Kelly v Amalgamated Metal Workers' and Shipwrights' Union

Link copied
Case Copied 54 min read

Re: IN THE MATTER OF THE CONCILIATION AND ARBITRATION ACT 1904
And: IN THE MATTER of an Application by Roderick Terence Kelly for an Inquiry
into an election for offices in the Amalgamated Metal Workers' and
Shipwrights' Union (1981) 56 FLR 124
No. 38 of 1981
Industrial Law - Conciliation and Arbitration

COURT

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA


NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY
INDUSTRIAL DIVISION
Sheppard J.(1)
CATCHWORDS

Industrial Law - elections for offices in registered organisation - calling of nominations - nominations called for orally from floor of branch meetings - compliance with regulations and rules of organisation - procedure not in accordance with requirements of regulations - Conciliation and Arbitration Act 1904, ss.133, 133A, 140, 141, 159, 164 and regulations 146AB to 146AE inclusive.

Conciliation and Arbitration - Registered organization - Election for offices - Inquiry - Determination of time and place for calling nominations - Advertisement calling for nominations - Requirements of - Union journal calling for nominations not fully circulated - Form of nominations - Nominations called for orally from floor of branch meetings - Not in writing - Irregularity - Discretion - Conciliation and Arbitration Act 1904 (Cth), ss. 133, 133A, 140, 141, 159, 164, 165 - Conciliation and Arbitration Regulations 1956, regs. 146AB, 146AC, 146AD, 146AE.

HEADNOTE

The applicant sought an inquiry pursuant to Pt IX of the Conciliation and Arbitration Act 1904 into an election for offices in a registered organization alleging that certain irregularities had arisen in their conduct. That was so because the procedure adopted by the returning officer provided only for the calling of nominations from the floor of the meeting. That was not a permissible method of calling for nominations.

Held: (1) Irregularities had occurred because - (a) The returning officer had not validly determined in accordance with the Conciliation and Arbitration Regulations reg. 146AC the times and dates of the commencement and close of the period for lodging nominations and the place for lodging nominations. (b) The advertisement containing details of the elections published in purported compliance with reg. 146AD was defective as it did not validly set out (i) the form in which nominations were to be made; (ii) the place for lodging nominations; (iii) the times and dates of the commencement and close of the period for lodging nominations. (c) The provisions of the organization's rules as modified by reg. 146AD (3) were not complied with in that (i) the notice in the relevant union journal informing members of the opening of nominations was not a notice in accordance with reg. 146AD (1); (ii) the distribution and circulation of that journal was not substantially as envisaged by the rules. (d) The relevant nominations which had not been made in the handwriting of the nominators were not in accordance with the requirements of the rules and of reg. 146AE (1) (a).

(2) These irregularities were irregularities within s. 4 of the Conciliation and Arbitration Act because if nominations were not called in accordance with the relevant…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kelly v Amalgamated Metal Workers' and Shipwrights' Union and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1981] FCA 207
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Kelly v Amalgamated Metal Workers' and Shipwrights' Union concerned the validity of elections held for the offices of National President, Assistant National Secretary, and National Organiser Division 2 within the union. The proceedings were brought before the Court, which was tasked with determining whether the irregularities that occurred during the elections warranted a declaration of their invalidity. The legal issues at the heart of this case involved whether the procedures followed during the union's elections adhered to the requirements set out in the Conciliation and Arbitration Act 1904 and the relevant regulations. Specifically, the Court had to examine if the calling of nominations, a critical procedural step, was conducted in accordance with the union's rules and the statutory provisions.

The Court's analysis hinged on whether the irregularities in the election procedures were substantial enough to potentially affect the outcomes. Given that the regulations and rules of the union required nominations to be called orally from the floor of branch meetings, the Court assessed whether the procedure followed during the 1980 elections met these specifications. The irregularities identified included deviations from the prescribed methods, which the Court found to be significant. These deviations potentially compromised the integrity of the election process, leading the Court to conclude that the results might have been influenced by the procedural non-compliance.

As a result of the findings, the Court declared the elections void, deeming them invalid due to the procedural irregularities. The Court ordered the Industrial Registrar to conduct new elections for the contested positions, setting specific dates for the opening and closing of nominations and stipulating that voting must commence no less than 12 weeks after the closing date. Additionally, the incumbent officers were to continue in their roles until the new elections were completed. The Court also outlined the tenure of the newly elected candidates and instructed modifications to the union's rules to reflect these changes. The decision concluded with a provision for liberty to apply, allowing for any further legal actions related to the case.

