Scarf v State of Queensland

Link copied
Case Copied 74 min read

IN THE SUPREME COURT

OF QUEENSLAND
  No 1272 of 1993

Brisbane

[Scarf v.  State of Queensland & Anor]

BETWEEN:

SEAN JAMES SCARF

Plaintiff

AND:
  STATE OF QUEENSLAND

First Defendant

AND:

COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF GOLD COAST
  Second Defendant

CATCHWORDS:     PERSONAL INJURY - tetraplegia - diving from bridge into creek - whether duty owed by highway authority - whether duty owed by local authority - whether warning signs required - higher guardrail - causation - quantum - employment prospects - future needs.

Counsel:Mr P Dutney QC for plaintiff

with him Mr R Morton
Mr S Williams QC for first defendant
with him Mr M Burns
Mr AJH Morris QC for second defendant
with him Mr J Rolls

Solicitors:Ebsworth & Ebsworth for plaintiff

(Murphy & Schmidt)
Crown Solicitor for first defendant
McLaughlins for second defendant

Hearing Dates:  10 to 17 August 1998

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT - WHITE J

Judgment delivered 30 October 1998

  1. The plaintiff is a 29 year old man who sustained serious spinal injury on 25 September 1990 when he was almost 21 years, after diving head first from the guardrail on the Tallebudgera Creek bridge into the water below.  As a consequence of his injury the plaintiff suffers from complete tetraplegia.  A four lane highway which is the main north-south east coast of Australia road, passes over that bridge. The plaintiff gave instructions that he sustained his injury on 24 September and that date appears in the original pleadings and in many of the medical reports when the information was obtained from him.  The pleadings have been amended to reflect the correct date and nothing turns upon it, but is mentioned to explain the discrepancy in some of the reports.

  2. The plaintiff has sued the State of Queensland as representative defendant, for the Commissioner of Main Roads and/or the Director-General, Department of Transport, in whom property in the bridge/road was vested pursuant to s.8 of the Crown Proceedings Act 1980, for failure to erect signs warning of the dangers associated with diving from the bridge or signs prohibiting diving and/or failing to erect a higher guardrail which would prevent such activity. There is no issue about the identity of the first defendant and it is convenient to refer at times to the Commissioner or to Queensland Transport, or simply to the first defendant.

  3. The plaintiff has sued the Council of the City of Gold Coast (“the Council”) as second defendant essentially for failure to erect warning signs alerting him to the dangers associated with diving from the bridge consequent upon its alleged powers in respect of this road and its occupation of a nearby recreational area.

  4. Both liability and quantum are in issue.

I N D E X

No:

  ITEM

  PAGE NO:

1

Facts

4

(a)   Tallebudgera Creek Bridge, its History and Recreational Use

4

(b)   The Plaintiff and Tallebudgera Creek Bridge

8

(c)   The Plaintiff’s dive on 25 September 1990

9

(d)   Knowledge of the Defendants about the Recreational Use of the Bridge

12

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Scarf v State of Queensland and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1998] QSC 233
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Scarf v State of Queensland, the plaintiff, Scarf, brought a case against the State of Queensland for an accident that occurred at Tallebudgera Creek, specifically at the bridge that spans the creek. The plaintiff alleged that the bridge's design was inherently dangerous and that the guardrails were inadequate, resulting in the accident. The dispute focused on whether the design and guardrails of the bridge were defective and whether the State of Queensland was negligent in maintaining the bridge. The case was heard in the Supreme Court of Queensland.

The primary legal issues before the court were whether the bridge's design and guardrails were defective and whether the State of Queensland breached its duty of care by failing to ensure the safety of the bridge. The court had to consider expert evidence regarding the design, construction, and maintenance of the bridge, as well as the adequacy of the guardrails. The court also needed to determine whether the State of Queensland could be held liable for the plaintiff's injuries.

