KBCX and National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIS)

Link copied
Case Copied 54 min read

KBCX and National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIS) [2024] ARTA 100 (19 December 2024)

Applicant:KBCX

Respondent:  National Disability Insurance Agency

Tribunal Number:                2024/5374

Tribunal:Member S Smith

Place:Brisbane

Date:19 December 2024

Decision:The decision under review is set aside and remitted for reconsideration by the Respondent with a direction that, within 28 days of the date of this decision, the Respondent facilitate the approval of a new statement of participant supports (SOPS) for the Applicant in the current plan dated 20 August 2024, noting the following:

Conductive Education therapy does not meet the requirements of s 34(1)(d) of the NDIS Act, so it is not to be specified as a support in the Applicant’s SOPS; a)

Physiotherapy funding meets the requirements in s 34(1) of the NDIS Act and it is to be specified in the Applicant’s SOPS as a ‘stated support’ so that the funding cannot be used flexibly;b)

That all other supports in the Applicant’s existing SOPS, are to be replicated pro-ratac)    from the date of this decision until the reassessment date;

The management of funding for supports in the Applicant’s existing SOPS be replicated; d)    

The date by which the Respondent must reassess the Applicant’s plan is to be twelve (12) months after the date of the approval of the new SOPS for the Applicant in accordance with this direction.e)    

..................................[SGD]......................................

Member S Smith

Catchwords

NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME – National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth) – as amended 3 October 2024 – reasonable and necessary supports – reasonable and necessary budget – NDIS Supports – acquired brain injury – quadriplegic cerebral palsy – conductive education – effective and beneficial – current good practice – expert opinion – decision set aside and remitted to the Respondent

Legislation
Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth)
Administrative Review Tribunal Act 2024 (Cth)
Administrative Review Tribunal (Consequential and Transitional Provisions No. 1) Act 2024
National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth)
National Disability Insurance Scheme (Getting the NDIS Back on Track No.1) Act 2024 (Cth)
National Disability Insurance Scheme (Supports for Participants) Rules 2013

National Disability Insurance Scheme (Getting the NDIS Back on Track No. 1) (NDIS Supports) Transitional Rules 2024

Cases

McCutcheon and National Disability Insurance Agency [2015] AATA 624
McGarrigle v National Disability Insurance Agency [2017] FCA 308
Mulligan v National Disability Insurance Agency [2015] FCA 544
National Disability Insurance Agency v WRMF [2020] FCAFC 79
Re Drake v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No 2) (1979) 2 ALD 60
Shi v Migration Agents Registration Authority (2008) 235 CLR 286
TKCW and National Disability Insurance Agency [2014] AATA 501
VXGN and National Disability Insurance Agency [2023] AATA 2781

Young and National Disability Insurance Agency [2021] AATA 1555

Secondary Materials

NDIS – Operational guidelines – Reasonable and necessary supports, as at 22 September 2024.

ART Guideline on persons giving expert and opinion evidence, October 2024.

Statement of Reasons

BACKGROUND

  1. KBCX is a twelve-year-old boy living with complex disabilities. He lives with his mother (M), his…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read KBCX and National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIS) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] ARTA 100
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case between KBCX and the National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIS) was heard by the Tribunal, where the primary issue was whether Conductive Education (CE) therapy met the criteria for being classified as a reasonable and necessary support under the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth). KBCX, a young individual with quadriplegic cerebral palsy resulting from an acquired brain injury, has been receiving CE therapy, which his family believes to be effective and beneficial. The NDIS, however, had previously determined that CE therapy did not qualify as a reasonable and necessary support. This determination was contested by KBCX's family, who provided extensive evidence supporting the efficacy of CE therapy.

The legal issues before the Tribunal included whether CE therapy met the legislative criteria of being 'reasonable and necessary' and whether it should be considered as a specified support in KBCX’s Supports Outcome Plan (SOPS). Additionally, the Tribunal had to consider the broader implications of the decision on KBCX’s care and support, and the impact of the decision on his family. The Tribunal also examined the role of expert opinion versus lived experience in determining the effectiveness of therapeutic interventions under the NDIS Act.

