S14/2002 v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural & Indigenous Affairs

Link copied
Case Copied 37 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

S14/2003 v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural & Indigenous Affairs [2003] FCA 1153

CORRIGENDUM

S14/2003 V MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & MULTICULTURAL & INDIGENOUS AFFAIRS

N 364 of 2003

MOORE J
22 OCTOBER 2003 (CORRIGENDUM 3 FEBRUARY 2004)
SYDNEY

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

 N 364 OF 2003

BETWEEN:

S14 OF 2003

AND:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND MULTICULTURAL AND INDIGENOUS AFFAIRS

JUDGE:

MOORE J

DATE:

22 OCTOBER 2003

PLACE:

SYDNEY

CORRIGENDUM

  1. The Applicant’s name shown on the cover sheet, the orders page, and the first page of reasons should read S14/2002, not S14/2003.

I certify that the preceding one (1) paragraph
is a true copy of the Corrigendum to
the Reasons for Judgment of his Honour
Justice Moore




Associate:

Date:              3 February 2004


FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

S14/2003 v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural & Indigenous Affairs [2003] FCA 1153

PRACTICE & PROCEDURE – typographical error in reasons of Tribunal – whether inference can be drawn as to conclusions of Tribunal – where no corrigendum issued – where Tribunal member not called to give evidence.

MIGRATION – failure to consider substance of claims – Tribunal did not address applicant’s membership of social groups – whether Tribunal had dealt with all “essential integers” of the applicant’s claims.

WORDS & PHRASES – ‘plausible’

Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs v Yusuf (2001) 206 CLR 323 referred to
Long v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural & Indigenous Affairs [2003] FCAFC 218 referred to
Minister for Immigration & Ethnic Affairs v Wu Shan Liang (1996) 185 CLR 259 referred to
Re Australian Insurance Employees Union; Ex parte Academy Insurance Pty Ltd (1988) 78 ALR 466 discussed
Vietnam Veteran’s Association of Australia New South Wales Branch Inc v Specialist Medical Review Council (2002) 69 ALD 553 referred to
Secretary of the Department of Family & Community Services v Sammut (1999) 58 ALD 691 discussed
Muin v Refugee Review Tribunal & Ors (2002) 190 ALR 601 discussed
SCAL v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural & Indigenous Affairs [2003] FCA 548 referred to SGBB v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural & Indigenous Affairs (2003) 199 ALR 364 referred to
Paul v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs (2001) 113 FCR 396 discussed
El Merhabi v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs (2000) 96 FCR 375 referred to
Re Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs; Ex parte Durairajasingham (2000) 168 ALR 407 referred to
Thevendram v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs (2000) 182 ALR referred to
W148/00A v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs (2001) 185 ALR referred to
W321/01A v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2002] FCA 210 referred to
Syan v Refugee Review Tribunal (1995) 61 FCR 284 referred to
Aras v Minister for Immigration & Ethnic Affairs (1998) 50 ALD 797 referred to
Al-Amidi v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs (2000) 177 ALR 506 referred to
Randhawa v Minister for Immigration, Local Government & Ethnic Affairs (1994) 52 FCR 437 referred to
X…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read S14/2002 v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural & Indige... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2003] FCA 1153
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case, S14/2002 v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural & Indigenous Affairs, concerns an appeal against a decision of the Refugee Review Tribunal (RRT) which found that the applicant, a citizen of Indonesia, was not a person to whom Australia had protection obligations under the Convention Relating to the Status of Refugees. The applicant sought to be granted a protection visa, which requires the Minister for Immigration to be satisfied that the applicant is a refugee. The RRT considered the applicant’s claims and evidence, including documentation and testimony, and ultimately determined that the applicant did not meet the criteria for a protection visa. The central legal issues in this case were whether the RRT correctly interpreted the evidence and applied the relevant legal standards in making its determination. Specifically, the court had to consider whether the RRT erred in its interpretation of the evidence, particularly in relation to the safety of the applicant in Indonesia and the accuracy of the Tribunal's recording of its reasons.

The Federal Court held that the RRT had correctly interpreted the evidence and applied the relevant legal standards. The court found that the RRT had not erred in its interpretation of the evidence, particularly in relation to the safety of the applicant in Indonesia. The court also found that, despite a potential error in the transcription of the RRT's reasons, it was clear from the context of the reasons as a whole that the RRT had concluded that Acehnese people were not targeted in Jakarta. The court held that the RRT's decision was not affected by any potential error in the transcription of its reasons. The court further found that the RRT had not denied the applicant procedural fairness by failing to provide him with certain documents or by considering documents that were not in English without translations. The court held that the RRT's decision was lawful and that the application for judicial review should be dismissed.

In light of the above findings, the court dismissed the applicant's appeal and ordered that the applicant pay the respondent's costs. This outcome reinforces the principle that the reasons for decision of administrative bodies such as the RRT must be read as a whole, and that errors in the transcription of reasons do not necessarily render a decision unlawful if the correct conclusions can be inferred from the context of the reasons as a whole.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application be dismissed.

2. The applicant pay the respondent’s costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

The criterion for the grant of such a visa is, subject to subd AL of Div 3 of the Act, that the applicant is a person to whom Australia has protection obligations under the Convention Relating to the Status of Refugees of 28 July 1951 as amended by the Protocol Relating to the Status of Refugees of 31 January 1967 (“the Convention”).Background facts The following are the claims of the applicant drawn from his visa application, the submission that accompanied that application (written by a migration agent acting for the applicant) and his oral evidence before the Tribunal. In his application, the applicant stated that he was born on 27 December 1967 in Jakarta, Indonesia, although the accompanying submission said he was born in the village of Lingkok, Kecamatan Mutiara in Aceh, Indonesia. The submission also stated that in Aceh he was known by a different name to the one stated on the application. At the Tribunal hearing, the applicant submitted that the name he was known by in Aceh (“the Aceh name”) was his true identity, and the name he had used throughout the application process was an alias (“the Jakarta name”). An Indonesian identity card was produced at the hearing, listing the applicant’s Aceh name, the date of birth as 5 November 1967, and the birthplace as Pidie, Aceh. The applicant’s Indonesian passport is in his Jakarta name. The applicant went to Jakarta to study at Universita Muhammadiyah and in 1996 gained a Bachelor of Engineering degree. The applicant was enrolled in university under his Aceh name. He lived in Jakarta from 1986 to 1998 (although some documentation suggests he arrived in 1991), working as a self-employed taxi driver from 1995 until 1998 when he left to live in Aceh, which at that time was safe. He lived there until 2000. He is married and his wife lives in Indonesia. He has one child who was born after the applicant arrived in Australia. He has no living parents. He has four brothers, three of whom live in Indonesia and one whose location he does not know. The applicant claimed that in 1999 the Indonesian military (Tentara Nasional Indonesia (“TNI”)) invaded Aceh to look for Free Aceh Movement (“GAM”) activists. The TNI killed, raped and seized the belongings of the Acehnese people. As a result, Acehnese people from Tangse in Pidie sought refuge in Kecamatan Mutiara. In 1999, he and other young people from Kecamatan Mutiara formed a humanitarian organisation to help these people (“the organisation”) and he was appointed fundraiser of the organisation. He made several trips to Jakarta from Aceh to raise funds. At the hearing the applicant explained that although he was not a member of GAM, many others in the organisation were, and he was present at some local GAM meetings. In 1999 two of his friends, also members of the organisation were kidnapped by BRIMOB (special forces of the Indonesian Police/anti-riot police, Police Mobile Brigade (Brigade Mobil, Brimob)). In August 1999 his brother went to Medan with a friend, carrying letters given to him by the applicant asking for financial support for the refugees. His brother was arrested in Medan and never returned.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

