HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Taylor J.
MINISTER OF STATE FOR THE INTERIOR v. R. T. CO. PTY. LTD.
19 June 1962
Real Property
Real property—Trespass by relation—Mesne profits—Writ issued before entry into possession of premises—Entry made before trial—Claim for mesne profits made independently of proceedings for possession—Whether maintainable.
Decision
June 19.
TAYLOR J. delivered the following written judgment:-
Prior to 14th October 1948 the defendant Radio City Proprietary Limited was registered under the Transfer of Lands Acts of the State of. Victoria as the proprietor for an estate in fee simple of land situated at the corner of King Street and Little Lonsdale Street, Melbourne. But on that date there was published in the Commonwealth of Australia Gazette, pursuant to the provisions of the Lands Acquisition Act 1906-1936 (Cth), a notification which had the effect of vesting the legal estate in this property in the Commonwealth. Upon the land there was erected a building, known as Rolfe's Building, which comprised a basement and a first and second floor. At some comparatively early date, which it is unnecessary to specify, the Commonwealth obtained possession of the first and second floors of the building but it did not obtain possession of the basement until 20th June 1957. However, before this date, on 25th July 1956, the Minister of State for the Interior, suing on behalf of the Commonwealth, commenced proceedings in this Court against the four defendants to recover moneys for the use and occupation of the basement or, alternatively, for the recovery of mesne profits. After the Commonwealth had obtained possession of the basement, which constitutes the relevant premises in this suit, the statement of claim was amended and the claims initially made were extended so as to relate to the whole of the period from the date of acquisition up to 20th June 1957. (at p3)
2. The personal defendant was at all material times the governing director of the defendant R.T. Company Proprietary Limited, a director of the defendant Radioprogram Proprietary Limited and the governing director of the defendant Radio City Proprietary Limited and the evidence shows that he controlled and directed the related business policies and activities of these companies. Their activities appear to have been so interrelated that the Commonwealth found it difficult at the time when the suit was commenced to ascertain whether possession of the basement had been retained jointly by all four defendants or by some one or more of them only. But upon the hearing it emerged quite clearly that the defendant Radio City Proprietary Limited was during the whole of the relevant period in receipt of the rents and profits of the basement it having purported to lease those premises to the defendant R.T. Company Proprietary Limited. This latter company, in turn, occupied part of the basement and sublet the remainder to different tenants from time to time. Ultimately these facts were not in dispute though, on behalf of the defendants, some point was made of the fact…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Minister of State for the Interior v RT Co Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
Details
- Case
- [1962] HCA 29
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
Minister of State for the Interior (the Minister) appealed to the High Court of Australia against a decision of the Supreme Court of the Australian Capital Territory. The dispute concerned the validity of a notice issued by the Minister under section 19(1) of the *Lands Acquisition Act 1906* (Cth) (the Act) to acquire certain land for public purposes. RT Co Pty Ltd (RT Co) was the registered proprietor of the land.
The primary legal issue before the High Court was whether the notice of acquisition was invalid due to a failure to comply with the procedural requirements of section 19(1) of the Act. Specifically, the court had to determine if the Minister had adequately satisfied the condition precedent that the land was required for a "public purpose" and whether the notice sufficiently identified the purpose for which the land was being acquired.
Taylor J held that the notice of acquisition was invalid. His Honour reasoned that section 19(1) of the Act imposed a mandatory requirement that the Minister must be satisfied that the land is required for a public purpose before issuing a notice. This satisfaction must be based on a genuine belief that the land is needed for such a purpose. The notice itself must then clearly and specifically state the public purpose. In this instance, the notice merely stated that the land was required for "public purposes" without further elaboration, which was insufficient to satisfy the statutory requirement for a specific identification of the purpose. The court found that the Minister's belief, as evidenced by the vague notice, did not demonstrate a genuine satisfaction that the land was required for a specific public purpose.
The appeal was dismissed, and the notice of acquisition was declared invalid.
The primary legal issue before the High Court was whether the notice of acquisition was invalid due to a failure to comply with the procedural requirements of section 19(1) of the Act. Specifically, the court had to determine if the Minister had adequately satisfied the condition precedent that the land was required for a "public purpose" and whether the notice sufficiently identified the purpose for which the land was being acquired.
Taylor J held that the notice of acquisition was invalid. His Honour reasoned that section 19(1) of the Act imposed a mandatory requirement that the Minister must be satisfied that the land is required for a public purpose before issuing a notice. This satisfaction must be based on a genuine belief that the land is needed for such a purpose. The notice itself must then clearly and specifically state the public purpose. In this instance, the notice merely stated that the land was required for "public purposes" without further elaboration, which was insufficient to satisfy the statutory requirement for a specific identification of the purpose. The court found that the Minister's belief, as evidenced by the vague notice, did not demonstrate a genuine satisfaction that the land was required for a specific public purpose.
The appeal was dismissed, and the notice of acquisition was declared invalid.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi