BDRY and National Disability Insurance Agency

Link copied
Case Copied 56 min read

BDRY and National Disability Insurance Agency [2023] AATA 3379 (19 October 2023)

Division:NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME DIVISION

File Number(s):      2021/4294

Re:BDRY

APPLICANT

AndNational Disability Insurance Agency

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Member D Barker

Date:19 October 2023

Place:Sydney

The Tribunal affirms the Decision under review.


....................................[SGD]....................................

Member D Barker

CATCHWORDS

NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME – reasonable and necessary supports – home repairs more appropriately funded by NSW Department of Communities and Justice Housing – consumables covered by assistive technology funding – capacity to add consumables funding with a s 47A variation – decision affirmed.

LEGISLATION

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth)
National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth)
National Disability Insurance Scheme (Supports for Participants) Rules 2013 (Cth)

Residential Tenancies Act 2010 (NSW)

CASES

Burchell and National Disability Insurance Agency [2019] AATA 1256
Fear by his mother Vanda Fear and National Disability Insurance Agency [2015] AATA 706
McGarrigle v National Disability Insurance Agency (2017) 252 FCR 121
National Disability Insurance Agency v WRMF (2020) 276 FCR 415

XNTW and National Disability Insurance Agency [2023] AATA 759

SECONDARY MATERIALS

National Disability Insurance Agency, Our Guidelines – Mainstream and community supports – Who is responsible for the supports you need? – Housing and community infrastructure (Web Page) < Disability Insurance Agency, Our Guidelines – Supports you can access - menu – Home and living supports – Home modifications (Web Page) <

NSW Department of Communities and Justice, Housing and homelessness – Tenant Repair Costs Policy (Web Page, accessed 6 September 2023) <

NSW Department of Communities and Justice, Housing Pathways – Evidence Requirements Information Sheet DH3001a (August 2023)

NSW Department of Communities and Justice, Repairs, modifications and maintenance to a property – Requesting maintenance and reporting problems (Web Page) < NSW, Housing and property – Social housing – Property maintenance issues and problems (Web Page) <

REASONS FOR DECISION

Member D Barker

19 October 2023

APPLICATION

  1. BDRY (the Applicant) is a ten-year-old participant in the National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS) who has diagnoses of Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD) (Level 3)[1], Global Developmental Delay (GDD)[2], Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD) and sleep disorder[3]. He has a disability arising from language difficulties, severe sensory processing difficulties and other impairments resulting from these conditions[4]. The Applicant gained access to the NDIS on the basis of his ASD (Level 3) on 16 August 2016[5].

    [1] Joint Hearing Bundle (JB), p 43).

    [2] Ibid.

    [3] Ibid, p 49.

    [4] Ibid, pp 288-336.

    [5] Respondent’s Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions (SFIC), [4].

  2. The Applicant lives in Sydney with his mother (Ms BDRY), who is also his representative in these proceedings, and six siblings who are aged between five and 22 years. A younger sister is also a participant of the NDIS.

  3. Ms BDRY made an application to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (the Tribunal) on 24 June 2021[6] on behalf of her son seeking a review of an internal…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read BDRY and National Disability Insurance Agency and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] AATA 3379
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by Ms BDRY, the applicant, for review of a decision made by the National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA). The dispute centred on whether certain supports requested for the applicant's son, who has Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD), severe global developmental delay, and severe language impairments, were reasonable and necessary under the National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS). Specifically, the applicant sought funding for home repairs and consumables, while the NDIA contended these were not NDIS-funded supports. The Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) was tasked with determining the appropriate funding for these supports.

The primary legal issues before the Tribunal were whether the requested home repairs constituted a reasonable and necessary support under section 34(1) of the NDIS Act, and whether consumables could be funded through assistive technology provisions or required a variation under section 47A of the NDIS Act. The Tribunal was required to consider the cumulative requirements of section 34(1), including the assistance the applicant's son would receive, whether the support represented value for money, and crucially, whether the NDIA was the most appropriate service delivery system compared to other potential funding avenues. The Tribunal also had to assess the NDIA's contention that general home maintenance and repairs were excluded from NDIS funding under the 'General criteria for supports' in Part 5 of the Support Rules.

The Tribunal reasoned that the requested home repairs were more appropriately funded by the NSW Department of Communities and Justice Housing, as they related to general living costs and were not solely attributable to the applicant's son's disability support needs, thus failing the criteria under section 34(1)(f) of the NDIS Act and Part 5.1(d) of the Support Rules. Regarding consumables, the Tribunal found that while they could be considered part of assistive technology funding, the capacity to add such funding was contingent on a section 47A variation. The Tribunal affirmed the NDIA's decision, concluding that the home repairs were not a reasonable and necessary support under the NDIS, and that consumables funding would require a specific variation.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons set out below, the Tribunal affirms the decision under review.BACKGROUND There is a history of ASD in both the Applicant’s paternal and maternal families. The Applicant was born at full-term via natural delivery following an uncomplicated pregnancy. He was discharged from hospital after birth with no complications and is reported to have met all early milestones within expected intervals. The Applicant’s language development was delayed and at 18 months of age, he was assessed to have partial hearing. The Applicant had grommets inserted in October 2015, when he was two years of age. The Applicant’s hearing was subsequently assessed as normal, however he remained non-verbal until the age of four and displayed increasing difficult behaviours over time[7].[7] Ibid, p 296. The Applicant was referred to a Paediatrician in 2016, Dr Macdessi, who assessed and diagnosed him with ASD. He was subsequently diagnosed with a severe level of GDD and severe language impairments by Liverpool Health Service, also in 2016.[8][8] Ibid. Goals identified in the Applicant’s NDIS Plans which are discussed in these Reasons are as follows:Short term goal:(a)I would like to improve my language and communication skills to develop my social skills.(b)I would like me to be able to regulate my emotions to improve my relationships.Medium or long-term goal:(a)I would like to develop my social skills to further my independence.(b)I would like to improve on my self-care skills to further my independence.(c)I would like to improve my cognitive skills to develop my daily living skills.(d)I would like to improve on my fine and gross motor skills to develop my daily life.[9][9] JB, pp 94-95. In relation to the Applicant’s goal of improving their self-care skills to further their independence, a consistent example provided in their NDIS Plans was to become more independent in daily living skills, with particular reference to becoming more independent when using the toilet. In relation to how the Applicant will be supported with this goal, the NDIS Plans state that he will be provided with opportunities at home to practice skills and strategies to support the goal.Statement of Participant Supports and NDIS Plan – 6 April 2021 On 6 April 2021, a delegate of the CEO of the NDIA made a decision under s 33(2) of the Act to approve a SOPS in the Applicant’s NDIS Plan for the period 6 April 2021 to 6 April 2022[10]. [10] Ibid, pp 129-142. Under this SOPS, total funding of $53,736.48 was approved for the period 6 April 2021 to 6 April 2022, including:(a)Core Supports of $21,246.55 NDIA-managed, including:(i)$1,000 for assistive technology for the purchase of Basic (Level 1) and Standard (Level 2) assistive technology, and minor repairs to assistive technology, to support the Applicant to achieve their goals and outcomes;(ii)funding for 1 hour per day to assist and/or supervise daily care needs.(b)Capacity Building Supports of $32,489.93, including:(i)$9,311.52 Plan-managed - Improved Daily Living (CB Daily Activity) for:oOccupational therapy - 24 hours, plus time for report writing;oSpeech therapy - 12 hours, plus time for report writing;oPhysiotherapy - 12 hours; andoTherapy assistant to support with implementing strategies - 3 hours per week.(ii)$10,312.10 NDIA-managed (CB Relationships) for:o$6,432.30 Specialist Behavioural Intervention Support – 30 hours;o$3,879.80 Behaviour Management Plan including Training In Behaviour Management Strategies – 20 hours;(iii)$6,573.84 Plan-managed - Increased Social and Community Participation (CB Social Community Civic); and(iv)$4,806.72 NDIA-managed - Support Coordination.The Internal Review Decision

