O’Hearn and National Disability Insurance Agency

Link copied
Case Copied 70 min read

O’Hearn and National Disability Insurance Agency [2023] AATA 4141 (15 December 2023)

Division:NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME DIVISION

File Number(s): 2022/9680

Re:Judith O’Hearn

APPLICANT

AndNational Disability Insurance Agency

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Member W Frost

Date:15 December 2023

Place:Canberra

The Tribunal sets aside the decision under review pursuant to subsection 43(1)(c) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 and makes a decision, in substitution for the decision so set aside, to approve a statement of participant supports that specifies:

(a)the Applicant’s National Disability Scheme (NDIS) plan is to be self-managed;

(b)the date by which the CEO of the Respondent must reassess the plan pursuant to Division 4 of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 is 12 months from the date of this decision; and

(c)the reasonable and necessary supports that will be funded under the NDIS are as follows:

Core supports:

  1. Low-cost AT - Communication or Cognitive Support – up to an amount of $1,500;
  2. Low-cost AT - Personal Care And Safety – up to an amount of $1,300;
  3. Low-cost AT - Hearing Related AT – up to an amount of $100;
  4. Pool hire fees for twice weekly physiotherapy sessions;
  5. Continence aids – up to an amount of $16,717.49;
  6. House And/or Yard Maintenance - 2 hours per fortnight (total of 52 hours per year);
  7. Assistance With Self-Care Activities - Standard - Weekday Daytime – 6 hours per week, for 52 weeks (total of 312 hours per year);
  8. Assistance with Personal Domestic Activities - 4 hours per week for 52 weeks (total of 208 hours per year);
  9. Medium Term Accommodation – 21 days;
  10. Access Community Social And Rec Activities - Weekday Daytime – 140 hours, consisting of:

xi.2 hours per week for 52 weeks (total of 104 hours per year);

xii.6 hours per week for 6 weeks (total of 36 hours); and

  1. Transport funding (level 3) to be paid into Ms O'Hearn's nominated bank account on a fortnightly basis;

Capacity building supports:

  1. Assessment Recommendation Therapy or Training – Physiotherapist – 244 hours per year, consisting of:

ii.156 hours of physiotherapy to be used flexibly in land and water-based environments;

iii.52 hours for physiotherapist travel;

iv.30 hours at the physiotherapy rate for a 6-week intensive rehabilitation period;

v.6 hours for report writing;

  1. Provision of Hearing Services by an Audiologist – 6 hours; and
  2. Support Coordination Level 2: Coordination of Supports 36 hours per year;

Capital supports:

  1. The bathroom modifications that are the subject of the quote from FTCI Pty Ltd dated 18 July 2023;
  2. Repairs and Maintenance – Wheeled Mobility Major (quote required);
  3. Minor repairs and maintenance of Assistive technology equipment – up to an amount of $500;
  4. Postural Support Using Air Floatation or Automated Pressure Management – up to an amount of $1,220.21;
  5. The vehicle modifications that are the subject of the quote from Problem Management Engineering Pty Ltd dated 27 February 2023;
  6. Hearing aids – up to an amount of $5,060.00;
  7. Building Works Project Management;
  8. The following kitchen modifications:
  • cook top with hob2hood - up to an…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read O’Hearn and National Disability Insurance Agency and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] AATA 4141
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by Ms O’Hearn for review of a decision by the National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA) regarding supports to be included in her NDIS plan. The primary dispute before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) was whether a requested bathroom modification constituted a "reasonable and necessary" support under the *National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013* (Cth).

The AAT was required to determine if the proposed bathroom modification met the criteria for reasonable and necessary supports as defined by section 34 of the NDIS Act, specifically whether it represented value for money and was most appropriately funded or provided through the NDIS. While other supports were initially in dispute, the parties reached agreement on most, leaving only the bathroom modification as the sole issue for determination.

The Tribunal found that the requested bathroom modification, which included the removal of the existing bath and installation of a custom bath with a transfer bench and steps, along with a shower screen, met the criteria for reasonable and necessary supports. The NDIA conceded that the support was appropriate and not more appropriately funded by other service systems. The Tribunal was satisfied that the modification represented value for money, considering the quote of $19,974.22 and the significant benefits to Ms O’Hearn's personal care, safety, and functional capacity, which would also help prevent further functional decline and reduce the need for future supports.

