Nichol v Discovery Africa Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Nichol v Discovery Africa Limited [2016] FCA 254

File numbers: WAD 87 of 2014
WAD 40 of 2016
WAD 47 of 2016
Judges: MCKERRACHER J
Date of judgment: 15 March 2016
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application for stay pending appeal in related cases – summary of relevant principles in the determination of a stay application – discretion to grant a stay – competing rights of parties – parlous financial position of respondent to stay applications  
Legislation:

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) s 200AA(1)

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 29

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) rr 36.08(2), 41.03

Cases cited:

Alexander v Cambridge Credit Corporation Ltd (1985) 2 NSWLR 685

Attorney-General v Emerson (1889) 24 QBD 56

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v BMW (Australia) Ltd (No 2) [2003] FCA 864

Commissioner of Taxation (Cth) v Myer Emporium Ltd (No 1) (1986) 160 CLR 220

Discovery Africa Ltd v Nichol [2015] FCA 1497

Harbour City Real Estate Pty Ltd t/as Re/Max Harbour City Real Estate (ACN 111 210 023) v Cargill [2008] FCA 1382

Henderson v Amadio Pty Ltd (No 3) (1996) 65 FCR 66

McBride v Sandland (No 2) (1918) 25 CLR 369

Re Middle Harbour Investments Ltd (in liq) (unreported, Court of Appeal NSW, 15 December 1976

Powerflex Services Pty Ltd v Data Access Corporation (1996) 67 FCR 65

Welcome Real-time SA v Catuity Inc (No 2) [2002] FCA 258

Wilson v Church (No 2) (1879) 12 Ch D 454

Date of hearing: 8 March 2016
Registry: Western Australia
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: Corporations and Corporate Insolvency
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 33
Counsel for Mr Nichol: Mr E van der Zanden
Solicitor for Mr Nichol: Hotchkin Hanly
Counsel for Mr van den Bergh: Mr S Penglis
Solicitor for Mr van den Bergh: Fletcher Law
Counsel for Discovery Africa Limited: Mr M L Bennett with Mr D Banda
Solicitor for Discovery Africa Limited: Bennett + Co
Table of Corrections
17 March 2016

Paragraph 1(d) of the interlocutory orders dated 15 March 2016 in both WAD 87/2014 and WAD 40/2016 will read: 

‘any failure to pay the sum into Court within 21 days resulting in the discharge of the order staying execution of the judgment.’


ORDERS

WAD 87 of 2014

BETWEEN:

DISCOVERY AFRICA LIMITED (ACN 147 324 847)

Applicant

AND:

KEVIN WILLIAM NICHOL

First Respondent

DANIE VAN DEN BERGH

Second Respondent

SINDISE MINING CC (and others named in the Schedule)

Third Respondent

JUDGE:

MCKERRACHER J

DATE OF ORDER:

15 MARCH 2016

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The orders and declarations of Gilmour J made in Discovery Africa Ltd v Nichol [2015] FCA 1497 on 23 December 2015 in relation to Mr van den Bergh be stayed, subject to and conditional upon:

(a)Mr van den Bergh paying $201,145 into Court within 21 days of this order of the Court;

(b)the funds paid into Court not be released until further order of the Court or with the consent of Discover…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Nichol v Discovery Africa Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] FCA 254
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Nichol v Discovery Africa Limited involved an application for a stay pending appeal in related cases. The dispute centered around the enforcement of judgments and declarations made by Gilmour J in previous proceedings. The applicants, Mr Nichol and Mr van den Bergh, sought a stay of execution of the judgment pending the outcome of their appeals. The legal issues before the court included the principles governing the grant of a stay pending appeal, the competing rights of the parties involved, and the financial circumstances of the respondent, Discovery Africa Limited.

The court considered the applicants' residency overseas and the need for adequate protection for Discovery Africa to enforce the judgments if the appeals were unsuccessful. The court noted that while there was an arguable case for appeal, the primary concern was ensuring that Discovery Africa was protected from financial loss. The court determined that stays should only be granted if the judgment sums were paid into court, along with provision for costs and security for the costs of the appeal. In the case of Mr van den Bergh, the court proposed an order for payment into court of $150,000 plus an additional $50,000, totaling $200,000, within 21 days. For Mr Nichol, the court proposed a payment of $325,000 within the same timeframe. The court also set conditions for the release of these funds and the consequences of non-payment.

The court's reasoning was grounded in the need to balance the applicants' rights to appeal with Discovery Africa's right to enforce the judgments. The court concluded that the proposed payments into court provided adequate protection for Discovery Africa while allowing the applicants to pursue their appeals. The court made specific orders for the stay of execution of the judgments, the hearing of the applications for leave to appeal with the appeals, and the filing of notices of appeal within 14 days, with specific directions regarding the content of these notices. The costs of these directions were to be in the cause. The court's decision was based on the principle that any stay of execution should be conditional upon the applicants providing sufficient financial protection to Discovery Africa.

Orders

Orders of the court

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1. The orders and declarations of Gilmour J made in Discovery Africa Ltd v Nichol [2015] FCA 1497 on 23 December 2015 in relation to Mr Nichol be stayed, subject to and conditional upon:

(a) Mr Nichol paying $325,000 into Court within 21 days of this order of the Court;

(b) the funds paid into Court not be released until further order of the Court with the consent of Discovery Africa;

(c) Discovery Africa being entitled to apply the funds paid into Court to enforce summary judgment, pre-judgment interest, post-judgment interest and costs, if any appeal is dismissed; and

(d) any failure to pay the sum into Court within 21 days will result in the application for leave to appeal being dismissed.

2. In relation to the application for leave to appeal:

(a) The application for leave to appeal be heard with the appeal.

(b) The application for leave to appeal and the appeal be listed for hearing before the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia on a date to be fixed.

(c) The applicant file and serve a notice of appeal within 14 days. The notice of appeal must include a statement to the effect that the appeal requires leave and the question of leave has been ordered to be heard with the appeal, and a copy of this order must be attached to the notice.

(d) Costs of these directions be in the cause.

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1. The application for leave to appeal be heard with the appeal.

2. The application for leave to appeal and the appeal be listed for hearing before the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia on a date to be fixed.

3. The applicant file and serve a notice of appeal within 14 days. The notice of appeal must include a statement to the effect that the appeal requires leave and the question of leave has been ordered to be heard with the appeal, and a copy of this order must be attached to the notice.

4. Costs of these directions be in the cause.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In the end, my view is that stays of orders and declarations of Gilmour J should only be granted if the judgment sums are paid into Court, together with provision for costs at first instance and security for costs of the appeal, given that each of the applicants resides overseas.CONCLUSION IN RELATION TO THE STAY APPLICATIONS The sum which Mr van den Bergh has offered to pay into Court or into a joint solicitors’ account comes close to the amount which I consider is appropriate. It falls short in relation to costs. In relation to Mr van den Bergh, Discovery Africa submits if the Court is minded to grant a stay (which Discovery Africa opposes) any stay would have to be subject to and conditional upon:(1)the funds frozen in the Commonwealth Bank account in the amount of $151,145 and an additional payment of at least $80,000 (which amount represents a fair and reasonable security for the summary judgment, interest and costs and security for the appeal) be paid into Court within 7 days of the order of the Court;(2)the funds paid into Court not being released until further order of the Court or unless with the consent of Discover Africa;(3)Discovery Africa being entitled to apply the funds into Court to enforce the summary judgment, interests and costs if the appeal is unsuccessful; and(4)any failure to pay $230,000 into Court by a specified date would result in the application for leave to appeal in WAD 47 of 2016 being dismissed. In relation to Mr Nichol, Discovery Africa submits if the Court is minded to grant a stay (which Discovery Africa opposes), then the stay should be subject to and conditional upon:(1)Mr Nichol paying into Court, within 7 days of the order, the amount of $380,000 (which represents a fair and reasonable security for the summary judgment orders, pre-judgment interest, post-judgment interest and costs);(2)the funds paid into Court not being released until further order of the Court unless with the consent of Discovery Africa;(3)Discovery Africa being entitled to apply the funds paid into Court to enforce summary judgment, pre-judgment interest, post-judgment interest and costs, if the appeal is not successful; and(4)any failure to pay $380,000 into Court by a specified date resulting in the application for leave to appeal being dismissed. I propose making orders largely consistent with those set out above, except that the amount in [27(1)] of $80,000 should be $50,000, and 7 days should be 21 days. In [27(4)], the order would be that any failure to pay the sum into Court within 21 days would result in the discharge of the order staying execution of the judgment. In relation to Mr Nichol, while reducing the sum of $380,000 in [28(1)] to $325,000 and otherwise making the same adjustments as for Mr van den Bergh, I would impose those conditions of any order granting a stay. If the parties seek to vary these orders (for example, by the funds being paid into a joint account), they should apply. In relation to the Mr Nichol’s application for leave to appeal (in WAD 40 of 2016), I make the following orders:1.The application for leave to appeal be heard with the appeal.2.The application for leave to appeal and the appeal be listed for hearing before the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia on a date to be fixed.3.The applicant file and serve a notice of appeal within 14 days. The notice of appeal must include a statement to the effect that the appeal requires leave and the question of leave has been ordered to be heard with the appeal, and a copy of this order must be attached to the notice.4.Costs of these directions be in the cause.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The sole ground on which Mr van den Bergh seeks leave to appeal turns on the proper construction of s 200AA(1) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). It is unnecessary to examine in detail the prospects of success in both of these applications/appeals because I am satisfied that, even if Mr van den Bergh has good prospects of success, which Discovery Africa strongly refutes, there is no reasonable basis for a stay of execution of the judgment, unless Discovery Africa is protected by payment into court. Submissions made by Mr van den Bergh effectively accept that position. That is, Mr van den Bergh does not oppose the stay being conditional upon:(a)Mr van den Bergh seeking a hearing of his application for leave to appeal/appeal at the earliest time convenient to the Court and parties; and(b)the amount held in Mr van den Bergh’s bank account, the subject of the freezing order (together with an additional sum to be paid by Mr van den Bergh so as to total the full amount of the judgment debt) being either paid into Court or into an interest bearing account in the joint names of the solicitors for Discovery Africa and solicitors for Mr van den Bergh to abide the outcome of Mr van den Bergh’s application for leave to appeal/appeal and to be paid out (including any interest) in accordance with any order made by the Court in due course. That is the essence of the orders I propose making, save that provision should also be made for costs and interest. MR NICHOL’S STAY APPLICATION The position concerning Mr Nichol was not as simple. As with Mr van den Bergh, he resides out of the jurisdiction, presently in Ireland and at other times in Singapore. His funds and assets within the jurisdiction are extremely limited. Summary judgment was ordered against Mr Nichol in the amount of $274,005.78 and costs. Although Mr Nichol produces a very rough and seemingly unverified list of assets said to total $308,013.86, it is common ground that only a small portion of that amount is readily available. Assets such as 50% of the net equity in a Singapore property (said to be worth approximately $180,000) held by Mr Nichol would not be readily realisable within the timeframe required for the making of these orders. The information provided in connection with assets held both within and outside this jurisdiction by Mr Nichol in support of his application is extremely limited. It is also clear, whether by way of misunderstanding or not, that Mr Nichol has not complied with freezing orders in the past. For example, funds have been made available to members of his family. Counsel for Mr Nichol submits that if there must be an order for payment into court, it should be for a relatively limited sum, such as the amount which Mr Nichol says he will be entitled to receive on or before 10 March 2016 from Consolidated Africa Limited. This is said to be USD50,000, or, on today’s currency exchange rate, approximately AUD69,628.15. As with Mr van den Bergh, I am prepared to assume that there is an arguable case to support the appeal. But this is by no means the end of the matter, particularly in Mr Nichol’s case as the judgment against him was, when compared with the net assets of Discovery Africa, a reasonably significant sum. As matters presently stand following the judgment, Discovery Africa submits that the fiscal difficulties of Discovery Africa are in no small measure due to the former management and payments to Messrs Nichol and van den Bergh.