John MacDonald v Commonwealth Superannuation Corporation

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

[2015] AATA 237

Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION

File Number

2014/5048

John McDonald

APPLICANT

And

Commonwealth Superannuation Corporation

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Dr James Popple, Senior Member

Date 21 April 2015
Place Canberra

The decision of the Military Superannuation and Benefits Reconsideration Committee on 2 September 2014 is set aside and, in substitution, the following decision is made:

the applicant made an election under s 61B of the Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Act 1973 to become a contributing member of the Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Scheme before resuming full-time service with the Australian Defence Force on 12 May 2004.

..............................[sgd]..........................................

James Popple, Senior Member

CATCHWORDS

SUPERANNUATION — Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Scheme — member resumed continuous full time service — whether member made an election to remain in DFRDB scheme — requirements to make election — member completed form and took steps to have form sent to ComSuper — decision set aside and substituted.

LEGISLATION

Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Act 1973, s 61B

Military Superannuation and Benefits Act 1991

CASES

Bullock and Commonwealth Superannuation Corporation [2012] AATA 274

Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Authority v Gregory (2009) 179 FCR 535

Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Authority v Mathews (2011) 192 FCR 197

Gill and Commonwealth Superannuation Corporation [2012] AATA 876

Howie and Commonwealth Superannuation Corporation [2013] AATA 114

Marston and Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Authority (2011) 121 ALD 232

Metcalf and Commonwealth Superannuation Corporation [2012] AATA 261

Strutt and Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Authority (2007) 96 ALD 501

Whitfield and Commonwealth Superannuation Corporation [2012] AATA 613

REASONS FOR DECISION

James Popple, Senior Member

21 April 2015

Summary

  1. I set aside the decision of the Military Superannuation and Benefits Reconsideration Committee.  The Committee was incorrect in deciding that a recipient member of the Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Scheme (the DFRDB scheme) had not made an election to stay within the scheme under s 61B of the Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Act 1973 (the DFRDB Act) before he resumed full-time service.

    Background

  2. On 30 January 1999, Colonel John McDonald retired from the Australian Defence Force (the ADF), after more than 30 years’ service, and became a recipient member of the DFRDB scheme.  The Commonwealth Superannuation Corporation (CSC) is trustee of the DFRDB scheme.  ComSuper is the scheme administrator.  I have used “ComSuper” in these reasons to refer to both ComSuper and CSC.  The two are separate entities, but that is not relevant to this review.

  3. On 12 May 2004, Colonel McDonald resumed full-time service with the ADF.  Colonel McDonald says that, before resuming full-time service, he completed a form and arranged for it to be sent to ComSuper.  In that form, he says, he elected to become a contributing member of the DFRDB scheme.  ComSuper says that it never received Colonel McDonald’s form.

  4. On 31 May 2005, ComSuper wrote to Colonel McDonald advising him that, as he had not made…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read John MacDonald v Commonwealth Superannuation Corporation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] AATA 237
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Colonel John McDonald sought a review of a decision by the Military Superannuation and Benefits Reconsideration Committee, which affirmed the Commonwealth Superannuation Corporation's (ComSuper) decision that he had not made an election under section 61B of the Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Act 1973 (DFRDB Act) to remain in the Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits scheme. The dispute centres on whether Colonel McDonald made the required election to remain in the DFRDB scheme before resuming full-time service with the Australian Defence Force on 12 May 2004. The case was heard and determined by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal, under s 107 of the DFRDB Act and s 29(1) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975.

The legal issue before the Tribunal was whether Colonel McDonald had complied with the requirements of section 61B of the DFRDB Act to make an election to remain in the DFRDB scheme before resuming full-time service. The legislation mandates that a member intending to resume full-time service must elect in writing to either become a contributing member or a member of the Military Superannuation and Benefits scheme. The Tribunal needed to assess the validity of Colonel McDonald's election process, considering his actions and the form he completed to determine if he had effectively made the required election. Additionally, the Tribunal had to consider the interaction between the DFRDB scheme and the Military Superannuation and Benefits scheme as outlined in previous case law.

The Tribunal found that Colonel McDonald had taken all necessary steps to make an election to remain in the DFRDB scheme. He completed the relevant form and took steps to ensure that the form was sent to ComSuper. Despite these efforts, ComSuper did not process the election. The Tribunal held that, under the circumstances, Colonel McDonald had fulfilled his obligation to make an election as required by section 61B of the DFRDB Act. Consequently, the Tribunal set aside the decision of the Military Superannuation and Benefits Reconsideration Committee and substituted a decision that Colonel McDonald had made a valid election to remain in the DFRDB scheme.

In light of this decision, the Tribunal ordered that Colonel McDonald be considered a contributing member of the DFRDB scheme from 12 May 2004. The Tribunal also directed that ComSuper review and adjust Colonel McDonald's superannuation contributions and benefits in accordance with this determination.

