VXGN and National Disability Insurance Agency

Link copied
Case Copied 51 min read

VXGN and National Disability Insurance Agency [2023] AATA 2781 (4 September 2023)

Division:NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME DIVISION

File Number(s):2022/0754      

Re:VXGN

APPLICANT

AndNational Disability Insurance Agency

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Senior Member Joanne Collins 

Date:4 September 2023

Place:Brisbane

The decision under review is set aside and remitted to the Respondent (‘the Agency’) with the directions that:

·Within 14 days of the date of this decision, the Agency include in the Applicant VXGN’s statement of participant supports the following supports as reasonable and necessary:

o8 hours per week of individual Applied Behaviour Analysis (ABA) therapy;

o4 hours per year for the preparation of a report by an Early Intervention therapist;

o26 hours per year of Level 2 Support Coordination at the applicable NDIS Price Guide rate;

o52 hours per year of occupational therapy to be included as a 'stated support' so that the funding cannot be used flexibly; and

o52 hours per year of speech therapy to be included as a 'stated support' so that the funding cannot be used flexibly.

·     The date by which the Agency must reassess the VXGN’s plan is to be 12 months after the date the date of this decision;

·     All other supports in VXGN’s existing statement of participant supports be replicated pro-rata from the date of this decision until the reassessment date; and

·     The supports for VXGN’s Improved Daily living budget are to be ‘plan managed’.[1]

[1] Section 42(2) National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (‘NDIS Act‘).

............................[SGD]............................

Senior Member J Collins

Catchwords

NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME – Autism - ABA therapy - reasonable and necessary supports – consideration of section 34 National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth) – current good practice – section 34(1)(d) National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth) - decision set aside and remitted to the Respondent

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) s2A, s33, s42D

National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth) s34, s35, s48, s103

National Disability Insurance Scheme (Supports for Participants) Rules 2013

Cases

Re Drake v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No 2) (1979) 2 ALD 60

G v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCA 1229

Mulligan v National Disability Insurance Agency [2015] FCA 544

Shi v Migration Agents Registration Authority (2008) 235 CLR 286

National Disability Insurance Agency v WRMF [2020] FCAFC 79

McGarrigle v National Disability Insurance Agency [2017] FCA 308

Secondary Materials

National Disability Operational Guidelines – Early childhood approach

National Guidelines for Best Practice in Early Childhood Intervention Early Years Learning Framework - Developmental Milestones 

REASONS FOR THE DECISION

  1. VXGN, a 5-year-old male, is a participant of the National Disability Insurance Scheme (‘the scheme’). He seeks an increase in his existing funding so that he can access an increase in the level of early intervention support which is already funded under the scheme. 

  2. The issue before the Tribunal is whether the level of early intervention support sought by VXGN is a ‘reasonable and necessary’ support pursuant to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read VXGN and National Disability Insurance Agency and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] AATA 2781
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by VXGN for review of a decision by the National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA) to refuse funding for certain supports. The NDIA had affirmed its original decision on 11 January 2022, asserting that the proposed supports were neither effective and beneficial having regard to current good practice, nor represented value for money, nor were they best provided under the scheme. VXGN subsequently applied to the Tribunal for a review of this decision.

The Tribunal was required to determine whether the supports sought by VXGN were reasonable and necessary, specifically considering the criteria under section 34(1)(d) of the *National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013* (Cth), which mandates that supports be effective and beneficial having regard to current good practice. This involved an assessment of the available evidence regarding the efficacy and intensity of early intervention therapies for children with Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD).

The Tribunal considered evidence from Dr. Michael Sandbank, who led the "Project AIM" meta-analysis of non-pharmacological interventions for children with ASD. Dr. Sandbank's evidence highlighted substantial methodological flaws in many studies, limiting confidence in their findings, and noted a scarcity of research on optimal intervention intensity and duration. The Tribunal also referred to the 2022 Autism CRC draft guidelines, which, developed within an evidence-based practice framework, recommended that the amount and duration of support be tailored to individual needs and cautioned that research does not support the notion that greater amounts of support consistently lead to better outcomes.

