Re Churchill

Link copied
Case Copied 9 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Inquiry relating to elections for offices in the United Firefighters’ Union of Australia, Victorian Branch; Re Churchill

[2001] FCA 608

INDUSTRIAL LAW – election inquiry – irregularity found – whether new election should be held – modification of rules

Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth) – s 223(1)(c)

Kelly v Amalgamated Metal Workers’ and Shipwrights’ Union (1981) 56 FLR 124 not followed

IN THE MATTER OF AN INQUIRY RELATING TO ELECTIONS FOR OFFICES IN THE UNITED FIREFIGHERS’ UNION OF AUSTRALIA, VICTORIAN BRANCH

V 687 of 2000

FINKELSTEIN J
MELBOURNE
25 MAY 2001


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

V 687 of 2000

IN THE MATTER OF AN INQUIRY RELATING TO ELECTIONS FOR OFFICES IN THE UNITED FIREFIGHERS’ UNION OF AUSTRALIA, VICTORIAN BRANCH

JUDGE:

FINKELSTEIN J

DATE OF ORDER:

25 MAY 2001

WHERE MADE:

MELBOURNE

THE COURT FINDS that an irregularity has happened in relation to the election of:

(a)John Fowler to the position of “Branch Committee of Management/ Firefighter/MFESB” on the Victorian Branch Committee of Management of the United Firefighters’ Union of Australia;

(b)Dean Gould to the position of “Branch Committee of Management/Officer/ MFESB” on the Victorian Branch Committee of Management of the United Firefighters’ Union of Australia;

(c)Dave Hamilton, Graeme Kellett and Danny Ward to the respective positions of “Branch Trustees” of the Victorian Branch Committee of Management of the United Firefighters’ Union of Australia (“the said positions”).

THE COURT DECLARES that the election in respect of the said positions is void and of no effect.

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

(a)Save for the requirement of calling for fresh nominations for the said positions, a new election be held in respect of the said positions.

(b)The present holders of the said positions continue to hold such office until a declaration of the results of the new election.

THE COURT DIRECTS the Industrial Registrar to make arrangements to conduct a fresh election in respect of the said positions, there being no requirement to call for fresh nominations therefor.

Note:    Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

V 687 of 2000

IN THE MATTER OF AN INQUIRY RELATING TO ELECTIONS FOR OFFICES IN THE UNITED FIREFIGHERS’ UNION OF AUSTRALIA, VICTORIAN BRANCH

JUDGE:

FINKELSTEIN J

DATE:

25 MAY 2001

PLACE:

MELBOURNE

SUPPLEMENTARY REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

  1. On the application of Mr Churchill I held an inquiry under s 219 of the Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth) to determine whether irregularities had happened in relation to the election for a number of offices in the United Firefighters’ Union of Australia, Victorian Branch. I delivered judgment on 26 April 2001, holding that there had been an irregularity, namely that votes had been counted in accordance with a system of preferential voting chosen by the electoral official, who had no power to impose that system. I said that I would declare the elections void and order there be new elections. However, because it…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Re Churchill and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] FCA 608
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case arose from an application by Mr Churchill for an inquiry into the elections for certain offices in the United Firefighters’ Union of Australia, Victorian Branch. The Federal Court of Australia was required to determine whether irregularities had occurred in the election process, and if so, what orders should be made to rectify the situation. The court found that an irregularity had indeed occurred, as votes were counted using a preferential voting system chosen by the electoral official, despite the official lacking the authority to impose such a system. The court further determined that while the chosen system was democratic and reasonable, it was not appropriate to assume that it would have been accepted by the members had they been aware of the possible alternatives.

The court considered the request by the members of the committee of the Victorian Branch of the union to reconsider its proposed orders, particularly in light of the recent amendment to the union's rules to include a voting system similar to the one chosen by the electoral official. The court found that despite the amendment, it was not appropriate to impose a system of voting that was not the one members believed would be employed in the election. The court also found that it did not have the power to modify the union's rules to shorten the term of office for the newly elected members, as such a modification would not be incidental or supplementary to the other orders made.

Ultimately, the court found that an irregularity had happened in relation to the election of certain positions, declared the election void and of no effect, and ordered a new election to be held for those positions. The present holders of the said positions were to continue to hold office until the declaration of the results of the new election. The court also directed the Industrial Registrar to make arrangements to conduct a fresh election in respect of the said positions, without the requirement to call for fresh nominations.

Background

Background to the litigation

An inquiry was held under section 219 of the Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth) to determine whether irregularities had occurred in the election for various offices within the United Firefighters' Union of Australia, Victorian Branch. The inquiry found that an irregularity had indeed occurred, as votes were counted using a preferential voting system selected by the electoral official, who lacked the authority to impose such a system. The irregularity affected the election of John Fowler, Dean Gould, Dave Hamilton, Graeme Kellett, and Danny Ward to their respective positions. The court declared these elections void and of no effect. The current officeholders were to continue in their roles until new elections were held.

The matter came before the Federal Court of Australia under the Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth). An initial judgment was delivered on 26 April 2001, declaring the elections void and ordering new elections. The current officeholders then applied to reconsider the orders, arguing that new elections should not be held as the union's rules had been amended to permit the same voting system used by the electoral official. The court considered the application and supplementary reasons were provided on 25 May 2001.

Decision

Reasons for decision

FINKELSTEIN J
Issues
1. Whether the court should exercise its discretion to withhold relief after finding an irregularity that has affected the result of an election.
2. Whether the court has the power to modify the union's rules to shorten the term of office for the new elections.
3. Whether the court should consider the union's recent rule amendments in determining the appropriate orders to be made.

Held
1. The court found that it should not exercise its discretion to withhold relief after finding an irregularity that has affected the result of an election. The court concluded that withholding relief would be inappropriate in this case as it was not clear that a new election would not produce a different result.
2. The court held that it does not have the power to modify the union's rules to shorten the term of office for the new elections. The court found that the power to modify union rules is limited to enabling a new election to be held, permitting a step in relation to an election to be taken again, or permitting an uncompleted step in an election to be taken.
3. The court decided not to consider the union's recent rule amendments in determining the appropriate orders to be made. The court found that the union's rules could not be treated as evidence in the inquiry and that reopening the inquiry would result in re-arguing the case.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: FINKELSTEIN J

The court began by considering whether it should exercise its discretion to withhold relief after finding an irregularity that had affected the result of an election. While the court acknowledged that such a discretion exists, it concluded that it should rarely be exercised. In this case, the court found that withholding relief would be inappropriate as it was not clear that a new election would not produce a different result. The court also found that imposing a system of voting that was not the system members believed would be employed in the election was not proper.

The court then addressed whether it had the power to modify the union's rules to shorten the term of office for the new elections. The court found that the power to modify union rules is limited to enabling a new election to be held, permitting a step in relation to an election to be taken again, or permitting an uncompleted step in an election to be taken. The court concluded that the order sought by the committee members was of a different character altogether and therefore outside the scope of the court's power.

Finally, the court considered whether it should take into account the union's recent rule amendments in determining the appropriate orders to be made. The court found that the union's rules could not be treated as evidence in the inquiry and that reopening the inquiry would result in re-arguing the case. The court decided not to consider the union's recent rule amendments in determining the appropriate orders to be made.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that the court has a discretion to withhold relief after finding an irregularity that has affected the result of an election, but this discretion should rarely be exercised. The court also has limited power to modify union rules, which can only be exercised to enable a new election to be held, permit a step in relation to an election to be taken again, or permit an uncompleted step in an election to be taken. The court departed from prior authority in finding that it did not have the power to modify the union's rules to shorten the term of office for the new elections.