The AAT set aside the NDIA's decision and substituted it with a new decision approving a statement of participant supports. This included the bathroom modifications, increased physiotherapy and hydrotherapy hours, medium-term accommodation, and various other core and capital supports, reflecting a total funded amount of $187,604.31.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The issue for determination by the Tribunal in this proceeding was whether the support requested by Ms O’Hearn to be funded by the NDIA, being a bathroom modification, is ‘reasonable and necessary’, pursuant to section 34 of the NDIS Act, for inclusion in the statement of participant supports in her NDIS plan. BACKGROUND Ms O’Hearn is 56 years old and lives with her family in the Northern Territory.[1] [1] Exhibit 1, page 140. In 1993, Ms O’Hearn was diagnosed with incomplete paraplegia at T5 level following surgery to remove a cyst from her spine and has from that time relied on a manual wheelchair to mobilise.[2] Ms O’Hearn has also been diagnosed with bilateral arthritis of the shoulders and a bilateral hearing impairment managed with hearing aids.[3] [2] Ibid., pages 21 and 1295. [3] Ibid. See also Exhibit 1, pages 95-122. Ms O’Hearn has worked full-time for the Northern Territory Government for 35 years and is currently a Career Practitioner with a senior secondary school.[4] Among other achievements, Ms O’Hearn competed at the Sydney Paralympics in 2000.[5] [4] Ibid., pages 1295-1296. [5] Ibid., page 1295. On 6 September 2022, the NDIA approved a statement of participant supports for Ms O’Hearn in a plan pursuant to subsection 33(2) of the NDIS Act. On 21 November 2022, the NDIA made a decision under subsection 100(6) of the NDIS Act affirming its decision of 6 September 2022.[6] The NDIA declined, among other requested supports, home modifications to the bathroom, kitchen, pool and pathways around Ms O’Hearn’s home.[7][6] Ibid., pages 13-19. [7] Ibid. On 24 November 2022, Ms O’Hearn made an application to the Tribunal for review of the NDIA’s decision.[8] On 31 March 2023, Ms O’Hearn confirmed the particular supports she requested be approved for her NDIS plan, relevantly including modifications to the main bathroom of the home entailing removal of the existing bath and installation of a custom bath for her use and increased support for physiotherapy and hydrotherapy. [8] Ibid., pages 4-12. On 14 September 2023, under subsection 42D(1) of the AAT Act, the Tribunal remitted the reviewable decision to the NDIA. On 18 September 2023, the NDIA set aside the reviewable decision and, in substitution for that decision, made a new decision which approved Ms O’Hearn’s current NDIS plan. That decision changed the statement of participant supports and provided total funded supports for Ms O’Hearn in the amount of $187,604.31.[9] Therefore, pursuant to subsection 42D(4)(a) of the AAT Act, the decision under review before the Tribunal became the NDIA’s decision of 18 September 2023. [9] Ibid., pages 139-153. Accordingly, during the course of this proceeding, Ms O’Hearn has withdrawn her request for certain supports and reached agreement with the NDIA regarding other supports. As a result, at the Tribunal hearing on 12 October 2023, the following supports remained in dispute between the parties:(a)the bathroom modification (including removal of the existing bath, installation of a custom bath containing a transfer bench and steps into the bath, and installation of a shower screen); (b)medium term accommodation for the period of time required for the bathroom modification and other works to be undertaken; (c)an increase to physiotherapy support funding (to allow for a total of 52 hours of physiotherapy support per year, instead of 38 hours of therapy assistant support); and (d)an increase to hydrotherapy support funding (to allow for a total of 104 hours of hydrotherapy support per year, instead of 48 hours).

