William Whitfield and Commonwealth Superannuation Corporation

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

[2012] AATA 613 

Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION

File Number

2012/0007

Re

William Whitfield

APPLICANT

And

Commonwealth Superannuation Corporation

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Ms N Isenberg, Senior Member

Date 13 September 2012
Place Sydney

The decision under review is set aside and in substitution thereof the Tribunal decides that:

1.The Applicant did not make a valid and effective election under s 61B(3) of the Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Act 1973; and

2.The Applicant was overpaid an amount of $3,861.17 but that overpayment is to be written off pursuant to s 126(4).

.........................[Sgd]..........................................

Ms N Isenberg, Senior Member

CATCHWORDS

MILITARY SUPERANNUATION:  Applicant required to elect whether or not to become a member of Military Superannuation Benefits Scheme prior to resuming service - Respondent did not receive election form by due date - Ceased membership of Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits at relevant date - Automatic transfer to Military Superannuation Benefits Scheme - Overpaid pension - Debt waived - Decision under review is set aside.

LEGISLATION

Acts Interpretation Act 1901, s 29

Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Act 1973, ss 61B, 126

Evidence Act 1995, s 160

Military Superannuation and Benefits Act 1991, s 6

CASES

Bullock and Commonwealth Superannuation Corporation [2012] AATA 274

Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Authority v Gregory [1993] HCA 21; (2009) 176 CLR 535
Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Authority v Mathews (2011) 192 CLR 197
Director-General of Social Security v Hales [1983] FCA 81; (1983) 78 FLR 373
Marston and Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Authority [2011] AATA 291
Metcalf and Commonwealth Superannuation Corporation [2012] AATA 261
Saunders and Commissioner of Superannuation [1994] AATA 14

REASONS FOR DECISION

Ms N Isenberg, Senior Member

13 September 2012

BACKGROUND

  1. On 24 June 1975, William Whitfield joined the Australian Defence Force (ADF). He achieved the rank of Chief Petty Officer in the Navy. After completing 20 years of service, he was discharged on 23 June 1995. He was paid retirement benefits under s 23 of the Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Act 1973 (DFRDB Act).

  2. Between May 1996 and May 2011, the Applicant resumed service with the ADF for a number of periods, providing both continuous full time service (CFTS) and some Reserve ‘diary days’.

  3. On 30 May 2011, the Applicant re-entered the ADF for another period of CFTS with an expected completion date of 5 September 2011. As this period was for less than 12 months, the Applicant was required to make an election, under s 61B(3) of the DFRDB Act, whether or not to become a member of the Military Superannuation and Benefits Scheme (MSBS).

  4. The Respondent did not receive the Applicant’s election until August 2011.  As a result, the Applicant was transferred to the MSBS.

  5. The Applicant was paid benefits of $3,861.17 under the DFRDB Act to which, as a member of MSBS, he would not be entitled.   

    ISSUES BEFORE THE TRIBUNAL

  6. Whether:

    ·the Applicant, before commencing CFTS of less than 12 months on 30 May…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read William Whitfield and Commonwealth Superannuation Corporatio... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] AATA 613
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In this case, William Whitfield, the applicant, brought proceedings against the Commonwealth Superannuation Corporation, the respondent, in the Administrative Appeals Tribunal. The dispute involved Whitfield's membership in the Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits (DFRDB) scheme and whether he made a valid election to remain in this scheme before resuming service, which would have resulted in an overpayment of his pension. The overpayment was subsequently waived, but the decision was under review. The central issue before the court was whether Whitfield made a valid and effective election to remain in the DFRDB scheme before resuming his service.

The court needed to determine whether the applicant's actions constituted a valid election to remain in the DFRDB scheme, as required by the relevant legislation. The evidence presented showed that Whitfield had completed and submitted the necessary forms to Comsuper, the agency that administers both the DFRDB and Military Superannuation Benefits (MSBS) schemes. The court had to consider whether these actions were sufficient to satisfy the legal requirements for making an election. Furthermore, the court had to assess whether the overpayment should be waived in light of the circumstances.

The court concluded that the applicant did not make a valid and effective election to remain in the DFRDB scheme. It was noted that Whitfield's previous submissions of election forms had not been followed by the necessary action to remain in the DFRDB scheme. The court found that the applicant was overpaid an amount of $3,861.17, but this overpayment was to be written off pursuant to section 126(4) of the DFRDB Act. The decision under review was set aside, and the Tribunal found that the applicant did not make a valid election, and the overpayment would be waived.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves William Whitfield and the Commonwealth Superannuation Corporation (CSC). Mr. Whitfield had served in the Royal Australian Navy for 20 years, retiring with the rank of Chief Petty Officer on 23 June 1995. He had been a member of the Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits (DFRDB) superannuation scheme throughout his service. Despite the introduction of the Military Superannuation Benefits Scheme (MSBS) in 1996, he did not transfer to the MSBS as it was less attractive. In 1996, he undertook a period of Continuous Full-Time Service (CFTS) of less than 12 months, during which he made an election to remain in the DFRDB scheme. He completed the election form, which noted that the form should be handed to the pay officer who would forward it to Comsuper. He claimed to have faxed the form to Comsuper and also mailed it.

