Malcolm Howie and Commonwealth Superannuation Corporation

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

[2013] AATA  114

Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION

File Number

2012/3812

Re

Malcolm Howie

APPLICANT

And

Commonwealth Superannuation Corporation

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Deputy President S D Hotop

Date 1 March 2013
Place Perth

The decision under review is affirmed.

.................[sgd]..........................................

S D Hotop, Deputy President

CATCHWORDS

DEFENCE – Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Scheme (DFRDBS) – Military Superannuation and Benefits Scheme (MSBS) – applicant retired from Australian Regular Army in July 2010 – applicant a recipient member of DFRDBS – applicant a member of Army Reserve – applicant undertook to render continuous full-time service (CFTS) with Australian Regular Army from 8 November 2011 to 7 March 2012 – applicant resumed CFTS on 8 November 2011 – applicant elected in writing not to become member of MSBS before 8 November 2011  – applicant did not communicate election to respondent before resuming CFTS on 8 November 2011 –  applicant became member of MSBS on 8 November 2011  – applicant continued to receive retirement pay under DFRDBS in period from 8 November 2011 to 23 February 2012  – retirement pay under DFRDBS not payable to applicant in that period  – amount of retirement pay under DFRDBS paid to applicant in that period recoverable by respondent – decision under review affirmed

LEGISLATION

Defence Act 1903 (Cth), s 4(1), s 30 and s 31

Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Act 1973 (Cth), s 3(1), s 5A(1), s 61B, s 61C and s 126

Military Superannuation and Benefits Act 1991 (Cth), s 6

CASES

Chapman v Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Authority (2001) 108 FCR 537
Re Gill and Commonwealth Superannuation Corporation [2012] AATA 876

Re Marston and Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Authority (2011) 121 ALD 232

Sargent v ASL Developments Ltd (1974) 131 CLR 634

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President S D Hotop

1 March 2013

Introduction

  1. Malcolm Howie (“the applicant”) has applied to the Tribunal for review of a decision of

    the Defence Force Case Assessment Panel (“DFCAP”) made on 3 August 2012 under s 102(1)(a) of the Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Act 1973 (Cth) (“DFRDB Act”).

  2. In its decision of 3 August 2012 the DFCAP confirmed a decision of a delegate of the Commonwealth Superannuation Corporation (“the respondent” or “CSC”), dated 2 March 2012, that the applicant had been overpaid “retirement pay” under the Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Scheme (“DFRDB Scheme”) in the amount of $8,386.99 in the period from 8 November 2011 to 23 February 2012 and that the amount of that overpayment was to be recovered from him by the CSC. In confirming that decision the DFCAP found that that overpayment had arisen because the applicant had ceased to be a member of the DFRDB Scheme on 8 November 2011 and had become a member of the Military Superannuation and Benefits Scheme (“MSB Scheme”) on that date because he had failed to make an election, under s 61B(3) of the DFRDB Act, not to become a member of the MSB…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Malcolm Howie and Commonwealth Superannuation Corporation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] AATA 114
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Malcolm Howie and the Commonwealth Superannuation Corporation involves a dispute regarding the recovery of overpaid retirement pay under the Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Scheme (DFRDB Scheme). The applicant, Malcolm Howie, a former member of the Australian Regular Army, retired in July 2010 and became a recipient member of the DFRDB Scheme. He subsequently became a member of the Army Reserve and resumed continuous full-time service on 8 November 2011 for a period of less than 12 months. The Commonwealth Superannuation Corporation (CSC), acting on behalf of the Commonwealth, sought to recover $8,386.99 in overpaid retirement pay from the applicant for the period from 8 November 2011 to 23 February 2012. The CSC argued that the applicant should have elected not to become a member of the Military Superannuation and Benefits Scheme (MSB Scheme) under section 61B(3) of the DFRDB Act before resuming full-time service, which he failed to do.

The central legal issue before the court was whether the applicant's failure to make a written election under section 61B(3) of the DFRDB Act, not to become a member of the MSB Scheme before resuming full-time service for a period of less than 12 months, resulted in his automatic membership of the MSB Scheme and the cessation of his eligibility for retirement pay under the DFRDB Scheme. The court had to determine if the applicant's continued receipt of retirement pay under the DFRDB Scheme during the period from 8 November 2011 to 23 February 2012 constituted an overpayment that was recoverable by the CSC. The court also needed to consider the implications of section 61C of the DFRDB Act, which provides for the suspension of retirement pay when a recipient member becomes a member of the MSB Scheme.

The court examined the statutory provisions and the applicant's actions in light of the statutory requirements. It found that the applicant, by failing to make a written election not to become a member of the MSB Scheme before resuming full-time service for a period of less than 12 months, had not complied with the statutory requirement under section 61B(3) of the DFRDB Act. As a result, he became a member of the MSB Scheme on 8 November 2011, and his eligibility for retirement pay under the DFRDB Scheme ceased. The court concluded that the applicant's continued receipt of retirement pay under the DFRDB Scheme during the specified period constituted an overpayment. Consequently, the court affirmed the decision of the Defence Force Superannuation Appeals Panel (DFCAP) that the amount of the overpayment was recoverable by the CSC.

