Allen and National Disability Insurance Agency

Link copied
Case Copied 33 min read

Allen and National Disability Insurance Agency [2018] AATA 3851 (15 October 2018)

Division:NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME DIVISION

File Number(s):      2017/7731

Re:Shareema Allen

APPLICANT

AndNational Disability Insurance Agency

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Professor R McCallum AO, Member

Date:15 October 2018

Place:Sydney

The reviewable decision is affirmed

.....................[sgd]...................................................

Professor R McCallum AO, Member

CATCHWORDS

NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME - access to the scheme - disability requirements - Hypermobile Ehlers-Danlos Syndrome - communication - social interaction - learning - mobility - self-care - self management - whether applicant satisfies the early intervention requirements - whether early intervention support most appropriately funded through the NDIS - decision affirmed

LEGISLATION

National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth)

National Disability Insurance Scheme (Becoming a Participant) Rules 2013 (Cth)

National Disability Insurance Scheme (Supports for Participants) Rules 2013 (Cth)

CASES

BBMC and National Disability Insurance Agency [2018] AATA 386

Kilgallin and National Disability Insurance Agency [2017] AATA 186
Pomeroy and National Disability Insurance Agency [2018] AATA 387
Re Drake and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No 2) [1979] AATA 179; (1979) 2 ALD 634.
Young and National Disability Insurance Agency [2014] AATA 401

YPRM and National Disability Insurance Agency [2016] AATA 1023

SECONDARY MATERIALS

National Disability Insurance Scheme, Operational Guidelines (Access)

REASONS FOR DECISION

Professor R McCallum AO, Member

15 October 2018

INTRODUCTION

  1. The Applicant, Ms Shareema Allen, lives in Sydney with her husband and three children. In February 2017, Ms Allen was diagnosed by a geneticist as having Hypermobile Ehlers-Danlos Syndrome which is also known as Type III EDS. Throughout this decision, I shall refer to Ms Allen’s Hypermobile Ehlers-Danlos Syndrome as her “HEDS”.

    How is Hypermobile Ehlers-Danlos Syndrome defined?

  2. Extracts from a booklet titled “Understanding Hypermobile Ehlers-Danlos Syndrome and Hypermobility Spectrum Disorder” by Claire Smith are before the Tribunal (Redcliff-House Publications, England: 2017).[1] On page 20 of this booklet, HEDS is pithily described as follows:

    Hypermobile Ehlers-Danlos syndrome (hEDS) is the newly defined term for the heritable disorder of connective tissue that has, until recently, been known synonymously as ‘Ehlers-Danlos hypermobility type’ and ‘joint hypermobility syndrome.’

    …

    Hypermobile Ehlers-Danlos syndrome (hEDS) is considered the most prevalent type of inherited genetic disorder of connective tissue in the world although the causational gene(s) are yet to be identified. It is defined by the association of generalised joint hypermobility, joint instability complications, widespread musculoskeletal pain, (minor) skin features and/or pelvic/rectal/uterine dysfunction, and is now widely recognised as being associated with the potential to affect multiple systems of the body including the cardiovascular autonomic system, the gastrointestinal system and mast sell activation. [citations omitted].

    [1] Exhibit A10.

  3. In paragraphs 10 to 13 of Ms Allen’s statement dated 20 April 2018,[2] she gives her opinion on how HEDS affects her. Ms Allen writes, in part, as follows:

    [2] Exhibit A4.

    I have type III of EDS which is the hypermobile form. It affects the collagen in my body. EDS causes hyper-extension of my arms, legs and other joints, which can result in joint dislocations and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Allen and National Disability Insurance Agency and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] AATA 3851
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by Ms Allen for review of a decision by the National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA) to refuse her access to the National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS). Ms Allen suffers from Hypermobile Ehlers-Danlos Syndrome (HEDS), and the dispute centred on whether her condition met the eligibility requirements for the NDIS, specifically the disability requirements under section 24 and the early intervention requirements under section 25 of the *National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013* (Cth). The Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) was tasked with determining these issues.

The Tribunal was required to consider two primary legal questions. Firstly, whether Ms Allen satisfied the disability requirements as set out in section 24 of the Act, which necessitates meeting all five specified criteria, including having a permanent impairment that affects her capacity for social and economic participation. Secondly, the Tribunal had to determine if Ms Allen met the early intervention requirements under section 25 of the Act, which relates to the provision of time-limited, goal-oriented services and therapies where the predominant purpose is treatment directly related to a person's health status.

In its reasoning, the Tribunal applied the principles established in previous cases, such as *YPRM and National Disability Insurance Agency*, which distinguish between services provided by the health system for chronic health conditions and supports provided by the NDIS for disabilities. The Tribunal found that while Ms Allen's HEDS was a permanent impairment affecting her capacity for social and economic participation, she did not meet the criteria under section 24(1)(c) of the Act, which requires a substantially reduced functional capacity in specific activities like communication, social interaction, learning, mobility, self-care, or self-management. Furthermore, the Tribunal concluded that the early intervention support Ms Allen required, as evidenced by reports from allied health professionals recommending strategies for managing her condition and improving physical function, was predominantly related to the management of her health status. Therefore, such support was considered to fall outside the scope of the NDIS and should be provided by the health system.

