Linwood Group Pty Ltd v Grange Warner Pty Ltd (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Linwood Group Pty Ltd v Grange Warner Pty Ltd (No 2) [2016] QDC 55

PARTIES:

LINWOOD GROUP PTY LTD ACN 091 421 715

(Plaintiff)

v

GRANGE WARNER PTY LTD ACN 124 421 567

(Defendant)

FILE NO/S:

3061/14

DIVISION:

Civil

PROCEEDING:

Trial

DELIVERED ON:

17 March 2016

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

On the papers

JUDGE:

Bowskill QC DCJ

ORDER:

Orders as per the attachment to these reasons.

COUNSEL:

P O’Brien for the Plaintiff

N Shaw for the Defendant  

SOLICITORS:

Crouch & Lyndon Lawyers for the Plaintiff

Porter Davies Lawyers for the Defendant

  1. On 3 March 2016 judgment was delivered in relation to the plaintiff’s claim and the defendant’s counterclaim:   Linwood Group Pty Ltd v Grange Warner Pty Ltd [2016] QDC 32 (the reasons).

  2. It was appropriate to give the parties time to consider the reasons, before making final orders.  Each party submitted a proposed draft order, together with submissions, which have been considered prior to making the final orders, which are set out below.

  3. In so far as the orders were the subject of difference or dispute between the parties, the reasons for the orders made are as follows.

  4. Special referees (order 3).   The defendant, in a draft order submitted at the end of the trial, proposed Andrew Heers and Mark William Pearce be appointed as special referees to take an account of the partnership, under r 527 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules (UCPR). This was reflected in the plaintiff’s draft order.  But in the more recent draft submitted by the defendant, only Mark Pearce was proposed to be appointed.  After seeking clarification from the parties about this, it was agreed that both Andrew Heers and Mark Pearce be appointed.

  5. Interest on loan moneys (order 4(d)).  The plaintiff claimed interest on each of the advances up to $625,000, found to have been made under the loan agreement, at the rate of 8.5% from the date of the advance, to the date of repayment.  This was on the basis of clauses 3.1 and 3.2 of the loan agreement, and the definition of “base interest rate”, being 8.5% in the absence of an overdraft rate for overdrafts of $100,000 published by the lender’s (Linwood’s) bankers.

  6. The defendant submits, firstly, that there is no “base interest rate”, because that applies “[s]hould there cease to be a published rate”, which was not the case here (rather, Linwood’s banker did not have an overdraft facility for amounts of $100,000).  I do not accept that argument.  As a matter of construction, the intent of the definition of “base interest rate”, in my view, is that 8.5% would be the default position.  

  7. The defendant further submits that in any event, interest ought not be recoverable, given that the continued funding of the project by Linwood was “informal and mostly undocumented”, that it is “probable that there was no specific agreement” between the parties “that the partnership would pay interest” and that “it is probable that the written terms…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Linwood Group Pty Ltd v Grange Warner Pty Ltd (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] QDC 55
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Linwood Group Pty Ltd v Grange Warner Pty Ltd (No 2), the court was called upon to make several directions concerning the presentation of evidence and the tasks of the special referees in a dispute between two partners over partnership accounts. The plaintiff, Linwood Group, sought orders to allow the books and records of the partnership to be used as evidence of their contents and to waive the requirement for receipts for payments over $250, while the defendant, Grange Warner, opposed these proposals. Additionally, the plaintiff sought directions to the statutory trustees for sale regarding payment of settlement amounts and provision of statements, which the defendant also opposed.

The legal issues before the court included whether it was appropriate to allow the books and records to be used as conclusive evidence of partnership transactions and whether the requirement for receipts should be waived. The court found that while the books and records could be used as evidence, either party retained the right to challenge specific entries. Given the informal nature of the partnership and the length of time over which it operated, the court deemed it reasonable to waive the requirement for receipts for payments over $250. However, regarding the directions to the statutory trustees for sale, the court was not satisfied that there was a proper basis to make such orders and thus declined to do so.

The court made orders allowing the books and records to serve as evidence of the matters contained within them and waiving the requirement for receipts for payments over $250, in line with the plaintiff's submissions. The court did not make the proposed directions to the statutory trustees for sale due to the lack of a proper basis for such orders. The final orders were detailed in an attachment to the reasons for judgment.

Orders

Orders of the court

Orders as per the attachment to these reasons.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Linwood Group Pty Ltd v Grange Warner Pty Ltd (No 2) involves a dispute between two companies, Linwood Group Pty Ltd and Grange Warner Pty Ltd, regarding the management and financial accounts of a partnership that existed between the two entities. The partnership, which began in March 2007, involved the companies working together in some capacity, though the exact nature of their business relationship is not entirely clear from the facts presented. The partnership eventually fell apart, leading to the present litigation where the plaintiff, Linwood Group Pty Ltd, seeks to resolve financial disputes arising from the partnership.