In light of the court's findings, it affirmed the decision of the DFCAP and upheld the CSC's right to recover the overpaid amount from the applicant. The court's decision was based on the statutory provisions and the applicant's failure to comply with the legislative requirements for making an election under section 61B(3) of the DFRDB Act. The court's ruling ensures that the applicant is held accountable for the overpayment and that the statutory framework governing military superannuation and benefits is upheld.

Background

Background to the litigation

Malcolm Howie, the applicant, retired from the Australian Regular Army in July 2010. He became a recipient member of the Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Scheme (DFRDB Scheme) and remained a member of the Army Reserve. The applicant undertook to render continuous full-time service (CFTS) with the Australian Regular Army from 8 November 2011 to 7 March 2012. He resumed CFTS on 8 November 2011 and elected in writing not to become a member of the Military Superannuation and Benefits Scheme (MSB Scheme) before 8 November 2011. However, he did not communicate this election to the Commonwealth Superannuation Corporation (CSC) before resuming CFTS on 8 November 2011. Consequently, the applicant became a member of the MSB Scheme on 8 November 2011. Despite this, the applicant continued to receive retirement pay under the DFRDB Scheme from 8 November 2011 to 23 February 2012. Retirement pay under the DFRDB Scheme was not payable to the applicant during this period. The amount of retirement pay under the DFRDB Scheme paid to the applicant during this period, amounting to $8,386.99, was recoverable by the CSC.

The decision under review was affirmed by the Defence Force Central Adjudication Panel (DFCAP) in its decision of 3 August 2012. The DFCAP confirmed a decision of a delegate of the CSC, dated 2 March 2012, that the applicant had been overpaid retirement pay under the DFRDB Scheme in the amount of $8,386.99 in the period from 8 November 2011 to 23 February 2012. The amount of that overpayment was to be recovered from the applicant by the CSC. The evidence before the Tribunal comprised the "T Documents" (T1–T44, pp 1–174) lodged by the respondent in accordance with s 37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth), and the oral evidence of the applicant.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In its decision of 3 August 2012 the DFCAP confirmed a decision of a delegate of the Commonwealth Superannuation Corporation (“the respondent” or “CSC”), dated 2 March 2012, that the applicant had been overpaid “retirement pay” under the Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Scheme (“DFRDB Scheme”) in the amount of $8,386.99 in the period from 8 November 2011 to 23 February 2012 and that the amount of that overpayment was to be recovered from him by the CSC. In confirming that decision the DFCAP found that that overpayment had arisen because the applicant had ceased to be a member of the DFRDB Scheme on 8 November 2011 and had become a member of the Military Superannuation and Benefits Scheme (“MSB Scheme”) on that date because he had failed to make an election, under s 61B(3) of the DFRDB Act, not to become a member of the MSB Scheme before resuming full-time service as a member of the Army Reserve for a continuous period of less than 12 months.The Evidence The evidence before the Tribunal comprised the “T Documents” (T1–T44, pp 1–174) lodged by the respondent in accordance with s 37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth), and the oral evidence of the applicant.The Relevant LegislationThe Military Superannuation and Benefits Act 1991 (Cth) Section 6 of the Military Superannuation and Benefits Act 1991 (Cth) (“MSB Act”) provides:“6 Membership of Superannuation Scheme(1) Subject to subsection (2), each of the following persons is, by force of this section, a member of the Scheme:(a) a member of the Permanent Forces;(b)a member of the Reserves who is rendering continuous full-time service under an undertaking to serve for a period of not less than 12 months;(c)a member of the Reserves who is rendering continuous full-time service under an undertaking to serve for a period of less than 12 months unless that member has elected not to become a member of the Scheme under section 61B of the DFRDB Act.(2)In spite of subsection (1), a person is not a member of the Scheme if the person is an eligible member of the Defence Force for the purposes of the DFRDB Act.”The DFRDB ACT The DFRDB Act relevantly provides:“3 Interpretation(1) In this Act, unless the contrary intention appears:…CSC (short for Commonwealth Superannuation Corporation) has the same meaning as in the Governance of Australian Government Superannuation Schemes Act 2011.date of commencement of the scheme means 1 October 1972.…eligible member of the Defence Force means:…but does not include:(c) a person who, under section 5A, is excluded from this definition;…member of the scheme means a person who is, or at any time on or after the date of commencement of the scheme, has been, an eligible member of the Defence Force. MSB scheme means the superannuation scheme established under the Military Superannuation and Benefits Act 1991.…recipient member means a member of the scheme who is entitled to retirement pay or invalidity pay, and includes:(a)a member of the scheme who, but for the suspension of his or her invalidity pay under subsection 35(3) or 61D(2), would be entitled to invalidity pay; and(b)a member of the scheme who, but for the suspension of his or her retirement pay under subsection 61C(1), would be entitled to retirement pay.Reserve means:(a)in relation to a member of the Navy – the Naval Reserve; and(b)in relation to a member of the Army – the Army Reserve; and(c) in relation to a member of the Air Force – the Air Force Reserve.…retirement pay means retirement pay payable under section 23.…service means service as a member of the Defence Force.…5A Persons excluded from definition of eligible member of the Defence Force(1)Subject to subsection (2), a person who:(a)becomes, on or after 1 October 1991, a member of the Defence Force; or(b)being a member of a Reserve, commences on or after that day to render continuous full-time service for a period of not less than 12 months;is excluded from the definition of eligible member of the Defence Force in subsection 3(1).…61B Election by recipient member intending to resume full-time service(1) Where a person:(a) who is a recipient member; or(b) in respect of whom deferred benefits are applicable under section 78;intends to resume full-time service:(c) as a member of the Permanent Forces; or(d)as a member of a Reserve for a continuous period of not less than 12 months;the person must, before resuming service, in writing addressed to CSC, elect:(e) to become a contributing member; or (f) to become a member of the MSB scheme.(2) Subsection (1) does not apply if the person has previously; (a) made an election under that subsection; or(b)made, under subsection (3), an election to become a member of the MSB scheme.(3) A recipient member who:(a)intends to resume full-time service as a member of a Reserve for a continuous period of less than 12 months; and(b)has not previously made, under this section, an election to become a member of the MSB scheme;must, before resuming service, in writing addressed to CSC, elect whether or not to become a member of that scheme.61C Recipient member in receipt of retirement pay who becomes member of MSB scheme(1)Where a recipient member in receipt of retirement pay becomes a member of the MSB scheme, payment of the member’s retirement pay is, subject to subsection (2), suspended.(2)A suspension under subsection (1) ceases to have effect when the recipient member whose retirement pay has been suspended ceases to be a member of the MSB scheme.…126 Recovery of amounts payable to Commonwealth…(4)Where, for any reason (including the making of, or cancellation of, an election under this Act), an amount of benefit has been paid that is not payable, or has become not payable, the amount so paid may be recovered by CSC, on behalf of the Commonwealth, in a court of competent jurisdiction as a debt due and payable to the Commonwealth.(5)Where, for any reason (including the making of, or cancellation of, an election under this Act), an amount of benefit has been paid that is not payable, or has become not payable, and the person to whom that amount was paid is receiving, or is entitled to receive, a benefit, that amount, or such part of that amount as CSC determines, may, if CSC in its discretion so directs, be recovered by deduction from that benefit.(6)In subsections (4) and (5), benefit includes pension or other money payable under the previous legislation.” THE FACTUAL BACKGROUND

