Martin & Pleasance Pty Ltd v A Nelson & Co Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 39 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Martin & Pleasance Pty Ltd v A Nelson & Co Limited [2021] FCA 368

File number: NSD 237 of 2021
Judgment of: WIGNEY J
Date of judgment: 30 March 2021
Date of publication of reasons: 19 April 2021
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application for stay of interlocutory judgment – whether appeal would be rendered nugatory without a stay – whether the balance of harm to the applicant outweighed the harm to the respondent in favour of a stay – whether leave application to be heard concurrently with or immediately before appeal – whether hearing of leave application and appeal to be expedited – whether applicant had an arguable case – relevant principles regarding whether a stay of the judgment should be granted
Legislation:

Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) Sch 2, Australian Consumer Law, ss 18, 29(1)(a), (g), (h)

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) ss 25(2), 25(2)(a), (e), 29, 37M

Federal Court Rules2011 (Cth) rr 36.08(2), 41.03

Cases cited:

A Nelson & Co Limited v Martin & Pleasance Pty Limited (No 2) [2021] FCA 242

A Nelson & Co Limited v Martin & Pleasance Pty Limited [2021] FCA 228

Alexander v Cambridge Credit Corporation Ltd (1985) 2 NSWLR 685

Australian Broadcasting Corporation v O’Neill (2006) 227 CLR 57; [2006] HCA 46

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v BMW (Australia) Limited (No 2) [2003] FCA 864

Beecham Group Limited v Bristol Laboratories Pty Limited (1968) 118 CLR 618

Collins House Pty Ltd v Golden Age Sunrise Development Pty Ltd (2015) 114 IPR 1; [2015] FCA 724

Décor Corp Pty Ltd v Dart Industries Inc (1991) 33 FCR 397

Ensham Resources Pty Limited v AIOI Insurance Company Limited [2012] FCA 822

Fair Work Ombudsman v Toyota Material Handling (NSW) Pty Ltd (2012) 237 FCR 454; [2012] FCA 347

House v R (1936) 55 CLR 499

In-N-Out Burgers, Inc v Hashtag Burgers Pty Ltd (No 2) [2020] FCA 772

Jennings Constructions Ltd v Burgundy Royale Investments Pty Ltd (1986) 161 CLR 681

Nichol v Discovery Africa Limited [2016] FCA 254

Oswal v Burrup Fertilisers Pty Ltd (recs and mgrs apptd) [2011] FCA 536

Phillip Morris (Australia) Limited v Nixon [1999] FCA 1281

Powerflex Services Pty Ltd v Data Access Corporation  (1996) 67 FCR 65

Samsung Electronics Co Ltd v Apple Inc (2011) 217 FCR 238; [2011] FCAFC 156

Division: General Division
Registry: New South Wales
National Practice Area: Intellectual Property
Sub-area: Trade Marks
Number of paragraphs: 71
Date of hearing: 30 March 2021
Counsel for the Applicants: Mr M J Darke SC with Mr D B Larish
Solicitor for the Applicants: Corrs Chambers Westgarth
Counsel for the Respondents: Mr M Hall SC with Ms A Campbell
Solicitor for the Respondents: Gilbert + Tobin

 

ORDERS

NSD 237 of 2021

BETWEEN:

MARTIN & PLEASANCE PTY LTD ACN 006 935 888

First Applicant

ALOE VERA INDUSTRIES PTY LTD ACN 063 710 832

Second Applicant

MARTIN & PLEASANCE WHOLESALE PTY LTD

Third Applicant

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Martin & Pleasance Pty Ltd v A Nelson & Co Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] FCA 368
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Martin & Pleasance Pty Ltd, Aloe Vera Industries Pty Ltd and Martin & Pleasance Wholesale Pty Ltd (collectively referred to as Martin & Pleasance) sought to appeal against an interlocutory judgment which restrained them from marketing, promoting, or supplying products using the word “RestQ” and using the packaging which they had been using in respect of those products. The applicants sought a stay of the interlocutory orders pending the hearing and determination of their proposed application for leave to appeal. The case was heard by Flick J, who had previously made the interlocutory orders, and subsequently by the Full Court.

The legal issues the court was required to decide were whether the appeal would be rendered nugatory without a stay, whether the balance of harm to the applicant outweighed the harm to the respondent in favour of a stay, whether the leave application should be heard concurrently with or immediately before the appeal, whether the hearing of the leave application and appeal should be expedited, and whether the applicant had an arguable case. The court also had to consider the relevant principles regarding whether a stay of the judgment should be granted.

The Full Court found that Martin & Pleasance had demonstrated that this was an appropriate case for a stay, and that there was a sound reason or proper basis for a stay in the particular circumstances of the case. The court concluded that Martin & Pleasance had at least an arguable case for the grant of leave to appeal, and that the decision of the primary judge was attended by sufficient doubt to warrant appellate attention. The court also found that there was a real likelihood that a successful appeal would be rendered nugatory, and that there was a real risk that it would not be possible for Martin & Pleasance to be restored substantially to their former position if Nelson was ultimately unsuccessful at the final hearing. The Full Court granted the stay and made orders for the hearing of the application for leave to appeal, and the appeal if leave was granted, to be expedited.

The final orders made by the Full Court were that the application for leave to appeal be heard concurrently with or immediately before the appeal sought in that application, that the hearing of the application for leave to appeal be expedited and listed on either 4, 5 or 6 May 2021 before the Full Court, that the orders made on 17 March 2021 by Flick J be stayed up to 4.15pm on the day the application for leave to appeal and the appeal, if leave is granted, are heard, that the confidential annexures and exhibits filed 23 March 2021 be treated as confidential for the purposes of r 2.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011, and that the costs of the interlocutory application filed 23 March 2021 be reserved. The applicants undertook to keep full and accurate records of all sales of the RestQ products during the period of the stay.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application for leave to appeal filed 23 March 2021 be heard concurrently with, or immediately before, the appeal sought in that application.

2. The hearing of the application for leave to appeal be expedited and listed on either 4, 5 or 6 May 2021 before the Full Court, as advised by the Court, with an estimated duration of one day.

3. Upon the undertaking referred to in the notation following these orders, order 2 of the orders made on 17 March 2021 by Flick J in NSD 154 of 2021 be stayed up to 4.15pm on the day the application for leave to appeal and the appeal, if leave is granted, are heard.

4. The confidential annexures and exhibits filed 23 March 2021, DGF-2 and RH-2, be treated as confidential for the purposes of r 2.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth).

5. The costs of the interlocutory application filed 23 March 2021 be reserved.

THE COURT NOTES THAT:

6. The applicants undertake to the Court that during the period of the stay of the orders referred to in order 3 above, they will keep full and accurate records of all sales of the RestQ products (as defined in [29] of the Statement of Claim filed on 2 March 2021 in the NSD 154 of 2021 proceeding).

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

On 30 March 2021, I made the orders sought by the applicants. These are my reasons for so doing.BACKGROUND The applicants, Martin & Pleasance Pty Ltd, Aloe Vera Industries Pty Ltd and Martin & Pleasance Wholesale Pty Ltd (collectively referred to as Martin & Pleasance) are companies that are involved in the manufacture, marketing, promotion and supply of healthcare products that are said to relieve sleeplessness. Those products are promoted, marketed and supplied in packaging which utilises the name or mark “RestQ”. Until fairly recent times, Martin & Pleasance was the exclusive Australian distributor of similar healthcare products which were also said to relieve sleeplessness. Those products were manufactured overseas and exported to Australia by the respondents, A Nelson & Co Limited and Bach Flower Remedies Limited (collectively referred to as Nelson). Nelson’s products were promoted, marketed and supplied in packaging which utilised the name or mark “Rescue”. On 2 March 2021, Nelson commenced a proceeding in this Court in which it alleged, amongst other things, that Martin & Pleasance had infringed its Rescue trademark, had passed off its products as Nelson’s products and had engaged in misleading and deceptive conduct contrary to s 18 and s 29(1)(a), (g) and (h) of the Australian Consumer Law (Sch 2 to the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth)). The originating application filed by Nelson also sought interlocutory relief restraining Martin & Pleasance from marketing, promoting or supplying its product in the RestQ packaging. That application for interlocutory relief was heard by the primary judge, sitting as duty judge, on 10 March 2021. On 17 March 2021, the primary judge delivered a judgment and made orders which restrained Martin & Pleasance from marketing, promoting and supplying products using the word RestQ and using the packaging which it had been using in respect of those products. The primary judge found that Nelson had established a prima facie case that Martin & Pleasance had committed the tort of passing off and had engaged in misleading and deceptive conduct contrary to s 18 and s 29(1)(a), (g) and (h) of the Consumer Law: A Nelson & Co Limited v Martin & Pleasance Pty Limited [2021] FCA 228 (Interlocutory Judgment) at [9]. His Honour did not make any finding concerning Nelson’s case that its trademark had been infringed. The primary judge also concluded that the balance of convenience militated towards granting Nelson the interlocutory relief it sought: Interlocutory Judgment at [9]. Later that day, Martin & Pleasance made an application to the primary judge for a stay of the interlocutory orders pending the hearing and determination of its proposed application for leave to appeal. That stay application was heard the following day. The primary judge refused to stay the orders up to the time an application for leave to appeal was heard and determined, but stayed the orders for seven days; that is until 4.00 pm on 25 March 2021: A Nelson & Co Limited v Martin & Pleasance Pty Limited (No 2) [2021] FCA 242 (Stay Judgment) at [19]-[23].

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

As for the grounds of appeal relating to the primary judge’s findings or reasoning concerning the status quo, Nelson submitted that the primary judge was plainly right to find, in effect, that the purpose of the interlocutory injunction was to keep the “invader of its existing market at bay until a decision has been reached as to whether the invasion is lawful or not”: cf Beecham Group Limited v Bristol Laboratories Pty Limited (1968) 118 CLR 618 at 627. The status quo, in other words, was the state of affairs before Martin & Pleasance’s entry into the market. EVIDENCE AND SUBMISSIONS RELATING TO THE CASE FOR A STAY Both Martin & Pleasance and Nelson adduced evidence which was directed to the factors that were or may be relevant to the extension of the limited stay granted by the primary judge. As already noted, the evidence filed by Martin & Pleasance included affidavit evidence from Mr Holyman concerning the economic and other harm that Martin & Pleasance would suffer if the interlocutory injunction was not stayed pending the hearing of the application for leave to appeal. That evidence was to the effect that Martin & Pleasance would suffer significant losses to its revenue and profits from its inability to supply its products and meet anticipated orders by retailers. Its inability to meet orders would also cause damage to its reputation and relationships with retailers, as well as the loss of money already expended or committed in respect of marketing and advertising. Mr Holyman’s evidence was that this loss and damage would be suffered by Martin & Pleasance even if the interlocutory application was in place for only a matter of weeks. He also said that he believed that the harm would be irreparable. Mr Holyman’s evidence also addressed the fact that Nelson is currently unable to supply its Rescue products in Australia. That is because Martin & Pleasance continues to be listed as the sponsor for those products on the ARTG and there is a dispute between Nelson and Martin & Pleasance about whether the terms of the distribution agreement between them obliged Martin & Pleasance to transfer that sponsorship. Mr Holyman’s evidence was that Martin & Pleasance had not supplied any of Nelson’s Rescue products in Australia since the end of the distribution agreement on 12 February 2021. His understanding was that neither Nelson nor its new distributor, Juno Laboratories Pty Limited, have been or are able to supply the Rescue products in Australia since that time because Juno is not listed on the ARTG as the sponsor of those products and there is at least significant uncertainty as to when that sponsorship issue will be able to be resolved. Martin & Pleasance submitted that the evidence clearly and incontrovertibly demonstrated that it would suffer a number of types of harm if the Court did not extend the existing stay or further stay the orders until the hearing of the application for leave to appeal. The categories of harm included: first, its inability to supply its RestQ products in satisfaction of existing or forecast future orders by pharmacies and other retailers; second, substantial lost profits and revenue from its inability to supply its products; third, losses arising from the fact that some of its existing stock may come close to expiring during the period that it is unable to supply, with the result that that stock will become unsaleable; fourth, damage to its reputation as a result of its inability to supply in all the circumstances; fifth, wasted money that it had expended or committed to expend in relation to marketing and advertising, including in conjunction with pharmacies and other retailers over the next few months; sixth, continuing harm arising from the fact that consumers may switch to rival products during the period that it is unable to supply; and seventh, harm to innocent third parties, including consumers who will be unable to purchase the RestQ products and harm to the public interest arising from the absence of competition.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Later that day, Martin & Pleasance made an application to the primary judge for a stay of the interlocutory orders pending the hearing and determination of its proposed application for leave to appeal. That stay application was heard the following day. The primary judge refused to stay the orders up to the time an application for leave to appeal was heard and determined, but stayed the orders for seven days; that is until 4.00 pm on 25 March 2021: A Nelson & Co Limited v Martin & Pleasance Pty Limited (No 2) [2021] FCA 242 (Stay Judgment) at [19]-[23]. In refusing to stay the orders up to the time of the determination of the application for leave to appeal, the primary judge found that none of the proposed grounds of appeal which had been articulated by Martin & Pleasance “provide[d] any reason to depart from or reverse any of the conclusions previously reached” and that there were at least some “difficulties” which would confront Martin & Pleasance on an application for leave to appeal: Stay Judgment at [13], [14]. His Honour noted, however, that his observations in that regard did not amount to a conclusion that the proposed grounds of appeal “may not expose some error of principle which may have some prospects of success, if leave to appeal were granted”: Stay Judgment at [14]. His Honour ultimately concluded that Martin & Pleasance “should not be shut out from seeking leave to appeal and persuading a different Judge that there has been some error of principle in granting interlocutory relief”: Stay Judgment at [22]. The primary judge made two other relevant findings in concluding that a stay should be granted, albeit a stay for only seven days. First, his Honour concluded that there was a real likelihood that a successful appeal would be rendered nugatory. That was because there was, according to his Honour, a real likelihood that Martin & Pleasance “may be forced in the exercise of their commercial judgment to rebadge their products pending the resolution of [Nelson’s] claims on a final basis, and thereby being shut out from the prospect of re-entering the market using their existing RestQ labelling in the event that their claims ultimately prevail and those of [Nelson] fail”: Stay Judgment at [19] (first dot point). His Honour had earlier noted (at [6]) that it had been held in Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v BMW (Australia) Limited (No 2) [2003] FCA 864 (ACCC v BMW) at [5] that the “general rule is that a stay will be granted where there is a likelihood that a successful appeal will be rendered nugatory”. Second, the primary judge concluded that there was a real risk that it would not be possible for Martin & Pleasance to be restored substantially to their former position if Nelson was ultimately unsuccessful at the final hearing. His Honour reasoned that the absence of Martin & Pleasance’s RestQ products from the market during the period before the final hearing and judgment would preclude them from “regaining the position in the market that they now have”: Stay Judgment at [19] (second dot point). His Honour had earlier noted (at [6]) that it had been held in Nichol v Discovery Africa Limited [2016] FCA 254 at [7] that the test for determining whether a stay should be granted pending appeal “may be satisfied where there is a real risk that it will not be possible for a successful appellant to be restored substantially to its former position if the judgment is executed”.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

As for Mr Raper’s evidence, Nelson submitted that it established that Nelson would be able to re-enter the market with its Rescue products through its new distributor, Juno, in the near future. The evidence, in Nelson’s submission, indicated that it was possible for Juno to apply for sponsorship and registration of the Rescue product, even if Martin & Pleasance refused to transfer its registration and sponsorship. Nelson also argued that, contrary to the submissions advanced by Martin & Pleasance, it was contractually entitled to secure or retake title to or possession of the existing Rescue stock still held by Martin & Pleasance. It would then be able to apply labels to that stock which included Juno’s name and registration number. It followed, according to Nelson, that the stock would become saleable and be in the marketplace by late April 2021.CONSIDERATION – SHOULD THE STAY BE EXTENDED? While the issue is somewhat finely balanced, I am persuaded that Martin & Pleasance has demonstrated that this is an appropriate case for a stay; that there is a sound reason or proper basis for a stay in the particular circumstances of the case. That is so for a number of reasons. First, I am satisfied that Martin & Pleasance has at least an arguable case for the grant of leave to appeal. The principles that underpin the grant of leave to appeal are well-established. In simple terms, the applicant for leave must generally demonstrate two things: first, that the decision of the primary judge is attended by sufficient doubt to warrant appellate consideration by the Full Court; and second, that substantial injustice would result if leave were to be refused, supposing the decision of the primary judge to be wrong: Décor at 398-400. There could be little doubt in this case concerning the second element. There could be little doubt in the circumstances that, supposing the primary judge’s decision to have been wrong, Martin & Pleasance would suffer substantial injustice if leave to appeal was refused, particularly if the final hearing of Nelson’s action does not take place for some significant period of time. The grant of the interlocutory injunction in those circumstances would have the practical effect of finally determining the rights of the parties and would certainly have a significant impact on the business of Martin & Pleasance: cf Samsung at [25] and [31]. Moreover, even though an interlocutory injunction is a matter of practice and procedure, an appeal or prospective appeal from an interlocutory injunction which involves matters of principle “stands somewhat above the ordinary appeal in a matter of practice and procedure”: Australian Broadcasting Corporation v O’Neill (2006) 227 CLR 57; [2006] HCA 46 at [53]. The critical consideration in determining whether Martin & Pleasance has a good arguable case for the grant of leave to appeal is whether the decision of the primary judge is attended by sufficient doubt to warrant appellate attention. That requires some attention to be given to the merits of the proposed grounds of appeal.