IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF QUEENSLAND
No. 2673 of 1995
Brisbane
Before The Hon. Mr Justice Ambrose
[Francis v. Nat. Mutual Life Assoc]
BETWEEN:
WILLIAM JAMES FRANCIS
Plaintiff
AND:
NATIONAL MUTUAL LIFE ASSOCIATION OF AUSTRALASIA
LIMITED (ACN 004 020 437)
Defendant
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT - AMBROSE J.
Judgment delivered the 26 day of June 1998
This is an application by the defendant to strike out the plaintiff’s action which was initiated by the issue of a Writ of Summons on 22 December 1995.
The Statement of Claim in the action was not delivered until 2 March 1998. Without analysing in detail the allegations on which the plaintiff relies, he seeks to recover a total sum of $393,066.23 paid between 30 June 1990 and 31 December 1990. It is his case that he has causes of action under the Trade Practices Act 1974 and for negligence, breach of fiduciary duty, and the recovery of moneys paid by mistake.
In its Defence to that Statement of Claim delivered 30 March 1998, the defendant denies any liability to the plaintiff under the various causes of action pleaded. In addition, the defendant pleads that the plaintiff became bankrupt on 16 November 1992, and that his alleged causes of action accrued prior to that date. Paragraph 16 of the Defence then proceeds:-
“16.In the event that the plaintiff had any cause of action against the defendant (which is denied) such cause of action was property which vested in the plaintiff’s trustee in bankruptcy on 16 November 1992 for the benefit of the plaintiff’s creditors.
17.In the premises the plaintiff has no standing to bring the claims made in this proceeding.”
On the hearing of this application on 18 June 1998 it was established that on 17 June 1998 the plaintiff’s solicitors served the defendant with copy of a Deed of Assignment executed by the Official Trustee in the plaintiff’s bankruptcy assigning to him the causes of action in respect of which he issued his Writ in December 1995.
The Deed of Assignment recites the fact that the property in the plaintiff’s causes of action against the defendant vested in the Official Trustee pursuant to the Bankruptcy Act 1996 and that on 22 December 1995 “proceedings were instituted in the Supreme Court of Queensland under Writ No 2673 of 1995 pursuant to such cause of action”.
Recital E reads:-
“E.The Assignor by these presents agrees to assign to the assignee the cause of action.”
The habendum of the Deed then provides
“1.The Assignor hereby absolutely assigns to the Assignee to the extent permissible at law or in equity as and from the 21st December 1995 all right and interest in and to the cause of action referred to in the Recitals and as is vested in the assignor.
2.Should the retrospective effect of this Deed fail, then it is deemed that this Deed will have effect as and from the date of execution by the Assignor.
3.The Assignee covenants to pay in consideration for…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Francis v Nat Mutual Life Assoc and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1998] QSC 131
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues in the case revolved around whether the plaintiff's Writ of Summons, issued on December 22, 1995, was a nullity due to the absence of a cause of action at the time of issuance, and whether the deed of assignment executed by the Official Trustee in Bankruptcy on June 16, 1998, could cure the nullity of the Writ. The plaintiff argued that the deed of assignment should be given retroactive effect, while the defendant contended that the assignment could not affect the validity of the Writ.
The court found that the plaintiff's Writ of Summons was indeed a nullity because the plaintiff did not have a cause of action at the time of issuance. The court held that the deed of assignment did not have the legal or equitable effect of vesting the cause of action in the plaintiff at the time the Writ was issued. The court further held that there was no power under either O.3 r.11 or O.32 of the Supreme Court Rules to breathe life into the null Writ of Summons. The court concluded that the plaintiff's action was never properly constituted and that it had no power to make any order that would overcome this deficiency.
In conclusion, the court granted the defendant's application to strike out the plaintiff's action, and ordered the plaintiff to pay the defendant's costs of and incidental to the application and the action.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi