W Cook Builders Pty Ltd (in Liq) v Matthew Lumbers

Link copied
Case Copied 55 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Full Court: Civil)

W COOK BUILDERS PTY LTD (IN LIQ) v MATTHEW LUMBERS & ORS

[2007] SASC 20

Judgment of The Full Court

(The Honourable Justice Sulan, The Honourable Justice Vanstone and The Honourable Justice Layton)

30 January 2007

RESTITUTION - GENERAL PRINCIPLES

Respondent land owners contracted with respondent building company for construction of house - appellant building company, which was related to respondent building company, carried out construction work - appellant building company incurred expenses in constructing the house - trial judge found that there was no assignment of the contract by one building company to the other - appellant building company was unlicensed and therefore recovery in contract precluded by s 39 Builders Licensing Act 1986 (SA) - whether appellant company could recover against the respondent land owners on a quantum meruit basis in restitution based on unjust enrichment - elements of unjust enrichment considered - whether the respondent land owners had received an incontrovertible benefit for the purpose of determining whether there had been an unjust enrichment.

Builders Licensing Act 1986 (SA), s 39; Builders Licensing Act 1971 (NSW), referred to.
Nunkuwarrin Yunti v A L Seeley Constructions Pty Ltd (1998) 72 SASR 21; Tea Tree Builders v Martin (1992) 59 SASR 344, applied.
Angelopoulos and Anor v Sabatino and Anor (1995) 65 SASR 1; BP Exploration Co (Libya) v Hunt (No 2) [1979] 1 WLR 783; Brenner and Anor v First Artists' Management Pty Ltd [1993] 2 VR 221; Cadorange Pty Ltd (In Liq) v Tanga Holdings Pty Ltd (1990) 20 NSWLR 26; Monks v Poynice Pty Ltd and Anor (1987) 8 NSWLR 662; Pavey & Matthews Pty Ltd v Paul (1987) 162 CLR 221, discussed.
Bruce v Tyley (1916) 21 CLR 277; Christiani & Nielsen Pty Ltd v Goliath Portland Cement Co Ltd (1993) 2 Tas R 122; Cressman and Anor v Coys of Kensington (Sales) Ltd (McDonald, Part 20 Defendant) [2004] 1 WLR 2775; Hampton v Glamorgan County Council [1917] AC 13; McKeown v Cavalier Yachts Pty Ltd and Anor (1988) 13 NSWLR 303; Marriott Industries Pty Ltd v Mercantile Credits Ltd (1991) 160 LSJS 288; Pan Ocean Shipping Ltd v Creditcorp Ltd [1994] 1 All ER 470; Rowe v Vale of White Horse District Council [2003] 1 Lloyd's Rep 418; Southway Group v Wolff (1991) 57 BLR 33; McKeown v Cavalier Yachts Pty Ltd and Anor (1988) 13 NSWLR 303, considered.

WORDS AND PHRASES CONSIDERED/DEFINED

"Incontrovertible benefit"