The Tribunal set aside the NDIA's decision and remitted the matter to the Respondent for reconsideration.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The ECIA guidelines identify a number of ‘key practices’ in early childhood intervention, one of which is ‘Evidence-Based Practice’. Relevant to this decision the ECIA guidelines provide as follows: Evidence-Based Practice‘Evidence-based practice is a decision-making process that integrates the best available research evidence with family and professional wisdom’ (Buysse and Wesley, 2006). In other words, evidence-based practice involves a balance of empirically supported interventions, clinical expertise or practice wisdom, and client or family values, preferences and circumstances (CCCH, 2014).To ensure that they are working from a base of evidence informed by the latest research and practice, ECI practitioners should maintain knowledge and skills through lifelong continuing professional development. ECI also requires ongoing review and monitoring to ensure that practices are achieving the desired outcomes.ECI practitioners become more effective through critical reflection and a strong culture of professional enquiry (DEECD, 2011). Ongoing self-reflection, self-assessment and monitoring of practices are at the centre of the proposed development of practice standards’.[66][66] R7, page 364. Dr Micheal Sandbank is an Assistant Professor at the Department of Occupational Science & Occupational Therapy, School of Medicine at the University of North Carolina in the USA. Two reports by Dr Sandbank were tendered on behalf of the Agency for consideration by the Tribunal.[67][67] R7, page 1833; R9(b). In 2017 Dr Sandbank led the research investigation ‘Project AIM’ (Autism Intervention Meta-analysis). Project AIM involved a comprehensive meta-analysis of all available ‘studies’ in respect of children (up to age eight) with ASD and tested the effect of non-pharmacological interventions on any outcome for these children. Project AIM was selected as one of the Top 20 Advances in Autism Research in 2020 by the Interagency Autism Coordinating Committee of the US Department of Health & Human Services. In November 2021, Project AIM updated its investigation by identifying and analysing any further ‘studies’ undertaken subsequent to 2017. As the lead researcher of Project AIM Dr Sandbank has read and analysed the full set of available experimental or quasi-experimental group studies in respect of early non-pharmacological interventions for children with ASD, published before November 2021. In addition, and prior to providing her report to the Tribunal, Dr Sandbank conducted a further search for any relevant studies published after November 2021 and prior to the hearing. The purpose of meta-analyses is to provide a quantitative summary of the entire set of the available research studies on interventions for children with ASD. This includes providing an estimation on whether an intervention is effective for improving an outcome for a child with ASD, and also how effective the intervention actually is.[68] [68] R7, page 1843 at [22]. Dr Sandbank’s evidence was informative and persuasive. At time of the hearing Dr Sandbank had read and analysed all available experimental or quasi-experimental group studies in respect of early interventions for children with ASD. This amount represented a total of approximately 289 studies, and included all studies tendered for consideration by the Tribunal. Dr Sandbank referred to a wide variety of methodological approaches by researchers over the years in their efforts to determine what interventions are of most benefit to children with ASD. In doing so, Dr Sandbank identified substantial flaws in the methodology of many of these studies, thereby limiting confidence in the respective findings.

