YPRM and National Disability Insurance Agency

Link copied
Case Copied 37 min read

YPRM and National Disability Insurance Agency [2016] AATA 1023 (14 December 2016)

Division

NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME DIVISION

File Number(s)

2016/0834

Re

YPRM

APPLICANT

And

National Disability Insurance Agency

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Deputy President Gary Humphries
Senior Member Jill Toohey

Date 14 December 2016
Place Canberra

The Tribunal affirms the reviewable decision.

.........................[sgd]...............................................

Deputy President Gary Humphries

Catchwords

National Disability Insurance Scheme – access – child – type 1 diabetes – early intervention requirements – whether early intervention supports not most appropriately funded through NDIS – whether more appropriately funded through other general systems – decision under review affirmed

Legislation      

National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013

Cases

McGarrigle and NDIA [2016] AATA 498

Mulligan and NDIA [2015] AATA 974 (Mulligan No 2)

Young and National Disability Insurance Agency [2014] AATA 401

Secondary materials

National Disability Insurance Scheme (Becoming a Participant) Rules 2016

NDIS Operational Guideline – Access – Early Intervention Requirements

Productivity Commission Inquiry Report, Disability Care and Support, Report No 54, August 2011

NDIS – Principles to Determine the Responsibilities of the NDIS and Other Service Systems (the COAG Principles)

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President Gary Humphries
Senior Member Jill Toohey

Introduction

  1. This decision concerns a five-year old child who was diagnosed with type 1 diabetes when she was four years old.  Her mother seeks review on her behalf of a decision by the National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA) that she does not qualify to be a participant in the National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS).

  2. A participant is a person who meets the access criteria in s 21 of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (the Act): s 28(1).  In addition to age and residence requirements, a person must meet the disability requirements in s 24(1) or the early intervention requirements in s 25. 

  3. A person who becomes a participant in the NDIS may receive funding for reasonable and necessary supports that satisfy the provisions of s 34(1).

  4. The child in this case meets the age and residence requirements.  Her mother acknowledges that she does not meet all of the disability requirements in s 24.  The question is whether she meets the early intervention requirements in s 25.

    The objective of early intervention

  5. The NDIS is conceived as an “insurance-based approach, informed by actuarial analysis, to the provision and funding of supports for people with disability”: s 3(2)(b).  Consistent with this approach, the objective of early intervention support is to “lower the costs and impacts associated with the disability for individuals and the wider community over the longer term”.[1]

    [1] Productivity Commission Inquiry Report, Disability Care and Support, Report No 54, 31 July 2011, vol 2, p 609.

  6. The early intervention requirements “consider the likely trajectory and impact of a person's impairment over time and the potential benefits of early intervention on the impact of the impairment on the person's functional capacity”.[2]  In this respect, the early intervention requirements differ from the disability requirements in s 24(1) which require

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read YPRM and National Disability Insurance Agency and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] AATA 1023
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Administrative Appeals Tribunal, presided over by Deputy President Gary Humphries, considered an application by YPRM concerning the National Disability Insurance Agency's decision regarding access to the National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS) for a child with type 1 diabetes. The dispute centred on whether the early intervention supports required by the child were more appropriately funded through the NDIS or other general systems.

The Tribunal was required to determine whether the early intervention supports sought for the child, arising from type 1 diabetes, were more appropriately funded through the NDIS or through other general systems, such as the health system. This involved assessing whether the supports were primarily related to managing a chronic health condition or addressed a disability.

The Tribunal reasoned that while the NDIS can fund early intervention supports, there is a broad division of responsibility between the NDIS and the health system. The health system is responsible for services addressing chronic health conditions, while the NDIS covers services for disabilities. Applying this to the case, the Tribunal found that the early intervention supports required by the child stemmed essentially from the management of her chronic health condition, type 1 diabetes, particularly during her youth. The evidence, including Professor Craig's report, highlighted the medical risks and the significant adult supervision required for managing the child's blood glucose levels and dietary intake. The Tribunal concluded that these supports, described as time-limited and goal-oriented services with a predominant purpose related to health status, should be provided outside the NDIS.

The Tribunal affirmed the decision under review, finding that the early intervention supports were not most appropriately funded through the NDIS.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In addition to full-time assistance at school, the mother says the child requires constant and ongoing monitoring throughout the day and night, and “holistic interventions focused on her medical needs, her social inclusion and her physical and mental ability for self-care”. We understand her to seek support that will improve the child’s functional capacity in social interaction, learning, self-care and self-management.Professor Craig’s evidence Professor Craig provided a written report dated 28 July 2016. It is relevant to reproduce parts of her report in full. In her report, Professor Craig stated:[The child’s] developmental milestones are delayed by the pervasive nature of type 1 diabetes, which markedly impairs her functional capacity in activities of daily living, every day, 24 hours a day. She is unable to perform a wide range of normal daily functions compared with other children of her age, due to the restrictions imposed on her by the effects of type 1 diabetes and its treatment. Specific milestones that have been delayed include self-care, achievement of personal-social skills, development of emotional maturity, gross motor skills and cognitive development. Professor Craig reported that the child’s ability to feed herself is “markedly delayed - she cannot feed herself without assistance at home, at school, or in any other setting”. She stated:Everything she consumes must be checked to evaluate whether it is a carbohydrate food or not, and the quantity weighed/measured and entered into her pump. Her blood glucose level must be checked at the same time. The insulin dose required for the amount of carbohydrate she will consume must then be entered into the pump (it is not automatic). In addition, a judgment needs to be made as to whether to increase or decrease in the amount of insulin the pump recommends, which depends upon on her blood glucose level at the time and planned activities. The dose must be checked by a responsible adult, and modified depending upon the situation. She must then be supervised to ensure she consumes the right amount of carbohydrate entered into the pump, because if she does not, she will have a hypo and if she doesn’t eat it all, the consequences can be disastrous (such as… her becoming unconscious or having a seizure). Every meal and snack, every day, must be managed by an adult – it is too complex for a child of her age to safety determine on the amount of carbohydrate or insulin dose, since an error can have serious, life-threatening consequences. Professor Craig reported that, whenever the child performs any form of exercise or activity, her blood glucose level must be checked and, if necessary, insulin administered to reduce it, or a specific type of fast-acting carbohydrate eaten to prevent hypoglycaemia. She stated that the child’s “motor skills are therefore delayed compared with a child of her age, who would ordinarily be able to participate in sport, play in the school ground or in their backyard without adult supervision and close monitoring…”. Further, Professor Craig stated that the restriction on her ability to exercise has limited her physical development as she is not able to participate in the same range of physical activities as other children of her age.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Of course, the fact that admitting a person, or by implication a class of persons, to be participants under the Act entails cost to the scheme does not conclusively dispose of such an application. Financial sustainability is but one of a number of considerations which decision-makers must bear in mind. Consideration The Tribunal recognises that the Act, and the extrinsic documents aiding in its interpretation, envisage a broad division of responsibility between the NDIS and (relevantly here) the health system. That division places at the feet of the health system the provision of services and supports that address chronic health conditions, and into the bailiwick of the NDIS services and supports addressing what might be colloquially described as disabilities. Notional examples of such chronic health conditions given in the Productivity Commission report include emphysema, haemophilia and breast cancer; examples of such “disabilities” include blindness, multiple sclerosis and amputated limbs.[9][9] Productivity Commission, Disability Care and Support Report, August 2011, p 752. The child in the present proceedings suffers from a chronic health condition – type 1 diabetes. We accept that sufferers from chronic health conditions may be able to meet the early intervention requirements of s 25, although the Productivity Commission report suggests they are less likely to do so than a person with what is commonly thought of as a disability. Having heard the evidence, we take the view that the early intervention support required by the child arises essentially out of the exigencies of her chronic health condition. Many of the early intervention supports described to the Tribunal as being sought by the child amount, in our opinion, to supports relating directly or indirectly to the management of her blood glucose levels during a period of particular vulnerability, namely her extreme youth. As such, they fall within what the Support for Participant Rules describes as “time-limited, goal-oriented services and therapies…where the predominant purpose is treatment directly related to the person’s health status”, that is, as services which should be provided outside the NDIS. The following observations on the evidence support that conclusion. Professor Craig’s evidence emphasised the medical risks associated with type 1 diabetes in young children, including sensory and autonomic nerve damage, and even death. Although Professor Craig also observed that diabetes led to a reduction in the child’s functional capacity, it seems to the Tribunal that this reduction in capacity stems substantially from the challenges surrounding the management of her blood glucose levels. Her inability, for example, to feed herself independently is the product of needing to manage potentially-disastrous outcomes if her insulin levels are not properly calibrated with her dietary intake, not of the condition per se. As she grows older, this reduction in functional capacity will lessen with maturity and experience, even though the condition itself is unlikely to ameliorate.