MOORE J
At the hearing before the Tribunal the applicant said that he would not be safe in Jakarta or Aceh. He said he would not feel safe in Jakarta because although when he was in Jakarta he is “not in Aceh”, his brother had been kidnapped in Medan, there had been an explosion at a place where he had been living in Jakarta and he had reason to believe Acehnese people in Jakarta had been taken away. He said he had been told by a friend who had attended a meeting held by an Acehnese leader in Australia that since Megawati Soekarnoputri had come to power many Acehnese in the Pasai Ming Gel area of Jakarta had been taken away.The Tribunal’s Decision The Tribunal’s reasons began with a discussion of the relevant legislation and what is comprehended by the definition of “refugee” in Article 1A(2) of the Convention. The Tribunal then discussed the applicant’s claims in a section of its reasons entitled “Claims and Evidence”. In this section the Tribunal recorded the sources of the material before it, including the applicant’s application for the protection visa and the submission that accompanied it. It set out an extract of a background political history of Aceh provided by the US Committee for Refugees. It then listed five documents before it at the hearing, none of which had been translated into English. These were:a)an internet media download about an explosion that had occurred at 4:30pm on 10 May 2001 in a boarding house in South Jakarta which housed Acehnese students. The applicant said he lived in that house in 1998, and he had stayed in that same house for a few days in 2000 when he had returned to Jakarta.b)a newspaper article regarding the same event.c)an Indonesian Identification (“ID”) card under the applicant’s Aceh name. The details on his ID card indicted he was born in Pidie on 5 November 1967. The ID card was issued in Guntur, South Jakarta on 5 November 2000 and valid till 5 November 2003. (The applicant claimed he had been compelled to use an alias for the purpose of getting a passport because he feared he would not have been able to leave the country had he used his own name.)d)a set of university documents under the applicant’s Aceh name.e)a letter in Indonesian from “Sarifuddin”, who the applicant claimed was his brother, advising him, amongst other things, not to come back because he was wanted by the TNI. The rest of this section of the Tribunal’s reasons took a particular form. It constituted a record, in indirect speech, of questions the Tribunal had asked, comments it had made to the applicant at the hearing and a record of the answers and explanations of the applicant (as understood by the Tribunal). In some instances, the Tribunal summarised the response of the applicant without recording the question. However, by and large, this section would read as a conversation or interrogation if put into direct speech. Many of the questions of the Tribunal, as recorded, were directed to the content of the five documents, leading to questions on other matters. The issues touched on (as recorded), included the May 2001 bombing, the time the applicant had spent in Jakarta, the two different names the applicant is known by, the information in his application for a protection visa and the submission that accompanied it, his University documents and the contents of the letter from his brother.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: MOORE J

The fourth issue involved two matters said to concern procedural fairness. The first related to a claim that the Tribunal denied the applicant procedural fairness by failing to provide to the applicant, before making its determination, the Reuters article referred to earlier and affording the applicant an opportunity to comment and adduce evidence in relation to its contents. The second related to the consideration of documents by the Tribunal which were not in English without it having obtained translations.Consideration The passage of the Tribunal’s reasons quoted at [19] above is pivotal to some issues raised by the applicant. There is a real possibility that the word “not” has accidentally been omitted from the final sentence in the first paragraph. Counsel for the applicant contended it had not been, counsel for the Minister contended to the contrary. No corrigendum has apparently been issued. It is necessary to determine whether Tribunal concluded that Acehnese people were targeted in Jakarta or concluded that they were not. I approach the matter on the basis that the content of the Tribunal’s reasons is a question of fact: see Long v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural & Indigenous Affairs [2003] FCAFC 218 at [32] and that it would be open to me to infer, as a matter of fact, that the Tribunal had omitted a word in its published reasons, having regard to the reasons as a whole and the context in which they were given. The question is whether such an inference should be drawn. It is well settled that the reasons for decision of bodies such as the Tribunal must be read as a whole and that it would be erroneous to comb through the words of the decision-maker with a fine appellate tooth-comb, against the prospect that a verbal slip will be found warranting the inference of an error of law: see Minister for Immigration & Ethnic Affairs v Wu Shan Liang (1996) 185 CLR 259 and particularly Kirby J at 291. However, the anterior question in this matter is whether the Tribunal meant to say that it was satisfied that the incident (the bombing of the boarding house) indicated Acehnese people were targeted in Jakarta, or was it of the opposite view and these conclusions were inaccurately recorded. There is authority supporting an approach that a decision maker can be taken to mean what he or she has said in any published reasons for decision: see Re Australian Insurance Employees Union; Ex parte Academy Insurance Pty Ltd (1988) 78 ALR 466. In that matter, the issue was whether the President of the Australian Conciliation and Arbitration Commission had applied the correct statutory test in dealing with a matter. The language used in the published reasons for the decision suggested that he had not. Dawson J said at 467 that “[t]he reasons given by the President are those which I must accept and do accept as being his reasons”. That is to say, in appropriate cases the lawfulness of a decision should be determined by reference to the language actually used: see Vietnam Veteran’s Association of Australia New South Wales Branch Inc v Specialist Medical Review Council (2002) 69 ALD 553 at 569-570.