Invisalign Australia Pty Ltd v SmileDirectClub LLC

Link copied
Case Copied 59 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Invisalign Australia Pty Ltd v SmileDirectClub LLC [2024] FCAFC 46

Appeal from: Invisalign Australia Pty Ltd v SmileDirectClub LLC (2023) 166 ACSR 215; [2023] FCA 395
File number(s): NSD 503 of 2023
Judgment of: O’CALLAGHAN, HALLEY AND BUTTON JJ
Date of judgment: 11 April 2024
Catchwords: CONSUMER LAW – whether primary judge erred in finding that certain promotional materials did not convey alleged representations under ss 18 and 29 of the Australian Consumer Law – where respondents ceased to trade after hearing of appeal and before delivery of reasons – where certain grounds of appeal proposed to be allowed – where further hearing of appeal adjourned to a date to be fixed
Legislation:

Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) s 4(1), Schedule 2 ss 18, 19

Corporations Act2001 (Cth) ss 440D, 471B

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) s 135

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) ss 28(1), 28(1)(c), 28(1)(f), 28(2), 30

Trade Practices Act1974 (Cth) ss 52, 53(a)

Cases cited:

Aldi Foods Pty Ltd v Moroccanoil Israel Ltd (2018) 261 FCR 301

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v TPG Internet Pty Ltd (2013) 250 CLR 640

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Limited [2023] FCA 1150

Beale v Government Insurance Office of New South Wales (1997) 48 NSWLR 430

Botany Bay Council v Saab Corp Pty Ltd (2011) NSWLR 171

Community and Public Sector Union v Telstra Corporation Ltd (No 2) (2001) 112 FCR 324

Croucher v Cachia (2016) 95 NSWLR 117

Gillette Australia Pty Limited v Energizer Pty Limited (2002) 193 ALR 629; [2002] FCAFC 223

Goodrich Aerospace Pty Limited v Arsic (2006) 66 NSWLR 186

Hatziandoniou v Ruddy (No 2) [2015] NSWCA 277

Holford v Melbourne Tramway and Omnibus Co Ltd [1909] VLR 497

Jones v Bradley [2003] NSWCA 81

Lianos v Order of AHEPA NSW Inc (No 2) [2020] NSWCA 304

Monash Health v Singh [2023] FCAFC 166

Monie v Commonwealth (No 2) [2008] NSWCA 15

Moylan v The Nutrasweet Company [2000] NSWCA 337

New Aim Pty Ltd v Leung (No 3) [2023] FCA 1295

Pateman v Higgin (1957) 97 CLR 521

Quinn v Rocla Concrete Pipes Ltd (1986) 6 NSWLR 586

RB (Hygiene Home) Australia Pty Ltd v Henkel Australia Pty Ltd [2024] FCAFC 10

Invisalign Australia Pty Ltd v SmileDirectClub LLC (2023) 166 ACSR 215; [2023] FCA 395

Self Care IP Holdings Pty Ltd v Allergan Australia Pty Ltd  (2023) 97 ALJR 388; [2023] HCA 8

Soulemezis v Dudley (Holdings) Pty Limited (1987) 10 NSWLR 247

Sovereign MF Limited v Compliance & Risk Services Pty Ltd [2013] VSC 213

Telstra Corporation Ltd v Optus Communications Pty Ltd (1996) 36 IPR 515

Trade Practices Commission v Telstra Corporation Limited (1993) ATPR 41-256

Unilever Australia Ltd v Rosella Foods Pty Ltd (2012) 15 DCLR (NSW) 185; [2012] NSWDC 221

Warren v Coombes (1979) 142 CLR 531

Waterways Authority v Fitzgibbon (2005) 79 ALJR 1816; [2005] HCA 57

X…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Invisalign Australia Pty Ltd v SmileDirectClub LLC and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] FCAFC 46
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Invisalign Australia Pty Ltd appealed against a decision of the Federal Court, where the primary judge dismissed its proceeding against SmileDirectClub LLC (SDC). The proceeding was brought under ss 18 and 29 of the Australian Consumer Law (ACL) for alleged misleading or deceptive conduct in relation to the costs of SDC’s aligner treatment. The primary judge found that none of the alleged representations was conveyed, except for one which SDC admitted had been made but denied was misleading or deceptive. The primary judge dismissed the proceeding.