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the applicant was required to make an election under s 61B(3) of the Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Act 1973 (DFRDB Act) before resuming full-time service as a member of the Army Reserve for a continuous period of less than 12 months.
2. Whether the applicant's failure to make such an election resulted in him becoming a member of the MSB Scheme on 8 November 2011.
3. Whether retirement pay under the DFRDB Scheme was payable to the applicant in the period from 8 November 2011 to 23 February 2012.
4. Whether the amount of retirement pay under the DFRDB Scheme paid to the applicant in that period was recoverable by the CSC.

Held
1. The court held that the applicant was required to make an election under s 61B(3) of the Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Act 1973 (DFRDB Act) before resuming full-time service as a member of the Army Reserve for a continuous period of less than 12 months.
2. The court held that the applicant's failure to make such an election resulted in him becoming a member of the MSB Scheme on 8 November 2011.
3. The court held that retirement pay under the DFRDB Scheme was not payable to the applicant in the period from 8 November 2011 to 23 February 2012.
4. The court held that the amount of retirement pay under the DFRDB Scheme paid to the applicant in that period was recoverable by the CSC.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the statutory framework under which the applicant was operating, specifically sections 61B(3) and 61C of the DFRDB Act, as well as the relevant provisions of the Military Superannuation and Benefits Act 1991 (Cth). The court found that the applicant, as a recipient member, was required to make an election under s 61B(3) of the DFRDB Act before resuming full-time service as a member of the Army Reserve for a continuous period of less than 12 months. The applicant did not make such an election, and therefore, the court held that he became a member of the MSB Scheme on 8 November 2011.

Under s 61C of the DFRDB Act, when a recipient member in receipt of retirement pay becomes a member of the MSB Scheme, their retirement pay is suspended. The court concluded that the applicant's retirement pay was suspended from 8 November 2011, making the retirement pay paid to him during the period from 8 November 2011 to 23 February 2012 not payable. Furthermore, the court held that the amount of retirement pay paid to the applicant in that period was recoverable by the CSC under s 126 of the DFRDB Act.

The court's reasoning was grounded in the statutory provisions and their application to the facts of the case. The court applied the statutory requirements for making an election under s 61B(3) of the DFRDB Act and the consequences of not making such an election under s 61C of the same Act. The ratio decidendi of the decision is that failure to make an election under s 61B(3) of the DFRDB Act when resuming full-time service as a member of the Army Reserve for a continuous period of less than 12 months results in the applicant becoming a member of the MSB Scheme, thereby suspending retirement pay under the DFRDB Scheme and making any such retirement pay paid during that period recoverable by the CSC.