Kaur v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship

Link copied
Case Copied 38 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

(DIVISION 2)

Kaur v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2025] FedCFamC2G 1608

File number(s): MLG 3345 of 2020
Judgment of: JUDGE CORBETT
Date of judgment: 3 October 2025
Catchwords: MIGRATION - Skilled Nominated (Permanent) (Subclass 190) visa – Application for judicial review – Typographical errors in Tribunal reasons – Alleged failure to discharge statutory task of review – Unreasonable decision making – Bias – Application dismissed.
Legislation: Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth) cls 190.216, 190.216(3), 190.312, 4020(1), 4020(4), Schs 2, 4
Cases cited: Applicant WAEE v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs (2003) 75 ALD 630
CCC v Minister for Immigration [2001] FCA 682
CQG15 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (2016) 253 FCR 496
CRI026 v Republic of Nauru (2018) 355 ALR 216; [2018] HCA 19
Dranichnikov v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2003] HCA 26
Ebner v Official Trustee in Bankruptcy [2000] HCA 63; (2000) 205 CLR 337
Hossain v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] HCA 34
LPDT v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2024] HCA 12; (2024) 98 ALJR 610
Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v Stretton [2016] FCAFC 11
Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v SZSRS [2014] FCAFC 16
Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v SZMDS [2010] HCA 16
Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v SZRKT (2013) 212 FCR 99
Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs v Wu Shan Liang (1996) 185 CLR 259
Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Eshetu [1999] HCA 21
Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Jia (2001) 205 CLR 507
Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Yusuf (2001) 206 CLR 323
MZAPC v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2021] HCA 17
Nadesan v Minister for Immigration [2013] FMCA 152
Refugee Review Tribunal, Re; Ex parte H [2001] HCA 28
S14/2002 v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2003] FCA 1153
SBAN v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2002] FCA 591
SCAA v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2002] FCA 668
Sharma v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCCA 2152
Singh v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs [1996] FCA 902
VFAB v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs (2003) 131 FCR 102
VFAB v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2003] FCA 872
WABC of 2002 v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2002] FCAFC 286
Division: Division 2 General Federal Law
Number of paragraphs: 77
Date of last submission/s: 25 September 2025
Date of hearing: 21 August 2025 and 25 September 2025
Place: Melbourne
Solicitor for the Applicants Mr T Meehan, Meehan Legal
Solicitor for the Respondents Ms K Petrovski, Sparke Helmore Lawyers

ORDERS

MLG 3345 of 2020

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA (DIVISION 2)

BETWEEN:

MANDEEP KAUR

First Applicant

ARMINDER SINGH AULAKH

Second Applicant

AND:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION, CITIZENSHIP, MIGRANT SERVICES AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS

First Respondent

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kaur v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] FedCFamC2G 1608
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Kaur and another v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship was a judicial review application filed in the Federal Court of Australia challenging the decision of the Migration Review Tribunal (MRT) to dismiss the applicants' application for a Skilled Nominated (Permanent) (Subclass 190) visa. The applicants, citizens of India, had applied for the visa with the assistance of a migration agent. The applicants argued that the MRT had failed to properly consider their evidence, had made significant errors in its reasons, and had displayed bias in reaching its decision.

The primary legal issues before the Court were whether the Tribunal had failed to properly consider the applicants' evidence, had made errors in its reasons, and whether those errors were so significant as to amount to a failure to discharge its statutory task of review. Additionally, the Court had to consider whether the Tribunal's conduct gave rise to a reasonable apprehension of bias.

The Court found that while the Tribunal had made some unfortunate typographical errors and had not thoroughly considered all the evidence, these errors were not so significant as to render the Tribunal's decision invalid. The Court noted that the Tribunal had considered the key evidence and had reached a finding that was open on the evidence. The Court also found that there was no reasonable apprehension of bias. The Tribunal had not displayed any conduct that would lead a fair-minded observer to conclude that it was biased. The Court concluded that the Tribunal had properly discharged its statutory task of reviewing the delegate's decision.

In light of the above, the Court dismissed the application for judicial review. The Court found that the Tribunal's decision was lawful and that the applicants had not established any grounds for the Court to intervene. The Court affirmed the decision of the MRT to dismiss the applicants' visa application.

