Linwood Group Pty Ltd v Grange Warner Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 61 min read

DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Linwood Group Pty Ltd v Grange Warner Pty Ltd [2016] QDC 32

PARTIES:

LINWOOD GROUP PTY LTD ACN 091 421 715

(Plaintiff)

v

GRANGE WARNER PTY LTD ACN 124 421 567

(Defendant)

FILE NO/S:

3061/14

DIVISION:

Civil

PROCEEDING:

Trial

DELIVERED ON:

3 March 2016

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

15, 16 and 17 February 2016

JUDGE:

Bowskill QC DCJ

ORDER:

1.   The plaintiff’s claim is dismissed. 

2.   The defendant’s counterclaim is allowed in part, in so far as the payments referred to in paragraph 74.2 and 74.4 are concerned.

3.   It is appropriate that an order be made for the dissolution of the partnership, and for the taking of accounts.

4.   Direct the parties, within 7 days, to submit a draft of such declarations, orders and directions as they agree ought to be made having regard to the reasons or, failing agreement, each party to submit the form of order they contend is appropriate, together with submissions.

CATCHWORDS:

PARTNERSHIP – RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN PARTNERS – CAPITAL, ADVANCES AND SHARE OF PROFIT OR LOSS – Partnership for the purposes of property development - Where the plaintiff made advances to the partnership under written and oral loan agreements, for the purposes of the partnership business - Whether the loan agreements, or any of them, were independent and separate from the partnership arrangements, so as to permit the plaintiff to maintain an action to recover half of the funds so advanced from the defendant, without the taking of an account

PARTNERSHIP – RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN PARTNERS – Whether there were various oral agreements for the payment of particular amounts by the partnership to the plaintiff – Whether the plaintiff was entitled to recover from the defendant its half share of an amount alleged to be payable under an alleged “service agreement” – Whether plaintiff liable to account to the partnership for amounts paid to the plaintiff which the defendant claimed were unauthorised

EVIDENCE – PROOF – STANDARD OF PROOF – claim based on communications with a deceased person – caution to be exercised

Partnership Act 1891 (Qld), ss 27 and 47

Brown v The New South Wales Trustee and Guardian (2012) 10 ASTLR 164; [2012] NSWCA 431
Clune v Collins Angus & Robertson Publishers Pty Ltd (1992) 25 IPR 246
Craig v Finance Consultants Pty Ltd [1964] NSWR 1012
Dillon v Dillon [1986] TASSC 8
Hurst v Bryk [2002] 1 AC 185
Neale v Bank of Western Australia [2014] NSWSC 315
Zisis v Knighton [2008] NSWCA 42

COUNSEL:

P O’Brien for the Plaintiff

N Shaw for the Defendant  

SOLICITORS:

Crouch & Lyndon Lawyers for the Plaintiff

Porter Davies Lawyers for the Defendant

Introduction

  1. This is a dispute arising from a partnership formed for the purpose of undertaking property development.

  2. The plaintiff (Linwood) and the defendant (Grange Warner) entered into a partnership in March 2007.   In their dealings with one another, Linwood was represented by its director, Michael Gafney; and up until about March 2013 Grange…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Linwood Group Pty Ltd v Grange Warner Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] QDC 32
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Linwood Group Pty Ltd took action against Grange Warner Pty Ltd, seeking to recover a portion of the funds advanced to a property development partnership, as well as to enforce an alleged service agreement. The dispute centred on whether the loan agreements between the parties were independent of the partnership, allowing Linwood to claim half of the advanced funds from Grange Warner without a formal account being taken. Additionally, Linwood argued that it was entitled to recover its half share of an amount under an alleged service agreement and questioned whether it should account to the partnership for certain payments.

The legal issues the court had to decide were whether the loan agreements were separate and independent from the partnership arrangements, whether there were any oral agreements for specific payments by the partnership to Linwood, and if Linwood was entitled to recover its share under an alleged service agreement. The court also had to consider whether Linwood was liable to account for certain payments to the partnership.

The court held that the loan agreements were not independent of the partnership arrangements, as they were integral to the partnership's operations. The court found that the principles of partnership law applied, requiring that any disputes between partners be resolved through an account after dissolution, unless the agreement was independent of the partnership. The court found that the loan agreements were not independent, and therefore Linwood could not recover its share without an account being taken. Furthermore, the court found no evidence of an independent service agreement and dismissed Linwood's claim for recovery under such an agreement. The court also found that Linwood was not liable to account for certain payments to the partnership.

The court dismissed Linwood’s claim, allowed Grange Warner’s counterclaim in part, ordered the dissolution of the partnership and the taking of accounts, and directed the parties to submit drafts of the necessary declarations, orders, and directions within 7 days.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The plaintiff’s claim is dismissed.

2. The defendant’s counterclaim is allowed in part, in so far as the payments referred to in paragraph 74.2 and 74.4 are concerned.

3. It is appropriate that an order be made for the dissolution of the partnership, and for the taking of accounts.

4. Direct the parties, within 7 days, to submit a draft of such declarations, orders and directions as they agree ought to be made having regard to the reasons or, failing agreement, each party to submit the form of order they contend is appropriate, together with submissions.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the same case, Brettingham-Moore J said, at [35]:“Where partners have made an agreement which does not involve any consideration of the partnership accounts they may sue upon such agreement as for a debt owing without an account being taken… But it must be clear that there has been agreement which is completely independent of the partnership arrangements. Normally the indebtedness of one partner to another as at the date of dissolution can only be ascertained by the taking of accounts …”[77][77] References omitted. Emphasis added. These statements of principle from Dillon were referred to with approval by McColl JA (with whom Hodgson and Tobias JJA) agreed, in Zisis v Knighton [2008] NSWCA 42 at [35]-[36] (Zisis). Immediately before referring to Dillon, McColl JA said, at [34]:“The relation between partners is not that of debtor and creditor unless and until the partnership accounts have been finally taken after dissolution and a balance has been ascertained to be owing from one to another. However, ‘[w]here a partner retires, either ad hoc or in accordance with the partnership agreement, and leaves his share in the firm, he no longer has any continuing interest or share in the assets, but is merely a creditor of the firm so that the retiring partner may sue the continuing partners for the value of his share in the assets of the firm or for any sum that the continuing partners agreed to pay the former upon his retirement without the necessity, first of all, of taking a general account’: Halsbury’s Laws of England, 4th ed, vol 35 (at pars [3], [122]).” The principles were also succinctly summarised in the following passage from the reasons of Lord Millett in Hurst v Bryk [2002] 1 AC 185 at 194:“… while partnership is a consensual arrangement based on agreement, it is more than a simple contract … it is a continuing personal as well as commercial relationship. Neither during the continuance of the relationship nor after its determination has any partner any cause of action at law to recover moneys due to him from his fellow partners. The amount owing to a partner by his fellow partners is recoverable only by the taking of an account in equity after the partnership has been dissolved: see Richardson v Bank of England (1838) 4 My & Cr 165; Green v Hertzog [1954] 1 WLR 1309. Only the Court of Chancery was equipped with the machinery necessary to enable such an account to be taken, and the basis upon which the account was taken reflected equitable principles. These could be modified by agreement, but they did not find their source in contract.”[78][78] Emphasis added. It is of course Linwood’s contention that these principles were modified in this case, by the loan agreement(s). Linwood relied in particular upon the decision in Zisis in support of its contention that the loan agreements in this case were separate and independent from the partnership, such as to enable Linwood to sue Grange Warner to recover its share of the moneys loaned, without the taking of accounts.