TKCW and National Disability Insurance Agency

Link copied
Case Copied 31 min read

[2014] AATA 501  

Division NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME DIVISION

File Number(s)

2014/0921

Re

TKCW

APPLICANT

And

National Disability Insurance Agency

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Senior Member J Toohey
Ian Thompson, Member

Date 23 July 2014  
Place Adelaide

The decision under review is affirmed.

..........................................................

Senior Member J Toohey

CATCHWORDS - NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME - child - Autism Spectrum Disorder- early intervention requirements - reasonable and necessary supports - The Listening Program - current good practice - child care support - decision under review affirmed

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act1975 s 35(2)

National Disability Insurance Scheme Act2013 ss 3, 3(3)(b), 4, 4(17), 21(1), 25(1), 32, 33(1) and (2), 34(1), 48(2), 100(6)

Secondary Materials

National Disability Insurance Scheme (Supports for Participants) Rules 2013

Kathy Carley “Sound Therapy: A Complementary Intervention for Individuals With Sensory Integration and Processing Disorders” (2013) 36 The American Occupational Therapy Association Inc

Margot Prior and Professor Roberts “Early Intervention for Children with Autism Spectrum Disorders: ‘Guidelines for Good Practice 2012’”

Sinha Y, Silove N, Hayen A and Williams K, “Auditory integration training and other sound therapies for autism spectrum disorders (ASD)” (2011) 12 The Cochrane Library

REASONS FOR DECISION

Senior Member J Toohey
Ian Thompson, Member

BACKGROUND

  1. This decision concerns TKCW, a three year old child who is one of twin brothers.  TKCW has Autism Spectrum Disorder.  He meets the early intervention requirements in the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (the NDIS Act) and is a participant in the National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS).

  2. As this matter concerns a child, the Tribunal has made an order under s 35(2) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 prohibiting the disclosure of information that might identify him.

    THE PLANS PREPARED FOR TKCW

  3. When a person becomes a participant in the NDIS, the National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA) must help him or her prepare a plan which comprises a statement of the person's goals, objectives, aspirations and personal circumstances, and a statement of participant supports which sets out the supports that will be funded or provided through the NDIS: ss 32, 33(1) and (2).

    The original plan

  4. In August 2013, the CEO of the NDIA approved a plan for TKCW that included funding for speech and occupational therapy, training for his parents in Creative Meaning therapy, specialist assessment of “in-home family support”, and childcare at home for parent respite for up to five hours each month.  We will call this plan, which came into effect on 30 August 2013, "the original plan".

  5. The original plan did not include funding for a carer to take TKCW to recreational activities each week, a carer for his twin brother while his mother takes him to weekly therapy sessions, support at home for TKCW's mother who has a disability herself, or for The Listening Program (TLP) which is a form of sound therapy.

    The amended plan

  6. In October 2013, the NDIA amended the original plan to include carer support for two hours each week to enable TKCW to attend a recreational activity…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read TKCW and National Disability Insurance Agency and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] AATA 501
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter under review was a decision of the National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA) not to fund the Listening Program (TLP) for TKCW, a child with Autism Spectrum Disorder, under the National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS). The decision was reviewed by the Tribunal, which was tasked with determining whether the NDIS should fund TLP for TKCW and whether the NDIS should fund a carer for TKCW's brother while TKCW attends therapy with his mother. The central issue was whether TLP met the criteria for funding as a reasonable and necessary support under the NDIS Act.

The Tribunal considered whether TLP represented current good practice and if there was sufficient evidence to suggest it would be effective and beneficial for TKCW. While acknowledging some positive anecdotal evidence, the Tribunal concluded that there was insufficient information to confidently assert the effectiveness and benefits of TLP for TKCW. The Tribunal also noted the importance of ensuring the financial sustainability of the NDIS, and the lack of reliable means to measure the benefits of TLP in TKCW's case. Consequently, the Tribunal found that funding TLP could undermine the financial sustainability of the scheme.