The plaintiff has proposed two orders regarding the use of books and records as evidence and the verification of payments over $250. Specifically, order 8 proposes that the books and records of the partnership be accepted as evidence of the matters contained within them. Order 9 seeks to exempt payments over $250 from the requirement of being verified by a receipt, which is ordinarily mandated by rule 530(4) of the UCPR. The defendant, Grange Warner Pty Ltd, opposes these orders, arguing that the books and records were maintained solely by Mr Gafney of Linwood and may not have been reviewed by Grange Warner, thus making the orders potentially unfair. Additionally, the defendant contends that order 9 might mislead the special referee into considering the books and records as conclusive evidence, contrary to their role. The plaintiff counters that verifying each payment over $250 by a receipt would be burdensome, given the nine-year period over which the partnership operated. The plaintiff also notes that any contested entries can be challenged under the UCPR.

In addition to the orders on books and records, the plaintiff has proposed directions for the special referees tasked with resolving the partnership's financial disputes. These directions aim to regulate how the statutory trustees for the sale of partnership assets should handle payments received from settlements and the provision of statements. The defendant opposes these directions, arguing that they were not part of the relief sought in the proceedings, are unnecessary, and questioning whether the court has jurisdiction to issue such directions to trustees appointed by the Supreme Court. The court decides not to make these directions, citing the lack of a proper basis for the court to intervene and the absence of further submissions on the matter.

The matter of Linwood Group Pty Ltd v Grange Warner Pty Ltd (No 2) has a complex procedural history involving various applications and orders pertaining to the evidence to be used in the accounting proceedings and the role of the special referees. The case originated as a partnership dispute concerning the financial dealings between the parties over a period of approximately nine years. It has since evolved through several stages, including interlocutory applications regarding the admissibility of certain evidence and the scope of the special referees' tasks. The matter came before this court for consideration of these procedural matters, rather than as a first-instance hearing or appeal of a prior decision. Prior to this court, the special referees were appointed to examine and report on the partnership's accounts, a process which involved contentious issues regarding the admissibility of the partnership's books and records and the requirement for receipts to verify payments. The plaintiff proposed specific orders to facilitate the special referees' task, including that the books and records be deemed evidence of their contents and that receipts for payments over $250 need not be provided. The defendant opposed these proposals, arguing that the orders were unfair and contrary to certain rules of court. The court ultimately considered these proposals in light of the specific circumstances of the case, including the length of the partnership, the nature of its dealings, and the pragmatic need to bring the matter to a conclusion. The court also considered additional proposed directions to statutory trustees for sale, which the defendant opposed on several grounds, including the scope of the court's jurisdiction. The court decided not to make these additional directions in the absence of further submissions or argument on the matter.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Books and records as evidence of contents, and no receipts (orders 8 and 9). The plaintiff proposed orders 8 and 9; the defendant opposes them. Order 8 (that the books and records of the partnership shall be evidence of the matters contained in them) is one of the directions contemplated by rule 528(1)(b) of the UCPR. Order 9 (that no payments shall be required to be verified by receipt) is contrary to rule 530(4) of the UCPR (which provides that payments over $250 are to be verified by receipt, unless the court otherwise orders). The defendant says that, since the books and records were maintained by Mr Gafney (Linwood), and may not have been seen by Grange Warner, these orders would be unfair; and the orders “might give the special referee the impression that he must take the books as conclusive, which is contrary to his role”. The plaintiff submits that it would be lengthy, expensive and disproportionate to verify each and every payment over $250 by receipt for a period of approximately 9 years; and notes that to the extent either party wishes to contest an aspect of the account or a payment, that is permitted under the UCPR, and is dealt with in the orders (see orders 13 to 15). In this regard, it is noted that rule 528(2) provides that “[i]f the court directs that the books and records of account are evidence of the matters contained in them, the parties have leave to take objections”. In my view, in the circumstances of this case, orders 8 and 9 are appropriate. Order 8 does not require the special referees to take the books and records as conclusive evidence. As both rule 528(2), and order 13 contemplate, it is open to either partner to challenge any particular entry in the accounts. Further to that, however, it is to be inferred in this matter that there has already been considerable analysis of the accounts, and that the disputed matters are those that were challenged in this proceeding. As to the provision of receipts, keeping in mind the length of time over which this partnership was in place (from March 2007), and the nature of the partnership, the relationship between the partners, and the way that they transacted business (informally, mostly by verbal agreements, and without extensive paperwork) – at least up until things fell apart – I accept the plaintiff’s submission that to require receipts for every expense over $250 would be unreasonable. There must be some pragmatism brought to bear, in bringing this matter to an end, especially in circumstances where the primary representative of Grange Warner has passed away. Special referees’ task (order 12). Order 12, proposed by the plaintiff, appears reasonable, and was not the subject of express opposition from the defendant. Statutory trustees for sale. The plaintiff had also proposed directions to the statutory trustees for sale, both in terms of payment of amounts received from settlements of sales, and for the provision of statements. The defendant opposes the making of these orders, on the bases that this did not form any part of the relief sought in the proceeding, the orders are unnecessary, and questioning whether this court has jurisdiction in any event to give directions to trustees appointed by the Supreme Court. I am not satisfied that there is a proper basis for this court to make the directions sought, and in the absence of further submissions and/or argument on this matter, I do not propose to make them.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the books and records of the partnership are admissible as evidence of the matters contained in them, in accordance with order 8 and rule 528(1)(b) of the UCPR.
2. Whether the requirement for receipts to verify payments over $250, as per rule 530(4) of the UCPR, should be applied in this case.
3. Whether the special referees’ task, as outlined in order 12, is reasonable and appropriate.
4. Whether the court has the jurisdiction to give directions to the statutory trustees for sale regarding the payment of amounts received from settlements of sales and the provision of statements.

