QTBR and National Disability Insurance Agency

Link copied
Case Copied 69 min read

QTBR and National Disability Insurance Agency [2021] AATA 1951 (28 June 2021)

Division:NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME DIVISION

File Number(s): 2019/3300

Re:QTBR

APPLICANT

AndNational Disability Insurance Agency

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Member W Frost

Date:28 June 2021

Place:Canberra

The Tribunal affirms the decision under review pursuant to subsection 43(1)(a) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975.

..............................[sgd]..............................

Member W Frost

Catchwords

NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME – reasonable and necessary supports – disability requirements – cerebral palsy – congenital cytomegalovirus – epilepsy – neural migrational defects – microcephaly – developmental delay – congenital profound sensorineural deafness – whether the disputed supports requested by Applicant are reasonable and necessary pursuant to subsection 34(1) of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act – whether requested supports are duplicates of other supports already funded by the National Disability Insurance Agency – decision under review affirmed.

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act1975 ss 42D, 43.

National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 ss 3-4, 33-35, 100, 209.

National Disability Insurance Scheme (Support for Participants) Rules 2013.

Cases

Drake and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No 2) (1979) 2 ALD 634.

Madelaine and National Disability Insurance Agency [2019] AATA 4025.

McCutcheon and National Disability Insurance Agency [2015] AATA 624.

McGarrigle v National Disability Insurance Agency [2017] FCA 308.

TKCW and NDIA [2014] AATA 501.

TYKL and NDIA [2021] AATA 135.

Secondary Materials

A. Ulate-Campos, F. Coughlin, M. Gaı´nza-Lein, I. Sa´nchez Ferna´ndez, P.L. Pearl, T. Loddenkemper, Automated seizure detection systems and their effectiveness for each type of seizure, Seizure, (Volume 40, pages 88-101).

Bibbo, Jessica, Kerri E Rodriguez, and Marguerite E O’Haire, Impact of Service Dogs on Family

Members’ Psychosocial Functioning, The American journal of occupational therapy : official

publication of the American Occupational Therapy Association 73.3 (2019): 7303205120, pages 1-11 < Amélie et al., Dog Alerting And/or Responding to Epileptic Seizures: A Scoping Review, PloS one 13.12 (2018): e0208280. < align="left">Including Specific Types of Supports in Plans Operational Guideline - Assistance Animals

Lundqvist, Martina, Jenny Alwin, and Lars-Ake Levin, Certified Service Dogs – A Cost Effectiveness Analysis appraisal, PLoS ONE 14.9 (2019): e0219911. < Martinez-Caja, Ana et al. Seizure-Alerting Behavior in Dogs Owned by People Experiencing Seizures, Epilepsy & Behavior 94 (2019), pages 104–111.

Operational Guideline – Planning – Deciding to include supports in a participant’s plan

REASONS FOR DECISION

Member W Frost

28 June 2021

INTRODUCTION

  1. The Applicant, QTBR, is eight years old and, since 2016, a participant in the National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS). She has multiple significant impairments, including cerebral palsy and epilepsy, that require substantial support from her family, medical practitioners, the community and the NDIS.

  2. In June 2018, the National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA) approved a statement of participant supports for QTBR under the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (NDIS Act). A subsequent decision of the NDIA in May 2019 regarding QTBR’s supports is the decision under review by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read QTBR and National Disability Insurance Agency and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] AATA 1951
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by QTBR for review of a decision made by the National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA) regarding the supports to be included in her NDIS plan. QTBR has multiple severe disabilities, including cerebral palsy, epilepsy, and profound sensorineural deafness. The Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) was required to determine whether certain disputed supports requested by QTBR were reasonable and necessary under subsection 34(1) of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth).

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was to assess whether the remaining disputed supports, which included funding for an assistance dog, a Thermomix, intensive feeding therapy, communication support, intensive neurological and physical habilitation, low-cost assistive technology, and additional capacity building support for report writing, met the criteria of being "reasonable and necessary" for inclusion in QTBR's NDIS plan. This assessment involved considering the NDIA's Operational Guidelines, which stipulate that supports will not be funded if they are likely to cause harm, are unrelated to the participant's disability, duplicate other funded supports, or relate to day-to-day living costs not attributable to disability needs.

The Tribunal considered the evidence presented, including the testimony of QTBR's mother, regarding the severity and impact of QTBR's conditions, particularly her frequent and severe epileptic seizures and the associated risks. Despite the NDIA having approved a significant amount of funding and agreeing to some previously disputed supports during the proceedings, the Tribunal found that the remaining disputed supports did not meet the criteria for being reasonable and necessary. The Tribunal applied the principles outlined in the NDIS Act and relevant Operational Guidelines, weighing the evidence against these legal standards.