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Section 35 of the NDIS Act permits NDIS rules to be made about the content of a SOPS. Subsection 35(1) of the NDIS Act provides that the NDIS rules may prescribe methods or criteria to be applied, or matters to which the CEO is to have regard, in deciding, the reasonable and necessary supports or general supports that will be funded or provided under the NDIS[21], reasonable and necessary supports or general supports that will not be funded under the NDIS[22], and reasonable and necessary supports or general supports that will or will not be funded or provided under the NDIS for prescribed participants[23]. EVIDENCE AND SUBMISSIONS[21] NDIS Act, s 35(1)(a).[22] Ibid, s 35(1)(b).[23] Ibis, s 35(1)(c). The documents before the Tribunal include: The ‘T-Documents’ (T1-T18, pp 1-237) provided under section 37 of the AAT Act to the Tribunal by the Respondent after the application for review was made, which comprises evidence provided by the Applicant to the Respondent and other documents available to the NDIA Internal Reviewer at the time of their decision. The Applicant’s material as follows:(a)Updated request for information & responses;(b)Behaviour Assessment and Recommendation Report by Adam Conway, Provisional Psychologist, Upscale Care, dated 30 March 2022;(c)Email from Just For Kids Therapy dated 24 February 2022;(d)NDIS Plan Review Report by Mohammed Makkouk, Physiotherapist, dated 15 April 2022;(e)Email from Sydney Olympic Park Authority dated 28 February 2022;(f)Letter of support from Sharnez Elghoul, Support Worker, dated 18 February 2022;(g)Positive Behaviour Support Plans prepared by Adam Conway, Provisional Psychologist and Behavioural Support Clinician, Upscale Care, dated 15 July 2022 and 28 September 2022;(h)Annotated extract from Applicant’s NDIS Plan, approved 23 December 2020; and(i)Letter of support regarding Ms BDRY from Dr Magedy Hawi, dated 20 January 2023. The NDIA, being the Respondent in this matter, lodged the following documents with the Tribunal:(a)Occupational Therapy Assessment Report prepared by Kate Morris, Occupational Therapist, dated 29 September 2022;(b)NDIS Guidelines - Home Modifications;(c)The NSW Communities and Justice Tenant Repair Costs Policy; and(d)Applicant’s NDIS Plan and SOPS approved on 31 May 2023. Other material was also provided as follows:(a)Respondent’s SFIC dated 28 April 2023;(b)Applicant’s SFIC email dated 30 May 2023;(c)Respondent email regarding NSW legislation and policies regarding repair costs, dated 9 June 2023; and(d)Applicant email statement in reply, dated 29 June 2023.CONSIDERATIONConsideration of whether the repairs to the family home can be funded through the NDIS The Tribunal considered whether the requested home modifications funding to repair damage to the family home caused by the Applicant (the home repairs) can be funded as a reasonable and necessary support through s 34(1) of the NDIS Act. The requirements in s 34(1) of the NDIS Act can be grouped into 3 categories. Subsections 34(1) (a), (b) and (d) require the Tribunal to focus on the assistance an Applicant will get from being provided with a particular support. Paragraph (c) requires the Tribunal to assess whether the support represents value for money. Subsections 34(1)(e) and (f) focus on whether the NDIA is the right party to be providing the support. Subsection 34(1)(e) requires consideration of what can be expected of families and other voluntary providers, and s 34(1)(f) requires consideration of whether another service delivery system is more appropriate than the NDIS to provide or fund the support the support that is being sought.