Held
1. The court held that the books and records of the partnership are admissible as evidence of the matters contained in them in accordance with order 8 and rule 528(1)(b) of the UCPR. The court concluded that the orders are appropriate in the circumstances of the case and that the parties have leave to take objections to any particular entry in the accounts.
2. The court held that the requirement for receipts to verify payments over $250, as per rule 530(4) of the UCPR, should not be applied in this case. The court concluded that requiring receipts for every expense over $250 would be unreasonable given the length of time over which the partnership was in place and the informal nature of the relationship between the partners.
3. The court held that the special referees’ task, as outlined in order 12, is reasonable and appropriate. The court noted that the defendant did not expressly oppose the order.
4. The court held that it does not have the jurisdiction to give directions to the statutory trustees for sale regarding the payment of amounts received from settlements of sales and the provision of statements. The court concluded that there is no proper basis for the court to make the directions sought, and did not propose to make them in the absence of further submissions or argument on the matter.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court in Linwood Group Pty Ltd v Grange Warner Pty Ltd (No 2) considered several orders proposed by the plaintiff, Linwood Group, and opposed by the defendant, Grange Warner. The court assessed each order in light of the specific circumstances of the case, the relevant legal principles, and the authorities cited. The court found that orders 8 and 9 were appropriate given the context of the case. Order 8, which permits the books and records of the partnership to be admitted as evidence of the matters contained within them, aligns with rule 528(1)(b) of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules (UCPR). The court reasoned that this order does not require the special referees to accept the books and records as conclusive evidence. Instead, it permits the parties to challenge specific entries if necessary, in line with rule 528(2) of the UCPR. The court accepted the plaintiff's argument that requiring receipts for every payment over $250 would be unreasonable, considering the informal nature of the partnership and the lengthy period over which it operated. This pragmatic approach was deemed appropriate to bring the matter to a conclusion.

Order 9, which exempts payments over $250 from verification by receipt, was also upheld by the court despite its contradiction with rule 530(4) of the UCPR. The court found that the practicalities of verifying each payment over a nine-year period would be excessively burdensome and disproportionate. The court accepted the plaintiff's assertion that the informal nature of the partnership, along with the way the partners conducted business, made such a requirement unreasonable. This decision reflects the court's willingness to apply a pragmatic approach to the case, especially considering the informal business practices and the length of time over which the partnership existed.

Regarding Order 12, which sets out the task for the special referees, the court found it to be reasonable and appropriate. The defendant did not explicitly oppose this order, suggesting that it did not pose any significant issues. The court's acceptance of this order indicates a belief that the task outlined is suitable for resolving the matters at hand, without raising any immediate concerns or objections from the defendant.

The court declined to make directions to the statutory trustees for sale, as proposed by the plaintiff, in response to the defendant's opposition. The defendant argued that this relief was not part of the original proceeding and questioned whether the court had the jurisdiction to issue such directions. The court did not find a proper basis for making these directions and, in the absence of further argument or submissions, decided against issuing them. This decision highlights the court's cautious approach to expanding the scope of its orders beyond what was initially sought in the proceeding, especially when there is no clear legal basis or necessity to do so.