Ultimately, the Tribunal affirmed the NDIA's decision under review. This means that the additional requested supports that remained in dispute were not approved for inclusion in QTBR's NDIS plan, as they were found not to meet the necessary criteria.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The Tribunal must decide whether the disputed supports requested by QTBR are reasonable and necessary pursuant to subsection 33(2) of the NDIS Act for inclusion in the statement of participant supports in her NDIS plan. BACKGROUND QTBR lives with her parents and two siblings in regional New South Wales. QTBR has been diagnosed with cerebral palsy, congenital cytomegalovirus, epilepsy, neural migrational defects, microcephaly, developmental delay, congenital profound sensorineural deafness, she is also non-verbal and has food intolerances.[1][1] Exhibit R1, T1, page 2; T7, page 27. Since September 2016, QTBR has been a participant in the NDIS. Relevant to this proceeding, the NDIA approved a statement of participant supports for QTBR under subsection 33(2) of the NDIS Act on 19 June 2018.[2] A review of this decision was requested on behalf of QTBR.[3][2] Exhibit R1, T24, pages 114-122. [3] Exhibit R1, T1B, pages 7-18. On 24 May 2019, the NDIA made a decision regarding the supports provided to QTBR.[4] This is the reviewable decision before the Tribunal. [4] Exhibit R1, T2, pages 19-21. On 12 June 2019, QTBR applied to the Tribunal for review of the NDIA’s decision.[5] Because of the nature of the NDIA’s decision regarding QTBR’s supports, there was uncertainty about the Tribunal’s jurisdiction to review that decision. In late June 2019, the Tribunal, differently constituted, was satisfied that the NDIA’s May 2019 decision could be treated as one made under section 100 of the NDIS Act and was therefore reviewable by the Tribunal. [5] Exhibit R1, T1, pages 1-5. On 3 June 2020, pursuant to subsection 42D(1) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (AAT Act), the Tribunal remitted the reviewable decision to the NDIA for reconsideration following the parties’ agreement regarding certain disputed supports in this proceeding. As a result, on 22 June 2020, the NDIA issued a new twelve month NDIS plan for QTBR. The total funded supports for QTBR under this NDIS plan was $644,258.11 for core supports, capacity building supports and capital supports. On 22 April 2021, again following the consent of the parties, the Tribunal remitted the decision under review to the NDIA for reconsideration pursuant to subsection 42D(1) of the AAT Act. On 3 May 2021, being the first day of the Tribunal hearing in this proceeding, the NDIA varied the decision under review to replicate QTBR’s existing supports until November 2021 and included further agreed supports.[6] QTBR’s total funding for this six month period is $288,343.42. [6] Exhibit R3. From 3 to 6 May 2021, the Tribunal held a hearing in this proceeding. In circumstances where the NDIA accepted a number of requested supports as reasonable and necessary during the course of this proceeding, and indeed accepted one communication support before closing submissions at the hearing due to the late provision of relevant evidence by QTBR, it is helpful to set out the following supports that remained in dispute between the parties and which are the subject of this decision:(a)Funding in the sum of $40,000 for an assistance dog from the Centre for Service and Therapy Dogs Australia (CSTDA) to be delivered over a two year program, plus yearly maintenance funding in the sum of $2,664 (First Disputed Support); (b)A Thermomix valued at $2,269 (Second Disputed Support); (c)Feeding Support, comprising: (i) an intensive feeding clinic of 10.9 hours; and (ii) regular sessions totalling 35.8 hours (Third Disputed Support); (e) Communication Support, being programming and training of assistive technology for 32 hours (Fourth Disputed Support); (f) Neurological and Physical Abilitation Centre (NAPA) intensive therapy for 120 hours (Fifth Disputed Support); (h) Low risk and low cost assistive technology totalling $2,690.45 (Sixth Disputed Support); and (i) An additional 30 hours of Capacity Building Support for report writing (Seventh Disputed Support).LEGISLATION & POLICYThe NDIS Act

