XNTW and National Disability Insurance Agency

Link copied
Case Copied 48 min read

XNTW and National Disability Insurance Agency [2023] AATA 759 (14 April 2023)

Division:NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME DIVISION

File Number(s):      2021/2380

Re:XNTW

APPLICANT

AndNational Disability Insurance Agency

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Senior Member O'Donovan

Date:14 April 2023

Date of written reasons:        14 April 2023

Place:Canberra

The decision under review is affirmed.

…………………………[sgd]………………………..

Senior Member Damien O’Donovan

CATCHWORDS

NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME – reasonable and necessary supports – dyslexia – dyscalculia – whether NDIA should fund services in numeracy and literacy – NDIA is not the appropriate source of funding or provision – decision under review affirmed

LEGISLATION

National Disability Insurance Scheme Act (2013) s33, 34

National Disability Insurance Scheme (Support for Participants) Rules 2013 Rule 3.5, Schedule 1

CASES

National Disability Insurance Agency v WRMF [2020] FCAFC 79
Fear by his mother Vanda Fear and National Disability Insurance Agency [2015] AATA 706

Burchell and National Disability Insurance Agency [2019] AATA 1256

SECONDARY MATERIALS

National Disability Strategy 2010-2020
Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities
Productivity Commission 2011, Disability Care and Support, Report No. 54, Canberra

Bilateral Agreement between the Commonwealth of Australia and the Australian Capital Territory on the National Disability Insurance Scheme

REASONS FOR DECISION

Senior Member O'Donovan

14 April 2023

  1. The applicant is an 11 year-old Canberra boy who is currently in year 5 at his local primary school. He is also a participant in the National Disability Insurance Scheme (the NDIS). He was initially granted access to the NDIS in 2018. The condition which was accepted as meeting the access criteria for the scheme was autism spectrum disorder (Level 3) (ASD). However, in March 2020 the applicant was found not to meet the disability requirements to access the scheme and was excluded from it.[1] The applicant’s mother submitted a fresh access request with supporting evidence on 21 January 2021.[2] The impairments relied on in that application were ASD (level 3), attention deficit disorder (ADHD), dyslexia, language disorder and anxiety.  In February 2021 a decision was made that the applicant met all the requirements to again become a participant in the NDIS.[3] The impairments which met the disability requirements to access the scheme were not specified in the decision.

    [1] T3.

    [2] T8.

    [3] T9.

  2. When a person becomes a participant in the NDIS, the National Disability Insurance Agency (the NDIA) is required to create a plan for them which includes a Statement of Participant Supports (Statement). That Statement identifies reasonable and necessary supports which will be funded by the NDIA. On 23 February 2021 a new plan commenced for the applicant. The goal of the plan was to improve the applicant’s ability to focus on one task at a time and improve his reading and writing to an age-appropriate level.[4] The plan did not include funding for specific supports to address the applicant’s dyslexia and his mother immediately objected.[5] Subsequently, a request for funding for a dyscalculia specialist (i.e. a person who can address…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read XNTW and National Disability Insurance Agency and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] AATA 759
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by XNTW, an eleven-year-old boy with dyslexia and dyscalculia, seeking funding from the National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA) for literacy and numeracy tutoring. The applicant had previously been a participant in the NDIS due to Autism Spectrum Disorder. The dispute before the Tribunal was whether the NDIA was the appropriate body to fund or provide the requested educational supports.

The legal issues before the Tribunal were whether the literacy and numeracy supports sought by the applicant were "reasonable and necessary" within the meaning of the National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS) Act, and crucially, whether these supports were "most appropriately funded or provided" by the NDIA or another service system. The Tribunal was required to consider the specific provisions of the NDIS Rules, particularly those relating to the division of responsibility between the NDIS and other service providers, including educational institutions.

The Tribunal's reasoning focused on the interpretation of Rules 7.13 and 7.14 of the NDIS Rules. Rule 7.13 outlines the NDIS's responsibility for supports associated with the functional impact of a disability on daily living, excluding those primarily relating to education or training attainment. Conversely, Rule 7.14 explicitly states that the NDIS will not be responsible for personalising learning or supports that primarily relate to a student's educational attainment. Applying these rules to the evidence, which included school reports and expert assessments detailing the applicant's struggles with reading comprehension and basic mathematics, the Tribunal concluded that the sought-after tutoring was primarily aimed at improving his educational attainment.