Consequently, the Tribunal found that Ms Allen did not fulfil the early intervention requirements under section 25 of the NDIS Act. The reviewable decision of the NDIA to affirm Ms Allen's ineligibility for the NDIS was therefore affirmed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In YPRM and National Disability Insurance Agency [2016] AATA 1023, the Tribunal dealt with a somewhat similar case concerning the treatment of a child with type 1 diabetes. At paragraphs 81-83, the Tribunal said:The Tribunal recognises that the Act, and the extrinsic documents aiding in its interpretation, envisage a broad division of responsibility between the NDIS and (relevantly here) the health system. That division places at the feet of the health system the provision of services and supports that address chronic health conditions, and into the bailiwick of the NDIS services and supports addressing what might be colloquially described as disabilities. Notional examples of such chronic health conditions given in the Productivity Commission report include emphysema, haemophilia and breast cancer; examples of such “disabilities” include blindness, multiple sclerosis and amputated limbs.[14]The child in the present proceedings suffers from a chronic health condition – type 1 diabetes. We accept that sufferers from chronic health conditions may be able to meet the early intervention requirements of s 25, although the Productivity Commission report suggests they are less likely to do so than a person with what is commonly thought of as a disability.Having heard the evidence, we take the view that the early intervention support required by the child arises essentially out of the exigencies of her chronic health condition. Many of the early intervention supports described to the Tribunal as being sought by the child amount, in our opinion, to supports relating directly or indirectly to the management of her blood glucose levels during a period of particular vulnerability, namely her extreme youth. As such, they fall within what the Support for Participant Rules describes as “time-limited, goal-oriented services and therapies…where the predominant purpose is treatment directly related to the person’s health status”, that is, as services which should be provided outside the NDIS. [14] Productivity Commission, Disability Care and Support Report, August 2011, p 752.The evidence before the Tribunal The following evidence concerning Ms Allen’s HEDS and its treatment is before the Tribunal. In her Functional Needs Assessment Report dated 19 April 2018, Ms Telford recommended that input from an Occupational Therapist is required to develop sustainable routines, pacing techniques, and to incorporate assistive technology into her daily life and a limited number of support worker hours e.g. three per week to assist in these activities of daily living. Ms Allen receives ten Allied Health sessions per year from Medicare and from her Aboriginal health plan. In her evidence before the Tribunal, Ms Telford said that ten Allied Health sessions each year were insufficient to assist Ms Allen in learning strategies and techniques. In his report dated 19 April 2018, Mr Tony Larven wrote:It is my view that this lady [Ms Allen] requires assistance in order to find the type, intensity and duration therapeutic physical activity that she might be able to perform which enables the muscles around all the joints above mentioned can be strengthened in order to provide some support and that may result in an improvement of her symptom behaviour.It is my view that this would require assessment and development of a program by a physiotherapist with some experience of dealing in patients with hypermobility syndromes. This would require implementation of a program over the first six to eight weeks, perhaps even on a weekly basis. From that point it may require monthly monitoring, progression and troubleshooting over a 12 month period.[15][15] Exhibit A6 at 3.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Therefore, I find that Ms Allen does not fulfil the early intervention requirements criteria under section 25 of the NDIS Act. DECISION The reviewable decision is affirmed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The CEO of the NDIA has also written operational guidelines to aid decision-makers. The operational guidelines are Government policy and should be applied by the Tribunal unless there are good reasons to depart from them: see Re Drake and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No 2)[1979] AATA 179; (1979) 2 ALD 634.CONSIDERATION There are two issues before the Tribunal:·First, whether Ms Allen can become a participant in the NDIS by meeting the disability requirements set out in section 24 of the NDIS Act; and·Second, whether Ms Allen can become a participant in the NDIS by meeting the early intervention requirements set out in section 25 of the NDIS Act.Ms Allen and the disability requirements Section 24 of the NDIS Act has been set out earlier in this decision. Section 24(1) will be satisfied if Ms Allen meets the five requirements specified in paragraphs (a) to (e) of this provision. As each paragraph is joined by the conjunction “and”, it is necessary for Ms Allen to meet all of the requirements to become a participant in the NDIS. The Respondent concedes that Ms Allen meets paragraphs (a), (b) and (d) of section 24(1) of the NDIS Act. From the evidence before me, I find that Ms Allen has a disability under paragraph (a) as her disability results from her impairments caused by HEDS. I also find that her impairments are permanent under paragraph (b). I further find that Ms Allen complies with paragraph (d) because her impairments affect her capacity for social and economic participation. Therefore, I am required to further decide whether Ms Allen meets the requirements set out in paragraphs (c) and (e) of section 24 of the NDIS Act. If I find that Ms Allen does not comply with paragraph (c), it will not be necessary for me to consider whether she complies with paragraph (e).Do Ms Allen’s impairments result in substantially reduced functional capacity to undertake one or more of the following activities: communication; social interaction; learning; mobility; self-care; or self-management within the meaning of section 24(1)(c)? It is important to appreciate that to comply with section 24(1)(c) of the NDIS Act, Ms Allen must show that her impairments result in substantially reduced functional capacity to undertake any one of the activities specified in subparagraphs (i) to (vi) of section 24(1)(c). Paragraph 5.8 of the Participant Rules is of assistance. It provides as follows:5.8 An impairment results in substantially reduced functional capacity of a person to undertake one or more of the relevant activities—communication, social interaction, learning, mobility, self-care, self-management (see paragraph 5.1(c))—if its result is that:(a) the person is unable to participate effectively or completely in the activity, or to perform tasks or actions required to undertake or participate effectively or completely in the activity, without assistive technology, equipment (other than commonly used items such as glasses) or home modifications; or(b) the person usually requires assistance (including physical assistance, guidance, supervision or prompting) from other people to participate in the activity or to perform tasks or actions required to undertake or participate in the activity; or(c) the person is unable to participate in the activity or to perform tasks or actions required to undertake or participate in the activity, even with assistive technology, equipment, home modifications or assistance from another person.