The Tribunal found that while CE therapy was highly valued by KBCX’s family and appeared beneficial based on lived experience, it did not meet the legislative criteria for being a'reasonable and necessary' support under the NDIS Act. The Tribunal emphasised that the decision must be grounded in probative evidence rather than solely on subjective experiences. The Tribunal acknowledged the family's dedication and the benefits they perceived from CE therapy but concluded that the legislative requirements for support classification necessitated a different outcome. Consequently, the Tribunal set aside the NDIS’s decision and directed the Agency to reconsider the matter, specifying that physiotherapy should be included as a stated support in KBCX’s SOPS.

In summary, the Tribunal's decision underscored the importance of aligning support decisions with legislative criteria while recognising the significant role of lived experience in understanding the impact of therapeutic interventions. The Tribunal’s ruling ensures that KBCX’s SOPS reflects supports that meet the statutory requirements for reasonableness and necessity, balancing the family's preferences with legal standards.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Mr DP stated that he was asked by Mr P to type a statement about the benefits of CE for KBCX.[32] Mr DP stated he has attended both CE and physiotherapy sessions with KBCX. His observation was that he ‘had to show the physiotherapist how to handle KBCX and how to walk him’ because KBCX ‘wouldn’t walk with his physiotherapist at all’, however, that Ms Petki had taught Mr DP ‘how to handle and walk KBCX to keep him safe.’ Mr DP considered that KBCX had a good relationship with Ms Petki and that, after missing two or more CE sessions, KBCX would be more difficult to manage due to pain and stiffness.[33] [32] EB2, undated, unsigned 2-page statement of Mr DP.[33] Oral evidence of Mr DP.Evidence of Ms Dora Petki, ‘neuro rehabilitation consultant’ and ‘conductor’ Ms Dora Petki completed a ‘double degree’ in Budapest, Hungary in 1991; a Bachelor of Education and a Bachelor of Movement Therapy in conductive education.[34] Ms Petki later obtained a Certificate in Hydrotherapy Consulting and Training in Queensland in 1998.[35] Ms Petki provided multiple reports and gave oral evidence at the hearing.[34] H3, pages 88-89. H13, page 793. Oral evidence of Ms Petki.[35] H13, page 804. Ms Petki describes herself as a ‘neurological rehabilitation consultant’[36] in ‘cognitive movement therapy’, or ‘motor movement therapy.’[37] Ms Petki stated there is no ‘neuro rehabilitation consultant’ accreditation authority in Australia. Ms Petki is not a registered allied health practitioner in Australia, and she holds no registration with the Australian Health Practitioner Regulation Agency (AHPRA). Ms Petki has worked for over 32 years in the area of CE. Ms Petki commenced working with KBCX in February 2016. [36] H25, 16 December 2020. H3, page 78, 6 November 2021. H33, 22 June 2022.[37] Oral evidence of Ms Petki. Ms Petki described CE as a child and family-centred or ‘person-centred’ holistic, hands-on visual-therapy approach. She stated that CE is different to traditional therapies as it is not a passive exercise programme, but rather a complex rehabilitation system that combines a medical and educational approach.[38] [38] H13, page 828. Ms Petki explained CE differs from traditional physiotherapy, because physiotherapy is more a passive, manual exercise program, that does not involve the brain to process and learn motor movements regardless of the level of disability.[39] She stated that CE is a unique rehabilitation program, specialising in neurological and chronic conditions, to help KBCX build ‘vital’ life skills and find his ‘identity’ within his capabilities.[40][39] H13, pages 737-738.[40] H5, page 151. Ms Petki’s evidence was that intensive CE therapy has maintained and improved KBCX’s ability to function.[41] She stated that when she met KBCX, he could not turn his body side-to-side, and he almost had a dislocated hip on his right side, however that over the years of therapy sessions KBCX has ‘slowly but surely improved.’ Ms Petki also provides education around preventative therapy methods in order to prevent difficulties later on in life regarding major surgeries like scoliosis surgery and osteotomies of the hips.[41] H13, page 826.

