PETER CRAIG METCALF and COMMONWEALTH SUPERANNUATION CORPORATION

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

[2012] AATA 261

Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION

File Number(s)

2011/4416

Re

PETER CRAIG METCALF

APPLICANT

And

COMMONWEALTH SUPERANNUATION CORPORATION

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Senior Member Dr K S Levy RFD

Date 4 May 2012
Place Brisbane

The decision under review is affirmed.

..................[Sgd]..........................................

Senior Member Dr K S Levy RFD

CATCHWORDS

PUBLIC ADMINISTRATION – Superannuation – Defence Force Retirements and Death Benefits – Periods of continuous full-time service – Election required to remain in Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Scheme – Automatic transfer to Military Superannuation and Benefits Scheme – Legislative interpretation – Decision under review affirmed 

LEGISLATION

Acts Interpretation Act 1901 (Cth) s 15AA

Defence Force Retirement and Benefits Act 1948 (Cth)
Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Act 1973 (Cth) ss 3, 5A, 23, 61B
Military Superannuation and Benefits Act 1991 (Cth) s 6

Superannuation Act 1976 (Cth)

CASES

CIC Insurance Ltd v Bankstown Football Club Ltd (1997) 141 ALR 618

Commissioner of Stamps v Telegraph Investment Co Pty Ltd (1995) 133 ALR 130
Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Authority v Gregory [2009] FCA 875
Defence Force Retirement and Death benefits Authority v Mathews [2011] FCA 160
Mills v Meeking (1990) 91 ALR 16
Project Blue Sky Inc v Australian Broadcasting Authority (1998) 153 ALR 490
Re Marston and Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Authority [2011] AATA 291
Re May v The Commissioner for Superannuation (1979) 2 ALD 951

Sweeney v Fitzhardinge (1906) 4 CLR 716

REASONS FOR DECISION

Senior Member Dr K S Levy RFD

4 May 2012

INTRODUCTION 

  1. The applicant is Commander Peter Craig Metcalf. He served in the Royal Australian Navy (RAN) for 33 years. After retiring, he received a retirement pension under s 23 of the Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Act 1973 (Cth) (the DFRDB Act). He later undertook two periods of continuous full time service (CFTS) and remained a member of the Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Scheme (DFRDB scheme) for both of those undertakings. Prior to completing the second period of CFTS, he undertook to perform a third period of service and completed the relevant form to elect DFRDB as his Superannuation Fund for that period. However, the form was not received by the Commonwealth Superannuation Corporation (CSC) until after he commenced that period of CFTS. He was then deemed to be a member of the Military Superannuation and Benefits scheme (MSB scheme).

  2. Commander Metcalf has now almost completed that third period of CFTS. Shortly after commencement of that period, he was advised by the CSC that as his election form for that period of CFTS was received after the commencement date of the present period of service, he could not be regarded as being a member of the DFRDB scheme for that period but, rather, he is deemed to be a member of the MSB scheme. He applied for review of that decision not to accept his application to be part of the DFRDB scheme to the Defence Force Case Assessment Panel. That review resulted in…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read PETER CRAIG METCALF and COMMONWEALTH SUPERANNUATION CORPORAT... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] AATA 261
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Peter Craig Metcalf and the Commonwealth Superannuation Corporation involved the interpretation of legislative provisions governing superannuation for members of the Defence Force. Specifically, the dispute centred around whether Commander Metcalf had effectively elected to remain in the Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits (DFRDB) scheme, or if he had inadvertently become a member of the Military Superannuation and Benefits (MSB) scheme. Commander Metcalf argued that he had completed the necessary D100 form to elect to remain in the DFRDB scheme but claimed that the form was not correctly received by the Commonwealth Superannuation Corporation (CSC). The tribunal had to determine if Commander Metcalf had made the election as required by the statutory provisions and if he was eligible to remain in the DFRDB scheme.

