Jonata Investments Pty Ltd v Mikhael

Link copied
Case Copied 37 min read

DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Jonata Investments Pty Ltd v Mikhael [2022] QDC 229

PARTIES:

JONATA INVESTMENTS PTY LTD
(ACN 010 959 163)

(Plaintiff/Respondent)

v
CINDY MIKHAEL

(Defendant/Applicant)

FILE NO/S:

70/2022

DIVISION:

Civil

PROCEEDING:

Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

District Court, Southport

DELIVERED ON:

14 October 2022

DELIVERED AT:

Southport

HEARING DATE:

29 July 2022

JUDGE:

Wooldridge KC DCJ

ORDER:

1.   The application to set aside default judgment is allowed.

2.   No order is made as to costs.

3.   The applicant is to file a Notice of Intention to Defend and Defence within 14 days.

CATCHWORDS:

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – JUDGMENTS AND ORDERS – APPLICATION – DEFAULT JUDGMENT – SETTING ASIDE – application pursuant to r 290 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules to set aside default judgment entered against the applicant – whether the Court should exercise its discretion to set aside the judgment

Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld) rr 137, 139, 150, 281, 282, 283, 290

Sale of Goods Act 1896 (Qld) ss 3, 4, 50
National Mutual Life Association of Australasia v Oasis Developments Pty Ltd [1983] 2 Qd R 441
Embrey v Smart [2014] QCA 75

COUNSEL:

D Parish for the applicant

K Wylie for the respondent

SOLICITORS: Brander Smith McKnight Lawyers for the applicant
Hickey Lawyers for the respondent

Nature of the application

  1. This is an application by Cindy Mikhael, pursuant to rule 290 of the UniformCivil Procedure Rules (“UCPR”), for an order setting aside the default judgment entered by order of a Deputy Registrar of this Court[1] on 20 May 2022, in favour of the plaintiff, Jonata Investments Pty Ltd[2] (the respondent), against the applicant, as defendant.

    [1]“Registrar” includes “Deputy Registrar”, see UCPR, Schedule 3.

    [2]ACN 010 959 163.

  2. Default judgment was obtained on the basis of the applicant having failed to file a Notice of Intention to Defend[3] where service of the claim was proved[4] and the claim was for a liquidated demand.[5] Pursuant to rule 283(10) UCPR, in granting the request the Registrar was not required to consider the merits of the claim against the applicant.

    Factual background to the claim[6]

    [3]        UCPR , r 281.

    [4]UCPR, r 282.

    [5]UCPR, r 283. See also UCPR, r 287. The claim for liquidated damages is with reference only to paragraph 1 of the claim filed 14 March 2022, for payment of the purchase price of $425 000, pursuant to the provisions of section 50(2) of the Sale of Goods Act 1896 (Qld).

    [6]These matters were not in contest as between the parties on the application. See Transcript of Proceedings of 29 July 2022 at page 4.

  3. The respondent was (and remains) the owner of a 2017 Holden HSV GTSR W557 motor vehicle (“the vehicle”).  The vehicle was one of a number of vehicles available for sale at an auction on 25 September 2021 by Lloyd’s Auctioneers and Valuers Pty Ltd (“Lloyd’s Auctioneers”).

  4. Prior to the auction the vehicle had been advertised for sale on the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Jonata Investments Pty Ltd v Mikhael and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] QDC 229
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Jonata Investments Pty Ltd v Mikhael involved an application by the applicant, Cindy Mikhael, to set aside a default judgment entered against her by the respondent, Jonata Investments Pty Ltd. The default judgment was obtained due to the applicant's failure to file a Notice of Intention to Defend within the required timeframe, as per the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules (UCPR). The claim was for the purchase price of a vehicle sold at an auction, amounting to $425,000, along with additional damages for breach of contract and interest. The primary legal issue before the court was whether the discretion to set aside the default judgment should be exercised under rule 290 of the UCPR.