The court examined the evidence presented regarding the bridge's design and the guardrails. It found that the bridge was constructed and maintained in accordance with the relevant standards and regulations at the time. The court also noted that the configuration of the creek and the channel were clearly visible, which would have been apparent to any observer on the bridge. The court concluded that the guardrails were adequate and that there was no evidence to support the claim that the bridge's design was inherently dangerous. The court held that the State of Queensland did not breach its duty of care and that the plaintiff's injuries were not caused by any negligence on the part of the State of Queensland.

In light of the court's findings, judgment was entered in favour of the defendants against the plaintiff. The court will hear submissions regarding the costs of the proceedings. The final orders of the court will be issued following the hearing on costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Facts Those who have seen Tallebudgera Creek and its surroundings at the site of the bridge as it runs towards the sea would be likely to describe it as a charming and most attractive place. On the north side from the bridge to the ocean is a heavily treed National Park. On the southern bank near the bridge is a popular sandy beach with nearby amenities provided by the Council including a caravan park, amenities block, parking and lawns (exhibit 1, photograph no.1). As the aerial photographs (exhibit 45) show, the surrounding areas are otherwise heavily populated. The Tallebudgera Creek at the point of the bridge is a wide tidal watercourse a short distance from the Pacific Ocean (exhibit 1, photograph no. 1). At high tide the level of the creek is about 5 metres below the level of the bridge. The bottom of the creek consists of shallow sandy shoals for about three-quarters of its width from the southern bank with a deeper channel on the northern side. The northern side of the creek is confined by a vertical rock face or wall which extends several metres above the waterline (exhibit 1, photographs nos. 2 and 3, exhibit 44). The location of the channel is usually able to be seen by an observer on the bridge and the shallower sandy bottom is clearly visible across the width of the bridge even at high tide. The configuration of the creek, its sandy shoals and the channel can be seen in aerial photographs taken in 1997 (exhibit 45). The normal width of the channel, according to Mr Patterson, an expert in coastal management engineering, is 60 metres plus or minus 5 metres, but in 1990, as a consequence of two episodes of flooding the main channel appeared to widen out to about 90 metres on the southern side which was deeper than the sandy shallows but shallower than the channel proper. This factor plays no part in this accident. From the late 1930s a bridge spanned Tallebudgera Creek in the same position as the southbound lanes of the present bridge. That bridge had a timber deck supported by a reinforced concrete pylon substructure with one lane of traffic in each direction. The Department of Main Roads constructed a new bridge to the west of the old bridge in the late 1960s which now carries the two northbound lanes of traffic. The old bridge was then demolished and the present southbound lanes constructed in its place joined as one bridge with the northbound lanes. The new bridge is approximately a half a metre higher than the old bridge. The old bridge had a guardrail on both sides constructed of joined water pipes with a mid-rail which can be seen in a photograph (exhibit 4) taken in 1968 when construction of the new bridge had just commenced. The present bridge has concrete pylons with a concrete deck on which is laid the four-lane highway. There is a pedestrian footpath on each of the eastern and western sides of the bridge. There was no evidence about the original guardrails of the present bridge but by 1983 they required maintenance and apparently looked unsightly. They were replaced towards the end of 1984 by the Department of Main Roads at the request of the Council at an estimated cost of $87,909 (exhibit 35). The rails are approximately 1,140 millimetres high supported on posts approximately 110mm x 70mm at approximately 1,800mm intervals. The top and bottom rails measured 50mm x 30mm in cross section. The vertical balusters were measured at 25mm square at 150mm centres fitted between the top and bottom rail. The top of the rail measured 970mm above the top of the bottom rail. Photographs and sketches in Dr F Grigg’s report (exhibit 31) illustrate the guardrail. A narrow ledge, which does not appear to have been measured, extends the bridge deck beyond the rails.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Conclusion There will be judgment for the defendants against the plaintiff. I will hear submissions as to costs. SCHEDULE OF FUTURE NEED FORMEDICAL AIDS AND OTHER EQUIPMENT

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.