The primary legal issues were whether Commander Metcalf had made the necessary election under section 61B(3) of the DFRDB Act, and if his eligibility under section 5A(2) of the DFRDB Act meant he was an eligible member of the Defence Force, thus exempting him from the MSB scheme. The tribunal examined the statutory requirements and the content of the D100 form, which provided explicit instructions and warnings regarding the necessity to adhere to strict time requirements for the election to be valid.

The tribunal found that despite Commander Metcalf's early efforts to complete and submit the D100 form, he had failed to ensure the form was actually received by the CSC before commencing his continuous full-time service (CFTS) on 1 May 2011. The tribunal emphasised the importance of strict adherence to the statutory and procedural requirements, noting the clear legislative intent to place the responsibility on the member. As Commander Metcalf did not complete the form within the specified timeframe, the tribunal affirmed the decision that he had not made the election as required by law, thus becoming a member of the MSB scheme. Consequently, the tribunal upheld the decision under review, confirming that Commander Metcalf was not eligible to remain in the DFRDB scheme and was, by default, a member of the MSB scheme.

Background

Background to the litigation

The issue here is whether Commander Metcalf ceased to be a member of the DFRDB scheme with effect from the date of commencement of his present CFTS on 1 May 2011. In legal terms, there are two questions to be answered by the Tribunal:(1)Did Commander Metcalf elect not to be a member of the MSB scheme (s 61B(3) of the DFRDB Act); and(2)Is Commander Metcalf, an eligible member of the Defence Force for the purpose of the DFRDB Act (s 5A(2)) or is he, by default, a member of the MSB scheme?THE FACTS Commander Metcalf joined the RAN on 5 January 1970 and ceased service as an officer of 2 February 2003. He has since received retirement pay under s 23 of the DFRDB Act. He then undertook CFTS for the following periods:(1)29 October 2007 to 14 December 2009 – a period greater than two years;(2)15 December 2009 to 24 April 2010 – a period of less than 12 months; and(3)1 May 2011 to 20 April 2012- a period less than 12 months. By legislative action, the DFRDB scheme and the MSB scheme are now both managed by an overarching statutory authority, the Commonwealth Superannuation Corporation (CSC). Commander Metcalf told the Tribunal that he rang the CSC prior to completing the D100 form, the latter of which is required prior to commencement of a term of CFTS for his superannuation election to be relevant. He said the form was completed on 8 March 2011, a copy of which was provided to the Tribunal. There is no dispute that the form was completed on that date. Commander Metcalf said he then took the form to the orderly room and asked a Chief Petty Officer, a person in a responsible position, to fax that form (and another form) relevant to the period of service to the appropriate addressees. He recalled that his family had arranged a period where they would be away shortly after that date until the end of April 2011, and wanted to complete all the administration required before he ceased his second period of CFTS and prior to the commencement of the third period. He was advised by the Chief Petty Officer that not all the forms needed to be faxed. Commander Metcalf commenced the third period of CFTS on 1 May 2011 and he was stationed in Darwin from that date. On 9 May 2011, he spoke to a visiting representative of CSC and learned that CSC had not in fact received the election form which he completed on the 8 March 2011 (T-documents, folio 83). He then sent an email to the CSC on 9 May 2011 informing it of the facts. Also, on the same date, he telephoned Chief Petty Officer Lea and asked him to fax the form, which was then on file, to CSC. The D100 form completed by Commander Metcalf shows that Part C of the D100 form is relevant to a member receiving retirement pay and who is going to undertake a period of CFTS in the Reserve Forces for less than 12 months. That is the situation relevant to Commander Metcalf. There were two options available and he had to choose one election – either he agreed to join the MilitarySuper Scheme (an election which was then irreversible); or he could elect, for the period of that engagement only, to continue to received his DFRDB scheme retirement pay and remain with the DFRDB scheme. Commander Metcalf’s form showed he had elected not to become a member of MSB scheme but, rather, remain with the DFRDB scheme. He signed that election which was dated 8 March 2011. It is also noted that there was a declaration on that form, which the applicant acknowledged, that he would have to complete a separate election for any future periods of CFTS. However, if he joined the MSB scheme, then it was “final” and “irreversible”. These words are shown in bold type so that a member would be aware that if they chose the MSB scheme, then any future service would result in them having superannuation contributions managed by the MSB scheme.

