Lewski v Commissioner of Taxation

Link copied
Case Copied 81 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Lewski v Commissioner of Taxation [2017] FCAFC 145

File number: VID 1496 of 2016
Judges: PERRAM, PAGONE AND MOSHINSKY JJ
Date of judgment: 18 September 2017
Catchwords:

TAXATION – income tax – deductions – when loss or outgoing is “incurred” – contracts for sale and purchase of land and for sale and purchase of aged care hostel business – whether certain amounts were incurred by purchaser upon execution of contracts – whether Tribunal erred in concluding that the amounts were not incurred upon execution of contracts

TAXATION – income tax – taxation of trusts – discretionary trust – where trustee resolved to distribute income to particular beneficiary but also resolved to distribute the income to a different beneficiary if the Commissioner disallowed a deduction or included an additional amount in assessable income – whether resolutions were valid – whether variation resolution, if invalid, was severable – whether first-mentioned beneficiary was “presently entitled” to a share of the income of the trust estate

TAXATION – review proceedings under Pt IVC of Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth) – application by taxpayer to rely on grounds not in objection – principles applicable

TRUSTS AND TRUSTEES – discretionary trust – distribution of income – where beneficiary executed deed of disclaimer – whether disclaimer effective – whether beneficiary had already accepted the distribution – whether knowledge of beneficiary’s agent should be imputed to beneficiary

TRUSTS AND TRUSTEES – discretionary trust – resolution of trustee to distribute income – where resolution expressed in terms of “income” of the trust – where distribution power in trust deed expressed in terms of “Net Income” – whether on its true construction the resolution related to Net Income of the trust

Legislation:

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth), s 44

Aged Care Act 1997 (Cth), Pts 2.1, 2.2

Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth), ss 51, 95, 97, 99A, 190

Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 (Cth), s 8-1

Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth), s 14ZZK

Transfer of Land Act 1958 (Vic)

Cases cited:

Adderley v Dixon (1824) 1 Sim & St 607; 57 ER 239

ANZ Executors and Trustees Ltd v Humes Ltd [1990] VR 615

Aon Risk Services Australia Ltd v Australian National University (2009) 239 CLR 175

Bank of New South Wales v Commonwealth (1948) 76 CLR 1

BRK (Bris) Pty Ltd v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (2001) 46 ATR 347

Byrnes v Kendle (2011) 243 CLR 253

Chapmans Ltd v Australian Stock Exchange Ltd (1996) 67 FCR 402

City of Subiaco v Local Government Advisory Board (2011) 184 LGERA 200; [2011] WASC 322

Coles Myer Finance Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation (Cth) (1993) 176 CLR 640

Commissioner of Taxation (Cth) v Citylink Melbourne Ltd (2006) 228 CLR 1

Commissioner of Taxation v Raymor (NSW) Pty Ltd (1990) 24 FCR 90

Commissioner of Taxation v Woolcombers (WA) Pty Ltd (1993) 47 FCR 561

Dougan v Ley (1946) 71 CLR 142

Federal Commissioner of Taxation v Cornell (1946) 73 CLR 394

Federal Commissioner of Taxation…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lewski v Commissioner of Taxation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] FCAFC 145
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Lewski v Commissioner of Taxation, the taxpayer challenged the Commissioner's objection decision regarding her assessable income for the 2006 and 2007 financial years. The taxpayer was a beneficiary of two discretionary trusts, the ACE Trust and the Arjod Trust. The Commissioner disallowed certain deductions claimed by the taxpayer, which pertained to the sale of properties and businesses. The taxpayer appealed the Tribunal's decision to dismiss her review application, arguing that the Tribunal erred in its conclusions about the timing of certain expenses and the distribution of trust income.

The primary legal issues involved the interpretation of the income tax laws, specifically the timing of deductions and the distribution of income within discretionary trusts. The court needed to determine whether the taxpayer could claim the deductions for certain expenses in the year they were incurred or if they had to be carried forward. Additionally, the court had to decide if the taxpayer was "presently entitled" to the income of the trusts as per the trust deeds and the applicable tax laws.