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Schedule 1 of the Supports Rules sets out the considerations to be taken into account when deciding whether it is appropriate for the NDIS to fund a particular support (as opposed to another service system), including health, mental health, higher education and vocational education and training, employment, housing and community infrastructure and transport. EVIDENCELay evidenceMs O’Hearn The Tribunal has considered Ms O’Hearn’s Statement of Lived Experience filed in this proceeding and dated 4 July 2023.[11] Most relevantly for the remaining disputed support, Ms O’Hearn stated the following:[12][11] Exhibit 1, pages 1295-1309. [12] Ibid., pages 1297 and 1301-1304. I do not have normal pain sensation, so I don’t always know if I have hurt myself or if I am doing something that harms me.I have poor core stability as my injury to my spine is just under my breast line. This results in having poor balance and diminished control of my trunk, reaching down requires me to pull myself upright with my arms.I cannot regulate my body temperature and can easily overheat or get hypothermia. I take on the temperature of my surroundings and find it hard to restore correct core temperature. I have poor circulation which means I am susceptible to fluid retention and injuries take longer to heal due to poor blood flow.I have poor bone density due to not weight bearing which means that a simple knock or fall can cause a fracture. I have fallen out of my chair on a couple of occasions and have caused fractures to my spine and I also ended up with 3 complete breaks in my leg.I cause abnormal wear and tear to parts of my body such as my arms as I am overloading them in a way they were not designed for. Recovery from any set back or harm to my arms take a lot longer to recover as I can take the load off them and requires more intense intervention. …My house has a main bathroom with a bath and shower combined. My ensuite has a shower, toilet and pedestal basin. When I bought my house, I was able to use my bath in the main bathroom. I currently use the ensuite shower which we modified at our own expense, when we first moved into our house. We added grab rails in the shower area and near the toilet and removed the shower screen and the ensuite door so that I could wheel in and fit in the space……I now do not have the functional capacity to stand and step into the shower recess. To use the ensuite shower I now have to do a wheel stand in my wheelchair to jump over the shower recess lip, wheel into the shower recess area and then do a seated transfer onto a plastic stool. To do this I am positioning my wheelchair on a wet surface to transfer onto the shower chair that is also on a wet surface. I have started to have falls onto the ensuite shower floor as my chair has slipped. I have jarred my arms from trying to break my fall and have caused further injury to my arms in this process. …Unfortunately, there is not enough space to add a solid permanent seat in the shower in a way that I could wheel next to. Adding more grabrails also would not fix the transfer hazard as I am still transferring onto a stool on a wet surface with less strength than I used to have.…I also used to use the main bathroom which has a large open space with a large triangular spa bath with an overhead shower. Initially I could get in and out of the bath with ease, as my legs had more function and my arms were stronger without any impingement to lift myself without any steps.Over time this ability to use the bath has decreased to the stage that it is currently impossible to get in and out, even using a bath board. I have not been able to access the bath now for a number of years. I have tried to get funding from NDIS for over 4 years now to properly modify the bath so that I can access it. …The bath is needed for much more than relaxation. There is so much more I can do in a bath that I cannot safely do in a shower. In a bath I can stretch my legs straight while supported which means that I can properly wash all of my body…I can reach my feet in a bath and I can safely collect any items I drop. Because I am able to stretch out in a bath I am able to take the pressure off my legs and give my feet some attention. I can lean forward to reach my feet without having any balance issues or fear of falling off the shower chair while I give my body more attention.…I have experienced a functional decline which has been exacerbated by not having proper funding to access sufficient therapy support hours and because I am overworking arms and shoulders to reach things due to my home and car not being appropriately accessible to cater adequately for my needs. …Transfers from my wheelchair to the custom bath will also incorporate important functional exercise to my routine as I will perform smaller incremental arm push up movements that strengthen arms and core to get into the bath. My OT and my physio have explained that these exercises will also then help to increase my functional capacity which will help make accessing my current ensuite shower safer in the future too. Increased functional capacity will help with safety for all transfers including use of the toilet etc and will help prevent further functional decline and the need for additional supports in the future. Transfers to the bath would be safer than transfers to a shower as I can position my chair on a dry surface, transfer to a dry surface and transfer onto a solid permanent structure. I can sense temperature in my upper limbs and can add a temperature gauge to the bath to remove any risk in relation to bath temperature. I have never had any issue with entering a bath that was too hot as I always test with my hand. If a bigger shower was added to my main bathroom I would still not be able to attend to personal care independently. I would still not be able to straighten my legs unsupported to attend to all personal care. I would still not have access to all of the other benefits a bath provides to address swelling with submersion, pain, relaxation and incorporated functional exercise. Being able to get all of these benefits in one place with a bath would be time efficient and clearly the most cost effective option.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Having considered all of the evidence, the Tribunal is satisfied that the requested support, being the bathroom modification, meets the requisite criteria to be approved as ‘reasonable and necessary’ under the NDIS Act and for inclusion in the statement of participant supports in Ms O’Hearn’s NDIS plan. DECISION The Tribunal sets aside the decision under review pursuant to subsection 43(1)(c) of the AAT Act and makes a decision, in substitution for the decision so set aside, to approve a statement of participant supports that specifies:(a)the Applicant’s NDIS plan is to be self-managed;(b)the date by which the CEO of the Respondent must reassess the plan pursuant to Division 4 of the NDIS Act is 12 months from the date of this decision; and(c)the reasonable and necessary supports that will be funded under the NDIS are as follows:Core supports: Low-cost AT - Communication or Cognitive Support – up to an amount of $1,500; Low-cost AT - Personal Care And Safety – up to an amount of $1,300; Low-cost AT - Hearing Related AT – up to an amount of $100; Pool hire fees for twice weekly physiotherapy sessions; Continence aids – up to an amount of $16,717.49; House And/or Yard Maintenance - 2 hours per fortnight (total of 52 hours per year); Assistance With Self-Care Activities - Standard - Weekday Daytime – 6 hours per week, for 52 weeks (total of 312 hours per year); Assistance with Personal Domestic Activities - 4 hours per week for 52 weeks (total of 208 hours per year); Medium Term Accommodation – 21 days; Access Community Social And Rec Activities - Weekday Daytime – 140 hours, consisting of:xi.2 hours per week for 52 weeks (total of 104 hours per year); xii.6 hours per week for 6 weeks (total of 36 hours); and Transport funding (level 3) to be paid into Ms O'Hearn's nominated bank account on a fortnightly basis;Capacity building supports: Assessment Recommendation Therapy or Training – Physiotherapist – 244 hours per year, consisting of: ii.156 hours of physiotherapy to be used flexibly in land and water-based environments; iii.52 hours for physiotherapist travel;iv.30 hours at the physiotherapy rate for a 6-week intensive rehabilitation period;v.6 hours for report writing; Provision of Hearing Services by an Audiologist – 6 hours; and Support Coordination Level 2: Coordination of Supports 36 hours per year;Capital supports: The bathroom modifications that are the subject of the quote from FTCI Pty Ltd dated 18 July 2023; Repairs and Maintenance – Wheeled Mobility Major (quote required); Minor repairs and maintenance of Assistive technology equipment – up to an amount of $500; Postural Support Using Air Floatation or Automated Pressure Management – up to an amount of $1,220.21; The vehicle modifications that are the subject of the quote from Problem Management Engineering Pty Ltd dated 27 February 2023; Hearing aids – up to an amount of $5,060.00; Building Works Project Management; The following kitchen modifications: cook top with hob2hood - up to an amount of $3,299.00; oven with telescopic rails – up to an amount of $3,199.00; and the building modifications that are the subject of the quote from FTCI Pty Ltd dated 18 July 2023; and The carport modifications that are the subject of the quote from Leadercrete dated 26 January 2023.(d)Pursuant to subsection 43(6) of the AAT Act, the Tribunal’s decision is to take effect on the day that is 21 days after the day of the Tribunal’s decision.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