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 7 June 2021, a delegate of the CEO of the NDIA made a decision under s 100(6)(a) of the Act (the internal review decision) to confirm the statement of participant supports approved on 6 April 2021[12].[12] JB, p 17.The AAT Review Application On behalf of the Applicant, Ms BDRY, on 24 June 2021, applied to the Tribunal for a review of the internal review decision[13]. Ms BDRY provided the following explanation for why she considered the internal review decision was wrong:[13] Ibid, p 1.My son cannot tell you what he needs and I, as his parent will be his voice. 1. I want to have the PLAN option as self- managed so that I can get the same carers that used to work with my son as they are not an NDIA registered but were the ones who used to make sure my son was out everyday either at the park or pools or even around other kids his age through a brotherhood program. The NDIS keep cutting off funding under all categories and cut off dramatically, he has become more angry and frustrated and self harming more via biting and hitting anyone in sight when not being understood and all he does now is stay at home.For example, under core support, the NDIS approved only ONE HOUR 1 hr per day of support, have forced me to change the option of my plan to an Agency Managed which is much not flexible and is harder to appoint a support worker, it is restrictive in my case. My support coordinator is not able to find someone willing to work with him or that I can trust bringing into my home as I'm a single parent with 7 kids trying to make it all work. I have another child who is on the NDIS with intellectual delays.Since his Speech and OT therapies have dropped to 1 day a week he is not benefiting at all when they do come to work with him as his behaviour has gotten worse because of all this new plan where the NDIS believe that what his getting is more than he needs. I want my son to lead a normal life.I want him to make friends he has no friendsI want to have a conversation with my son and be able to ask him - How was your day? Did you have fun at school? How do you feel?I wish that I can get responses for these questions from him but I can't as my son just repeats what you ask he has no answers as he does not comprehend anything that you say just repeats what you say.In addition, my sons school also strongly believe that my son needs more than what he is receiving right now. We are having to deal with his aggressive behaviour on many occasions where I had to go pick him up as he would hit teachers as well as students. At the moment, he is suspended from school which make it even worse for his situation to improve. His therapists have stated that the one day is not enough for him whatsoever.[14][14] JB, p 5.The Statement of Participant Supports and NDIS Plan – 31 May 2023 In the course of these proceedings and at the request of the Parties the Tribunal considered and found it appropriate to, on 29 May 2023, remit the reviewable decision for further consideration to the Respondent pursuant to s 42D of the AAT Act. The Respondent’s delegate reconsidered the reviewable decision on 31 May 2023. This resulted in the Respondent’s delegate making a new decision to approve another SOPS in the Applicant’s Plan[15]. This decision is now the decision that is under review for the purpose of this review application.[16][15] NDIS Plan approved on 31 May 2023, filed by the Respondent on 31 May 2023. [16] S 42D(4)(a) of the AAT Act.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Other material was also provided as follows:(a)Respondent’s SFIC dated 28 April 2023;(b)Applicant’s SFIC email dated 30 May 2023;(c)Respondent email regarding NSW legislation and policies regarding repair costs, dated 9 June 2023; and(d)Applicant email statement in reply, dated 29 June 2023.CONSIDERATIONConsideration of whether the repairs to the family home can be funded through the NDIS The Tribunal considered whether the requested home modifications funding to repair damage to the family home caused by the Applicant (the home repairs) can be funded as a reasonable and necessary support through s 34(1) of the NDIS Act. The requirements in s 34(1) of the NDIS Act can be grouped into 3 categories. Subsections 34(1) (a), (b) and (d) require the Tribunal to focus on the assistance an Applicant will get from being provided with a particular support. Paragraph (c) requires the Tribunal to assess whether the support represents value for money. Subsections 34(1)(e) and (f) focus on whether the NDIA is the right party to be providing the support. Subsection 34(1)(e) requires consideration of what can be expected of families and other voluntary providers, and s 34(1)(f) requires consideration of whether another service delivery system is more appropriate than the NDIS to provide or fund the support the support that is being sought. Even if a support meets the requirements in s 34(a)-(d), the support can only be included in a SOPS if the decision maker, which is now the Tribunal, is satisfied that provision through, or funding by, the NDIS, is the most appropriate system for delivering the support. This is because, as is discussed earlier in these Reasons, the requirements in s 34(1) are cumulative and s 34 of the NDIS will not be met if any of the criteria in s 34(1) are not satisfied. The Respondent contends that the NDIS is prohibited from funding general home maintenance and repairs (such as damage to internal walls) by operation of the ‘General criteria for supports’ which will not be funded under Part 5 of the Support Rules.[24] Part 5 of the Support Rules provides that: [24] Respondent’s SFIC, [34].General criteria for supports5.1A support will not be provided or funded under the NDIS if:(a)it is likely to cause harm to the participant or pose a risk to others; or(b)it is not related to the participant’s disability; or(c)it duplicates other supports delivered under alternative funding through the NDIS; or(d)it relates to day-to-day living costs (for example, rent, groceries and utility fees) that are not attributable to a participant’s disability support needs.5.2The day-to-day living costs referred to in paragraph 5.1(d) do not include the following (which may be funded under the NDIS if they relate to reasonable and necessary supports):(a)additional living costs that are incurred by a participant solely and directly as a result of their disability support needs;(b)costs that are ancillary to another support that is funded or provided under the participant’s plan, and which the participant would not otherwise incur.