Burchell and National Disability Insurance Agency

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read

Burchell and National Disability Insurance Agency [2019] AATA 1256 (4 June 2019)

Division:NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME DIVISION

File Number(s):      2018/4659

Re:Colin Burchell

APPLICANT

AndNational Disability Insurance Agency

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Deputy President B W Rayment OAM QC

Date:4 June 2019

Place:Sydney

The reviewable decision is set aside and the matter is remitted to the respondent for reconsideration with the direction that the support claimed, based upon the eating plan of 4 October 2018 is a reasonable and necessary support.

.................................[sgd].................................

Deputy President B W Rayment OAM QC

CATCHWORDS

NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME – reasonable and necessary supports – cerebral palsy – dysphagia – thickened fluid and food supplements – statutory interpretation – resort to extrinsic materials – services offered by other health service providers – whether support services “offered” include services not actually made available – whether NDIS can fund supports more appropriately provided but not actually offered by other health services – decision set aside and remitted

LEGISLATION

Acts Interpretation Act 2001 (Cth)

National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth) ss 1, 3, 4, 25, 34, 43, 209

CASES

Alcan (NT) Alumina Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Territory Revenue (Northern Territory) [2009] HCA 41; (2009) 239 CLR 27

BBMC and National Disability Insurance Agency [2018] AATA 386
CIC Insurance Ltd v Bankstown Football Club Ltd (1997) 187 CLR 384
Fear by his mother Vanda Fear and National Disability Insurance Agency [2015] AATA 706
Mulligan v National Disability Insurance Agency [2015] FCA 544; (2015) 233 FCR 201
P v Child Support Registrar [2013] FCA 1312
Port of Brisbane Corporation v Deputy Commissioner of Taxation [2004] FCA 1232; (2004) 140 FCR 375
Saeed and Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2010] HCA 23; (2010) 241 CLR 252
Young and National Disability Insurance Agency [2014] AATA 401

YPRM and National Disability Insurance Agency [2016] AATA 1023

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities Articles 10 and 25

Revised Explanatory Memorandum to the National Disability Insurance Scheme Bill
National Disability Insurance Scheme (Supports for Participants) Rules 2013 Rules 7.4, 7.5
Operational Guidelines of the National Disability Insurance Agency Clause 10.8

Productivity Commission 2011, Disability Care and Support, Report No. 54, Canberra.

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President B W Rayment OAM QC

4 June 2019

  1. Colin Burchell was born a normal child in May 1985. At six weeks of age he was admitted to a Sydney children’s hospital for tests and contracted bronchitis while in hospital. He was transferred to the ICU ward and was given oxygen. He died or appeared to die in the ICU apparently due to mistakes made by a trainee nurse and was resuscitated. He awoke with permanent disabilities. Today he is aged 34 and his mental age is that of a one year old.

  2. He has cerebral palsy, developmental delay, severe intellectual disability, diabetes, constipation, severe bowel impaction, haemorrhoids and rectal prolapse, and a number of other conditions. He has dysphagia as a result of his cerebral…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Burchell and National Disability Insurance Agency and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] AATA 1256
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by Mr Burchell against a decision of the National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA) regarding funding for thickened fluid and food supplements for his cerebral palsy and dysphagia. The Administrative Appeals Tribunal was required to determine whether these supports were reasonable and necessary under the National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS).

The core legal issues before the Tribunal were the interpretation of Rules 7.1 to 7.5 of the NDIS Rules, which delineate the boundaries between NDIS funding and other service systems, particularly health services. Specifically, the Tribunal had to consider whether the supports related to Mr Burchell's ongoing functional impairment and enabled him to undertake activities of daily living, and whether the NDIS was responsible for funding supports that are more appropriately provided by other health services, even if those services were not actually made available.

The Tribunal considered the Explanatory Memorandum and the Productivity Commission's 2011 report, "Disability Care and Support," as extrinsic material to aid in the construction of the NDIS Act and Rules. It noted that the NDIS was intended to complement, not replace, mainstream services, and that NDIS funds should not be used to fill gaps in generic services. The Tribunal reasoned that if a support is health-related, it will not be funded by the NDIS, regardless of whether it is funded or provided by a health authority. The Tribunal found that the applicant's submission that Rule 7.4 covered the case was not applicable as the supports were not delivered or supervised by clinically trained or qualified health practitioners.