However, as detailed above, the NDIA in its written closing submissions in this proceeding accepted that there should be an increase in the number of hours for Ms O’Hearn’s physiotherapy and hydrotherapy, including the recommended six week intensive ‘booster period’ of these therapies. In addition, the NDIA accepted at the Tribunal hearing that Ms O’Hearn’s NDIS plan made on 18 September 2023, after the commencement of this proceeding, contained a number of errors and did not include some of the supports that are reasonable and necessary for Ms O’Hearn. Accordingly, the NDIA submitted that the decision under review should be set aside and substituted with a decision to detail all of the reasonable and necessary supports to be included in Ms O’Hearn’s NDIS plan, including the increased therapy hours, but not the requested bathroom modification. CONSIDERATION The Tribunal sets out below its consideration and findings in relation to the bathroom modification requested by Ms O’Hearn to be funded under the NDIS, which remained the only support in dispute between the parties in this proceeding after the receipt of their written closing submissions. This support is a modification of the main bathroom in the family home, which would include the removal of the existing bath, installation of a custom bath containing a transfer bench and steps into the bath, and the installation of a shower screen. It would also include an overhead shower in the bathtub. As set out above, the dispute between the parties ultimately focused on the requested bathroom modification and whether or not that support satisfied subsection 34(1)(c) and (d) of the NDIS Act or engaged rule 5.1 of the Supports Rules. Subsection 34(1) of the NDIS Act requires satisfaction of all of the matters set out in that provision. It was not disputed by the NDIA that the requested support met the balance of the provisions in subsection 34(1) of the NDIS Act. For the avoidance of doubt, based on the available evidence, the Tribunal is satisfied that the requested bathroom modification meets subsection 34(1)(a), (b), (e) and (f) of the NDIS Act. Does the bathroom modification represent value for money? Subsection 34(1)(c) of the NDIS Act requires the Tribunal to be satisfied that the requested bathroom modification represents value for money in that the costs of the support are reasonable, relative to both the benefits achieved and the cost of alternative support. Rule 3.1 of the Supports Rules sets out matters to be considered in deciding whether a support represents value for money. The costs of the requested support, which were unchallenged by the NDIA, were contained in a quote most recently provided in July 2023 by an installer in the Northern Territory, which totalled $19,974.22.[23] The bathroom modification works quote included: construction of a new custom bathtub and ‘transition bench/seat to new dimensions of 2800mm long x 900mm wide x 600mm high’, with the bathtub to be a ‘minimum of 1750mm in length’; the building of ‘2 x set of steps for entry/exit to the bath with handrails mounted to LHS [left hand side] of bathtub to meet Australian Standards’; and installation of ‘new non-slip floor tiles to the remaining bathroom floor’.[24] [23] Exhibit 1, pages 1318-1319. [24] Ibid.