The Tribunal further examined whether TLP represented value for money by considering factors such as comparable supports, evidence of long-term benefits, and potential reductions in future costs. Given the uncertainties around the effectiveness of TLP and the lack of comparable evidence suggesting it would achieve better outcomes at a lower cost, the Tribunal determined that TLP did not represent value for money.

Based on these findings, the Tribunal affirmed the NDIA's decision not to fund TLP for TKCW. The Tribunal also concluded that it did not have the authority to review the subsequent plans made by the NDIA, as they were not decisions made by a reviewer under the NDIS Act.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

DB reports that she is not trained in TLP but she has worked with children and families who have used the program who have reported that "it has made a significant difference in their child's ability to regulate, attend, listen and understand what is being said" and this has had "a positive impact on the child's communication, social and play skills and ability to integrate into their community and educational settings".Ms Steer’s evidence Since graduating from the University of South Australia in 1975 with a Diploma in Technology (which became a Bachelor of Applied Science in Occupational Therapy in 1990), Ms Steer has worked predominantly in the field of paediatric and neuro-developmental occupational therapy for children with learning and neuro-motor difficulties. She also has a Diploma in Kinesiology. She has been a sole practitioner since 2005, with referrals mostly from her former practice, word-of-mouth and some psychologists. Ms Steer told us that, between 1989 and 2005, she used mainly sensory integration therapy with children with learning difficulties including children on the autism spectrum. She was sceptical about the benefits of sound therapy until she looked at it more closely and underwent training. She became a sound therapist in 2000. She started using TLP in 2004. Ms Steer explained that Auditory Integration Training (AIT) and TLP evolved from the work of Alfred Tomatis, a French ENT surgeon, in the 1950s. Whereas AIT is an intensive program over 10 hours in a clinic, TLP is a home-based program used over a longer period. TLPS is a calmer, gentler version of TLP that uses classical music exclusively with bone as well as air conduction. It is always used in conjunction with other therapies. The neurophysiological principle underlying TLP is, in summary, that different frequencies correspond to different areas of brain and body function: low frequencies target the vestibular system and improve balance and spatial sense; middle frequencies target speech and language, and improve memory and attention, aspects of literacy and receptive language; higher frequencies target higher-level cortical areas. Based on observations of the individual child, his or her medical diagnosis, and formal testing if possible, TLP can be adjusted for different frequencies. Ms Steer estimates she has used TLP with more than 100 children, predominantly children with auditory processing difficulties. Each was screened for suitability for TLP. Ms Steer said it is rare to see no change at all using TLP. Auditory processing skills improve on standardised testing and parents report the child “seems like they’ve grown up”. Articulation usually improves and socially they are more at ease; language may improve and visual motor skills and emotional regulation usually improve in children with autism to varying degrees, depending on the individual. Ms Steer said she has seen only one case of an adverse effect in a child, when particular frequencies were used, but once they were adjusted, he made significant changes. She said she would not recommend TLP for certain children such as those who have uncontrolled seizures or epilepsy; repeated colds causing a blocked nose affecting the ears; or who show signs they may not be receptive to stimulation, such as children who have eczema or tummy pains due to food intolerances.

