Dyson and National Disability Insurance Agency

Link copied
Case Copied 78 min read

Dyson and National Disability Insurance Agency [2022] AATA 3252 (11 October 2022)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2019/6305

Re:Nina Dyson

APPLICANT

AndNational Disability Insurance Agency

RESPONDENT

Decision              

Tribunal:Member I Thompson

Date:11 October 2022

Place:Adelaide

The decision under review, made by the Agency on 30 September 2019, is affirmed.

..........[Sgnd]....................................................

Member I Thompson

Catchwords

NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME – access to the scheme – disability requirements – early intervention requirements – consideration of medical history – decision affirmed

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975
National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013
National Disability Insurance Scheme Amendment (Participant Service Guarantee and Other Measures) Act 2022
National Disability Insurance Scheme (Becoming a Participant) Rules 2016

Cases

Mulligan v NDIA (2015) FCA 544
Madelaine & National Disability Insurance Agency [2020] AATA 4025
Allen & National Disability Insurance Agency [2018] AATA 3851
Jourifan & National Disability Insurance Agency [2020) AATA 1883
MHZQ & National Disability Insurance Agency [2019] AATA 810
Holmes & National Disability Insurance Agency [2017] AATA 2750
Kilgallin & National Disability Insurance Agency [2017] AATA 186
Nika & National Disability Insurance Agency (2021) AATA 2127

REASONS FOR DECISION

Member I Thompson

11 October 2022

INTRODUCTION

  1. The applicant, Ms Nina Dyson, made an access request to the National Disability Insurance Agency (the Agency) to become a participant in the National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS).

  2. The Agency declined the request. Ms Dyson sought an internal review of that decision, which was subsequently affirmed, and confirmed to Ms Dyson by letter from the Agency dated 30 September 2019 (the reviewable decision).[1] On internal review a delegate of the Agency was not satisfied that Ms Dyson met the disability or early intervention requirements. In applying to the Tribunal for a review, Ms Dyson wrote: “I believe that the decision is wrong and very unfair considering the health issues that I have.”[2]

    [1] Exhibit B, T2 – NDIA letter 30 September 2019

    [2] Exhibit B, T1

  3. Ms Dyson wrote in her pre-hearing statement[3] that she has a back condition which is a long-term impairment as a result of an accident at work in 1994, together with depression, which was first diagnosed in 2000 and is a direct result of the chronic back pain. The Agency accepted that Ms Dyson has a disability attributable to impairments resulting from a cervical disc prolapse, cervical disc herniation and spinal stenosis, although not from depression. The Agency considered that evidence about her impairments did not meet the necessary criteria about permanency.[4]

    [3] Exhibit C

    [4] Exhibit B, T2 – NDIA letter 30 September 2019

  4. The hearing in the Tribunal took place by video. Ms Dyson was self-represented, with support from her advocate, Ms Coates. The Agency was represented by counsel, Mr d’Assumpcao.

  5. Ms Dyson is now 62 years old. She provided written statements prior to the hearing and gave oral evidence by video at the hearing.

  6. To qualify as a participant in the NDIS, an applicant must meet the criteria outlined in s…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Dyson and National Disability Insurance Agency and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] AATA 3252
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application for review by Ms Dyson of a decision by the National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA) to refuse her access to the National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS). The Tribunal was required to determine whether Ms Dyson met the disability requirements or the early intervention requirements for access to the NDIS.

The primary legal issue was whether Ms Dyson's impairments resulted in a substantially reduced functional capacity, as required by section 24(1)(c) of the NDIS Act. The Tribunal also considered the impact of amendments to sections 24 and 25 of the NDIS Act, which came into effect during the review process, particularly concerning impairments attributable to psychiatric conditions.

The Tribunal noted that while Ms Dyson had a significant medical history, including chronic back pain and various other conditions, the NDIA's principal contention was that she did not meet the criteria for substantially reduced functional capacity. The Tribunal referred to operational guidelines which clarified that reliance on commonly used items or undertaking tasks differently or more slowly does not necessarily equate to a substantially reduced functional capacity. The Tribunal found that Ms Dyson met the age, residence, and certain other disability requirements under section 24(1) of the NDIS Act, but crucially, she did not satisfy the requirement under section 24(1)(c) concerning substantially reduced functional capacity.

