Yankee Doodles Pty Ltd v Blemvale Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

IN THE SUPREME COURT

OF QUEENSLAND

Writ No 78 of 1998

Mackay District Registry

[Yankee Doodles P/L v Blemvale P/L]

BETWEEN:

YANKEE DOODLES PTY LTD
  (ACN 072 339 961)
  Applicant/Defendant
AND:

BLEMVALE PTY LTD
  (ACN 010 989 830)
  Respondent/Plaintiff

CATCHWORDS:     PROCEDURE - SUPREME COURT PROCEDURE - QUEENSLAND - PRACTICE UNDER RULES OF COURT - DEFAULT OF APPEARANCE - whether default judgment final or interlocutory

PROCEDURE - JUDGMENTS AND ORDERS - AMENDING, VARYING AND SETTING ASIDE - application to set aside default judgment - whether judgment irregularly entered - whether discretion should be exercised to set aside judgment - matters to be considered on application to set aside judgment - effect of delay in making application

Counsel:A E Lyons for the applicant

R W Morgan for the respondent

Solicitors:Macrossans Lawyers for the applicant

McKays Solicitors (Mackay) for the respondent

Hearing dates:   16 December 1998, 5 May 1999

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT - ATKINSON J

Judgment delivered 23 June 1999

  1. This is an application to set aside all or part of a judgment entered against the defendant in default of appearance on 19 June 1998.  It was submitted that the judgment should be set aside firstly, because it was irregularly entered and secondly, if it was regularly entered, that it should be set aside in exercise of the discretion given under the Rules of the Supreme Court O.15 r.10 or the inherent jurisdiction.

  2. The judgment entered was for recovery of possession of land, mesne profits and costs:

    “1.The plaintiff recover possession of the land in the endorsement of the Writ described as 85 Victoria Street, Mackay in the State of Queensland described as lots 4, 5 and 6 on registered plan number 70800 in the County of Carlisle and the Parish of Howard, Title Reference 21510189.

    2.The plaintiff recover against the defendant the sum of twenty-three thousand and thirty dollars and seventy-one cents ($23,030.71) for mesne profits.

    3.The plaintiff recover against the defendants [sic] the sum of seven hundred and eighty dollars and fifty cents ($780.50) for costs.”

    A writ of possession was issued by the Court on the same date.

  3. The rules which are relevant to such a judgment being entered are found in O.15 where r.3 relevantly provides:

    “Liquidated demand endorsed
    3.  When the writ of summons is endorsed for a debt or liquidated demand only, whether by special endorsement or otherwise, and the defendant fails ... to appear thereto, the plaintiff may enter final judgment against such defendant for any sum not exceeding the sum endorsed on the writ, together with interest at the rate claimed by the endorsement as the rate agreed upon (if any) or, if no rate is claimed to have been agreed upon, at the rate of 10% per annum, to the date of the judgment, and costs as provided by order 6, rule 8.”

    However where the claim is not liquidated, an interlocutory judgment may be entered for damages to be assessed under O.15 r.5 which provides:

    “Interlocutory judgment…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Yankee Doodles Pty Ltd v Blemvale Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1999] QSC 134
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Yankee Doodles Pty Ltd brought an action against Blemvale Pty Ltd for unpaid rent. The claim was made by way of a writ of summons. Blemvale Pty Ltd failed to defend the claim and judgment was entered against it by default. Blemvale Pty Ltd subsequently applied to set aside the default judgment on the basis that it had a prima facie defence. Blemvale Pty Ltd argued that it had paid the outstanding rent and that any dispute over the amount owed was a matter of credit that could only be resolved at trial. The primary issue before the court was whether the default judgment should be set aside. The court had to consider whether Blemvale Pty Ltd had a satisfactory explanation for its failure to defend, whether its delay in making the application to set aside was such as to preclude it from obtaining relief, and whether it had a prima facie defence on the merits.

The court found that Blemvale Pty Ltd had failed to provide a satisfactory explanation for its failure to defend. While Blemvale Pty Ltd claimed to have paid the outstanding rent, it had not provided any evidence to support this claim. The court noted that Blemvale Pty Ltd had admitted to failing to pay rent before judgment was entered. The court also found that Blemvale Pty Ltd's delay in making the application to set aside the judgment was such as to preclude it from obtaining relief. The court found that Blemvale Pty Ltd had not demonstrated a very compelling reason for its failure to appear and that it had not provided any evidence to suggest that its defence was plausible. The court held that Blemvale Pty Ltd had not satisfied the requirements for setting aside a default judgment.

The application to set aside the default judgment was dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In my view, the judgment should not be set aside on the ground that it was irregularly entered.Setting aside a regularly entered judgment The defendant also argued that even if the judgment was regularly entered, it should be set aside in the exercise of the discretion of the court under O.15 r.10 or in the inherent jurisdiction of the court. Order 15 r.10 provides:“Any judgment by default under this order may be set aside or varied by the Court or a Judge upon such terms as to costs or otherwise as the Court or Judge may think fit.” The matters to be considered on an application to set aside a default judgment are whether the defendant has given a satisfactory explanation of the failure to defend; whether the defendant’s delay in making the application to set aside is not such as to preclude it from obtaining relief; and whether the defendant has a prima facie defence on the merits.[13] The decision whether or not to set aside a default judgment is discretionary.[14] An affidavit in support of an application to set aside judgment entered into in default of appearance to a writ of summons must set out all the defences on which the defendant intends to rely and briefly set out the facts by which the defendant seeks to establish such defences.[15] A mere statement by the defendant that he or she has a good defence is not sufficient to justify a review of the exercise of judicial discretion. The defendant must demonstrate “a very compelling reason” for the failure to appear and that it has a plausible defence either in law or in fact. Before allowing a defendant to come in and defend, the court should have before it material which enables it to say how it came about that the defendant found itself bound by a judgment regularly entered; that the defendant genuinely desires to be allowed to come in and present its case; and that issues are raised in such a form as to require serious consideration of the defence put forward.[16][13]Aboyne Pty Ltd v Dixon Homes Pty Ltd [1980] Qd R 142 at 143-144; National Mutual Life Association of Australasia Ltd v Oasis Developments Pty Ltd [1983] 2 Qd R 441 at 449-450; Bratic v Toohey [1988] 2 Qd R 140 at 146-147.[14]Evans v Bartlam [1937] AC 473 at 478, 481, 482; Bratic v Toohey (supra) at 145.[15]Sue Oclee Pty Ltd v Bak (1979) 29 ACTR 8.[16]Watson v Anderson (1976) 13 SASR 329. The defendant here says it has a prima facie defence on the merits. The defendant says that it has paid the moneys alleged to be outstanding in para 7 of the statement of claim and that the denial by Mr Higgins on behalf of the plaintiff simply raises an issue of credit that can only be resolved at trial. However in order to satisfy the court that it ought to be allowed in to defend, the defendant must make more than a bare allegation of this kind. The allegation must be supported by some reference to evidence to suggest that the defence is plausible and not just raised for the purpose of having default judgment set aside. Indeed in this case, the defendant admits a failure to pay rent in a period before the writ of possession issued. It appears from the defendant’s material that the business it was operating on the premises, a nightclub known variously as Paradise Nights Night Club, Paros Night Club, Glaciers or Yankee Doodles, had closed and it had failed to pay its rent before judgment was entered.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.