Background

Background to the litigation

Reference in these reasons to ‘CB’ pages are references to the Court Book prepared for this proceeding that was tendered and admitted as evidence at the hearing and designated exhibit ‘R1’.BACKGROUND The applicants are citizens of India and first arrived in Australia in 2009 on a Student visa (CB 75-7). On 11 July 2017, the first applicant applied for the visa with the assistance of a migration agent. The applicant’s husband (second applicant) was a secondary applicant for the visa and a migrating member of the family unit (CB 6). The first applicant had previously been refused a subclass 457 visa (CB 78). On 17 September 2018, the Department sent the applicants a request for further information letter. The letter requested that the applicants provide evidence to satisfy the Public Interest Criterion (PIC), including national police checks, personal particulars for character assessment (Form 80) and immigration health examinations (CB 282-293). On 9 October 2018, the applicants undertook the required health examinations requested by the Department on 17 September 2018 (CB 393). Prior to the examination, a medical history questionnaire is required to be provided. Departmental records indicated that the second applicant answered ‘no’ to all medical history questions and was “recommended clear” by the Commonwealth physician on 11 October 2018. Relevantly, the second applicant answered “no” to the question directed to alcohol or drug dependence and ‘no’ to the question whether he was taking any prescribed pills or medication. On 12 October 2018, the applicants’ representative requested further time to provide police checks however provided; County Court of Victoria appeal results, a letter from the first applicant (CB 304), two reference letters regarding the second applicant’s character (CB 305, 306), medical documents, and completed Form 80’s for the applicants (CB 294-352, 314-331, 332-349). The County Court of Victoria appeal results detailed that the second applicant had been sentenced to a two-year community corrections order on 27 September 2018. The order directed the second applicant to undergo assessment and treatment for mental health, drug abuse and dependency as a result of his conviction for multiple driving offences (driving unregistered vehicle, driving with a suspended/disqualified license, theft of motor vehicle) and possession of illicit substances offences. On 17 October 2018, the second applicant provided a letter to the Department containing an explanation of his history of offending, a pharmacy collection record for methadone treatment and a community service attendance log (CB 356-366). The letter sought to explain that his offending was due to his loss of employment as a Truck Driver, financial difficulties, enduring pain from back and knee surgery in 2009 and concomitant mental health issues (CB 356-9). On 4 December 2018, the Department requested further evidence of the second applicant’s character (CB 367-373). On 11 December 2018, the applicants’ representative provided further documents regarding the second applicant’s community corrections order, offence sheet and current prescriptions for methadone (CB 374-389).

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In response to the submissions made on behalf of the Minister, Mr Meehan for the applicants submitted that the records relating to the second applicant’s offending and addiction to illicit substances were provided because they were relevant to address character matters only, not any medical condition and it was not his clients’ intention to mislead the Minister rather it was a simple and inadvertent mistake that should be excused. Further, on his instructions the second applicant was prescribed methadone syrup for pain relief and addiction. There was no attempt to conceal those matters and it was incumbent on the Tribunal to properly address the explanation for providing inaccurate information when completing the medical questionnaire.FURTHER EVIDENCE AND SUBMISSIONS At the conclusion of the hearing on 21 August 2025, the Court made orders for the applicants’ solicitor to deliver a copy of the transcript to the solicitors for the Minister. The Court also ordered that the Minister indicate whether there is any objection to the transcript being admitted into evidence, and if so, for both parties to file and serve any further written submissions regarding the relevance of the transcript to the issues to be determined. A copy of the transcript was produced as ordered and no objection was taken by the Minister to the Court receiving the transcript as evidence. The proceeding was listed for mention before the Court on 24 September 2025 to allow the parties to address the relevance of the transcript and make further submissions. The transcript was formally tendered on behalf of the applicants and marked exhibit ‘A1’. The applicant also tendered a bundle of documents which were marked exhibit ‘A2’ which were said to be the documents that the Tribunal member was “downloading” and “trying to open” at the Tribunal hearing. These were the documents which the applicants say the Tribunal failed to consider when making the Decision. It was submitted that these were important documents and the omission to properly consider them indicated the Tribunal’s want of engagement with the issues under review. The documents included a submission prepared by the applicants’ migration agent dated 8 August 2022. The remaining documents in the bundle were documents in the Court Book obtained from the Tribunal file. When asked if the transcript and bundle of documents were relied on to support the allegation of apprehended or actual bias, Mr Meehan was reluctant to categorise either as evidence of bias. Instead, Mr Meehan relied on the transcript and documents to support the submission that the Tribunal member could not have considered these documents during the short period that the Tribunal member was attempting to “download” the documents (A1 at 00:56:57) and the delivery of the oral reasons for decision which occurred (A1 at 1:00:18). This reflected predetermination of the evidence and a failure to afford a fair hearing by the Tribunal. Ms Petrovski on behalf of the Minister submitted that there was no dispute that the submissions dated 8 August 2020 were included in the Tribunal file but were inexplicably not included in the Court Book. It appears that another document that resembles a submission has been reproduced at CB 477–488. However, paragraphs [17]-[20] of the Decision and the transcript of the oral reasons reflect that the Tribunal did consider the documents that were referred to in the transcript and downloaded, including the submission and the statements of both the first and second applicants.CONSIDERATION

