Young and National Disability Insurance Agency

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

Young and National Disability Insurance Agency [2021] AATA 1555 (2 June 2021)

Division:National Disability Insurance Scheme Division

File Number(s):      2019/7895

Re:Mandie Young

APPLICANT

AndNational Disability Insurance Agency

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Chris Puplick AM, Senior Member

Date:2 June 2021

Place:Sydney

The decision under review is set aside and substituted with the decision that:

(a)the Applicant should be funded for:

(i)4 hours of personal care per day,

(ii)48 hours of counselling per year with 4 hours of writing per year,

(iii)15 hours of Level 2 Support Coordination,

(iv)support for continence products as per the assessment of Continence Nurse Jane Clark (16 April 2021).

(b)Assistive Technology Assessments should be considered (where already provided) or conducted/funded in relation to the Applicant’s claims for:

(i)a hoist and sling system compatible with the Applicant’s i-care electric bed,

(ii)a shower commode,

(iii)a door wedge for use in the bathroom,

(iv)a Batec power add-on for existing manual wheelchair and associated accessories which include off road tyres, backrest and battery,

(v)changes to or adaptations of the Applicant’s motor vehicle, and

(vi)the trial of one form of “alternate” therapy drawn from the list of yoga, pilates, horse therapy, Zumba dance classes, alternate diet arrangements, arts/self-expression therapy.

...............................[sgd].........................................

Chris Puplick AM, Senior Member

CATCHWORDS

NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME – whether claimed supports are reasonable and necessary – where certain supports not subject to internal review – Tribunal has no jurisdiction to consider such supports – where supports agreed – where supports agreed conditionally – where supports declined for insufficient evidence as reasonable and necessary – where supports agreed to be excluded – where supports are contested as to being before the internal review process – decision under review set aside and substituted

LEGISLATION

National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth) s 34, 37, 48, 99, 100

CASES

NNXF and National Disability Insurance Agency [2019] AATA 5552

QDKH and National Disability Insurance Agency [2021] AATA 922

SECONDARY MATERIALS

NSW Health and the Arts Framework, Improving the health of the community through integrating The Arts into the design and delivery of health services and public health messaging: Ministerial Taskforce on Health and the Arts, Report of the NSW Ministerial Taskforce on Health and the Arts (April 2016): The PAtH Forward – Partnering Arts to Health:  FOR DECISION

Chris Puplick AM, Senior Member

2 June 2021

BACKGROUND

  1. The National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth) (the Act) establishes a scheme whereby persons with disability (disabilities) can, in accordance with the provisions of the Act have a Plan developed to assist them in the management of their disability (disabilities).

  2. Ms Mandie Young (the Applicant) had such a Plan developed which came into effect on 8 March 2019.

  3. Any National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS) Plan, once it has come into effect cannot be varied, however, it may be terminated and replaced with another Plan pursuant to section 37 of the Act. It may also cease if the participant ceases to be a participant in the scheme.

  4. Subsection 48(1) of the Act provides…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Young and National Disability Insurance Agency and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] AATA 1555
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by the Applicant to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) for review of a decision made by the National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA) regarding funding for supports under the National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS). The Applicant contended that the funding provided was insufficient to maintain her quality of life, a primary objective of the NDIS. The NDIA had commissioned a report from Emeritus Professor Stewart Einfeld, a clinical psychiatrist, to assess the Applicant's needs.

The Tribunal was required to determine which of the Applicant's claimed supports were reasonable and necessary within the meaning of the NDIS legislation. This involved assessing the evidence presented, including the Applicant's own testimony and Professor Einfeld's report and oral evidence, and considering whether certain supports were properly before the Tribunal for review. The Tribunal also had to consider the NDIA's reasons for declining certain supports, which were primarily based on insufficient evidence of their reasonableness and necessity.

The Tribunal found that Professor Einfeld's report had limitations, noting that his expertise was primarily in child and adolescent psychiatry and that his assessment of the Applicant was based on a single, brief telephone interview. While Professor Einfeld expressed reservations about the efficacy of certain therapies such as yoga, pilates, horse therapy, and arts therapy, the Tribunal specifically rejected his characterisation of the evidence for these interventions as "weak." The Tribunal referred to extensive literature and policy documents, including the NSW Health and the Arts Framework, to support the value of arts-based therapies in managing health conditions. Consequently, the Tribunal set aside the NDIA's decision and substituted it with a decision that the Applicant should be funded for specific personal care, counselling, support coordination, and continence products. Furthermore, the Tribunal ordered that assistive technology assessments be considered or conducted for various items, including a hoist and sling system, shower commode, door wedge, wheelchair power add-on, motor vehicle adaptations, and the trial of one alternate therapy from a specified list.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Applicant throughout her evidence maintained that this is insufficient funding for her to be able to maintain the quality of life which is a primary objective of the NDIS.REPORT AND EVIDENCE OF PROFESSOR EINFELD The Respondent commissioned Emeritus Professor Stewart Einfeld to give a report on the Applicant for these proceedings. Professor Einfeld is a qualified clinical psychiatrist and a Professor of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry. Professor Einfeld provided a written report of some 7 pages (accompanied by a curriculum vitae of 53 pages[19]) and gave oral evidence at the hearing.[19] Report by Professor Einfield, Respondent’s Further Evidence at 41-93. Professor Einfeld’s examination of the Applicant took place over the telephone and was followed up a few days later with another brief conversation. The Applicant stated that she found the initial interview pointless and that Professor Einfeld had promised to recontact her the following day but did not do so until several days later when she was, of all places, attending a funeral. She agreed that he spoke briefly to her housemate Bryce who himself has some cognitive difficulties and asked him (Bryce) to report on the Applicant’s health and wellbeing. Professor Einfeld recognises the limitations of his own report, stating:“It is not possible to make definitive judgements about this complex psychiatric presentation within the confines of a single, and brief subsequent interview, representing a single period.”[20]“Again, I report my impressions from one telephone interview and brief follow up, and they are consequently somewhat speculative.”[21][20] Ibid at 35, [5.1(a)].[21] Ibid at 38, [5.1(c)]. Professor Einfeld conceded that his principal area of expertise was in child and adolescent psychiatry, although he has qualifications in general psychiatry. In any case, he felt that he had been asked for a report by the Respondent on the basis of his expertise in dealing with autism. In this respect his conclusions were that the Applicant displayed “some features” of what he characterised as “mild Autism”.[22][22] Ibid at 37, [5.1(a)]. Professor Einfeld was asked for his opinion in relation to the value of interventions such as yoga, pilates, horse therapy and arts therapy as ways of assisting the Applicant to manage her levels of stress or to improve her levels of wellbeing. He was generally dismissive of such interventions although conceded in his report that they “may be helpful in reducing stress”.[23][23] Ibid at 40, [5.1 (e)]. In his oral evidence Professor Einfeld, in relation to the effective use of arts therapy to help improve mental health functioning, described the evidence for this as “weak” and referred to a lack of research in this area. The Tribunal specifically rejects this characterisation. The literature, both in Australia and internationally is extensive and the value of arts-based therapies in the management of both mental and physical health conditions is overwhelming. Without going into excessive detail, the Tribunal refers simply to the evidence contained in the Report of the NSW Ministerial Taskforce on Health and the Arts (April 2016): The PAtH Forward – Partnering Arts to Health[24] which resulted in the formal adoption by NSW Health of the NSW Health and the Arts Framework as public policy to improve health outcomes.[25][24] NSW Ministerial Taskforce on Health and the Arts, Report of the NSW Ministerial Taskforce on Health and the Arts (April 2016): The PAtH Forward – Partnering Arts to Health: Disclaimer – this Taskforce was chaired by the Presiding Member conducting this hearing.[25] NSW Health and the Arts Framework: Improving the health of the community through integrating The Arts into the design and delivery of health services and public health messaging:

Decision

Reasons for decision

It agrees that the other items in the Applicant’s claims cannot be considered at this stage and, if pressed by the Applicant, must be made the subject of a further application for review of her Plan.DECISION The decision under review is set aside and substituted with the decision that:(a)the Applicant should be funded for:(i)4 hours of personal care per day,(ii)48 hours of counselling per year with 4 hours of writing per year,(iii)15 hours of Level 2 Support Coordination,(iv)support for continence products as per the assessment of Continence Nurse Jane Clark (16 April 2021).(b)Assistive Technology Assessments should be considered (where already provided) or conducted/funded in relation to the Applicant’s claims for:(i)a hoist and sling system compatible with the Applicant’s i-care electric bed,(ii)a shower commode,(iii)a door wedge for use in the bathroom,(iv)a Batec power add-on for existing manual wheelchair and associated accessories which include off road tyres, backrest and battery,(v)changes or adaptations of the Applicant’s motor vehicle, and(vi)the trial of one form of “alternate” therapy drawn from the list of yoga, pilates, horse therapy, Zumba dance classes, alternate diet arrangements, arts/self-expression therapy.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established