The court found that the Tribunal had erred in its interpretation of the tax laws and the trust deeds. Regarding the timing of the deductions, the court held that the expenses incurred in the sale of properties and businesses were indeed "incurred" in the relevant financial years, contrary to the Tribunal's findings. Concerning the distribution of trust income, the court found that the taxpayer was "presently entitled" to the income of the trusts, as per the trust deeds, despite the Commissioner's objections. The court also determined that the disclaimers executed by the taxpayer were valid and that the trustee's resolutions to distribute income were valid and binding.

The appeal was allowed, and the decision of the Tribunal was set aside. The matter was remitted to the Commissioner for redetermination in accordance with the court's findings. The court ordered that the Commissioner's objection decision be set aside and that the matter be remitted for redetermination. The court also ordered the Commissioner to pay the taxpayer's costs of the appeal, subject to taxation if not agreed.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be allowed.

2. The decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal made on 9 December 2016 at Melbourne be set aside and, in lieu thereof, it be ordered that:

(a) the objection decision of the respondent with respect to the 2006 and 2007 years of income be set aside; and

(b) the matter be remitted to the respondent for redetermination according to law.

3. Subject to paragraph 4, the respondent pay the applicant’s costs of the appeal, to be taxed if not agreed.

4. If either party seeks a variation of the costs order in paragraph 3, the party shall give written notice to the Court and the other party within seven business days. Directions will then be made for the filing and service of written submissions on costs.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

It follows that the appeal is to be allowed. The decision of the Tribunal should be set aside and, in lieu thereof, orders made that the Commissioner’s objection decision be set aside and the matter remitted to the Commissioner for redetermination according to law.Background facts The following statement of background facts is based on the findings in the reasons of the Tribunal (TVKS and Commissioner of Taxation [2016] AATA 1010) (the Reasons) and the documents in the Application Book filed in this Court. It will be convenient to deal, first, with the facts relating to the ACE Trust (which are relevant for the 2006 year) and then, second, with the facts relating to the Arjod Trust (which are relevant for the 2007 year).The ACE Trust The ACE Trust was established by a deed executed on 17 June 1997. By a deed executed on the following day, 18 June 1997, ACPS was appointed as trustee. The applicant was a General Beneficiary of the Trust. The applicant’s husband, William Lewski (Mr Lewski), was the sole Specified Beneficiary. By cl 2.1 of the trust deed, the Settlor declared that the Trustee would hold, and the Trustee declared that it held, the “Trust Fund and any Income or gain accruing to the Trust Fund upon the trusts and with and subject to the powers and provisions contained” in the trust deed. The “Trust Fund” was defined as meaning: the Settled Sum; all moneys, investments and property paid, transferred to, or accepted by the Trustee as additions to the Trust Fund; accumulations of Income directed or empowered to be made by the trust deed; all accretions and additions to the Trust Fund from any source; the investments and property from time to time representing the Settled Sum, money, investments, property, accumulations, accretions and additions; and any specific asset for the time being forming part of the Trust Fund. “Income” was defined in cl 1.15 of the trust deed as including, but not being limited to, “assessable Income as defined in the Tax Law”. “Net Income” was defined in cl 1.17 of the trust deed as follows:“Net Income” means the amount calculated as the net Income of the Trust Fund for an Accounting Period in accordance with section 95(1) of Tax Law including:1.17.1any net capital gain included in the assessable Income of the Trust Fund by virtue of section 160ZO of Tax Law; and1.17.2to the extent allowable, any taxation credits available to the Trustee under Tax Law including but not limited to:1.17.2.1 foreign tax credits;1.17.2.2 prescribed payment tax credits; and1.17.2.3 dividend imputation credits;unless the Trustee determines in respect of any Accounting Period that Net Income for that Accounting Period means the Income produced from the investment of the Trust Fund calculated in accordance with established accounting principles and trust law; … Clause 3 was headed “Allocation of Income” and cl 3.1 set out certain rules that applied for the purpose of ascertaining the Net Income of the Trust Fund. Clause 3.2.1 provided that the Trustee “must, in respect of each Accounting Period, collect, receive and get in all dividends, interest, rents and all classes of Income arising from the constituent investments and the Trust Fund, pay all costs and disbursements, commissions, fees, taxes …, management charges and all other proper outgoings, losses and expenses …”.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