The court examined the reasons provided by the applicant for her failure to file the Notice of Intention to Defend and the subsequent circumstances that led to the entry of the default judgment. The applicant argued that she had a valid explanation for her failure, had attempted to file her defence on the same day the default judgment was sought, and had a potentially arguable defence. The court acknowledged that the applicant had promptly engaged legal representatives and had taken steps to file her defence, but these efforts were unfortunately not timely enough to prevent the entry of the default judgment. The court concluded that the applicant had demonstrated sufficient grounds to warrant setting aside the default judgment, considering the circumstances of the case and the applicant's explanation.

In setting aside the default judgment, the court allowed the application but made no order regarding costs. The applicant was directed to file a Notice of Intention to Defend and Defence within 14 days from the date of the judgment. This decision provides a nuanced understanding of the discretionary powers of the court in setting aside default judgments, highlighting the importance of timely compliance with procedural rules and the court's willingness to consider reasonable explanations and circumstances where appropriate.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application to set aside default judgment is allowed.

2. No order is made as to costs.

3. The applicant is to file a Notice of Intention to Defend and Defence within 14 days.

Background

Background to the litigation

Default judgment was obtained on the basis of the applicant having failed to file a Notice of Intention to Defend[3] where service of the claim was proved[4] and the claim was for a liquidated demand.[5] Pursuant to rule 283(10) UCPR, in granting the request the Registrar was not required to consider the merits of the claim against the applicant. Factual background to the claim[6][3] UCPR , r 281.[4]UCPR, r 282.[5]UCPR, r 283. See also UCPR, r 287. The claim for liquidated damages is with reference only to paragraph 1 of the claim filed 14 March 2022, for payment of the purchase price of $425 000, pursuant to the provisions of section 50(2) of the Sale of Goods Act 1896 (Qld). [6]These matters were not in contest as between the parties on the application. See Transcript of Proceedings of 29 July 2022 at page 4. The respondent was (and remains) the owner of a 2017 Holden HSV GTSR W557 motor vehicle (“the vehicle”). The vehicle was one of a number of vehicles available for sale at an auction on 25 September 2021 by Lloyd’s Auctioneers and Valuers Pty Ltd (“Lloyd’s Auctioneers”). Prior to the auction the vehicle had been advertised for sale on the website for Lloyd’s Auctioneers. The auction was undertaken online. Interested parties could become registered bidders to bid at the auction remotely, using a computer. A registered bid of $425 000 was made at the auction for the purchase of the vehicle, in the name of the applicant as the registered bidder.[7] This was the final and highest bid made for the vehicle at the auction. [7]By paragraph 14(a) of the proposed Defence, the applicant contends that her spouse participated in the auction under her authority. The applicant did not subsequently make payment of the amount of $425 000 for the purchase of the vehicle. Chronology of the proceedings On 14 March 2022 the respondent filed a Claim,[8] and accompanying Statement of Claim, in the District Court at Southport against the applicant Cindy Mikhael, as the named defendant, seeking, effectively:1.Orders (further, or in the alternative to one another):a. That the defendant pay the purchase price of $425 000 pursuant to s.50(2) Sale of Goods Act 1896 (Qld);[9] b. For specific performance of the contract;c. For the payment of damages for breach of contract;[10] and2.Interest (further, or in the alternative to one another), calculated pursuant to:a. (the terms of) the contract;b. Section 58 Civil Proceedings Act 2011. [8]D70/2022.[9]It is this first limb of the claim which gives rise to the claim for liquidated damages on which the application for default judgment by the Deputy Registrar, pursuant to rule 183 was predicated. [10]Per the Statement of Claim these are said to be in the amount of $150 000. The aforementioned Claim and Statement of Claim[11] were served on the applicant, personally, on 23 March 2022.[12] The applicant did not file a Notice of Intention to Defend or Defence in the Registry within 28 days as required by rules 137 and 139 of the UCPR.[13] [11]Along with the Form 1 - Notice to Respondent under the Service and Execution of Process Act 1992 (Cth).[12]Affidavit of Kareem Kenan Kabbara sworn 13 May 2022, filed 20 May 2022. See also the affidavit of the applicant Cindy Mikhael sworn 20 June 2022, filed 27 June 2022, at paragraph 4. 13 The Claim itself also included the pro forma notice, as required by rule 23, referring to the requirements for filing of the Notice of Intention to Defend. See also Service and Execution of Process Act 1992 (Cth), section 17(1)(a)(ii).