The Tribunal set aside the NDIA's decision and remitted the matter for reconsideration.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

In Mulligan v National Disability InsuranceAgency [2015] FCA 544; (2015) 233 FCR 201 Mortimer J made reference to a paragraph of the Productivity Commission Report which had been referred to in the Explanatory Memorandum. See [53] and [54]. That is not an indication that reference to the Productivity Commission’s report may be made for any purpose in construing the Act. The Explanatory Memorandum had referred to a section of the Report which it indicated was the purpose of the section in question to enact.THE EARLIER DECISIONS OF THIS TRIBUNAL The line of reasoning which appears in a group of earlier decisions of the Tribunal is as follows: (a)The report of the Productivity Commission in 2011, Disability Care and Support, Report No 54. 31 July 2011 deals at several points with the intersection between health matters and the NDIS. The parts of the report which are referred to include parts of section 5.3 at pages 238-239, and the references to intersection between health and the NDIS at pages 182-184. In one of the cases, Fear by his mother Vanda Fear and National Disability Insurance Agency [2015] AATA 706 at [39]-[41] the relevant passages were set out:(39)The NDIS implemented, in large part, the recommendations of the Productivity Commission’s 2011 report, Disability Care and Support, Report No 54, 31 July 2011. Regarding the role of “mainstream” services such as education, health care, public housing, transport and education services, the Commission said (at p 238): It is generally accepted that disability services should not replace mainstream or other specialist services available to the broader population, or be expected to meet all the needs of people with disability. Indeed, a key policy goal is to move away from primary reliance on specialist disability services to the use of mainstream services or at least a mix of the two.(40)Further, the Commission said:Access to generic services, such as health and housing, can affect demand for NDIS-funded services, and vice-versa. It will be important for the [NDIS] not to respond to problems or shortfalls in mainstream services by providing its own substitute services. To do so would weaken the incentives by government to properly fund mainstream services for people with a disability, shifting the cost to another part of government (such as from a state government to the NDIS, or from one budget ’silo’ to another). This ‘pass the parcel’ approach would undermine the sustainability of the scheme and the capacity of people with a disability to access mainstream services.(41)That said, the Commission recognised (at pp 238-239) that there were difficulties establishing “clear boundaries” between the disability service system and other mainstream service systems and that, even where boundaries were clear, they were not always consistent as between the states. It recommended that primary care and inpatient and outpatient hospital-based services, and medical and pharmaceutical products, should remain outside the scope of the scheme. Even then, it said (at p 182), it was “likely that some ambiguity will remain around the respective responsibilities of the health and disability system”, in particular “which system is responsible for meeting the support needs of individuals with a chronic health condition”. Moreover, it recognised (at p 183) that “gaps between disability and health services persist”.(b)Reference to the material is justified because the Report was part of the basis on which agreement between the Commonwealth and the States was arrived at to set up the NDIS. (c)By implication, that report is extrinsic material to which resort may be had in construing s.34(1)(f) of the Act. That resort is authorised by s.15AB of the Acts Interpretation Act 2001 (Cth), and common law principles of statutory interpretation, in order to establish purpose, object or mischief, or because of ambiguity, obscurity, or absurdity, or to establish context.(d)It follows from the passages of the Report that the funds of the NDIS should not be used to fill in gaps in generic services.(e)If the support in question is health-related, even if it is not funded or provided by a health or related authority, it will not be funded by the NDIS.(f)That construction should be put upon s.34(1)(f). .

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Rules 7.1-7.5 provide as follows:Schedule 1 Considerations relating to whether supports are most appropriately funded through the NDIS7.1 The Act limits the supports that can be provided or funded under the NDIS to supports that are not more appropriately funded or provided through other service systems, for example as part of a universal services obligation or in accordance with reasonable adjustments required under a law dealing with discrimination on the basis of disability. 7.2 The considerations set out in this Schedule must be taken into account by the CEO in deciding whether a support is more appropriately provided or funded by the NDIS or another service system. 7.3 For the avoidance of doubt, while this Schedule sets out considerations relevant to whether a support should be considered to be more appropriately provided or funded through another service system, it does not purport to impose any obligations on another service system to fund or provide particular supports. Note: The considerations set out in this Schedule are derived from the Principles to determine the responsibilities of the NDIS and other service systems, agreed to by the Council of Australian Governments, and dated Friday 19 April 2013. That document also includes principles relating to aged care. They are not relevant to this Schedule, but are given effect to in section 19 of the Act, and the National Disability Insurance Scheme (Becoming a Participant) Rules 2013.Health (excluding mental health)7.4 The NDIS will be responsible for supports related to a person’s ongoing functional impairment and that enable the person to undertake activities of daily living, including maintenance supports delivered or supervised by clinically trained or qualified health practitioners where these are directly related to a functional impairment and integrally linked to the care and support a person requires to live in the community and participate in education and employment.7.5 The NDIS will not be responsible for:(a)the diagnosis and clinical treatment of health conditions, including ongoing or chronic health conditions; or (b)other activities that aim to improve the health status of Australians, including general practitioner services, medical specialist services, dental care, nursing, allied health services (including acute and post-acute services), preventive health, care in public and private hospitals and pharmaceuticals or other universal entitlements; or(c)funding time-limited, goal-oriented services and therapies:(i) where the predominant purpose is treatment directly related to the person’s health status; or (ii) provided after a recent medical or surgical event, with the aim of improving the person’s functional status, including rehabilitation or post-acute care; or(d)palliative care. The applicant submits that rule 7.4 covers the present case. That raises whether the supports relate to the applicant’s ongoing functional impairment and also whether they enable him to undertake activities of daily living. The words following the word “including” in the rule do not appear to apply because the supports are neither delivered nor is their delivery supervised by clinically trained or qualified health practitioners.