Mercedes Holdings Pty Ltd v Waters (No 5)

Link copied
Case Copied 79 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Mercedes Holdings Pty Ltd v Waters (No 5) [2011] FCA 1428

Citation: Mercedes Holdings Pty Ltd v Waters (No 5) [2011] FCA 1428
Parties: MERCEDES HOLDINGS PTY LIMITED, MAX INVESTMENTS (AUST) PTY LIMITED, MANSTED ENTERPRISES PTY LTD, MICHELLE O'GARR, JM CUSTOMS & FREIGHT SERVICES PTY LIMITED, OSVON PTY LIMITED, ADAM JOHN THORN & GRAHAM DEAN and MARK ROBERT HODGES & JANET ANNE HODGES v ANDREA JANE WATERS, MICHAEL JOHN ANDREW, WELLINGTON INVESTMENT MANAGEMENT LIMITED, OCTAVIA LIMITED, GUY HUTCHINGS, JOHN ARTHUR WHATELEY, JACK SIMON DIAMOND, CRAIG ROBERT WHITE, DEBORAH BEALE, STEVEN KRIS KYLING, STUART ROBERTSON PRICE, MICHAEL GORDON HISCOCK, MICHAEL CHRISTODOULOU KING, PAUL JOSEPH MANKA and IAN ZELINSKI
File number: NSD 324 of 2009
Judge: PERRAM J
Date of judgment: 14 December 2011
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – Pleadings – statement of claim – application to amend – whether pleading discloses reasonable cause of action – whether leave to amend prohibited by prior orders of the Court – application for summary dismissal – former pleading not defended – whether costs orders appropriate
Legislation:

Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth) ss 82, 229
Crimes Act 1914 (Cth) s 4AA
Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ss 9, 208, 210, 601FD, 601HG, 1285, 1311, 1325
Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 31A
Trusts Act 1973 (Qld) s 21

Federal Court Rules 1979  O 62, rr 3, 29

Cases cited:

Aon Risk Services Australia Ltd v Australian National University (2009) 239 CLR 175 cited
Auto Group Ltd v England (2008) 6 ABC(NS) 72 cited
Brimaud v Honeysett Instant Print Pty Ltd (1988) 217 ALR 44 cited
Byrne v Australian Airlines Ltd (1995) 185 CLR 410 cited
Caltex Refineries (Qld) Pty Ltd v Stavar (2009) 75 NSWLR 649 cited
Cubillo v Commonwealth (1999) 89 FCR 528 cited
Cuckmere Brick Co Ltd v Mutual Finance Co Ltd [1971] Ch 949 cited
Cummings v Claremont Petroleum NL (1996) 185 CLR 124 cited
David v Britannic Merthyr Coal Co [1909] 2 KB 146 cited
Dey v Victorian Railways Commissioners (1949) 78 CLR 62 cited
Downs v Williams (1971) 126 CLR 61 cited
Esanda Finance Corporation Ltd v Peat Marwick Hungerfords (1997) 188 CLR 241 cited
Florgale Uniforms Pty Ltd (Receiver and Managers Appointed) (in liq) v Orders (2004) 11 VR 54 cited
Forge v Australian Securities and Investments Commission (2004) 213 ALR 574 cited
GE Capital Australia v Davis (2002) 180 FLR 250 cited
Gama v Qantas Airways Ltd (2006) 195 FLR 475 cited
Groves v Lord Wimborne [1898] 2 QB 402 cited
Harris v Harris (No 1) (1861) 54 ER 567 cited
Khoo Tek Keong v Ch'ng Joo Tuan Neoh [1934] AC 529 cited
Leawell Pty Ltd v Watershed Premium Wines Ltd (No 2) (2009) 180 FCR 392 cited
London Passenger Transport Board v Upson [1949] AC 155 cited
Lubrano v Proprietors of Strata Plan No 4038 (1993) 6 BPR 13,308 cited
Martin v Herzog 228 NY 164 (1920) cited
MBF Investments Pty Ltd v Nolan [2011] VSCA 114 cited
McHugh v Union…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mercedes Holdings Pty Ltd v Waters (No 5) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] FCA 1428
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Mercedes Holdings Pty Ltd, as the plaintiff, brought proceedings against Waters, among others, in the Federal Court of Australia. The dispute involved allegations of misconduct and failure to comply with a compliance plan. The central issues before the Court were whether the plaintiffs were entitled to amend their pleadings to include new claims and whether the defendants' applications for summary dismissal should be granted. The Court also considered whether costs orders were appropriate given the circumstances of the case.

