Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Lloyd Price Carnarvon Pty Ltd v Avon Plastics Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
Details
- Case
- [2013] WADC 134
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
Lloyd Price Carnarvon Pty Ltd (LPC) sued Avon Plastics Pty Ltd in the District Court of Western Australia, seeking possession of land, mesne profits, payment of variable outgoings, and interest and costs. The claim arose from Avon's continued occupation of premises at 67 Miguel Road, Bibra Lake, after the termination of a periodic tenancy. LPC applied for summary judgment, which Avon conceded on the issue of possession but contested on other claims. The court determined that a claim for mesne profits could not be pursued in the same action as a claim for possession, as a landlord must first re-enter the land before suing for mesne profits for the tenant's trespass. The court dismissed the balance of LPC's summary judgment application and ordered the action to be discontinued without prejudice to LPC's right to claim mesne profits in a future action.
The court rejected LPC's request to make a finding as to the date on which LPC became entitled to possession, which would set the start date for the claim for mesne profits. The court held that such a finding was not necessary for an action in tort for ejectment or possession, as it is only necessary for the court to find that the plaintiff is entitled to immediate possession of the land. The ascertainment of the relation back date is an inherent part of a claim for mesne profits and should not be disconnected from that process. The court also declined to determine the ownership of a stockpile of tyres found on the premises, finding that such a determination was not necessary for the grant of possession and that the court did not have the required certainty to make a summary determination. The court ordered Avon to deliver up possession of the premises by a specified date and to pay certain costs. The court also granted liberty to the parties to apply for costs or other practical issues arising out of the orders.
The court rejected LPC's request to make a finding as to the date on which LPC became entitled to possession, which would set the start date for the claim for mesne profits. The court held that such a finding was not necessary for an action in tort for ejectment or possession, as it is only necessary for the court to find that the plaintiff is entitled to immediate possession of the land. The ascertainment of the relation back date is an inherent part of a claim for mesne profits and should not be disconnected from that process. The court also declined to determine the ownership of a stockpile of tyres found on the premises, finding that such a determination was not necessary for the grant of possession and that the court did not have the required certainty to make a summary determination. The court ordered Avon to deliver up possession of the premises by a specified date and to pay certain costs. The court also granted liberty to the parties to apply for costs or other practical issues arising out of the orders.