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The applicant contends[25] that the order for judgment in default ought be set aside for reason that:(a)The applicant “has explained her failure to appear”; (b)The respondent failed to observe the custom of giving a solicitor notice of their intention to seek default judgment;(c)The applicant sought to file her defence on the same day that default judgment was sought; and(d)The applicant “has at least an arguable defence”. Explanation for the failure of the applicant to file the Notice of Intention to Defend, and the circumstances leading to the obtaining of judgment in default[25]Applicant’s Outline of Submissions, paragraph 3. The matters relating to the chronology of the litigation[26] are inter-related and may conveniently be considered together. [26]That is not pertaining to the merit of any potential defence. The reference to “failure to appear” may be understood in this instance to be the failure to file the Notice of Intention to Defend the subject claim within the timeframe required. As concerns the applicant having sought to file a Notice of Intention to Defend and Defence, the affidavit material relied upon by the applicant contends as follows:(a)That upon being served with the Statement of Claim, the applicant, (on or about the same date),[27] instructed her legal representative to assist her in the preparation of her defence in the proceedings. (b)That on 19 May 2022, prior to the respondent’s Request for Default Judgment being forwarded to the Court, the applicant’s legal representatives had prepared a Notice of Intention to Defend and a Defence in response to the Statement of Claim. (c)That on 19 May 2022 at 2:46pm an agent of the applicant’s legal representatives sent copies of the Notice of Intention to Defend and the Defence to be relied upon by the applicant by email to the Southport District Court Registry. An auto-response was received from the Southport District Court Registry email address, confirming receipt of the email correspondence and that the email would be “actioned accordingly”.[28] (d)That on 19 May 2022 the applicant’s legal representative, Mr Smith, sent a copy of the Notice of Intention to Defend and the Defence to be relied upon by the applicant by Express Post to the Registry of the Southport District Court.[29] (e)That on 20 May 2022 the Notice of Intention to Defend and Defence were “delivered at the Court” at 11:46am.[30] (f)On 23 May 2022, correspondence was sent on behalf of the Registrar of the Southport District Court Registry to the legal representatives of the applicant, returning the Notice of Intention to Defend and Defence unfiled, due to Judgment in Default having been entered on 20 May 2022.[31] [27]See the affidavit of Cindy Mikhael sworn 20 June 2022, filed 22 June 2022 at paragraph 5 and the affidavit of Mark Rodger Smith affirmed 20 June 2022, filed 27 June 2022, at paragraph 4.[28]See the affidavit of Mark Rodger Smith affirmed 20 June 2022, filed 27 June 2022 at paragraph 9, and Exhibit B thereto reproduced at pages 27-28.[29]See the affidavit of Mark Rodger Smith affirmed 20 June 2022, filed 27 June 2022 at paragraph 8.[30]See the affidavit of Mark Rodger Smith affirmed 20 June 2022, filed 27 June 2022, at paragraph 10, and the Australia Post Tracking Record reproduced within Exhibit “A” at pages 23-26. The record indicates “Delivered – Most recent update – Delivered to post office box SOUTHPORT BC – Fri 20 May, 11:44am”. [31]See the affidavit of Mark Rodger Smith affirmed 20 June 2022, filed 27 June 2022 at paragraph 12, and Exhibit D thereto.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.