Orders

Orders of the court

THE COURT HAVING DETERMINED that irregularities have occurred in or in connection with the elections with the Amalgamated Metal Workers' and Shipwrights' Union for the offices of National President, Assistant National Secretary and National Organiser Division 2 which elections were completed on the 18th day of November 1980 AND THE COURT BEING OF OPINION having regard to such irregularities that the result of the said elections may have been affected thereby IT IS ORDERED AND DECLARED:

1.

That the said elections be and are hereby declared to be void.

2.

That the Industrial Registrar take all necessary steps to conduct an election for each of the said offices from and including the fixing of dates for the opening and closing of nominations, being 8 March, 1982, and 21 March, 1982, respectively with voting to commence not less than 12 weeks after the closing date for nominations.

3.

That until the completion of the elections hereby directed to be conducted by the Industrial Registrar, Mr. R. Scott, Mr. L. Carmichael and Mr. W. Martin continue to occupy and perform the duties of the respective offices as if they had been duly elected thereto in accordance with the rules of the organisation.

4.

That upon completion of the said elections the candidates declared elected to each of the said offices shall hold office for the period for which they would have held office if they had been elected to take up their offices in March 1981 and that the operation of the Rules of the organisation be modified accordingly.

5.

That there be liberty to apply.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case concerns elections held by the Amalgamated Metal Workers' and Shipwrights' Union for the offices of National President, Assistant National Secretary, and National Organiser Division 2. These elections took place on 18 November 1980. The unions involved are subject to the regulations and rules set out under the Conciliation and Arbitration Act 1904, specifically sections 133, 133A, 140, 141, 159, 164, and regulations 146AB to 146AE inclusive. The procedure for calling nominations for these positions required that nominations be called for orally from the floor of branch meetings. However, the court found that the procedure followed in these elections did not comply with the requirements of the regulations and rules of the organisation, leading to potential irregularities in the election process.

This case came before the court following concerns raised about the conduct of the elections for the offices within the Amalgamated Metal Workers' and Shipwrights' Union. The irregularities in the election process led to a declaration that the results of the elections may have been affected. The matter was heard by the court, which examined the procedural compliance with the relevant industrial laws and regulations. The court subsequently made findings regarding the validity of the elections and ordered steps to rectify the irregularities, including the re-conducting of the elections by the Industrial Registrar.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the elections for the offices of National President, Assistant National Secretary, and National Organiser Division 2 in the Amalgamated Metal Workers' and Shipwrights' Union complied with the requirements of the regulations and rules.
2. If the court finds non-compliance, whether the irregularities in the election process affected the outcome of the elections.
3. What orders should be made to address the irregularities and ensure a fair and lawful election process moving forward.

Held
1. The court determined that the elections for the offices of National President, Assistant National Secretary, and National Organiser Division 2 in the Amalgamated Metal Workers' and Shipwrights' Union did not comply with the requirements of the regulations and rules.
2. The court found that the irregularities in the election process may have affected the outcome of the elections.
3. The court ordered that the elections be declared void and directed the Industrial Registrar to conduct new elections, with specified dates for nominations and voting. The current officeholders were to continue in their roles until the new elections were completed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by examining the procedures followed during the elections for the offices of National President, Assistant National Secretary, and National Organiser Division 2. It noted that the calling of nominations was done orally from the floor of branch meetings, a procedure that did not align with the requirements of the regulations and rules of the union. The court relied on sections 133, 133A, 140, 141, 159, and 164 of the Conciliation and Arbitration Act 1904, as well as regulations 146AB to 146AE, which stipulated specific procedures for conducting elections in registered organisations. These provisions mandated that nominations must be called in writing, a requirement not met in this case. Consequently, the court concluded that the elections were not conducted in accordance with the necessary legal requirements, rendering them void.

The court also considered whether the irregularities affected the outcome of the elections. It reasoned that given the procedural flaws, it could not be assured that the elected candidates would have won the elections if the proper procedures had been followed. Therefore, the court concluded that the irregularities might have influenced the election results.

Finally, the court ordered the Industrial Registrar to conduct new elections for the offices in question, specifying the dates for the opening and closing of nominations and the commencement of voting. The current officeholders were to continue in their roles until the new elections were concluded, and the rules of the organisation were to be modified to reflect the terms of the new election results. The court's decision was based on the need to ensure a fair and lawful election process, adhering strictly to the legal requirements set forth in the Conciliation and Arbitration Act 1904 and the related regulations. This decision underscores the importance of procedural compliance in union elections to maintain the integrity and legitimacy of the electoral process.