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 11 January 2022 the Agency affirmed its original decision to refuse funding for these supports (‘the decision under review’). Refusal was made on the basis the Agency did not consider that these supports: ·Would be, or would likely to be effective and beneficial for VXGN, having regard to current good practice pursuant to section 34(1)(d) of the NDIS Act;·Represented value for money pursuant to section 34(1)(c) of the NDIS Act;[7] and[7] T1B.·Were best provided by under the scheme pursuant to section 34(1)(c) of the NDIS Act having regard to what is reasonable to expect families, carers, informal networks and the community to provide.[8] [8] R1(b); T2. VXGN subsequently applied to the Tribunal for a review of the decision under review on 1 February 2022.[9][9] T1; Section 103(2) NDIS Act. On 21 November 2022 in the context of these proceedings and in order to ensure continued funding for VXGN, the Agency reconsidered VXGN’s December - 2021 SOPS. This reconsideration was possible by the operation of section 42D of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) (’AAT Act’). At that time the Agency extended VXGN’s December - 2021 SOPS on a pro-rata basis for a period on seven months, with a review date of 22 June 2022 (the ‘November - 2022 SOPS’). For reasons which are unclear, the plan management of VXGN’s ‘Improved Daily Living’ budget contained in the November – 2022 SOPS was changed from ‘plan managed’ to ‘NDIA managed’.[10] [10] Paragraph [5] of these Reasons for the Decision; Section 42(2) NDIS Act. VXGN’s mother ‘S’ subsequently raised with the Agency the change to the plan management in VXGN’s ‘Improved Daily Living’ budget, as provided for in the November – 2022 SOPS.[11][11] Respondent’s Supplementary Statement dated 10 February 2022 at [10]. On 1 December 2022 the Agency issued a further SOPS (the ‘December- 2022 SOPS’). The amount of funding in the December - 2022 SOPS was identical to the funding in the November - 2022 SOPS, however the budget for VXGN’s ‘Improved Daily Living’ was re-instated to be ‘plan managed’. The review date of the December – 2022 SOPS was determined as 2 July 2023. The Agency’s interaction notes recorded that the variation made of the November – 2022 SOPS to the December – 2022 SOPS was pursuant to section 47A of the NDIS Act. Section 47A of the NDIS Act provides as follows:Variation of participant's plan on request of participant or CEO's own initiative(1) The CEO may, in writing, vary a participant's plan (except the participant's statement of goals and aspirations) if:(a) the variation:(i) is covered by subsection (1A); or(ii) is a correction of a minor or technical error; and(b) any conditions prescribed by the National Disability Insurance Scheme rules are satisfied.Each variation must be prepared with the participant.(1A) For the purposes of subparagraph (1)(a)(i), the following variations of a participant's plan are covered:(a) a variation to the reassessment date of the plan;(b) a variation of the statement of participant supports included in the plan in relation to the management of:(i) the funding for supports under the plan; or(ii) other aspects of the plan;(c) a variation of the statement of participant supports included in the plan if:

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In 2022 the Lancet Commission on the future of care and clinical research in autism by Lord et al stated as follows:‘If evidence-based approaches to support the lives of autistic children, adolescents, and adults who are living now are to be developed (in contrast to the fervent hopes for neurobiological approaches in the future), knowing what works for whom, when, and at what intensity is imperative, and will allow the design of systems that are cost-effective, affordable, and scalable across the globe. Such approaches are not possible on the basis of the currently existing data, but, might become possible in the future.…………….Intensity and durationKnowledge about how much and for how long a given intervention should be delivered is scarce, and few systematic comparisons have been done to date. A recent study by Rogers and colleagues, done across three different sites, compared two types of intervention (applied behavior analysis and Early Start Denver Model) at two different, relatively high intensities (12 h per week vs 20 h per week) for 2-year-olds with autism. There was no difference in outcome according to either treatment type or treatment intensity on autism manifestations, although greater improvement was found at one of the three sites with greater intensity. This finding is a start; the next step would be to determine if regular, relatively intense, face-to-face interventions of this kind have effects different from those of typical clinic visits or low-intensity, parent-mediated interventions that occur even less frequently’’[61] (Tribunal emphasis added).[61] R9(b), page 19 and page 51. In July 2022 Autism CRC issued the ‘National guidelines for supporting the learning, participation, and wellbeing of autistic children and their families in Australia (Draft Guideline for public consultation) (‘2022 Autism CRC draft guidelines’)’.[62] The 2022 Autism CRC draft guidelines were developed within an evidence-based practice framework and were informed by the best available research evidence, evidence from clinical practice and the preferences and priorities of children and their families. [62] R7, page 389. The objective of the 2022 Autism CRC draft guidelines was to provide practitioners with an evidence-based practice framework facilitating the safe and effective provision of support to children aged 12 years or younger with ASD.[63] 84 recommendations were made, and relevant to this decision was ‘Recommendation 56’ which provided as follows:‘Practitioners should deliver supports in an amount and duration that is likely to lead to the most meaningful and sustained increase in the child’s learning, participation, and wellbeing.Good Practice Points56.1 The amount and duration of support provision should be tailored to the individual needs of the child and family. The includes consideration of the frequency, length and time of day of support sessions, and variations in support needs over time.56.2 Practitioners should inform parents that there is no set number of hours per week of practitioner delivered supports that leads to the best outcomes for all children.56.3 Practitioners should be aware that research evidence does not support the concept that supports delivered in greater amounts consistently leads to better child and family outcomes’ (Tribunal emphasis added).[63] R7, page 416.