Consequently, as Ms Dyson failed to meet all the requirements under section 24(1) of the NDIS Act, she did not fulfil the disability access criteria. The Tribunal concluded that it was not necessary to determine whether she met the early intervention requirements under section 25 of the Act, as her failure to meet the disability requirements was determinative.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Tribunal has regard to s 8.3.1 of the Operational Guideline,[36] and in particular, the following passages about an impairment resulting in substantially reduced functional capacity: [36] Exhibit B, T18By itself, reliance on commonly used items will not result in a substantially reduced functional capacity to participate effectively or completely in an activity. Commonly used items include glasses, walking sticks, non-slip bathmats, bathroom grab rails, stair rails, age appropriate child safety locks, simple adapted kitchen utensils and dressing aids.In considering the role played by assistive technology, home modifications and equipment, the NDIA will consider specific needs arising from the prospective participant's impairment, and whether those needs are met (or need to be met) through the use of specialist disability aids and/or equipment.Such items would generally be specifically designed to assist in increasing the functional capacity and participation of people with disability and be formally prescribed by a medical practitioner, specialist clinician or allied health professional such as an occupational therapist, physiotherapist or speech therapist.When considering whether a person requires assistance from others to participate or perform tasks associated with an activity, the NDIA will have regard to whether a person's need for assistance is consistent with normal expectations of a person of a similar age…A person will be unable to participate effectively or completely in an activity if they cannot safely complete one or more of the tasks required to participate in an acceptable period. Undertaking a task more slowly or differently to others will not necessarily mean a person cannot participate effectively or completely in an activity.[37] [37] Exhibit B, T18, Operational Guideline – Access, pp 105–106Allied health evidence The Agency arranged for an independent assessment of Ms Dyson to be undertaken by an occupational therapist, Ms De Vries. She attended Ms Dyson’s home on 21 October 2020, and she wrote a report on 30 October 2020 about that assessment and her findings. The report [38] was admitted into evidence at the hearing and Ms De Vries gave evidence about it by video. Before the assessment, she was provided with various background reports and material, which were listed in her report and in which she acknowledged that Ms Dyson’s primary illness or injury was described to her as chronic lower back pain, disc prolapse, cervical disc herniation and spinal stenosis, and depression. She noted background information about Ms Dyson, which included the onset of lower back symptoms following a workplace injury in 1994, when she ruptured two discs in her lumbar spine, a fusion of those ruptured discs four years later, rupturing of discs in the cervical region of the spine during surgery, a compression fracture at T6 while having physiotherapy treatment, a diagnosis of T6 syndrome and nerve irritation following a suspected heart attack, nerve damage and generalised weakness in arms and legs, occasional sciatica with increased symptoms in her right leg, aggravation of pre-existing injuries to the lower back and neck in two rear end motor vehicle accidents, bursitis in both shoulders, arthritis in knees, shoulders and thumb joint, global osteoarthritis with symptoms in all joints across her body, chronic fatigue and fibromyalgia, weight gain and type II diabetes, depression and anxiety from the initial injury, post-traumatic stress disorder relating to chronic pain and her experiences on WorkCover, asthma, eczema, and underactive thyroid and a large bunion on the medial side of her right foot. [38] Exhibit R1