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

These Operational Guidelines represent government policy and, to the extent they are consistent with the relevant legislation, should be applied by the Tribunal unless there is a good reason not to do so.[10] EVIDENCEQTBR’s Mother[10] Drake and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No 2) (1979) 2 ALD 634. See also Madelaine and National Disability Insurance Agency [2019] AATA 4025 at [9]. Examination-in-chief QTBR’s mother (Mother) gave evidence to the Tribunal by MS Teams. Although qualified and occasionally working in the natural health field, the Mother is now predominantly the full-time carer for QTBR. QTBR’s mother and father (Father), a self-employed tradesman, also have two other children. The couple tragically lost another child after birth. QTBR’s Father was said to suffer Post-traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) due to this death and from witnessing QTBR suffering her seizures. QTBR was born at 28 weeks gestation, but it was not until an MRI was performed at six months of age that she was diagnosed with severe disabilities. The couple first noticed QTBR’s experiencing her ‘first big’ epileptic seizure when she was four years old. Her Mother said the seizures can happen at ‘any time’ during either the day or night and these can become ‘clusters’ of seizures. These occurred between one and two times each week. On a ‘bad day’, QTBR can have thirty seizures. Her Mother said that she and her husband have been told that QTBR is at high risk of ‘SUDEP’, being sudden unexpected death due to epilepsy. This means ‘the best thing’ they can do is get to QTBR as ‘soon as possible’, even shaking her to ‘get her out the seizure’, because the longer a seizure continues the higher the risk of death. QTBR’s Mother told the Tribunal that her daughter’s seizures are becoming ‘a lot worse’. When QTBR was four, she had a seizure once a month; they are now daily. QTBR is given the medication, ‘Midazolam’, for her seizures, but she is becoming ‘more resistant’ to this medication. She often requires intravenous assistance. QTBR was said to have experienced a ‘big’ brain injury in February last year, following which she lost the ability to swallow and had to be fed by a feeding tube. She has slowly regained her oral feeding and drinking ability. The Tribunal was told by her Mother that QTBR having a longer fit can lead to brain damage due to a lack of oxygen; she turns blue and goes into hypoxia. QTBR requires oxygen ‘most times’ when she is having a cluster of seizures, at around four to five times each day for ‘big ones’. Her Mother was asked to explain the difference between a tonic seizure and a clonic seizure. The Tribunal was told that most tonic seizures resulted in a stiffening of the body that was gradual and hard to detect, especially in someone with low muscle tone. Whereas a clonic seizure involves repetitive movement of the body. Her Mother said 90% of QTBR’s seizures are now tonic seizures, where she does not move. She said it is ‘hard to tell’ when QTBR is ‘fitting’; she has to keep an eye on her face and QTBR can be ‘blue’ or ‘frothing at the mouth’. When the other person looks directly at QTBR’s face they may notice a twitch of her lip or that her eyes are turning up to one side.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The NDIA is currently providing substantial support to QTBR. During the hearing, the NDIA approved further support that had until then been in dispute in this proceeding. However, at this time, and weighing all the evidence, the additional requested supports that remained in dispute do not, as a result of the Tribunal’s findings, meet the necessary criteria to be approved as ‘reasonable and necessary’ for inclusion in the statement of participant supports in QTBR’s NDIS plan. DECISION The Tribunal affirms the decision under review pursuant to subsection 43(1)(a) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Clauses 5.1 and 5.2 of the Rules set out general criteria for supports, as follows:A support will not be provided or funded under the NDIS if:(a) it is likely to cause harm to the participant or pose a risk to others; or(b) it is not related to the participant’s disability; or(c) it duplicates other supports delivered under alternative funding through the NDIS; or(d) it relates to day-to-day living costs (for example, rent, groceries and utility fees) that are not attributable to a participant’s disability support needs.The day-to-day living costs referred to in paragraph 5.1(d) do not include the following (which may be funded under the NDIS if they relate to reasonable and necessary supports):(a) additional living costs that are incurred by a participant solely and directly as a result of their disability support needs;(b) costs that are ancillary to another support that is funded or provided under the participant’s plan, and which the participant would not otherwise incur.Operational Guidelines The NDIA has made numerous operational guidelines in relation to the application of the NDIS Act and the Rules. Relevant to this proceeding are the Operational Guideline – Planning – Deciding to include supports in a participant’s plan[8] and the Including Specific Types of Supports in Plans Operational Guideline - Assistance Animals (Assistance Animal Guideline).[9] The Assistance Animal Guideline contains guidance on the question of whether assistance animals are a reasonable and necessary support within the meaning of subsection 34(1) of the NDIS Act and Part 5 of the Rules. [8] Exhibit R1, T29, pages 170-212. [9] Exhibit R2, R13, pages 472-477. These Operational Guidelines represent government policy and, to the extent they are consistent with the relevant legislation, should be applied by the Tribunal unless there is a good reason not to do so.[10] EVIDENCEQTBR’s Mother[10] Drake and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No 2) (1979) 2 ALD 634. See also Madelaine and National Disability Insurance Agency [2019] AATA 4025 at [9]. Examination-in-chief QTBR’s mother (Mother) gave evidence to the Tribunal by MS Teams. Although qualified and occasionally working in the natural health field, the Mother is now predominantly the full-time carer for QTBR. QTBR’s mother and father (Father), a self-employed tradesman, also have two other children. The couple tragically lost another child after birth. QTBR’s Father was said to suffer Post-traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) due to this death and from witnessing QTBR suffering her seizures. QTBR was born at 28 weeks gestation, but it was not until an MRI was performed at six months of age that she was diagnosed with severe disabilities. The couple first noticed QTBR’s experiencing her ‘first big’ epileptic seizure when she was four years old. Her Mother said the seizures can happen at ‘any time’ during either the day or night and these can become ‘clusters’ of seizures. These occurred between one and two times each week. On a ‘bad day’, QTBR can have thirty seizures. Her Mother said that she and her husband have been told that QTBR is at high risk of ‘SUDEP’, being sudden unexpected death due to epilepsy. This means ‘the best thing’ they can do is get to QTBR as ‘soon as possible’, even shaking her to ‘get her out the seizure’, because the longer a seizure continues the higher the risk of death.