Clark and Commonwealth Superannuation Corporation

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

Clark and Commonwealth Superannuation Corporation [2018] AATA 681 (22 March 2018)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2017/1199 and 2017/5110

Re:Ian Clark

APPLICANT

Commonwealth Superannuation CorporationAnd  

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Deputy President J Sosso

Date:22 March 2018

Place:Brisbane

The Tribunal:

(a)varies the decision under review dated 14 February 2014 (2017/1199); and

(b)affirms the decision under review dated 11 August 2017 (2017/5110)

.........................[Sgd]...............................................

Deputy President J Sosso

CATCHWORDS

SUPERANNUATION – Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Scheme – member resumed continuous full time service – member required to elect whether or not to become member of the Military Superannuation Scheme - whether member made a valid election to remain in DFRDB scheme prior to re-commencing service – requirements to make election – where member completed and sent D 100 form after re-commencing service – decision under review varied (2017/1199) - decision under review affirmed (2017/5110)

LEGISLATION

Defence Force and Death Benefits Act 1973 (Cth)

Military Superannuation and Benefits Act 1991 (Cth)

CASES

Chapman v Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Authority (2001) 108 FCR 537
Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Authority v Gregory (2009) 179 FCR 535
Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Authority v Mathews (2011) 192 FCR 197
Howie and Commonwealth Superannuation Corporation [2013] AATA 114
Marston and Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Authority (2011) 121 ALD 232
McDonald and Commonwealth Superannuation Corporation [2015] AATA 237
Strutt and Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Authority [2007] AATA 1614
Whitfield and Commonwealth Superannuation Corporation [2012] AATA 613

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President J Sosso

22 March 2018

INTRODUCTION

  1. Mr Ian Clark (the Applicant) served in the Australian Defence Force from September 1979 until March 2010 (the first period of continuous full-time service (CFTS)).  The Applicant subsequently undertook two periods of CFTS in the Army Reserves:

    (a)23 March 2015 – 17 January 2016 – the second period of CFTS; and

    (b)6 May 2016 – 20 January 2017 – the third period of CFTS.

  2. Whilst enlisted during his first period of CFTS, the Applicant joined the Defence Forces Retirement and Death Benefits Scheme (the DFRDBS). The DFRDBS is established by the Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Act 1973 (the Act) and provides a range of benefits, including retirement benefits for “eligible members of the Defence Force”.

  3. The DFRDBS was replaced in 1991 by the Military Superannuation and Benefits Scheme (MSBS), and thereafter the DFRDBS was closed to new members.  Further, an existing member of the DFRDBS who resumed CFTS after 1991 automatically became a member of the MSBS unless they made an election in writing to continue to contribute to the DFRDBS.

  4. When the Applicant commenced his second and third periods of CFTS, s 5A of the Act (which has since been repealed) provided as follows:

    “5A      Persons excluded from the definition of eligible member of the Defence Force

    (1) Subject to subsection (2) a person who:

    (a) becomes, on or after 1 October 1991, a member of the Defence Force; or

    (b) being a member…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Clark and Commonwealth Superannuation Corporation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] AATA 681
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by the Applicant, WO1 Clark, against decisions of the Commonwealth Superannuation Corporation concerning his superannuation entitlements. The central dispute revolved around whether the Applicant had made a valid election under section 61B of the relevant Act to remain in the Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Scheme (DFRDB) rather than becoming a member of the Military Superannuation Scheme (MSBS) prior to recommencing a period of continuous full-time service (CFTS) on 23 March 2015.

The legal issue before the Tribunal was whether the Applicant had complied with the requirements of section 61B of the Act by giving written notice of his election to the Respondent before he commenced his second period of CFTS. This required determining the precise timing of the Applicant's election and whether it was effectively communicated to the Respondent prior to his recommencement of service.

The Tribunal considered the Applicant's evidence and documentary material, including an AD 600 form signed on 2 March 2015, which acknowledged his responsibility to elect a superannuation fund before undertaking CFTS. However, the Tribunal found significant inconsistencies in the Applicant's account of when he submitted his election. Crucially, the Applicant stated in an email to Major Pointon that he did not sign and fax a D100 form until 25 March 2015, after commencing his CFTS. Further, an email from the Respondent on 25 March 2015 indicated the Applicant had made an enquiry, contradicting his assertion that the Respondent had contacted him. The Tribunal also noted the Applicant's contradictory statement in a later email that he had emailed his D100 form, which he had previously denied. Based on these inconsistencies and the absence of documentary evidence supporting an election prior to 23 March 2015, the Tribunal concluded that the Applicant had not made a valid election before resuming service.

Consequently, the Tribunal varied the decision under review dated 14 February 2017 to state that the Applicant failed to complete an election not to become a member of the MSB Scheme prior to recommencing service on 23 March 2015, and as a result, he became a member of the MSB Scheme as at that date. The Tribunal also affirmed the decision under review dated 11 August 2017.