The appeal was heard on 13 grounds. The court held that it would allow grounds 3, 4, 5, 8, 9 and 11 of the appeal. It proposed to allow the appeal and grant a new trial of the proceeding, before a different judge, in respect of the Price Comparison Representations, the Lower Cost Representation and the Comparable Treatment Representations. However, given that SDC US was ordered to be liquidated and that SDC AU no longer trades, it is unlikely that a new trial will be ordered. The further hearing of the appeal was adjourned to a date to be fixed. The parties were required to file any written submissions on the future conduct of the appeal within 21 days.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The further hearing of the appeal be listed on a date to be fixed.

2. The parties file any written submission on the future conduct of the appeal within 21 days.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Invisalign alleged that SDC represented to consumers that the total cost associated with SDC Aligner Treatment was either $2,825 for upfront payment or $3,155 if paid by instalments and that the Total Cost Representation was misleading, false or deceptive because the advertised costs did not include “Additional Costs”, including the ongoing costs associated with purchasing retainers, necessary to keep teeth in their position and maintain the “Lifetime Smile Guarantee”.THE EVIDENCE The promotional material that was the subject of Invisalign’s claim was set out in Annexure A to its original concise statement. It was later attached as Annexure A to the amended concise statement. The promotional material was then further particularised in another version of the Annexure, called “Schedule 1 to Invisalign’s closing submissions.” On appeal, the court was provided with a document titled “SCHEDULE 1 Promotional material relied upon by [Invisalign]”. It was attached to Invisalign’s written submissions in reply and included annotations referring to particular circumstances in relation to each excluded item of evidence (eg noting where certain evidence had been excluded despite SDC having withdrawn its initial objection). Another version of that document was subsequently provided containing various notations inputted by SDC’s counsel, in response to Invisalign’s comments. It contained references and hyperlinks to a large number of documents and, like its predecessors, contained column headings corresponding to the alleged representations. The final version of that document, containing both Invisalign’s and SDC’s annotations, is attached to these reasons, marked Annexure A. The column headed “Comprehensive Solution” can be ignored. The case made below in that regard is not pressed on appeal. At the hearing of the appeal, we were taken to a selection of the materials referred to in Annexure A. Those promotional materials fell into these broad categories:(a)Image-based social media posts.(b)Text-based “advertorials”.(c)Video advertisements.(d)Blog posts.(e)Screenshots of website pages. Many of the platforms or sites were interconnected. For example, the SDC AU website contained hyperlinks to its various social media platforms, including Facebook, Instagram, YouTube and also to something called the “Grin Life Blog”. The SDC AU Facebook page contained a hyperlink to the SDC AU website. The SDC AU Instagram account also contained a hyperlink to the SDC AU website. Before turning to the evidence of the promotional materials, we should mention an evidentiary issue that arose during closing submissions below about what promotional materials were to be in evidence before the primary judge. His Honour ruled inadmissible certain evidence that Invisalign sought to rely on in closing, because it was outside the “pleadings”, and because it was too late. The documents shaded in yellow in Annexure A to these reasons are documents that the primary judge ruled were inadmissible. Invisalign’s case was that the primary judge was wrong to exclude the documents or materials highlighted in yellow in Annexure A because SDC had, at the hearing, agreed that some of those documents with the notation (added by their counsel) “no objection by SDC” should be in evidence, and some documents were excluded by the primary judge in respect of a particular representation, but allowed in respect of other representations. SDC accepted, on the appeal, that the primary judge had erred in excluding the documents it had agreed to.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The primary judge found that, with one exception, none of the alleged representations was conveyed. In the case of that exception, SDC admitted that the alleged representation had been made, but denied that it was false, misleading or deceptive. The primary judge agreed, and dismissed Invisalign’s proceeding. See Invisalign Australia Pty Ltd v SmileDirectClub LLC (2023) 166 ACSR 215; [2023] FCA 395 (Primary Judgment). SDC AU also brought a cross-claim against Invisalign, which was also dismissed. SDC AU did not bring an appeal against that dismissal. By its amended notice of appeal dated 27 November 2023, Invisalign pressed most of the allegations it made below. There were 13 grounds of appeal. Invisalign contended that SDC made five categories of representations which were false, misleading or deceptive or likely to mislead or deceive in contravention of ss 18 and 29 of the Australian Consumer Law (the ACL, being Schedule 2 to