Lumbers v W Cook Builders Pty Ltd (in liq)

Link copied
Case Copied 44 min read

HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA

GLEESON CJ
GUMMOW, HAYNE, CRENNAN AND KIEFEL JJ

MATTHEW LUMBERS AND ANOR   APPELLANTS

AND

W COOK BUILDERS PTY LTD
(IN LIQUIDATION)   RESPONDENT

Lumbers v W Cook Builders Pty Ltd (in liquidation)
[2008] HCA 27
18 June 2008
A39/2007

ORDER

1.        Appeal allowed with costs.

2.Set aside the orders of the Full Court of the Supreme Court of South Australia made on 1 March 2007 and, in their place, order that the appeal to that Court be dismissed with costs.

On appeal from the Supreme Court of South Australia

Representation

D F Jackson QC with M R Burnett for the appellants (instructed by Lynch Meyer Lawyers)

G O'L Reynolds SC with R D Ross-Smith and B R Kremer for the respondent (instructed by Rick Schroeder)

Notice:  This copy of the Court's Reasons for Judgment is subject to formal revision prior to publication in the Commonwealth Law Reports.

  1. GLEESON CJ.   In September or October 1993, W Cook & Sons Pty Ltd ("Sons") entered into an oral agreement with the appellants, Mr Matthew Lumbers and Mr Warwick Lumbers, to construct a house at North Haven, near Adelaide.  Mr Matthew Lumbers owned the land and Mr Warwick Lumbers had an unregistered lease for life over the property.  For present purposes, it is unnecessary to distinguish between Mr Matthew Lumbers and Mr Warwick Lumbers ("the Lumbers") as parties to the contract.  The house was described by the primary judge as "quite distinctive".  It ultimately cost more than $1 million to build.  It was completed in May 1995.

  2. In circumstances that will be described below, most of the work required by the contract, which included the engagement of building subcontractors and supervision of their work, was performed, not by Sons, but by W Cook Builders Pty Ltd (in Liquidation) ("Builders").  This change in the identity of the builder occurred without the knowledge or approval of the Lumbers.  Builders and Sons were members of the same corporate group, but their shareholders and directors were not identical, and at some stage, for reasons that were not made clear in the evidence, their interests diverged.  The proceedings giving rise to this appeal arose out of claims by Builders to be remunerated for its services.  The claims included claims for reimbursement of amounts paid to various subcontractors, and a fee for supervision.  The Lumbers made progress payments to Sons, as requested, at intervals over the period from April 1994 to May 1995.  Without the knowledge of the Lumbers, Sons paid those amounts to Builders.  Builders claimed that a balance (ultimately found to be $261,715) remained due and unpaid.

  3. The making of the 1993 building contract by the Lumbers and Sons was asserted by Builders in its Statement of Claim, and was not denied.  It was never suggested that there was a novation of the contract, or that the contract was terminated, either by the Lumbers or by Sons.  The trial judge found that the payments made to Sons by the Lumbers did not cover the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lumbers v W Cook Builders Pty Ltd (in liq) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] HCA 27
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of Australia considered an appeal by the Lumbers against W Cook Builders Pty Ltd (in liq) concerning a claim for payment arising from the construction of a domestic dwelling. The Lumbers had entered into an oral agreement with W Cook Builders Pty Ltd for the construction, but the respondent company, a related entity, performed some of the work and paid subcontractors. The dispute centred on whether the respondent could claim compensation from the Lumbers for the difference between the amounts paid by the Lumbers and the respondent's outlays, plus a margin for supervision and profit, particularly as the Lumbers had not requested the respondent to perform services or pay subcontractors directly.

The legal issues before the High Court included whether the respondent was entitled to recover compensation on the basis of a claim in *quantum meruit* or for money paid, and whether a claim for restitution based on unjust enrichment was available. Specifically, the court had to determine if the Lumbers had accepted a benefit from the respondent's work and expenses in circumstances where it would be unconscionable for them to retain that benefit, notwithstanding that they had not made a direct request to the respondent. The court also considered the effect of an informal reorganisation within the building company's corporate group, where the benefit and burden of the oral agreement were informally assigned to the respondent company without notice to the Lumbers.

The High Court allowed the appeal, setting aside the orders of the Full Court of the Supreme Court of South Australia. The court reasoned that the respondent's claims failed because the Lumbers had not requested the respondent to perform the work or incur expenses, nor had they freely accepted the benefit of the respondent's services in circumstances that would give rise to an obligation to pay. The court found that the Lumbers had met all progress claims and paid all monies due under the oral agreement to the original building company. The informal reorganisation and assignment of the contract within the corporate group, without notice to the Lumbers, did not create a direct contractual or restitutionary liability on their part to the respondent. The court emphasised that the principles of unjust enrichment require more than simply receiving a benefit; there must be an absence of a request or a free acceptance of the benefit, which was not established in this case.

The High Court ordered that the appeal to the Full Court of the Supreme Court of South Australia be dismissed with costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Appeal allowed with costs.

2. Set aside the orders of the Full Court of the Supreme Court of South Australia made on 1 March 2007 and, in their place, order that the appeal to that Court be dismissed with costs. (Per judgement of Gleeson CJ and joint judgment of Gummow, Hayne, Crennan and Kiefel JJ

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

GLEESON CJ GUMMOW, HAYNE, CRENNAN AND KIEFEL JJ
On 8 November 1999, Builders served the Lumbers with a notice of demand for payment of $274,791, comprising the alleged deficiency of $181,904, together with a 10% supervision fee of $92,887. On 11 November 1999, Builders caused a workers' lien to be registered on the title to the property. Builders' claim was made some four years after the construction had been completed. Mr Warwick Lumbers suggested in his evidence that the claim might have been considered differently had he been provided with a bundle of invoices rather than a notice of demand.The decision of the primary judge Some features of the procedural context in which the matter came for hearing before Judge Beazley have been noted above. He remarked that "complexity has arisen from the casual basis upon which the parties have chosen to deal with each other, and indeed in the manner in which they have conducted the litigation." The fact that Sons took no part in the trial, that Mr McAdam did not give evidence, and that Mr Jeffrey Cook, although an experienced builder, was "able to give only scant evidence with respect to 'administration issues'" added to the difficulties. It may be remarked that the restitutionary principles on which the respondent relied were designed to overcome what otherwise would have been deficiencies in the law, but in the present case they appear to have been called in aid principally to overcome deficiencies in evidence and unusual aspects of procedure. There were issues at trial, not presently relevant, concerning the amount of the claim; there were questions of the total amount of payments to subcontractors, allowances for defects, and the fee for supervision and management. The trial judge resolved most of those issues in favour of Builders, and quantified the claim at $261,715. There was also an issue, which was the subject of argument in the present appeal but which may be put to one side for the moment, arising out of the fact that Builders was unlicensed. Section 39 of the Builders Licensing Act 1986 (SA) ("the Builders Licensing Act") provided:"An unlicensed person who performs building work in circumstances in which a licence is required under this Act shall not be entitled to recover any fee or other consideration in respect of the building work unless the Tribunal or any court hearing proceedings for recovery of the fee or consideration is satisfied that the person's failure to be licensed resulted from inadvertence only." For reasons that turned upon the evidence of Mr Jeffrey Cook, the primary judge found that Builders' failure to obtain a licence did not result from inadvertence. There is no challenge to that finding. The main issue was a dispute as to whether Builders was entitled to claim directly against the Lumbers. Referring to the conduct of Mr Jeffrey Cook after the reorganisation, the judge said: "He did not speak to Mr McAdam, Warwick Lumbers or [the architect] about the terms of the contract which he and his immediate family were apparently taking over in Builders. He did not raise the question of price despite the fact that all of the major variations took place after the re-organisation. He had no involvement in quantifying the amounts to be requested of the Lumbers, despite the large sums being debited to Builders' accounts for the work.I have already discussed the failure of Builders to obtain a licence. Jeffrey Cook did not request the Lumbers to make payments direct to Builders rather than Sons ...Finally when the building work was completed, Mr Cook appears to have made no attempt to quantify what was outstanding or seek payment from the Lumbers. It was only well after the liquidation of Builders that anyone put the Lumbers on notice that any sum was outstanding, and suggested a direct claim as an equitable assignee."

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: GLEESON CJ, GUMMOW, HAYNE, CRENNAN AND KIEFEL JJ

Full text does not contain this section.