In relation to the 2007 year, the Commissioner assessed the applicant on the basis that her taxable income was $3,204,593. This amount was determined on the basis that:(a)Drewvale, as trustee of the Arjod Trust, did not have a tax loss for the 2000 year;(b)the net income of the Arjod Trust under s 95 of the 1936 Act for the 2007 year was $6,643,199; and(c)the applicant should have included $3,143,199 in assessable income in her 2007 tax return as a result of being presently entitled to a share of the income of the Arjod Trust pursuant to s 97 of the 1936 Act.The objection and objection decision On 5 July 2013, the applicant objected to the amended assessments. On 9 July 2015, the Commissioner allowed the applicant’s objection to the following extent: ACPS (as trustee of the ACE Trust) was entitled to a deduction of $230,000 in the 2006 year in relation to the Glendale Property Syndicate; and, accordingly, an amount of $9,878,621 (instead of $10,108,621) was to be included in the assessable income of the applicant for the 2006 year, as a result of her being presently entitled to 100% of the net income of the ACE Trust. Otherwise, the objection was disallowed. On 18 August 2015, the Commissioner issued to the applicant a further amended assessment for the 2006 year.The disclaimers On 15 December 2015, the applicant executed the Deeds of Disclaimer. Each was headed “Disclaimer of Entitlement to Income”. One related to the ACE Trust and the other to the Arjod Trust. The terms of the disclaimer in relation to the ACE Trust were as follows:I understand and acknowledge that I am one of the beneficiaries of the ACE No 4 Trust (ACE No 4).I hereby disclaim and reject absolutely any entitlement I have to any interest whatsoever that I may have now or in the future or have had at any time since 1 July 2005, to any income, capital or gift at all from ACE No. 4.This disclaimer takes effect on and from 1 July 2005. The Deed of Disclaimer with respect to the Arjod Trust was in similar terms:I understand and acknowledge that I am one of the beneficiaries of the Arjod Trading Trust (Arjod).I hereby disclaim and reject absolutely any entitlement I have to any interest whatsoever that I may have now or in the future or have had at any time since 1 July 2006, to any income, capital or gift at all from Arjod.This disclaimer takes effect on and from 1 July 2006.The Tribunal decision On 4 September 2015, the applicant lodged with the Tribunal an application for review of the Commissioner’s objection decision. The issues before the Tribunal were identified in the following documents filed by the parties:(a)the applicant’s amended statement of facts, issues and contentions dated 5 March 2016; and(b)the Commissioner’s statement of facts, issues and contentions dated 11 February 2016. In relation to the ACE Trust, the applicant stated in her amended statement of facts, issues and contentions that ACPS had prepared its tax returns on the basis that: it was a 40% member of the Glendale Property Syndicate in 1999; the syndicate had incurred outgoings in the 1999 year pursuant to the Contract of Sale and the Purchase of Business Agreement; and as a result of deductions that ACPS was entitled to claim based on those outgoings, ACPS was entitled to claim carry forward losses. The applicant contended as follows:(a)Insofar as the Contract of Sale was concerned, the amounts incurred in the 1999 year were the initial deposit of $1 million (which was not in dispute) and the Settlement Amount of $1.74 million. The applicant accepted that the further amounts payable under the Contract of Sale (namely, the First Post Settlement Amount and the Final Post Settlement Amount) were not incurred in the 1999 year.(b)In relation to the Purchase of Business Agreement, the amount incurred in the 1999 year was the whole of the Purchase Price, namely, the deposit of $1.75 million (which was not in dispute) and the balance of $5.51 million, subject to any adjustment.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established