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 25 August 2020, the Tribunal published its written reasons for decision (CB 564-571) (Decision).TRIBUNAL DECISION In the Decision, the Tribunal set out the background facts relevant to the application, the criteria for the grant of the visa and the requirements of PIC 4020. The Tribunal found that the second applicant provided false and misleading answers to an officer of the Commonwealth regarding his drug addiction and medical history. The Tribunal considered the evidence of the second applicant where he explained why he provided incorrect answers, namely that he was rushed and “to get the matter over quickly, I just signed no to everything” (CB 568-570 [1]-[22]). The Tribunal found it was reasonable to expect that the second applicant would be aware of his recent medical treatment and history, and did not accept the second applicant’s explanation that he did not realise that he was providing wrong information, or that he did not intentionally lie or mislead the medical officer in completing his health declaration (CB 570 [22]-[23]). The Tribunal found the secondary applicant’s incorrect responses were a deliberate attempt to not disclose his drug dependency and found there was an element of purposeful falsity in his completion of the form which constituted the provision of false and misleading information in a material particular (CB 570 [24]-[25]). The Tribunal turned to consider whether to waive the PIC 4020 criteria. The Tribunal found, on the basis of the applicants’ representative’s submissions to the Tribunal, that there were no circumstances that would lead to the grant of a waiver of the criteria (CB 570 [27]). The Tribunal had regard to the applicants’ evidence that the secondary applicant made an innocent mistake, that he had trouble with his English, and wanted a second chance (CB 570-571 [28]-[31]). The Tribunal found that the second applicant had breached PIC 4020, that he did not satisfy cl 190.312, and so the first applicant did not satisfy cl 190.216 of Sch 2 to the Regulations, which required each member of the family unit to meet PIC 4020. The Tribunal affirmed the decision on review (CB 571 [32]-[34]).PROCEEDINGS IN THIS COURT By amended application filed on 18 July 2025, the applicant seeks judicial review of the Decision. The amended application raises six grounds of review as follows:GROUND 1:(1)The Tribunal got my husband’s name wrong throughout the decisionParticulars:(a)On the first page of the decision, the Tribunal incorrectly identified my husband as “Mr Bansal Singh Aulakh” when his correct legal name is “Arminder Singh Aulakh”.(b)My husband’s correct name “Arminder Singh Aulakh" is clearly written in:(i)The original government decision that refused our visas on 9 September 2019(ii)All our visa application documents(iii)All the statements and documents we provided to the Tribunal(iv)Every single piece of evidence in our case(c)This is not just a small typing mistake. The Tribunal was supposed to be deciding out case, but they could not even get my husband’s name right. This makes us question whether they were properly considering our actual case or someone else’s.GROUND 2:(2)The Tribunal Got Important Dates WrongParticulars(a) In paragraph 19 of their decision, the Tribunal said my husband’s important statement was “dated 29 March 2018” but this is completely wrong – it was actually dated 29 March 2019.(b) They got the year wrong by a whole year. This shows:(i) They were not carefully reading our evidence(ii)They did not understand when things happened in our case(iii)They were not paying proper attention to important documents(c) Getting this date right was important because:(i)It shows when my husband was trying to explain what happened(ii)It shows his state of mind after getting out of prison(iii)It shows the timing of everything that happened to usGROUND 3:(3)The Tribunal was confused about the lawParticulars(a) The Tribunal kept missing up the legal rules they were supposed to apply, sometimes calling it “PIC 4020” and other times calling it “PICD 4005” when talking about the same thing.(b) In paragraph 24, they wrote “PICD 4005 under clause 190.312” when they should have written “PIC 4020”.(c) This confusion shows they did not properly understand the law they were supposed to apply to our case.GROUND 4:(4)The Tribunal did not give us a fair hearingParticulars(a) The Tribunal did not give us a fair chance to explain our side and ignored important evidence that supported us.(b) In paragraph 23, the Tribunal said: “I do not accept your explanation that you did not realise that you were providing wrong information” but they did not properly consider all the strong evidence we provided showing it was an honest mistake.