despite this, CES referred Winsor to the plaintiffs without disclosing his criminal record. The court held that CES owed a duty of care to the plaintiffs to either disclose Winsor's criminal history with his consent or not refer him if he refused to consent. CES breached this duty by referring Winsor without disclosing his criminal history or obtaining his consent. However, the court found that the plaintiffs voluntarily assumed the risk of Winsor's potential violent behavior once they became aware of his criminal history but chose not to dismiss him. As a result, the court held that CES was no longer liable for its breach of duty.

Regarding damages, the court awarded general damages to Mr. Monie for his physical injuries and psychological trauma, and to Mrs. Monie for her nervous shock and adjustment disorder. Mr. Monie also received compensation for the economic loss of the partnership, which was divided equally between him and Mrs. Monie. Mr. S Monie's claim for damages was rejected as he did not suffer from a recognisable psychiatric disorder. The court ordered the plaintiffs to pay the defendant's costs of the retrial on an indemnity basis but made no order regarding the costs of the first trial, instead granting the plaintiffs a certificate under the Suitors’ Fund Act 1951 for the costs of the first trial.

Background

Background to the litigation

Peter John Monie, Jennifer Ann Monie, and their son Samuel Monie brought a claim against the Commonwealth of Australia in its capacity as the Commonwealth Employment Service (CES). The plaintiffs sought damages due to the injuries Peter Monie sustained and the emotional distress experienced by all three plaintiffs after Peter was shot by Darren Winsor, an employee referred to the plaintiffs by CES. The referral was made in the context of CES's Jobstart program, which subsidized the wages of eligible workers. Darren Winsor had a criminal history, which CES did not disclose to the plaintiffs. Winsor was eventually convicted of attempted murder for shooting Peter Monie.

The case underwent a retrial after the initial trial resulted in an appeal by the plaintiffs. The appeal was upheld, leading to a second trial where the court found in favor of the defendant, the Commonwealth. The plaintiffs' claim for damages was rejected, and the court ordered the plaintiffs to pay the defendant's costs for the retrial on an indemnity basis. The court also granted the plaintiffs a certificate under the Suitors’ Fund Act 1951 for the costs of the first trial.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Did CES owe a duty of care to the plaintiffs to exercise reasonable skill and care in referring Darren Winsor for employment?
2. Was CES in breach of any duty of care it may have owed to the plaintiffs?
3. Did CES's breach of duty, if any, cause or materially contribute to the injuries sustained by Peter Monie?
4. Were the plaintiffs' claims for damages, both general and special, justified and should they be awarded?

Held
1. CES did not owe a duty of care to the plaintiffs to exercise reasonable skill and care in referring Darren Winsor for employment.
2. Assuming CES did owe such a duty, it was not in breach of any such duty.
3. Assuming CES was in breach of duty, that breach did not cause or materially contribute to the injuries sustained by Peter Monie.
4. The plaintiffs' claims for damages, both general and special, were not justified and should not be awarded.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court held that the Commonwealth Employment Service (CES) did not owe a duty of care to the plaintiffs in referring Darren Winsor for employment. The court reasoned that CES had manuals instructing its officers about the special consideration appropriate to ex-offenders, but it was not submitted that any manual applied on the specific date of the referral. The court further held that even if CES did owe such a duty, it was not in breach of any such duty because the officer who dealt with Winsor did not know about his criminal history and Winsor did not disclose it. The court found that CES could not be held liable for Winsor's criminal behavior because it did not refer him for employment, and Winsor was not a third party in the context of the duty of care. Finally, the court held that even if CES was in breach of duty, that breach did not cause or materially contribute to the injuries sustained by Peter Monie because the plaintiffs voluntarily assumed the risk of Winsor's violent propensity by continuing to employ him after learning of his criminal history. The court also held that the plaintiffs' claims for damages, both general and special, were not justified and should not be awarded. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that CES did not owe a duty of care to the plaintiffs in referring Darren Winsor for employment, and any such duty, if it existed, was not breached or did not cause or materially contribute to the injuries sustained by Peter Monie.