W COOK BUILDERS PTY LTD (IN LIQ) v MATTHEW LUMBERS & ORS
[2007] SASC 20

Full Court:      Sulan, Vanstone and Layton JJ

  1. SULAN & LAYTON JJ:                 The appellant, W Cook Builders Pty Ltd (In Liq) (“Builders”), brought an action in the District Court seeking a judgment against the first and second respondents, Matthew Lumbers and Warwick Lumbers (“the Lumbers”) for the sum of $274,791.  The claim was for the balance of monies due for work performed by Builders…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read W Cook Builders Pty Ltd (in Liq) v Matthew Lumbers and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] SASC 20
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of W Cook Builders Pty Ltd (in Liq) v Matthew Lumbers was before the court to determine whether W Cook Builders Pty Ltd (the appellant) could recover against Matthew Lumbers (the respondent) on a quantum meruit basis in restitution based on unjust enrichment. The respondent land owners had contracted with the respondent building company, W Cook & Sons Pty Ltd, for the construction of a house. However, the appellant building company, which was related to the respondent building company, carried out the construction work. The appellant incurred expenses in constructing the house but was unlicensed and therefore precluded from recovering in contract by s 39 Builders Licensing Act 1986 (SA). The trial judge found that there was no assignment of the contract by W Cook & Sons Pty Ltd to W Cook Builders Pty Ltd. The legal issues the court was required to decide included whether there was an assignment of the benefit of the contract from W Cook & Sons Pty Ltd to W Cook Builders Pty Ltd, whether s 39 of the Builders Licensing Act precluded recovery in contract by W Cook Builders Pty Ltd, and whether W Cook Builders Pty Ltd could recover against the respondent land owners on a quantum meruit basis in restitution based on unjust enrichment. The court held that there was no injustice to the Lumbers to require them to remunerate W Cook & Sons Pty Ltd. There was no suggestion that delay, failure to insure, or the effect of W Cook Builders Pty Ltd not having been licensed had affected the position. There had been no evidence that there had been a diminution in the value of the benefit by W Cook Builders Pty Ltd having undertaken the work, rather than W Cook & Sons Pty Ltd having performed its obligations under the contract. However, W Cook Builders Pty Ltd had established that the Lumbers had been unjustly enriched by their provision of services. The provision of building services, and the coordination and payment of subcontractors, provided the Lumbers with an incontrovertible benefit, which they accepted and retained. It would be unconscionable for the Lumbers to retain that benefit without making restitution to W Cook Builders Pty Ltd. The court allowed the appeal and ordered the respondents to pay W Cook Builders Pty Ltd the sum of $261,715. The parties would be heard on the question of interest and costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The claim was initially made against the Lumbers and Sons. However, as a consequence of Builders’ failure to provide security for Sons’ costs, a Master of the District Court stayed the action against Sons whilst permitting Builders to continue the action against the Lumbers. Sons therefore took no part in the trial, nor in the appeal before this Court.Background In order to deal with the issues of law, it is necessary to relate the facts in some detail. The facts, which were largely undisputed, are dealt with in the judgment of the District Court Judge, and we relate them mainly from his summary and findings.The initial discussions The construction of the house, which was far from a standard building, commenced in about February 1994 and was completed in May 1995. Matthew Lumbers owned the land, which had been transferred to him as a distribution under the terms of a family trust. Warwick Lumbers, who was the father of Matthew Lumbers, was granted an unregistered lease for his life over the property. The negotiations for the construction of the house were conducted between Warwick Lumbers and David McAdam in and prior to November 1993. David McAdam was a senior executive of the Cook group of companies. We will deal in detail with his position and the role he played in the negotiations later in these reasons. As a result of the negotiations, the Lumbers entered into a contract with W Cook & Sons Pty Ltd (“Sons”) for the construction of the house. We will consider the terms of this contract later. Matthew Lumbers had little to do with the arrangements for construction of the house. Michael Fielder, an architect and brother-in-law of Warwick Lumbers, undertook the design work. The arrangement between the Lumbers and Michael Fielder was of an informal nature. Fielder had prepared detailed plans and specifications well prior to the engagement of Sons as builders. The Cook group of companies The Cook family had been involved in the building industry for many years. Sons had been the main operating company. Over the years, as the business and the family grew, other companies were formed. All the companies were involved directly or indirectly in the building industry. Builders was established some years after the businesses had been operating. This company was used to build properties as a speculator, and in the 1980s built home units. Sons’ primary business was the construction of domestic houses. In about 1990, after the death of his father, Jeffrey Cook became a director of Sons. In 1993, Jeffrey Cook, his brother and a cousin were involved in the businesses. David McAdam, who was a long-time friend and employee, managed the administration side of all the businesses. In 1993, Sons was the main operating company. At this time, Jeffrey Cook managed the building side of the business and spent most of his time on site. David McAdam managed the office. They were the only two who dealt with clients. David McAdam had been responsible for financial management and contract administration in respect of the businesses of the companies since 1963. He had commenced working for the group in 1959. He was originally employed as a bookkeeper, which involved as part of his duties contract administration. He was a very experienced contract administrator.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In our view, there is no injustice to the Lumbers to require them to remunerate Sons. There is no suggestion that delay has affected the position. There is no suggestion that failure to insure has affected the position. There is no effect of Builders not having been licensed. There has been no evidence that there has been a diminution in the value of the benefit by Builders having undertaken the work, rather than Sons having performed its obligations under the contract. Conclusion Builders’ claim based on there being an assignment of the benefit of the contract from Sons fails. We agree with the trial Judge that the requisite intention to assign has not been established by Builders. In any event, s 39 of the Builders Licensing Act precludes recovery in contract by builders that are unlicensed for a reason other than inadvertence. Builders’ failure to hold a licence in the circumstances precludes their recovering contractual damages. Builders have established that the Lumbers have been unjustly enriched by Builders’ provision of services. We consider that the provision of building services, and the coordination and payment of subcontractors, provided the Lumbers with an incontrovertible benefit, which they accepted and retained. It would be unconscionable for the Lumbers to retain that benefit without making restitution to Builders. We would allow the appeal. We would order that the first and second respondents pay Builders the sum of $261,715. We will hear the parties on the question of interest and costs.VANSTONE J:Introduction The appellant, W Cook Builders Pty Ltd (In Liq) (“Builders”), took proceedings in the District Court seeking payment for certain building work carried out at the premises of the first and second defendants, Matthew and Warwick Lumbers (“the Lumbers”). It was not contended that there was a contract between Builders and the Lumbers. The claim was based on an assertion that there was an oral contract between the third defendant, W Cook & Sons Pty Ltd (“Sons”) and the Lumbers and that such a contract had been assigned by Sons to Builders. Alternatively (though faintly) the claim was put as one for payment on the quantum meruit or restitution. After a trial in the District Court the plaintiff’s claim was dismissed, the trial judge finding that there had been no assignment of the contract and that the prerequisites for a claim for restitution had not been met. Upon the appeal the claim of Builders was principally addressed to restitution, although the equitable assignment claim was also maintained.Background In a detailed judgment the trial judge set out comprehensive findings as to the nature of the relationships between the parties and of the events which occurred. I shall mention only those features which are essential to the issues on the appeal. The arrangement between the contracting parties, the Lumbers and Sons, was an unusual one. There was a close relationship between Warwick Lumbers and one McAdam, then a director of Sons, who represented it in the negotiations and in the subsequent dealings as the house premises were built. Agreement was reached in September or October 1993 that Sons would act as builder to construct a house as specified in plans prepared by the Lumbers’ architect. Some of the work, including the steel work, was to be performed or subcontracted by the Lumbers. In respect of the work commissioned or carried out by Sons, McAdam was entrusted with the task of assessing and approving invoices rendered by subcontractors and rendering invoices for any work done by Sons itself. Although a price was never determined, it was agreed that the Lumbers would pay Sons an amount to cover supervision of the project, which would be determined by McAdam. The judge was unable to ascertain more precisely the terms of the contract because it was never formalised, because of the lapse of time since the relevant discussions and because McAdam did not give evidence.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.