(c) The Tribunal ignored or did not properly consider:(i) The doctor’s report from Dr John Sherman confirming my husband need the medication for medical reasons(ii) The psychologist’s report from Ms Shagufta Riaz about my husband’s mental health(iii) Evidence that my husband was following all his court orders properly(iv)Proof that my husband was getting treatment and trying to get better(v)My husband’s detailed explanation of what really happened(d)In paragraph 22, the Tribunal had already made up their mind before properly considering our evidence. They said they “do not accept” my husband’s explanation about being rushed without fairly weighing all the evidence of his mental state and difficult circumstances.(e)The Tribunal’s approach showed they had a closed mind and were not willing to fairly consider that it was an honest mistake.GROUND 5:(5)The Tribunal’s decision makes no logical sense.Particulars:(a) No reasonable person looking at all our evidence could have reached the same conclusion as the Tribunal. Their decision ignores obvious facts and contradicts itself.(b)The Tribunal’s rejection of our explanation that it was an honest mistake makes no sense given all the evidence showing:(i) My husband was severely mentally distressed after 37 days in prison(ii) He was released only 10 days before the medical exam(iii) A professional psychologist confirmed his poor mental state(iv) He has documented problems with English and needed an interpreter at the hearing(v) Even the Tribunal admitted the medical centre was “very busy” and stressful(c) The Tribunal's reasoning contradicts itself because they:(i) Admitted all these problems existed in paragraphs 18 and 22(ii) Then completely dismissed them in paragraph 23 without explaining why(iii) Failed to explain how these serious problems were not enough to cause an honest mistake(d) The Tribunal ignored the obvious fact that my husband had no reason to lie when he had already told the government everything about his drug problems and criminal history in other documents.(e) It makes no sense that someone would try to hide something they had already openly disclosed in their official statement to the government.(f) In paragraph 30, the Tribunal acknowledged my husband's problems were •drug related• but failed to see how this supported our explanation, since he had always been open about his drug problems.GROUND 6:(6)The Tribunal’s conduct and reasoning give rise to a reasonable apprehension of biasParticulars:(a) A fair-minded observer would reasonably apprehend that the Tribunal did not bring an impartial mind to the resolution of our case. This is evident through:(i) The Tribunal's immediate dismissal of compelling evidence without proper engagement or consideration;(ii) A clear pattern of errors that indicate a lack of attention and care in dealing with our matter;(iii) The Tribunal's language and overall approach, which appeared prejudged;(iv) The Member's failure to adequately prepare for the hearing.(b) The Tribunal came to the hearing unprepared and failed to review key documents:(i) Throughout the hearing, the Member repeatedly said he was "downloading" or "trying to open" documents that had already been submitted well in advance;(ii) At approximately 53:16-57:04 of the hearing recording, when Mr Bansal attempted to discuss important documents, the Member confirmed the documents were "currently downloading" and he was still "trying to open” them;(iii) Even documents submitted prior to the hearing-had not been reviewed by the Member;(iv) This suggests the outcome may have been predetermined, as evidence was not properly read or considered.(7)The Tribunal demonstrated actual bias through its conduct:(a) The Member got my husband's name wrong In the decision, referring to him as “Bansal Singh Aulakh” instead of Arminder Singh Aulakh”, which suggests the Tribunal was not properly engaged with the specific details of our case;(b) The decision contains multiple factual errors, including incorrect dates and legal references, reflecting a careless and dismissive approach;(c) The Tribunal made dismissive comments about our explanations without fair consideration, as evident In the hearing transcript where the Member repeatedly interrupted the secondary applicant and focused disproportionately on his criminal history rather than the specific circumstances of the medical declaration.(8)The Tribunal failed to consider our evidence fairly and with an open mind:(a) In paragraph 23, our explanation was immediately rejected without being properly weighed;(b) While mitigating factors were acknowledged in paragraphs 18 and 22, they were dismissed without proper reasoning;(c) There was a clear pattern of accepting adverse material while unfairly rejecting supporting evidence;(d) Adverse findings were made in relation to documents the Member himself admitted had not been read.