Decision

Reasons for decision

In order to become a participant in the NDIS, an applicant must meet each of the paragraphs in s 24(1) of the NDIS Act. As Ms Dyson does not meet the requirements of s 24(1)(c) of the NDIS Act to become a participant in the NDIS it is not necessary for the Tribunal to decide whether she meets the criteria in s 24(1)(e) of the NDIS Act.DISABILITY REQUIREMENTS – CONCLUSION Ms Dyson meets the age requirements under s 22 and the residence requirements under s 23 of the NDIS Act. Ms Dyson meets the requirements under s 24(1)(a), (b), and (d) of the NDIS Act. Ms Dyson does not satisfy the requirements under s 24(1)(c) the NDIS Act. She must satisfy all the requirements in s 24(1) in order to meet the disability requirements. Accordingly, she does not fulfil the disability access criteria to become a participant in the NDIS. EARLY INTERVENTION REQUIREMENTS Section 25 of the NDIS Act sets out the requirements for access to the NDIS under the early intervention criteria. At the time when the Agency made its internal review decision, a person met the early intervention requirements under s 25 (1)(a)(i) and (ii) if the person:(i) has one or more identified intellectual, cognitive, neurological, sensory or physical impairments that are, or are likely to be, permanent; or(ii) has one or more identified impairments that are attributable to a psychiatric condition and are, or are likely to be, permanent… In tandem with the amendment to s 24 (1) (a) which removed the reference to an impairment attributable to a psychiatric condition, an amendment on 1 July 2022 to s25(1) (a) did the same. The amendment removed the reference to impairments attributable to a psychiatric condition. From 1 July 2022 the person meets the disability requirements under s 24 (1) (a) (ii)if the person:(ii)has one or more identified impairments to which a psychosocial disability is attributable and that are, or are likely to be, permanent… Section 2.5(b) of the NDIS Rules includes the following passage about the rationale for the early intervention requirements as an alternative to accessing the scheme through the disability requirements: A person can access the NDIS through the early intervention requirements without having substantially reduced functional capacity. Instead, the early intervention requirements consider the likely trajectory and impact of a person’s impairment over time and the potential benefits of early intervention on the impact of the impairment on the person’s functional capacity. Section 9 of the Operational Guideline provides guidance about the purpose and potential benefits of early intervention. It states: Early intervention support is available to both children and adults who meet the early intervention requirements. The intention of early intervention is to alleviate the impact of a person’s impairment upon their functional capacity by providing support at the earliest possible stage. Early intervention support is also intended to benefit a person by reducing their future needs for supports.[112][112] Exhibit B, T18, Operational Guideline – Access, pp 105–106

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In its Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions prior to the hearing, the Agency did not dispute that Ms Dyson suffers from chronic back pain. The Agency’s principal contention was that Ms Dyson does not meet any of the six criteria in s 24(1)(c) of the NDIS Act regarding a substantial reduction in functional capacity.CONSIDERATIONDISABILITY – S 24(1)(a) NDIS Act The concept of impairment, rather than a definition of disability, is central to the threshold provisions such as s 24. In Mulligan, the Federal Court (Mortimer J) pointed out that while the NDIS Act refers frequently both to “disability”, without defining it, and to “impairment”, without defining it,[11] “the undefined statutory phrase ‘people with a disability’ is not to be construed as limited to people who meet the access criteria in Ch3 of the Act. The access criteria have a number of components and thresholds”.[12] The Court pointed out in Mulligan, at [56]:No decision-maker need be satisfied a person’s impairment is “serious”, or more serious than another person’s. No qualitative judgments in that sense are called for. Rather, the legislative scheme is based on a functional, practical assessment of what a person can and cannot do.[11] As above, at [16][12] As above, at [18] In this case there is no dispute that Ms Dyson meets the age and residence requirements. Generally, the age requirements are met if the person was under the age of 65 when an access request was made. The question is whether she meets the disability requirements under s 24, or the early intervention requirements under s 25, of the NDIS Act. Before proceeding further, it is necessary to note that amendments to ss 24 and 25 of the NDIS Act came into effect on 1 July 2022. The Tribunal had not completed its review of Ms Dyson’s application by the time the amendments commenced. Both the original decision which the Agency made regarding Ms Dyson’s access request, and the Agency’s internal review decision, were made prior to those amendments. The Tribunal’s decision is made subsequent to those amendments. At the time when the Agency made its internal review decision, a person met the disability requirements under s 24(1)(a) if:the person has a disability that is attributable to one or more intellectual, cognitive, neurological, sensory or physical impairments or to one or more impairments attributable to a psychiatric condition. The amendments removed the reference to impairments attributable to a psychiatric condition and replaced them with the phrase “one or more impairments to which a psychosocial disability is attributable”. From 1 July 2022, the person meets the disability requirements under s 24(1)(a) if:the person has a disability that is attributable to one or more intellectual, cognitive, neurological, sensory or physical impairments or the person has one or more impairments to which a psychosocial disability is attributable. The transitional provisions at schedule 2, item 54 of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Amendment (Participant Service Guarantee and Other Measures) Act 2022 provide that:(1)The amendments of sections 24 and 25 of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 made by this Schedule apply in relation to the following:(a) an access request made on or after the commencement of this item;(b) an access request that was pending immediately before that commencement; (c) a revocation under section 30 of that Act made on or after that commencement.