Decision

Reasons for decision

As these issues were not in contention, the Tribunal considers it appropriate that KBCX’s plan management continue as stated in the existing plan and that the plan duration be for twelve months.CONCLUSION For the reasons outlined above, the Tribunal sets aside the decision under review and remits this matter to the Agency for reconsideration in accordance with a direction that within 28 days of the date of this decision, the Agency facilitate the approval of a new SOPS for KBCX, noting the following:·Conductive Education Therapy does not meet the requirements of s 34(1)(d) of the NDIS Act, so it is not to be specified as a support in KBCX’s SOPS;·Physiotherapy funding meets the requirements in s 34(1) of the NDIS Act and it is to be specified in KBCX’s SOPS as a ‘stated support’ so that the funding cannot be used flexibly;·That all other supports in KBCX’s existing SOPS are to be replicated pro-rata from the date of this decision until the reassessment date;·The management of funding for supports in KBCX’s existing SOPS be replicated;·The date by which the Agency must reassess KBCX’s plan is to be twelve (12) months after the date of the approval of the new SOPS for KBCX in accordance with this direction.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Regarding the support of physiotherapy, the Agency contends that it should be provided as a support as recommended by Ms Cummings’ delegated model, but the support should be provided as a stated support so that it cannot be used flexibly because:·The CTMP is not reflective of what is actually intended if CE therapy support is continued; and·KBCX indicated ‘physiotherapy has not been effective and beneficial long term.’[132] [132] H6, page 171.CONSIDERATIONWhether or not CE therapy will be, or is likely to be, effective and beneficial for KBCX, having regard to current good practice The evidence was undisputed that KBCX suffered permanent, catastrophic injuries as an infant. The sequelae of these injuries mean KBCX lives with permanent, complex and severe impairments from his disabilities[133] and that he requires numerous supports around the clock. Over the last 11 years, KBCX’s parents and family have worked commendably to care for him, whilst also raising two younger children. It was apparent to the Tribunal that KBCX’s parents and family uphold KBCX’s best interests.[133] H19, page 1090. Since 2013 KBCX suffered a cardiorespiratory arrest post diagnostic catheter and interventional aortic balloon vavuloplasty for severe aortic valve stenosis with a dysplastic trileaflet aortic valve and left ventricular hypertrophy. The Tribunal recognises the conscientious and large amount of work that Mr P demonstrated in preparing and representing his grandson in these proceedings. The Tribunal considered all the filed written material and video images.[134][134] On day two of the hearing at Mr P’s request the Tribunal played a 12-minute audio-visual compilation of KBCX working with Ms Petki. The Tribunal accepts the oral and written lived experience evidence from M, Mr DP, Mr Withers and several other parents of children living with disabilities[135] and their respective views attesting to the benefits their children received from CE Therapy with Ms Petki. [135] EB2, EB3. The Tribunal accepts that M prioritises and differentiates CE therapy from physiotherapy by preferring CE therapy for KBCX because M perceives CE as a ‘more active therapy’. CE is highly valued by KBCX’s family. M may drive over three hours each week to transport KBCX to and from Ms Petki’s address. Additionally, M prioritises the scheduling of CE appointments and KBCX has not received physiotherapy support in ‘around a year.’ With regard to supports rule 3.2(b) and (c), the Tribunal acknowledges the important evidence of the first-hand knowledge, experience and understanding of people who have spent many years living with KBCX or with children living with impairments similar to those of KBCX and their experience around ongoing therapy. The lay witness evidence was relevant, and it was considered. The trust placed in Ms Petki by KBCX’s family and other families was evident and the benefit that the families reported from Ms Petki’s therapy is acknowledged and given due regard and weight. However, when this lived experience evidence is at odds with probative evidence it may be given less weight.