(9)The Tribunal relied on irrelevant and prejudicial considerations:(a) In paragraph 30, the focus shifted to criminal history, rather than the specific question of whether the medical declaration was an innocent mistake;(b) There was undue emphasis on past drug use, which appears to have prejudiced the Tribunal's assessment of credibility;(c) The Tribunal failed to distinguish between historical conduct and the actual issues under review.(10) The cumulative effect of these issues would lead a fair-minded observer to conclude that:(a) The Tribunal had already made up its mind before considering our evidence;(b) Our explanations were never seriously going to be considered;(c) There was an underlying bias against applicants with criminal histories;(d) The hearing was treated as a formality rather than a genuine opportunity for review.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Ms Petrovski on behalf of the Minister submitted that there was no dispute that the submissions dated 8 August 2020 were included in the Tribunal file but were inexplicably not included in the Court Book. It appears that another document that resembles a submission has been reproduced at CB 477–488. However, paragraphs [17]-[20] of the Decision and the transcript of the oral reasons reflect that the Tribunal did consider the documents that were referred to in the transcript and downloaded, including the submission and the statements of both the first and second applicants.CONSIDERATION The function of this Court is to review the Decision and determine if the Tribunal has fallen into error by failing to conduct the statutory task of reviewing the delegate’s decision according to law. In the Decision the Tribunal identified the issue to be determined as whether the applicants satisfied the requirements of reg 190.216 (CB 568 [4]). One of the requirements of the regulations was whether the applicant and each member of the applicant’s family satisfied PIC 4020 contained in cl 4020 of Sch 4 of the Regulations. Subclause 4020(1) requires that there is no evidence before the Minister that the applicant has given, or caused to be given, to the Minister, an officer or a Medical Officer of the Commonwealth a bogus document or information that is false or misleading in a material particular in relation to the application for the visa (reg 4020(1)). The second applicant gave false and misleading information to a Medical Officer of the Commonwealth in relation to the application for the visa. The Tribunal found that the second applicant breached PIC 4020 (CB 570 [25], [26]). The Tribunal then found (because it was conceded) that there were no grounds upon which the Tribunal or the Minister could waive the breach (cl 4020(4) (CB 570 [27]). Having found that the second applicant was in breach of PIC 4020, the only finding available to the Tribunal was that the applicants’ application for the visa did not satisfy reg 190.216(3) of the Regulations (CB 571 [32]). Therefore, the Tribunal was required to affirm the decision under review where the delegate reached the same conclusion. In finding that there was a failure to satisfy reg 190.216(3), the Tribunal considered the claim made by the second applicant that the misleading information provided to the Medical Officer of the Commonwealth in the medical questionnaire, was innocently made or inadvertent due to stress and anxiety (CB 569-570 [18], [19], [20], [21] and [22]). The Tribunal did not accept this claim and held that the second applicant knew or ought to have known that the medical questionnaire was an important document that should not be misleading in the answers given (CB 570 [23], [24]). This was a finding that was open on the evidence.Errors The typographical errors made by the Tribunal were unfortunate and reflect an omission to proofread the written reasons. However, the errors were not so material as to render the findings and conclusions reached as jurisdictional (see CRI026 at [57] per Kiefel CJ, Gageler and Nettle JJ and S14/2002 v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2003] FCA 1153 at [34] per Moore J). The Tribunal clearly identified the issue to be determined as a relatively simple one and considered the evidence of a failure to satisfy the regulations, and the absence of circumstances, that may have invoked the limited circumstances in which the Minister and Tribunal may waive a breach of PIC 4020. The typographical error in relation to the second applicant’s name on the first page of the Decision did not detract from the reasoning when read as a whole. The transcript that was tendered on behalf of the applicants also shows that there was no error by the Tribunal in identifying the correct name of the second applicant at the time of the hearing and in the ex tempore reasons given at the conclusion of the hearing.