McCutcheon and National Disability Insurance Agency

Link copied
Case Copied 42 min read

McCutcheon and National Disability Insurance Agency [2015] AATA 624 (21 August 2015)

Division

National Disability Insurance Scheme Division 

File Number(s)

2015/1624

Re

Kylie McCutcheon

APPLICANT

And

National Disability Insurance Agency

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Senior Member J F Toohey

Date of decision
Date of reasons

21 August 2015
24 August 2015

Place Melbourne

The decision under review is set aside and in its place the decision is substituted that chiropractic treatment is a reasonable and necessary support for Ms McCutcheon.

........................................

Senior Member J F Toohey

CATCHWORDS – NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME – reasonable and necessary supports – spina bifida – scoliosis – whether chiropractic treatment a reasonable and necessary support – whether chiropractic treatment will be, or is likely to be, effective and beneficial having regard to current good practice – whether most appropriately funded through the NDIS – whether more appropriately funded through general health system – decision under review set aside

Legislation

National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 ss 3, 4, 5, 9, 21, 33, 34, 48(4) & (5), 100(6), 103, 209(3)

Cases

TKCW and National Disability Insurance Agency [2014] AATA 501

Re Drake and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No 2) (1979) 2 ALD 634

Secondary Materials

National Disability Insurance Scheme (Supports for Participants) Rules 2013

Operational Guideline – Planning and Assessment – Supports in the Plan – Interface with Health

The Australian Oxford Dictionary

Chronic Disease Management – Individual Allied Health Services under Medicare

Hidalgo et al “The efficacy of manual therapy and exercise for different stages of non-specific low back pain: an update of systematic reviews” Journal of Manual and Manipulative Therapy 22: 59-74 (2014) 

Bronfort et al “High-quality evidence that spinal manipulative therapy for chronic low back pain has a small, short term greater effect on pain and functional status compared with other interventions” Evidence-Based Medicine 17: 81-82 (2012)

Thomas S Webb “Optimising Health Care for Adults with Spina Bifida” Development Disabilities Research Reviews 16: 76-81 (2010)

Terri Mears “Spina Bifida Adult Resource Team (SBART) Service Evaluation” Northcott (2015)

REASONS FOR DECISION

Senior Member J F Toohey

24 August 2015

Background

  1. Ms Kylie McCutcheon has spina bifida, scoliosis, Perthes’ disease in her left hip, chronic renal failure and heart disease.  She is a participant in the National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS) and receives funding for a number of reasonable and necessary supports.

  2. Ms McCutcheon seeks review of a decision by the National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA), the agency responsible for administering the NDIS, that chiropractic treatment is not a reasonable and necessary support within the meaning of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (the Act).

    The National Disability Insurance Scheme

  3. The NDIS commenced operation on 1 July 2013.  It provides supports for people with disability in the form of coordination, strategic and referral services; funding to persons or organisations to enable them to assist people with disability to participate in economic and social life; and funding for reasonable and necessary supports for persons who qualify to be participants in the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read McCutcheon and National Disability Insurance Agency and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] AATA 624
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal was an appeal by Ms McCutcheon against a decision of the National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA) to deny funding for chiropractic treatment as a reasonable and necessary support under the National Disability Insurance Scheme. Ms McCutcheon, a participant in the NDIS, sought to have chiropractic treatment funded to manage her complex medical conditions, which include spina bifida, scoliosis, and renal disease, among others. The NDIA had previously affirmed its decision that the provision of chiropractic treatment did not constitute a reasonable and necessary support for Ms McCutcheon.

The central legal issues for the Tribunal were whether chiropractic treatment would be or is likely to be effective and beneficial for Ms McCutcheon, and whether it is most appropriately funded or provided through the NDIS rather than through other general systems of service delivery or support services. The Tribunal had to assess the available evidence, including expert medical opinions and Ms McCutcheon's personal testimony, to determine if chiropractic treatment met the statutory criteria for being a reasonable and necessary support.

The Tribunal considered the evidence and concluded that chiropractic treatment could amount to current good practice and could be effective and beneficial for Ms McCutcheon, particularly in maintaining her mobility and overall functioning. The Tribunal found that Ms McCutcheon's lived experience, supported by her treating chiropractor and physiotherapist, provided valuable insight into the benefits of chiropractic treatment. It determined that the NDIA's decision did not sufficiently account for the evidence presented and set aside the decision, substituting it with a decision that chiropractic treatment is a reasonable and necessary support for Ms McCutcheon.