the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth)). They were referred to as the Price Comparison Representations and the Lower Cost Representation (Grounds 3, 4 and 5), the Less than $4 a Day Representation (Grounds 6 and 7), the Comparable Treatment Representations (Grounds 8 and 9), and the Total Cost Representation (Ground 10). We have formed a different view to the learned primary judge in certain critical respects. We would allow grounds 3, 4, 5, 8 and 9, for reasons we will explain below. Grounds 1 and 2 added nothing to grounds 3–10, and the substance of the complaints made in grounds 1 and 2 (that the primary judge failed to assess the effects of the promotional materials on consumers and misunderstood Gillette Australia Pty Limited v Energizer Pty Limited (2002) 193 ALR 629; [2002] FCAFC 223) are dealt with below. We would also allow ground 11, which concerned the primary judge’s rejection of Invisalign’s inclusion of various documents in its schedule setting out the documents by which the various representations were said to have been made. Ground 12, which concerned the primary judge’s methodology, is unnecessary to decide. Ground 13, which concerned the reproduction of submissions in the judgment below, was not pressed. We propose, therefore, to allow the appeal. In the ordinary course of things, we would also propose that there be an order under s 28(1)(f) of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) (Federal Court Act) granting a new trial of the proceeding in respect of the Price Comparison Representations, the Lower Cost Representation and the Comparable Treatment Representations, before a judge other than the primary judge. We say “in the ordinary course of things” because on 26 January 2024, two months after the hearing of this appeal was finished, a United States Court ordered that SDC US be liquidated under the supervision of a trustee. And SDC AU no longer trades, and there is no intention for it to do so again. It is not currently earning, and is not expected in future to earn, any revenue. It is to be assumed that its assets are of little, if any, value.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Invisalign also relied on other promotional material to similar effect, listed in Annexure A to these reasons, but the primary judge did not include any of it in his reasons. It was, and is, not necessary to do so because the “Which aligners are right for you?” advertisement is a sufficient exemplar. Consideration The primary judge found that Comparable Treatment Representations were not conveyed by any of the promotional material relied on by Invisalign. He concluded at [877]–[881] of the Primary Judgment:An analysis of the above representation, in my view however, shows a comparison between SDC’s aligners, SDC’s Nighttime Aligners and Traditional Braces, with three elements that have been accentuated, which are:(1) treatment time;(2) hours worn per day; and(3) price.Invisalign’s Comparable Treatment Representation is foreclosed by the principles set out by the Full Court in Gillette Australia. As in Gillette Australia, SDC has advertised its product by reference to particular features (here: treatment time, hours worn and price). The above representation does not give rise to any implied representation about “like for like” (or equivalent) products or about other potential bases for comparison. Nothing in item (a) above gives rise to any express or implied misrepresentation about the “clinical outcomes” or “efficacy” of its products compared to braces or Invisalign aligners.Like in Gillette Australia, if a consumer formed the conclusion, after viewing item (a) above, that SDC Aligner Treatment is of comparable efficacy to braces or Invisalign treatment for all or the majority of cases, it would be their own mistaken assumption, and not from anything SDC has represented in its promotional material. While Invisalign submits that SDC “set[s] itself up as an alternative to Invisalign and braces” and that in doing so “SDC has to market the SDC Aligner Treatment as capable of correcting the range of malocclusions that Invisalign and braces can correct”, this submission is not supported by SDC’s promotional material which states that SDC aligners are designed for correction of mild to moderate teeth crowding and spacing. It is contrary to the principles in Gillette Australia to assume that because a comparison is made in respect of certain features of a product, that the comparison represents that the products are alike or comparable in all respects. SDC has made no representation to consumers that it provides treatment of the same efficacy that a consumer would receive from Invisalign Aligner Treatment or braces. With respect to Invisalign’s submission that the words “new smile” would convey to a consumer that they will end up with the same smile irrespective of whether they chose braces or SDC Aligner Treatment, this places an exaggerated and fanciful emphasis on the ordinary use of the words and is plainly wrong. We do not, with respect, agree. As Invisalign submitted, the “Which aligners are right for you?” advertisement conveys that SDC Clear Aligners are comparable, or an alternative to (“vs”) traditional braces. Consumers are told that they can get their “new smile” from either SDC Clear Aligners or SDC Nighttime Aligners or (that is “vs’) “Traditional Braces”. And, again as Invisalign submitted, “[i]t is the same new smile that is portrayed as the end goal for consumers”.