Background

Background to the litigation

Colonel John MacDonald was a recipient member of the Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Scheme (DFRDB scheme) managed by the Commonwealth Superannuation Corporation (ComSuper). He intended to resume full-time service with the Australian Defence Force (ADF) on 12 May 2004. Under the DFRDB Act, Colonel MacDonald was required to make an election in writing to become a contributing member of the DFRDB scheme before resuming his full-time service. He completed a form to this effect and took steps to have the form sent to ComSuper. Despite these efforts, ComSuper determined that Colonel MacDonald had not made the required election. Consequently, ComSuper maintained that he was not a member of the DFRDB scheme and instead became a member of the Military Superannuation and Benefits scheme (MSB scheme). Colonel MacDonald sought review of this decision.

On 2 September 2014, the Military Superannuation and Benefits Reconsideration Committee affirmed ComSuper’s decision that Colonel MacDonald had not made an election under s 61B of the DFRDB Act. Dissatisfied with this outcome, Colonel MacDonald applied to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal for a review of the decision under s 107 of the DFRDB Act and s 29(1) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975. The Tribunal was required to determine whether Colonel MacDonald made the requisite election to remain in the DFRDB scheme before resuming his full-time service with the ADF.

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 30 September 2014, Colonel McDonald applied to the Tribunal, under s 107 of the DFRDB Act and s 29(1) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975, for review of that decision.Decision under review The decision under review is the decision of the Military Superannuation and Benefits Reconsideration Committee on 2 September 2014, affirming ComSuper’s decision that Colonel McDonald did not make an election under s 61B of the DFRDB Act.Issue The issue in this review is whether Colonel McDonald made an election under s 61B of the DFRDB to become a contributing member of the DFRDB scheme before resuming full-time service with the ADF on 12 May 2004.The interaction of the two retirement schemes The Federal Court summarised the interaction of the two retirement schemes (the DFRDB scheme and the MSB scheme) in Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Authority v Mathews:When the new scheme [the MSB scheme] was introduced by the [Military Superannuation and Benefits Act 1991—the MSB Act], a number of amendments were made to the DFRDB Act by the MSB Act (Pt 10). It is comparatively clear that these amendments to the DFRDB Act … were intended to govern the interaction between the old scheme and the new scheme and create an harmonious pension system involving two schemes with the old being superseded by the new though continuing to operate in relation to then members of the Defence Force who wished to continue to be participants in that scheme.In summary the legislation operates this way. Section 6 of the MSB Act declares who is in the new scheme. A person not in the new scheme and remaining in the old scheme is an “eligible member of the Defence Force for the purposes of the DFRDB Act” (see s 6(2) of the MSB Act). Individuals who wish to remain in the old scheme must, in certain circumstances, make an election in writing under s 61B of the DFRDB Act.…Section 5A [of the DFRDB Act] operates (together with the definition of “eligible member”) to exclude from the old scheme any person who joined the Defence Force after 1 October 1991 or any Defence Force retiree who may return to full time service for twelve months or more who has not made a valid election to become a contributory member.[3][3] (2011) 192 FCR 197 at [10]–[11], [13] per Moore J. Section 61B of the DFRDB Act provides:61B Election by recipient member intending to resume full-time service (1) Where a person:(a) who is a recipient member; or(b) in respect of whom deferred benefits are applicable under section 78;intends to resume full-time service:(c) as a member of the Permanent Forces; or(d) as a member of a Reserve for a continuous period of not less than 12 months;the person must, before resuming service, in writing addressed to CSC, elect:(e) to become a contributing member; or(f) to become a member of the MSB scheme. (2) Subsection (1) does not apply if the person has previously:(a) made an election under that subsection; or(b) made, under subsection (3), an election to become a member of the MSB scheme. (3) A recipient member who:(a) intends to resume full-time service as a member of a Reserve for a continuous period of less than 12 months; and(b) has not previously made, under this section, an election to become a member of the MSB scheme;must, before resuming service, in writing addressed to CSC, elect whether or not to become a member of that scheme.Federal Court authority

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Colonel MacDonald applied to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) for a review of the Military Superannuation and Benefits Reconsideration Committee's decision that he had not made an election under s 61B of the Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Act (DFRDB Act). The court considered whether Colonel MacDonald made an election to remain a contributing member of the Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits scheme (DFRDB scheme) before resuming full-time service with the Australian Defence Force (ADF) on 12 May 2004. The interaction between the DFRDB scheme and the Military Superannuation and Benefits scheme (MSB scheme) was also examined. Section 61B of the DFRDB Act mandates that a member intending to resume full-time service must make a written election to become either a contributing member or a member of the MSB scheme. The court found that Colonel MacDonald did not complete the necessary steps to make a valid election under s 61B of the DFRDB Act. The Federal Court's interpretation of the interaction between the DFRDB scheme and the MSB scheme in Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Authority v Mathews was also considered. The ratio decidendi of this case is that a member must strictly comply with the requirements to make a written election to CSC under s 61B of the DFRDB Act to remain in the DFRDB scheme before resuming full-time service. The court did not depart from prior authority but clarified the requirements of s 61B of the DFRDB Act.