Orders

Orders of the court

The decision under review is set aside and in its place the decision is substituted that chiropractic treatment is a reasonable and necessary support for Ms McCutcheon.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Also before the Tribunal are a written statement by Ms McCutcheon, documents provided by the NDIA (the “T-documents”), reports from Dr Young, Ms Zahl and Dr Sherry, a letter from Ms McCutcheon’s general practitioner Dr Carmen Hristea, and a number of reports concerning the effectiveness or otherwise of manipulative therapy in the treatment of spinal and other disorders.Ms McCutcheon’s evidence Ms McCutcheon is 38 years old and the single parent of an eight-year-old daughter. Her medical conditions are complex. She was born with closed spina bifida. When she was 13, she underwent an extensive fusion of her lumbar spine from L2-S1 to correct her scoliosis and de-tether her spinal cord. She has left hip Perthes’ disease. She is on nocturnal dialysis following a failed kidney transplant and is on the waiting list for a further transplant. In about 2008, she suffered a heart attack, possibly related to her renal disease, and had a stent inserted. After studying bookkeeping and administration, Ms McCutcheon worked part-time from 2000 to 2007 as a bookkeeper and receptionist for the Barwon Disability and Resource Council. She was paid for 20 hours a week but says her hours were often longer. She stopped working around the time her daughter was born. After her daughter started school in 2012, Ms McCutcheon went back to work, managing her church’s opportunity shop. She was paid for 10 hours a week but says she often worked longer hours. She left that position in mid-2013 because of what she describes as “difficult personal circumstances”. She then started cleaning houses for friends and worked for up to six hours a week cleaning two to three houses. She stopped that work in about May 2014 when she could not continue because of her deteriorating physical health. She gave evidence that she has applied for a number of jobs since, and has had a number of interviews, but prospective employers “see only the wheelchair, and not the person”. Before her daughter was born, Ms McCutcheon used a walking frame, sticks and a wheelchair at different times. She gave evidence that, when she learned she was pregnant, she decided she had to do something to improve her mobility so that she could care for her daughter. Between 2002 and 2008, Ms McCutcheon’s general practitioner referred her from time to time to the Barwon Community Rehabilitation Centre (BCRC) where she was assessed and reviewed for gait aids, exercise programs, wheelchair assessment, and a multidisciplinary program including occupational therapy, rehabilitation and physical therapy. She was discharged from BCRC in 2008 when she became eligible for State funding for an Individual Support Package (ISP). She received ISP funding until transferring to the NDIS when she became a participant in that scheme. Progress notes from Barwon Health in July 2006 show that Ms McCutcheon had been seeing a chiropractor regularly to assist with neck and back pain and headaches, and realignment of her upper spine. A note in November 2007 shows she was advised to see her chiropractor “for ongoing back”.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The CEO of the NDIA has made Operational Guidelines to assist staff in making decisions and performing other functions under the Act. The Operational Guidelines represent government policy and should be applied by the Tribunal unless there is good reason not to do so: Re Drake and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No 2) (1979) 2 ALD 634.The decision under review Ms McCutcheon became a participant in the NDIS on 9 January 2014. On 19 April 2014, a plan was approved by which funding was provided for supports including occupational therapy and household assistance. It did not include funding for chiropractic care. Ms McCutcheon asked the NDIA to review that decision. On 24 July 2014, the NDIA affirmed its decision that the provision of chiropractic treatment was not a reasonable and necessary support within the meaning of the Act. That decision was made under s 100(6) of the Act and is one that the Tribunal has power to review (see s 103). The issue The NDIA submits that chiropractic treatment is not a reasonable and necessary support for Ms McCutcheon because it does not meet s 34(1)(d) or s 34(1)(f). The other criteria in s 34(1) are not in dispute and I am satisfied that each is met. I have to decide whether chiropractic treatment for Ms McCutcheon:(i)will be, or is likely to be, effective and beneficial for her, having regard to current good practice; and (ii)is most appropriately funded or provided through the NDIS, and is not more appropriately funded or provided through other general systems of service delivery or support services offered by a person, agency or body, or systems of service delivery or support services offered: (i) as part of a universal service obligation; or (ii)in accordance with reasonable adjustments required under a law dealing with discrimination on the basis of disability.Information before the Tribunal The Tribunal heard evidence at a hearing on 11 August 2015 from Ms McCutcheon, her treating chiropractor Dr Belinda Young, her current physiotherapist Ms Emma Zahl, and Dr Elisabeth Sherry, a rehabilitation physician who gave evidence at the request of the NDIA. Also before the Tribunal are a written statement by Ms McCutcheon, documents provided by the NDIA (the “T-documents”), reports from Dr Young, Ms Zahl and Dr Sherry, a letter from Ms McCutcheon’s general practitioner Dr Carmen Hristea, and a number of reports concerning the effectiveness or otherwise of manipulative therapy in the treatment of spinal and other disorders.Ms McCutcheon’s evidence Ms McCutcheon is 38 years old and the single parent of an eight-year-old daughter. Her medical conditions are complex. She was born with closed spina bifida. When she was 13, she underwent an extensive fusion of her lumbar spine from L2-S1 to correct her scoliosis and de-tether her spinal cord. She has left hip Perthes’ disease. She is on nocturnal dialysis following a failed kidney transplant and is on the waiting list for a further transplant. In about 2008, she suffered a heart attack, possibly related to her renal disease, and had a stent inserted.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