Background

Background to the litigation

The sole issue to be determined by the Tribunal was whether the Applicant complied with s 61B of the Act by giving written notice to the Respondent before he commenced his second period of CFTS on 23 March 2015.FACTS On 2 March 2016, the Applicant signed an AD 600 form: “Personal Particulars – Undertaking by a Member of the Army Reserve to Render Continuous Full-time Service” – Exhibit 2 T7 pp. 35 – 37. At the end of Part 1 of the form are the following words – Exhibit 2 T7 p. 35:“I voluntarily undertake to render continuous full-time military service with the Australian Regular Army (ARA) for the period commencing on 23 Mar 2015 and ending on the 17 Jan 2016 for the period of 301 days.” Immediately above the signature block where the Applicant signed his name are two key paragraphs – Exhibit 2 T7 p. 35:“7. I acknowledge that it is my responsibility to elect a superannuation fund prior to undertaking the period of CFTS and I am aware that if an election is not made, I will become a member of MSBS.8. I acknowledge that I have been informed that I should seek financial advice before making a superannuation decision.” The Applicant’s signing of the form was witnessed by Major Foster, and was endorsed by the Unit Commander, Major Pointon, on 5 March 2015. Subsequently, it was “signed off” by Colonel Fegan on 9 March 2015 and finally by Colonel Winter on 19 March 2015 – Exhibit 2 T7 pp. 35 – 36. Major Pointon also prepared on 5 March 2015 a Minute providing reasons for employing the Applicant on a full-time basis. The two page document comprehensively summed up the Applicant’s qualifications, the proposed service to be rendered, justification for employing him, risks and tenure. Amongst the other matters also dealt with was his pension. Major Pointon noted – Exhibit 2 T8 p. 39:“DFRDB pension: WO1 Clark is in receipt of a DFRDB pension and has been directed to contact CommSuper for specific advice and lodge a D 100 pension stoppage for the duration of CFTS.” On 23 March 2015, the Applicant resumed CFTS. On 25 March 2015, the Applicant contacted the Respondent. At 3:10 pm on the same day, Geri Waddleton, Customer Information Representative, sent the following email to the Applicant – Exhibit 2 T9 p. 40:“Dear Mr Clark,Thank you for your enquiry.Please find enclosed the D100 form as requested….Yours sincerely…” The Applicant completed and submitted the D 100 form which was forwarded with the above email from the Respondent. At the hearing, the Applicant confirmed that the handwriting on the form was his. Question 6 of the form asks – Exhibit 2 p. 47: “Intended date you will resume service in the Defence Force”. The Applicant’s answer was: “26 03 2015” instead of his actual starting date of 23 March 2015. Also, in Part C of the form the Applicant elected not to join the MSBS. On 30 March 2015, the Applicant resubmitted his D 100 form by email – Exhibit 2 T13 pp. 56 – 57:“Please find attached my D100 & Signed. I did fwd this last week by Email & Fax.Commence Date 26 Mar 15End Date 17 Jan 16WO1 Ian Clark”

Decision

Reasons for decision

Accordingly, I find that the Applicant did not make a valid election pursuant to s 61(B)(3) of the Act prior to resuming service on 23 March 2015.DECISION The Tribunal:(a) varies the decision under review dated 14 February 2017 (2017/1199) to provide that:“The Applicant failed to complete an election not to become a member of the MSB Scheme prior to his re-commencing service with the ADF on 23 March 2015 and as a consequence he became a member of the MSB Scheme as at that date”;(b) affirms the decision under review dated 11 August 2017 (2017/5110).

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In Marston, Member Webb made the following observations (at [13]):“It is clear enough that a written election must be made prior to the resumption of service: between the time the undertaking to serve is given by a person and the time that person actually resumes service. But this does not mean in all cases that the election must be received by the authority prior to that point in time. The section does not expressly require it; the requirement is for the election to be effectively made prior to the resumption of service.”CONSIDERATION As Member Webb observed in Marston (at [13]):“for an election to be effective it must be properly made in writing and telegraphed or communicated to the authority. These are matters for proof in the face of uncertainty.” The sole issue to be determined is whether the Tribunal accepts the Applicant’s account that he faxed his duly completed D 100 form in which he made an election to rejoin the DFRDBS on 20 March 2015. The Tribunal, having considered all of the written evidence and listened to the Applicant give evidence, does not accept that he faxed his election to the Respondent on 20 March 2015. On 11 October 2017, the Applicant emailed Major Pointon seeking his assistance with these proceedings. In the body of the email, the Applicant made this statement – Exhibit 7:“My CFTS had a start date of 23 Mar 15 however, I did not sign a D100 and fax in [sic] until the 25 Mar 15…” When this was put to the Applicant by Ms McGree, he could not give a plausible explanation as to why he stated unequivocally to Major Pointon that he had only sent one D 100 form to the Respondent and this was not effected until 25 March 2015. Further, in the email sent on 25 March 2015 by Geri Waddleton to the Respondent, the opening sentence is: “Thank you for your enquiry”. In other words, unlike the Applicant’s version of events where he claims he was contacted by the Respondent, this email suggests that it was the other way around. Finally, the Applicant denied that he had emailed his D 100 form to the Respondent. Yet in his email message of 30 March 2015 to the Respondent he states (Exhibit 2 T13 p. 56): “Please find attached my D100 & Signed. I did fwd this last week by Email & Fax”. Again, the Applicant was unable to provide a plausible explanation for his own statement that he had, in fact, emailed his election to the Respondent. Where the Tribunal is confronted with two plausible scenarios relating to the communication of an election under s 61B, it generally approaches the matter in a generous way for an Applicant. It does so with the knowledge that the legislative schemes in question are inflexible, the consequences for minor non-compliance disproportionately harsh and the obvious difficulties experienced by persons in assembling evidence sometime after the event – see, as an example, McDonald and Commonwealth Superannuation Corporation [2015] AATA 237 at [26] – [34]. In this matter, the evidence leads inexorably to the conclusion that the Applicant, for whatever reason, did not make his s 61B election until after he resumed service on 23 March 2015. The evidence suggests that he made contact with the Respondent on 25 March 2015 and only completed his D 100 form on that day. He put his date for resumption of service as 26 March 2015, no doubt to ensure that the Respondent would form the belief that he had made a valid election. The inconsistencies in the Applicant’s evidence, the absence of any documentary evidence by the Applicant of his purported 20 March 2015 election and, finally, the absence of any evidence that the Respondent ever received such an election, all weigh against the Applicant.