Lennon v Gympie Motel (BN 3451616)

Link copied
Case Copied 74 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Lennon v Gympie Motel (BN 3451616) [2016] QSC 315

PARTIES:

Karla Lucy-May Lennon

(Plaintiff)

v
Gympie Motel (BN 3451616)

(Defendant)

FILE NO/S:

SC No 3797 of 2006

DIVISION:

Supreme Court – Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Trial

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

22 December 2016

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

11, 12 and 13 October 2016

JUDGE:

Flanagan J

ORDER:

The liability of the defendant to pay the plaintiff damages should be apportioned as to 85 per cent against the defendant and 15 per cent against the plaintiff.  I will hear the parties as to costs.

CATCHWORDS:

TORTS – NEGLIGENCE – ESSENTIALS OF ACTION FOR NEGLIGENCE – DUTY OF CARE – SPECIAL RELATIONSHIPS OR DUTIES – OCCUPIERS – where the plaintiff was injured at a pool on the defendant’s premises – where the plaintiff was twelve years and nine months of age at the time of the injury – where there was a sign at the pool requiring adult supervision of children using the pool – where there were no signs prohibiting diving or indicating the depth of the pool – whether the failure to display signs prohibiting diving and/or indicating the depth of the pool was a breach of the duty, owed by the defendant, to the plaintiff – whether the failure to display signs prohibiting diving and/or indicating the depth of the pool was causative of the plaintiff’s injury – whether the plaintiff was contributorily negligent

Central Goldfields Shire v Haley (2009) 24 VR 378, cited
Felhaber v Rockhampton City Council [2011] QSC 23, cited
Hornberg v Horrobin & Anor [1997] QSC 207, distinguished
Inverell Municipal Council v Pennington & Anor (1993) 82 LGERA 268, considered
McHale v Watson (1966) 115 CLR 199; [1966] HCA 13, cited
Miller v Livingston Shire Council [2003] QCA 29, cited
Mulligan v Coffs Harbour City Council (2005) 223 CLR 486; [2005] HCA 63, cited
Public Trustee v Sutherland Shire Council (1992) 75 LGRA 278, considered
Nagle v Rottnest Island Authority (1993) 177 CLR 423; [1993] HCA 76, cited
Simpson v Grundy [2013] 2 Qd R 384, considered
Thomas v Trades & Labour Hire Pty Ltd (in liq) & Anor [2016] QCA 332, cited
Vairy v Wyong Shire Council (2005) 223 CLR 422; [2005] HCA 62, considered

Roads & Traffic Authority of NSW v Dederer (1970) 123 CLR 185; [1970] HCA 28, considered

COUNSEL:

G R Mullins with S J Cilento for the plaintiff

S C Williams QC with M P Williams for the defendant

SOLICITORS:

Rostron Carlyle for the plaintiff

Mills Oakley for the defendant

Introduction

  1. This case concerns injuries, suffered by the plaintiff, on 21 February 1998 at a pool located at the Gympie Motel. The plaintiff was rendered tetraplegic as a result of the events which occurred on that day. By orders dated 6 May 2016 Atkinson J directed, pursuant to rule 483 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lennon v Gympie Motel (BN 3451616) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] QSC 315
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Lennon v Gympie Motel (BN 3451616) involved the plaintiff, Lennon, who suffered injuries while using a pool at the defendant's motel. Lennon was twelve years and nine months old at the time of the incident. The motel had a sign requiring adult supervision of children using the pool, but there were no signs prohibiting diving or indicating the depth of the pool. The court had to decide if the motel's failure to display such signs constituted a breach of duty of care, whether this breach caused Lennon's injury, and if Lennon was contributorily negligent.

The court considered several legal issues, including whether Lennon's injuries were a result of diving into the pool, if the motel had a duty to take steps to reduce the risks of injury by having depth markers and/or signs prohibiting diving, and if taking such steps would have prevented the injuries. Additionally, the court assessed whether Lennon's injuries would have been avoided if the motel had displayed the signs and whether Lennon was contributorily negligent.

The court found that the motel had a duty to warn of the dangers of diving and the depth of the pool, especially given that Lennon was a child. It was more probable than not that Lennon's injuries occurred as a result of diving into the pool, and that the motel's failure to display signs prohibiting diving and/or indicating the depth of the pool was a breach of the duty owed to Lennon. The court also found that the motel's breach of duty was causative of Lennon's injury. Regarding contributory negligence, the court found that Lennon was 15% contributorily negligent.

The court ordered that the liability of the defendant to pay Lennon damages should be apportioned as to 85 per cent against the defendant and 15 per cent against Lennon. The court also noted that it would hear the parties as to costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

The liability of the defendant to pay the plaintiff damages should be apportioned as to 85 per cent against the defendant and 15 per cent against the plaintiff. I will hear the parties as to costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The issues for determination are:1. Is it more probable than not that the plaintiff’s injuries occurred as a result of her diving into the pool? (The mechanics of the injuries).2. Does the content of the defendant’s duty of care extend to taking steps to reduce the risks of injury, by having depth markers in place and/or erecting a sign warning that diving was prohibited? (Breach of duty).3. Would the plaintiff’s injuries have been avoided had any of the steps in paragraph 2 been taken? (Causation)4. If the defendant did breach its duty of care and the plaintiff’s injuries were caused by that breach, was the plaintiff contributorily negligent? The Plaintiff’s Evidence The plaintiff has no recollection of the events of 21 February 1998.[16] Her recollection of events prior to the incident is limited in that she appears able to recall some events very clearly, but is unable to recall other events at all.[17][16] T1-29, lines 14 to 16. [17] T1-41, lines 5 to 12. A particularly striking example of the plaintiff’s inability to recall certain events prior to 21 February 1998 emerged in the course of cross-examination where the plaintiff stated that she could not remember an occasion where she had dived prior to 21 February 1998.[18] The plaintiff stated that she could not remember ever having dived into a pool.[19][18] T1-39, lines 33 to 35. [19] T1-39, lines 43 to 44.The Plaintiff’s Memory Dr Steven Costello, who was employed at the Gympie General Hospital in February 1998,[20] signed the plaintiff’s patient discharge form.[21] The patient discharge form states that:“A diagnosis of hypoxic brain injury secondary to immersion due to a cervical spine injury with aspiration pneumonia was made.”[20] T2-38, line 47.[21] Exhibit 18. Dr Costello gave evidence that short-term and long-term memory and behavioural issues may be included in the constellation of symptoms that can arise from a hypoxic brain injury.[22] [22] T2-39, lines 30-35. Dr Costello noted that the presence of a hypoxic brain injury is not necessarily consistent with hypoxic brain damage having occurred.[23] According to Dr Costello, the existence of a hypoxic brain injury can only be determined prospectively. The effect of his evidence is that the symptoms flowing from a hypoxic brain injury can only be determined after the fact, through multiple tests.[24][23] T2-40, lines 7 to 11. [24] T2-40, lines 22 to 33. There is no evidence before me, aside from the patient discharge form detailing the existence of a hypoxic brain injury and the plaintiff’s testimony, to suggest that her memory was impaired as a result of the incident on 21 February 1998. In explaining her memory difficulties the plaintiff stated that she has problems with short term recall.[25] As well as this there are parts of her childhood, prior to the incident, which she cannot recall at all.[26] She can however, recall specific things that she used to do in her childhood.[27][25] T1-49, lines 21 to 29.[26] T1-50, lines 3 to 6.[27] T1-50, lines 4 to 6.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established