On the information before me, I am satisfied that chiropractic treatment can amount to current good practice for the purposes of s 34(1)(d). Taking into account that Dr Young, Ms Zahl and Dr Sherry agree that it serves a purpose in maintaining Ms McCutcheon’s functioning, I am satisfied that a collaborative approach which includes chiropractic treatment as proposed by Dr Sherry and supported by Ms Zahl reflects current good practice in her case. How long it remains effective and beneficial, and whether other forms of treatment or therapy are more so, will have to be determined in time. Consideration The NDIA submits that the quality of the available evidence is insufficient for the Tribunal to be satisfied, on the balance of probabilities, of the likely effectiveness and benefits of chiropractic treatment for Ms McCutcheon. It is submitted that, at best, it will assist in maintaining a level of functioning, and there is no evidence that it will achieve any medium or long term change or improvement in her condition. Moreover, it is submitted, her mobility declined even with continuing chiropractic treatment until early 2015. Dr Sherry readily acknowledged the limitations of the research she was able to do in the short time available to her and the limited role that literature can play in determining the most effective treatment in an individual case. In particular, she acknowledged the limited clinical history she had and the limited relevance of the studies to Ms McCutcheon’s particular conditions. Against that are a number of studies suggesting positive outcomes which also suffer from limited relevance to Ms McCutcheon’s particular conditions. In these circumstances, Ms McCutcheon’s lived experience is especially relevant. The NDIA submits that Ms McCutcheon’s evidence of her “lived experience” is of limited probative value because s 34(1)(d) necessarily requires a degree of objectivity that is lacking in her evidence and that of Dr Young. I do not think this argument can be sustained. Ms McCutcheon’s “lived experience”, which I understand to mean her first-hand knowledge, experience and understanding of her conditions and various treatments, will inevitably be subjective. How much weight “lived experience” should be given will depend on all of the available evidence. Where it is consistent with reliable, relevant, independent evidence, it will likely be given a good deal of weight. Where it is at odds with other evidence, it may be given less weight. Where reliable, relevant, independent evidence is lacking, evidence of “lived experience” may be particularly important. Dr Sherry had no argument with the role of chiropractic treatment in maintaining Ms McCutcheon’s functioning. She questioned how much this was attributable to the psychological effect of Ms McCutcheon’s “faith” in the treatment but she did not question the role of that strong belief in achieving a benefit. It is not suggested that Ms McCutcheon was not open and truthful. I have no reason to doubt her evidence or that of Dr Young that, from around 2007, she was able, with chiropractic treatment in combination with other treatments, to improve her mobility and manage for the most part without walking aids or a wheelchair. The evidence is that, from around April 2014 when her treatment became less regular, she experienced increasing problems with her mobility. From around the time she ceased chiropractic treatment altogether, she has become heavily dependent on a wheelchair and her ability to function in caring for her daughter, managing household tasks, and in social and work activities, is now seriously reduced.