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 22 January 2014, a delegate of the CEO set aside the original plan and made a new plan, effective 27 January 2014, which increased to three hours per week the carer support for TKCW to attend recreational activities. It did not include funding for TLP, a carer for TKCW’s brother while he attends therapy with his mother, or help at home for his mother.THE DECISION UNDER REVIEW On 20 February 2004, TKCW's mother, on his behalf, asked the Tribunal to review the decision dated 22 January 2014 not to fund TLP or a carer for TKCW's twin brother while he attends therapy. In April 2014, the NDIA made a fourth plan and, on 2 July 2014, a fifth plan, both of which stated they were to start on 22 January 2014. Each made minor amendments to the third plan but left unchanged the decisions concerning TLP and the carer for TKCW's brother. Some time was spent at the hearing identifying which decision the Tribunal has power to review. We understand the April 2014 and July 2014 plans were made on the initiative of the NDIA under s 48(2) of the NDIS Act. As they were not decisions made by a reviewer under s 100(6) of the Act, the Tribunal has no power to review them. The parties agree, and we are satisfied, that the decision under review is the decision by the reviewer on 22 January 2014 to set aside the original plan and make a new plan in its place. That decision was made under s 100(6) of the Act and the Tribunal has power to review it. In effect, then, we have to decide whether the NDIS should fund TLP for TKCW and whether the NDIS should fund a carer for TKCW's brother while TKCW attends speech and occupational therapy with his mother. THE NDIS Before going further, we will say something briefly about the NDIS generally and about funding for reasonable and necessary supports. The objects of the NDIS Act are set out in s 3. As well as giving effect to Australia's obligations under the UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities, they include:·supporting the independence and social and economic participation of people with disability;·providing reasonable and necessary supports for participants; and·enabling people with disability to exercise choice and control in the pursuit of their goals and the planning and delivery of their supports. The NDIS provides support for people with disability in the form of: general supports by way of coordination, strategic and referral services or activities; funding for persons or entities to enable them to assist people with disability participate in economic and social life; and individual plans under which funding for reasonable and necessary supports is provided to persons who qualify to be participants in the NDIS. To become a participant, a person must meet the access criteria in s 21(1) of the NDIS Act. TKCW meets the access criteria, in particular the early intervention requirements which means, in summary, that early intervention supports are likely to benefit him by reducing the effect of his disability, and his need for supports, in the future: s 25(1).

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

We understand from the NDIA representatives at the hearing that this leaflet may have been produced before the NDIS actually commenced. It seems to reflect the intention in s 3(g) but, in any event, we do not read it as suggesting an intention to do anything different from what is described in s 34(1)(d). Consideration In our view, there is insufficient information on which to say with any confidence that TLP will be, or is likely to be, effective and beneficial for TKCW having regard to current good practice. We acknowledge the report from the American Occupational Therapy Association Inc but we do not think it puts TLP higher than a therapy for which there are emerging signs of positive outcomes. That is not to say that TLP would be of no benefit to TKCW or that TLP ought not be funded until such time as there is unarguable evidence of its benefits for children with autism. It may be many years before that sort of evidence is available. In the meantime, evidence, even if anecdotal, from a sufficient number of qualified therapists of positive outcomes in sufficient numbers of children may be enough to say that it should be regarded as current good practice. In coming to this conclusion, we have borne in mind the provisions in the NDIS Act that require us to have regard to the need to ensure the financial sustainability of the scheme. In our view, it could undermine that financial sustainability to provide funding for a support whose effectiveness and benefits are largely unknown, especially where a reliable means of measuring any benefits of the support in a single case is lacking.Does TLP represent value for money? In relation to whether a support represents value for money, Part 3 of the Support for Participant Rules state:3.1In deciding whether the support represents value for money in that the costs of the support are reasonable, relative to both the benefits achieved and the cost of alternative support, the CEO is to consider the following matters:(a)whether there are comparable supports which would achieve the same outcome at a substantially lower cost;(b)whether there is evidence that the support will substantially improve the life stage outcomes for, and be of long‑term benefit to, the participant;(c)whether funding or provision of the support is likely to reduce the cost of the funding of supports for the participant in the long term (for example, some early intervention supports may be value for money given their potential to avoid or delay reliance on more costly supports);(d)for supports that involve the provision of equipment or modifications:i.the comparative cost of purchasing or leasing the equipment or modifications; andii.whether there are any expected changes in technology or the participant’s circumstances in the short term that would make it inappropriate to fund the equipment or modifications;(e)whether the cost of the support is comparable to the cost of supports of the same kind that are provided in the area in which the participant resides;(f)whether the support will increase the participant’s independence and reduce the participant’s need for other kinds of supports (for example, some home modifications may reduce a participant’s need for home care).