Decision

Reasons for decision

While I accept Commander Metcalf as a witness of truth and appreciate he has a view that future reserve service will not be attractive if he loses his DFRDB pension while he performs that service, I must nevertheless determine the matter according to law. The law seems to me to be clear, taking the legislative scheme as a whole, and it shows that the relevant statutory provisions and the imperatives put in the D100 form have been inserted to urge the responsibility to be placed on the member and adherence to strict time requirements. Without such adherence to those requirements, member’s superannuation for future service will converge into the latest scheme for their future entitlements, that is, the MSB scheme. In this case, it cannot be said that the election has been satisfied as required by the statutory provisions, despite the early attention to the completion of the D100 form and the intention which the applicant had. DECISION The decision under review is affirmed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Part E of the D100 form deals with lodgement of the form. It states: It is your responsibility to send this completed form to DFRDB/MilitarySuper before resumption of service in the ADF. This form can be:Posted to: PO Box 22, BELCONNEN ACT 2616Faxed to: (02) 6272 9616. You must also send a copy of this form to your Pay Unit before resumption of service. Doing both of these things will help to ensure your election is valid, avoid possible overpayments and safeguard your entitlement to future benefits. CONSIDERATION I have considered all the evidence presented and the relevant law. The statutory scheme which applies in this case involve the following statutory provisions:Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Act 1973 (the DFRDB Act)61B Election by recipient member intending to resume full‑time service(1) Where a person:(a) who is a recipient member; or(b) in respect of whom deferred benefits are applicable under section 78;intends to resume full‑time service:(c) as a member of the Permanent Forces; or(d) as a member of a Reserve for a continuous period of not less than 12 months; the person must, before resuming service, in writing addressed to CSC, elect:(e) to become a contributing member; or(f) to become a member of the MSB scheme.(2) Subsection (1) does not apply if the person has previously:(a) made an election under that subsection; or(b) made, under subsection (3), an election to become a member of the MSB scheme.(3) A recipient member who:(a) intends to resume full‑time service as a member of a Reserve for a continuous period of less than 12 months; and(b) has not previously made, under this section, an election to become a member of the MSB scheme;must, before resuming service, in writing addressed to CSC, elect whether or not to become a member of that scheme.Military Superannuation and Benefits Act 1991 (the MSB Act)6 Membership of Superannuation Scheme(1) Subject to subsection (2), each of the following persons is, by force of this section, a member of the Scheme:(a) a member of the Permanent Forces;(b) a member of the Reserves who is rendering continuous full‑time service under an undertaking to serve for a period of not less than 12 months;(c) a member of the Reserves who is rendering continuous full‑time service under an undertaking to serve for a period of less than 12 months unless that member has elected not to become a member of the Scheme under section 61B of the DFRDB Act.(2) In spite of subsection (1), a person is not a member of the Scheme if the person is an eligible member of the Defence Force for the purposes of the DFRDB Act. For the purpose of s 6(2) of the MSB Act, a person is an “eligible member of the Defence Force” as defined in s 3 of the DFRDB Act. That definition encompasses a person in the position of Commander Metcalf, but does not include:…(c) a person who, under s 5A, is excluded from this definition. … Section 5A(1) of the DFRDB Act excludes a person who, broadly, becomes a member of the Defence Force on or after 1 October 1991. Section 5A(2)(b) however, says an exclusion will not apply to …(b) a person to whom s 61B applies and who has elected under that section to become a contributing member;…