In 2009, Mr. Whitfield undertook another period of CFTS for more than 12 months. He faxed his election form to Comsuper by the Reserve cell at Headquarters. For a subsequent period of CFTS in March 2010, Mr. Whitfield's election form was faxed to Comsuper on 28 November 2009. He was unsure by whom it was faxed but thought he also mailed it. He made telephone inquiries to ensure that Comsuper received his forms before the Christmas stand-down period, as he wanted to ensure his pension would continue over the holiday period. His pension started on 28 January 2010. In January 2011, Mr. Whitfield undertook another period of CFTS for less than 12 months, starting on 30 May 2011. He filled out and submitted his 'D100' election form before this period, but there is no evidence he delivered it to Comsuper by the due date.

The matter came before the court as a review of a decision made by the Military Superannuation Review Tribunal (MSRT). The Tribunal had previously ruled that Mr. Whitfield had not made a valid election to remain in the DFRDB scheme, leading to his automatic transfer to the MSBS and an overpayment of pension. The Tribunal had ordered Mr. Whitfield to repay the overpaid amount. Mr. Whitfield appealed this decision, arguing that he had made a valid election to remain in the DFRDB scheme. The appeal was heard by the court, which was tasked with reviewing the Tribunal's decision and determining whether Mr. Whitfield's election was valid. The court's review focused on the evidence of Mr. Whitfield's circumstances and the procedural steps leading to the Tribunal's decision.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Therefore, in consideration of the factors identified in Hales, I find that the evidence of the Applicant’s circumstances are such as to warrant the writing-off of the overpayment.DECISION The decision under review is set aside and the Tribunal finds that:(a)The Applicant did not make a valid and effective election to remain in the DFRDB scheme; and(b)The Applicant was overpaid an amount of $3,861.17 but that overpayment is to be written off pursuant to s 126(4) of the DFRDB Act.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Section 126(4) of the DFRDB Act provides that:(4)Where, for any reason (including the making of, or cancellation of, an election under this Act), an amount of benefit has been paid that is not payable, or has become not payable, the amount so paid may be recovered by CSC, on behalf of the Commonwealth, in a court of competent jurisdiction as a debt due and payable to the CommonwealthCONSIDERATIONDid the applicant make an election to remain in the DFRDB scheme before resuming CFTS on 30 May 2011? The Applicant’s evidence was that he had served in the Navy for 20 years, retiring on 23 June 1995 with the rank of Chief Petty Officer. Throughout his service he had been a member of the DFRDB superannuation scheme. During the latter part of his service the MSBS was introduced but, despite various inducements, it was less attractive than the DFRDB scheme and he, and many other members, did not transfer to it. In 1996, shortly after leaving the Navy, he undertook his first period of CFTS of less than 12 months as an instructor. He was obliged to make an election about his preferred scheme. The form contained a note stating that “after having completed this form prior to re-entry, on the first day of service hand the form to your pay officer who will place a copy of it on your file and will then send the original to Comsuper [the agency that administers both schemes]”. He said that was precisely what he did. He agreed that he had faxed it to Comsuper and that the original was to be forwarded by the pay office. In 2009, he undertook another period of CFTS but for more than 12 months, and his election was faxed to Comsuper by the Reserve cell at Headquarters. The Applicant was due to commence another period of CFTS of less than 12 months in March 2010. From the papers it appeared that on 28 November 2009 his election form was faxed to Comsuper, but he did not know precisely by whom. He said he thought he also mailed it to Comsuper. He was referred to records of telephone conversations noted in the Respondent’s papers that he had telephoned on 1, 9 and 14 December 2009 about his forms. He said that he telephoned in order to make sure the forms had been received before the Christmas stand-down period which would commence in mid-December. He wanted to ensure that his pension would continue over the holiday period. On 7 January 2010, it was confirmed that the forms had been received and he wanted to know when his pension would start. On 20 January 2010, he was informed that his pension would commence on 28 January 2010. The Applicant was asked in cross-examination about those earlier occasions when he had followed up with Comsuper, in particular in 2009, and he said that he was concerned because the pension was due to restart and he was anxious to have money over the holiday period. He undertook another period of CFTS for less than 12 months, from 17 January 2011. He says he had posted his election form to Comsuper. Before this period ended on about 9 May 2011, he was offered another period of CFTS for less than 12 months. He started preparing his paperwork, including his ‘D100’, the election form. The Applicant was to start on 24 May 2011, but the start date was postponed until a position against which his service was to be held could be identified. He was only informed shortly before 27 May 2011 that a position had been identified and he could start the following Monday, namely 30 May 2011.