The Court had to decide whether the plaintiffs had disclosed a reasonable cause of action through their proposed amended pleadings and whether the prior orders prohibiting amendment should be adhered to. Furthermore, the Court needed to determine whether the plaintiffs' new claims against the defendants warranted the continuation of the proceedings or if they should be dismissed summarily. The Court examined the balance between allowing amendments to pleadings and the principles of case management and finality in litigation.

In reaching its decision, the Court held that the plaintiffs should be granted leave to amend their pleadings to include the new claims against the defendants. The Court found that the plaintiffs had formulated a coherent case against the defendants, which warranted a trial. The Court dismissed the applications for summary dismissal, ruling that the proceedings should not be terminated at that stage. The Court also noted that appropriate costs orders could address the expense and delay caused by the amendments and the procedural complexities of the case.

The Court ordered that the parties prepare short minutes of order by a specified date to give effect to the decision and to set a timetable for the closing of pleadings. The Court emphasized that the costs of the amendments and the proceedings would be addressed through appropriate orders to ensure fairness and efficiency in the litigation process.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The parties bring in short minutes of order by 31 January 2012 giving effect to these reasons and setting a timetable for the closing of pleadings.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The auditors’ difficulty is twofold. The paragraph does not identify what steps ASIC would have taken nor how those steps would have prevented the responsible entity from acting in breach of the compliance plan. Compendiously the auditors demand ‘clarity and precision… in the counterfactual world’ – a worthy sentiment, no doubt. The applicants submit that the material fact is that ASIC would have taken steps to ensure that MFSIM complied and that how that allegation is proved is a matter of evidence. I agree.(g) Conclusions in relation to the auditors The applicants should be granted leave to proceed against the auditors in the form of their proposed pleading subject to the particulars I have mentioned. They must pay the costs thrown away by reason of the amendment. The auditors filed an application to dismiss the applicants’ proceedings which, in view of the conclusion at which I have arrived, must be dismissed with costs.III. The proposed proceedings against Mr Whateley, Mr Diamond and Ms Beale These three directors of the former responsible entity of the Fund were represented by Mr Jackman SC with Mr Colquhoun of counsel. Mr Jackman SC had three points. His first was as follows: the conclusion in Mercedes (No 3) was that the applicants should not be permitted to reformulate any case against his clients. The grant of leave which had been extended to the applicants in that decision was limited in its application to the claims against the auditors and even this had been limited to their claims in negligence. The Court’s prior order that the applicants were to reformulate their case against the auditors by 22 April 2011 (subsequently extended to 27 April 2011) ‘come what may’ was an indication that, at least so far as Mr Jackman SC’s clients were concerned, the terminal threshold had been surpassed. That being so the Court should simply not even entertain the applicants’ present attempts to formulate a new case. Elements of this argument are very seductive but I believe its charms should be resisted. As I will shortly explain the applicants have now formulated a coherent case against Mr Jackman SC’s clients. As the record of the Court presently stands the applicants have proceedings on foot against Mr Jackman SC’s clients and whilst it is true that they have now applied for judgment under s 31A of the Federal Court of Australia Act I am bound not to grant that relief if the applicants have a real case warranting trial. Since I am of that view it follows that judgment may not be entered against them. Should they then be prevented from amending their case to raise this new case? If I did not accede to the amendment application the proceedings would be consigned to a procedural limbo where they could not advance to trial nor be consigned to judgment. The only device by which this stalemate might be broken is through the notion of want of prosecution but the facts of the history of this case show that such a contention is untenable. Furthermore, this is not a case like Aon Risk Services Australia Ltd v Australian National University (2009) 239 CLR 175 where questions of case management have arisen in the shadow of a trial. Here the defences are not even filed and what all sides now steal themselves for is a long and drawn out procedural Stalingrad in which no quarter will be given. Case management no doubt has its role to play in such an affair but I think it is subsidiary, at this stage, to the concept of a real case proceeding to trial. The expense and delay involved may, I think, be redressed in the current case by appropriate costs orders.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established