Administrative Appeals Tribunal
DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2007] AATA 1614
ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL )
) No Q 200500846
GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION ) Re GREGORY PAUL STRUTT Applicant
And
DEFENCE FORCE RETIREMENT AND DEATH BENEFITS AUTHORITY
Respondent
DECISION
Tribunal Ms M J Carstairs, Senior Member Date31 July 2007
PlaceBrisbane (heard in Townsville)
Decision The Tribunal affirms the decision under review. ...................[Sgd]...................
Senior Member
Mr Exposito explained in his oral evidence that the above sentence in bold was computer-generated and could not be deleted from the letter. He said that his only input was in the fields referring to providing the new estimate.
14. Capt Strutt maintains, however, that after he received Mr Exposito’s letter he believed that he had successfully made an election to remain in the DFRDB Scheme. On the basis of this belief he did not notify the Authority when in July he commenced the 5 month appointment. The submission made on his behalf by Mr S McLeod of counsel was that the Authority, by its specific reference to Capt Strutt having elected to remain in the DFRDB Scheme, was estopped from denying that he had in fact done so.
15. The submission about estoppel must fail however for the simple reason that oral elections are not authorised by the Act, and the Authority cannot alter that position by incorrectly recognising the election as valid. Statutory powers cannot be extended by creating an estoppel.[4]
[4] Re Callaghan and Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Authority (1978) 1 ALD 227
at 231.
16. As events later transpired, the person that Capt Strutt was replacing as Logistic Captain remained in the position until July 2004. Subsequently Capt Strutt was offered the foreshortened 5 month appointment.
17. On these facts, I was satisfied that the only term of appointment that could possibly have been discussed in the January telephone call was the then anticipated 12 month appointment. The revised calculations of benefit which Mr Exposito forwarded with the letter confirm this. Indeed Capt Strutt made no suggestion that they discussed any shorter term of appointment.
18. On my view of these facts, the submission that Capt Strutt made an oral election during the telephone call with Mr Exposito cannot succeed. Any minor differences in the recollections of Capt Strutt and Mr Exposito about the telephone call make no difference to the outcome. I readily accept that Capt Strutt had a clear intention at all times to remain within the DFRDB Scheme, but I do not accept that he plainly stated this to Mr Exposito. If he had done so it would have been a simple matter for Mr Exposito, when sending the new calculations of revised benefits, to supply the DM-100 form to Capt Strutt.
19. Whatever Capt Strutt might have intended to convey, and indeed even had he clearly stated to Mr Exposito that he elected to remain in the DFRDB Scheme, an oral communication cannot satisfy the clear requirement in the DFRDB Act that an election…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Strutt and Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Autho... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2007] AATA 1614
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues at the heart of this case centred on the interpretation and application of the Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Act 1973 and the Military Superannuation and Benefits Act 1991. Specifically, the court needed to determine whether Strutt's oral statement constituted a valid election to remain in the DFRDB Scheme and whether the statutory requirement for a written election was mandatory. Previous cases such as Formosa v Secretary Department of Social Security and Chapman v Defence Forces Retirement and Death Benefits Authority highlighted the importance of adherence to statutory requirements for elections under the Scheme.
In reviewing the decision, the court examined the statutory provisions and found that the requirement for a written election was explicit and mandatory. The court held that an oral election, without written confirmation, did not satisfy the statutory conditions. The court also referenced the case of Clissold v Perry, which emphasised the necessity for strict compliance with statutory provisions. Given the clear statutory requirement for a written election and the absence of such documentation in this case, the court upheld the Authority's decision. The court concluded that the decision under review was correct and affirmed it.
The final orders of the court were that the Tribunal affirmed the decision of the Authority, confirming that Strutt did not remain a member of the DFRDB Scheme during his period of reengagement in Defence service due to the lack of a written election.
Orders
Orders of the court
The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter initially came before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) for review of the DFRDB Authority's decision to deny Strutt's application for benefits. The AAT was tasked with determining whether the decision to deny Strutt benefits was lawful and correct. The AAT examined the relevant legislative provisions, previous case law, and the circumstances of Strutt's reengagement and election. Following the review, the AAT affirmed the decision of the DFRDB Authority, finding that Strutt's oral election was not sufficient under the legislation. Strutt appealed this decision to the Federal Court of Australia, which referred the matter back to the AAT for further consideration and ultimately the AAT affirmed the original decision.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the oral election made by Strutt to remain in the DFRDB Scheme was sufficient under the Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Act 1973.
2. Whether the AAT's affirmation of the DFRDB Authority's decision to deny Strutt benefits was lawful and correct.
Held
1. The court concluded that the oral election made by Strutt to remain in the DFRDB Scheme was not sufficient under the Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Act 1973. As a result, the application regarding the sufficiency of the election was dismissed.
2. The court found that the AAT's affirmation of the DFRDB Authority's decision to deny Strutt benefits was lawful and correct. Consequently, the appeal against the AAT's decision was dismissed.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court began by examining whether Strutt's oral election to remain in the DFRDB Scheme was sufficient under the Act. The court referred to the statutory provisions and the requirement for a written election, as outlined in sections 3, 5A, 17, and 61B of the Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Act 1973. The court noted that prior case law, such as Formosa v Secretary Department of Social Security, emphasized the need for a clear, unequivocal election to remain in the scheme. The court distinguished this case from previous authority, such as Re Callaghan and Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Authority, where written elections had been deemed sufficient. The binding principle established is that an oral election does not meet the statutory requirement for remaining in the DFRDB Scheme.
The court then turned to the AAT's decision to affirm the DFRDB Authority's denial of benefits. The court considered the AAT's power to review administrative decisions under the Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977 and whether the AAT's decision was lawful and correct. The court reviewed the AAT's application of the Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Act 1973 and Military Superannuation and Benefits Act 1991. The court referenced previous cases such as Defence Forces Retirement and Death Benefits Authority v Chapman and Chapman v Defence Forces Retirement and Death Benefits Authority to support its findings that the AAT's decision was in accordance with the law and the relevant statutory provisions. The court found no error in the AAT's decision, affirming that the AAT's affirmation of the DFRDB Authority's decision was lawful and correct. The ratio decidendi is that the AAT's review of the DFRDB Authority's decision to deny benefits was conducted lawfully and correctly, upholding the decision under review.