Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Authority v Mathews

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Authority v Mathews [2011] FCA 160

Citation: Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Authority v Mathews [2011] FCA 160
Appeal from: Mathews v Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Authority [2010] AATA 548
Parties: DEFENCE FORCE RETIREMENT AND DEATH BENEFITS AUTHORITY v NICHOLAS MATHEWS
File number: NSD 1084 of 2010
Judge: MOORE J
Date of judgment: 2 March 2011
Catchwords: ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – Retirement schemes – whether member of Defence Force remained an eligible member of the Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Scheme – meaning of "valid election" for the purposes of s 61B(3) of the Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Act 1973 (Cth) - whether respondent a member of the Military Superannuation Benefits Scheme and disentitled to retirement pay otherwise payable.
Legislation: Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Act 1973 (Cth) ss 3, 5, 5A, 17, 23, 61B
Military Superannuation and Benefits Act 1991 (Cth) s 6
Naval Defence Act 1910 (Cth) s 32A
Cases cited: Chapman v Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Authority  (2001) 108 FCR 537
Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Authority v Chapman (2001) 63 ALD 351
Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Authority v Gregory (2009) 179 FCR 535
Date of hearing: 9 December 2010
Place: Sydney
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 43
Counsel for the Applicant: D O'Donovan
Solicitor for the Applicant: Australian Government Solicitor
Counsel for the Respondent: P R Callaghan SC and H P T Bevan
Solicitor for the Respondent: Essex Legal

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

NSD 1084 of 2010

ON APPEAL FROM THE ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL
BETWEEN:

DEFENCE FORCE RETIREMENT AND DEATH BENEFITS AUTHORITY
Applicant

AND:

NICHOLAS MATHEWS
Respondent

JUDGE:

MOORE J

DATE OF ORDER:

2 MARCH 2011

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The appeal is allowed.

2.The decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal of 22 July 2010 is set aside.

3.The matter is remitted to the Tribunal for determination according to law.

Note:Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.
The text of entered orders can be located using Federal Law Search on the Court’s website.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

NSD 1084 of 2010

ON APPEAL FROM THE ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL
BETWEEN:

DEFENCE FORCE RETIREMENT AND DEATH BENEFITS AUTHORITY
Applicant

AND:

NICHOLAS MATHEWS
Respondent

JUDGE:

MOORE J

DATE:

2 MARCH 2011

PLACE:

SYDNEY

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

  1. This is an appeal from a decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal: Mathews v Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Authority [2010] AATA 548. The appeal raises a question of law concerning the payment of retirement pay to the respondent and whether the Military Superannuation and Benefits Act 1991 (Cth) operates to disentitle him to retirement pay otherwise payable under the Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Act 1973 (Cth).

    Background

  2. The respondent served in the Navy for…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Authority v Math... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] FCA 160
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Authority v Mathews, the High Court considered the entitlement of a retired Navy member to retirement pay under the Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Act 1973 (Cth) and whether he was disentitled under the Military Superannuation and Benefits Act 1991 (Cth). The case arose from an appeal against a decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal which found that the respondent remained a member of the Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Scheme. The central legal issues revolved around the interpretation of "valid election" under s 61B(3) of the DFRDB Act and whether the respondent's service and elections complied with the legislative requirements to remain a member of the old scheme.

The court analysed the statutory language and legislative history, particularly focusing on the interplay between the DFRDB Act and the MSB Act. The High Court noted that the MSB Act, which established a new scheme in 1991, intended to close the old scheme to most re-entrants. The court considered previous cases such as Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Authority v Gregory and Chapman v Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Authority to understand the consequences of failing to make a valid election under s 61B(3). It was established that the respondent's failure to make a valid election resulted in him becoming a contributing member of the new scheme, thereby losing his eligibility for retirement pay under the old scheme.

The court concluded that the respondent's actions did not satisfy the requirements for a valid election, and thus, he was not an eligible member of the Defence Force under the DFRDB Act. Consequently, he was subject to the provisions of the MSB Act, which disentitled him to the retirement pay he sought. The High Court allowed the appeal, set aside the Tribunal's decision, and remitted the matter back to the Tribunal for reconsideration in light of the court's findings.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal is allowed.

2. The decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal of 22 July 2010 is set aside.

3. The matter is remitted to the Tribunal for determination according to law.

Note:

Background

Background to the litigation

This is an appeal from a decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal: Mathews v Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Authority [2010] AATA 548. The appeal raises a question of law concerning the payment of retirement pay to the respondent and whether the Military Superannuation and Benefits Act 1991 (Cth) operates to disentitle him to retirement pay otherwise payable under the Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Act 1973 (Cth).Background The respondent served in the Navy for over twenty years. He retired on 30 June 1997. He started receiving retirement pay under the Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Scheme (the old scheme) established by the DFRDB Act. It is common ground his entitlement to retirement pay at this point was not under the new scheme, the Military Superannuation and Benefits Scheme, established by the MSB Act in 1991. On 6 January 2003 the respondent commenced a period of continuous full time service in the Reserves. That period of service was stipulated to be for more than twelve months. It ended on 31 December 2004. On 19 December 2002 the respondent made an election under the DFRDB Act effectively to remain a member of the old scheme. It is common ground that this election was effective. On 11 November 2005 the respondent commenced another period of continuous full time service in the Reserves. That period was again stipulated to be for more than twelve months. It ended on 15 February 2007. On 11 October 2005 the respondent purported to make an election under the DFRDB Act effectively to remain a member of the old scheme. It is common ground that this election was unnecessary. I will discuss the precise terms of both the 19 December 2002 and 11 October 2005 elections later in these reasons. On 18 February 2007 the respondent commenced another period of continuous full time service in the Reserves (the contentious period). In contrast to the preceding periods, the contentious period was stipulated to be for less than twelve months, commencing 5 February 2007 and concluding on 25 January 2008. He was offered the further service in a letter dated 18 January 2007. The letter said:The purpose of this letter is to advise you that, subject to your acknowledgment to the Conditions of Service set out below, security clearance and medical fitness, you will be employed in a Permanent Navy position as a member of the Naval Reserves on Unprotected Continuous Full Time Service (CFTS) commencing 5 February 2007 to the expiration of 25 January 2008.Reserve personnel serving on CFTS are entitled to the same remuneration and conditions of service, and subject to the same service obligations, laws, regulations and procedures as a Permanent Force member. These Conditions of Service include a liability for service at sea. Specific Conditions of Service relating to salary and superannuation are detailed at Annex A.You are requested to sign the attached proforma and return it to the Directorate of Naval Officers' Postings as soon as possible. If you have any queries regarding this matter, please direct them to Staff Officer (Reserves), LCDR Lewis Gaha, Telephone: (02) 6265 3273, Facsimile: (02) 6265 1189, or E-mail: RCMC@defence.gov.au.You should note that this CFTS is only for the period specified above and that an extension to this CFTS period cannot be guaranteed.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The respondent contended that the Tribunal correctly found that s 61B(3) did not apply to the respondent. It was submitted that the respondent did not cease to be a member of the old scheme nor fall within the scope of s 6(1)(c) of the MSB Act which would apply to exclude him from membership of the new scheme, irrespective of the construction of s 6(2) of the MSB Act and s 5A of the DFRDB Act. Section 61B(2) operated to relieve the respondent from making a further election and s 61B(3) has no application. Consideration It is convenient to commence by considering some of the authorities. The consequences of failing to make an election under s 61B of the old scheme were considered in detail in Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Authority v Gregory (2009) 179 FCR 535. In that case the respondent had served for more than twenty years in continuous full time service in the regular Army and retired on 28 October 2001. He transferred to the Army Reserve and was entitled to receive retirement benefits under the old scheme as a "recipient member" (s 23 of the DFRDB Act). Subsequently, on three separate occasions between 2003 and 2006, he resumed continuous full time service. When the respondent resumed service in 2003 he did not provide a written notice under s 61B(3) and, in default of notification he became by operation of s 5A(1)(a) of the DFRDB Act and s 6 of the MSB Act a contributing member of the new scheme. Due to an administrative error the respondent's pension was not suspended and he was paid $37,472. The respondent claimed that when he resumed service for four months he became an "eligible member of the Defence Force" under s 3(1) of the DFRDB Act and asserted that s 6(2) of the MSB Act operated to exclude him from the new scheme. Justice Cowdroy held that the respondent's failure to make an election under s 61B(3) of the DFRDB Act resulted in the respondent not being excluded from the operation of s 5A(1)(a) of the same Act and therefore he ceased to be an "eligible member" from the time he recommenced service. It was held that the new scheme makes it clear that failure to elect under s 61B has the consequence of placing the respondent in the new scheme. While the respondent had made an election under s 132 of the DFRDB Act, this was held to be a different election to the one required by s 61B(3) and a fresh election was required. His Honour referred to the decision of the Full Federal Court in Chapman v Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Authority (2001) 108 FCR 537 and the reasoning of Weinberg J at first instance in Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Authority v Chapman (2001) 63 ALD 351 regarding the importance of s 5A(1)(a) of the DFRDB Act. In Chapman the appellant did not remain in the old scheme because he did not become an "eligible member of the Defence Force" under s 3(1) of the DFRDB Act when he transferred from the Army Reserve to the regular Army. He was required to contribute to the new scheme after his application to rejoin the old scheme had been rejected. Justice Weinberg held at [75] that the effect of s 5A was to close the old scheme to all but a very limited classes of re-entrants specifically identified in s 5A(2) and at [25] referred to the second reading speech of the Minister for Defence Science and Personnel:The Military Superannuation and Benefits Bill has the effect of making the existing Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits (DFRDB) scheme a closed scheme. That is to say that the only persons who will be permitted to join the superseded scheme will be pensioner re-entrants who chose not to join the new Military Superannuation and Benefits scheme and a couple of rare classes of re-entrants.His Honour observed at [44] that Parliament should be understood to have intended to close the doors on access to the old scheme as at 1 October 1991 and to have closed the door to persons who alter the nature of their service so as to commence rendering service on or after that date.