Consequently, the Tribunal found that the literacy and numeracy supports were not most appropriately funded or provided by the NDIA, as these fall within the purview of educational services. The decision under review, which affirmed that the NDIA was not the appropriate source of funding for these specific supports, was therefore affirmed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Once Rules 7.13 and 7.14 are taken into account, it is difficult in the circumstances of this case, to reach any conclusion other than that the supports sought are not most appropriately funded by the NDIA.Evidence The evidence before me consists of the following:(a)The T-Documents with pages numbered 1-207 (T-Docs);(b)A Tender Bundle agreed by the parties with pages numbered 1-833 (Exhibit 1);(c)The School Report of the applicant for Semester 2 of 2021 (Exhibit 2);(d)An Excel Spreadsheet of test results at Canberra Reading Clinic (Exhibit 3);(e)Documents produced under summons from Canberra Reading Clinic, pages 1-242 made an exhibit on 3 April 2023 (Exhibit 4);(f)Witness Statement of Sarah Dorrough dated 1 June 2022 (Exhibit 5); and(g)The oral evidence of the following witnesses:(i)Marcelle Sternbeck-Rutter;(ii)the applicant’s mother;(iii)Andrew Buesnel;(iv)Jo Whithear; and(v)Sarah Dorrough.Facts As noted above, the applicant is an 11 year old boy. His father is Russian and his mother is a recent émigré from Kazakhstan. The applicant has one sibling and speaks Russian at home. His parents separated in 2015 and his mother lives in very straightened circumstances but is determined to provide her children with the very best opportunities to succeed in her adopted country. The applicant’s father did not give evidence in the matter, but it appears on the evidence available to me that he may be less willing to make financial sacrifices to explore measures which may improve his son’s capacity to read and write and understand mathematics. As noted above, the applicant first became a participant in the NDIS in 2018 on the basis of his ASD. He remained part of the scheme until 2020 when a decision was made to exclude him. He was re-admitted as a participant in the NDIS as a result of a decision in February 2021. A variety of disabilities and impairments were referenced in the application to become a participant including dyslexia.[10][10] T8 (n 2) 88. Prior to his re-admission to the NDIS, it was already clear that the applicant was struggling with literacy and numeracy. He was behind his peers in developing these skills. His mother had observed that he failed to progress in reading, and in particular, reading comprehension. When he read a basic text, he was unable to answer simple questions in relation to the material he was reading. In relation to numeracy the applicant struggled to remember basic number facts, could not tell the time and was unable to do basic calculations about the cost of an item and what change he would receive when purchasing items in a shop. His mother’s observations have been confirmed by his primary school teachers and other professionals. As a result of these concerns, the applicant’s mother decided to enrol him in various after school programs to address these problems. In 2018 and 2019 there was no suggestion that these programs should be funded by the NDIA. The applicant was enrolled at the Canberra Reading Clinic, a private organisation specialising in improving a child’s reading. The applicant was enrolled from the start of Term 4 2018 to the end of Term 4 2019.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Rules of particular relevance in Schedule 1 are the following:7.1 The Act limits the supports that can be provided or funded under the NDIS to supports that are not more appropriately funded or provided through other service systems, for example as part of a universal services obligation or in accordance with reasonable adjustments required under a law dealing with discrimination on the basis of disability.7.2 The considerations set out in this Schedule must be taken into account by the CEO in deciding whether a support is more appropriately provided or funded by the NDIS or another service system. 7.3 For the avoidance of doubt, while this Schedule sets our considerations relevant to whether a support should be considered to be more appropriately provided or funded through another service system, it does not purport to impose any obligations on another service system to fund or provide particular supports. …7.13 The NDIS will be responsible for supports that a student requires that are associated with the functional impact of the student’s disability on their activities of daily living (that is, those not primarily relating to education or training attainment), such as personal care and support, transport to and from school and specialist supports for transition from school education to further education, training or employment that are required because of the student’s disability. Any supports funded by the NDIS will recognise the operational requirements and educational objectives of schools.7.14 The NDIS will not be responsible for personalising either learning or supports for students that primarily relate to their educational attainment (including teaching, learning assistance and aids, school building modifications and transport between school activities). Other relevant aspects of the decision-making framework To flesh out the Tribunal’s decision-making task, there is also one Federal Court decision which bears on the operation of the Support Rules. The Federal Court gave consideration to the statutory task of approving Statements in the matter of National Disability Insurance Agency v WRMF.[8] In its judgment, the Court resisted determining what could be regarded as the outer limits of the phrase ‘reasonable and necessary supports’, but made one observation about the statute which is relevant to this case. The Court made the point that the matters in section 34 of the NDIS Act are not merely mandatory considerations but are in the nature of criteria which the decision maker must be satisfied of on the material before it. It is therefore clear that the Tribunal must be satisfied of all of the specific matters identified in the paragraphs of section 34(1) before a support can be included in a Statement.[9] [8] [2020] FCAFC 79.[9] Ibid [201]. In the present context this means that the applicant must satisfy me that the tutoring which the applicant seeks is ‘most appropriately funded or provided through’ the NDIS before I can specify it in the applicant’s Statement.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established