Jack Gance and Mario Verrocchi v Ian Tauman

Link copied
Case Copied 37 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re:Oppositions by Jack Gance and Mario Verrocchi to registration of trade mark applications 1572995, 1572997, 1572998 all in Classes 35 and 42 – Direct Chemist Outlet/DCO Logos - filed in the name of Ian Tauman.

Delegate: Iain Campbell Thompson
Representation: Opponent: Peter Creighton-Selvay of Counsel instructed by Nicola Prestia of Rotstein Commercial Lawyers
Applicant: Ian Horak of Counsel instructed by Emma Mitchell of Sladen Legal
Decision: 2015 ATMO 118
s52 proceedings; sections 60 and 42(b); whether 42 ground should be decided after related Federal Court decision; s60 and 42(b) not established; neither section 60 nor 42(b) established.
Request for full costs - costs awarded against Opponent as per Schedule

Background

  1. These matters proceed under the Trade Marks Act 1995 (‘the Act’) and concern the three applications (‘the Applications’) for registration of trade marks filed by Ian Tauman (‘the Applicant’) which appear below:

Application No:  1572995
Priority Date:  6 August 2013
Services:  Class 35: Pharmacy retail services

Class 44: Pharmacy advice; Pharmacy advisory services; Pharmacy dispensary services

Trade Mark:  

Application No:  1572997
Priority Date:  6 August 2013
Services:  Class 35: Pharmacy retail services

Class 44: Pharmacy advice; Pharmacy advisory services; Pharmacy dispensary services

Trade Mark:  

Application No:  1572998
Priority Date:  6 August 2013
Services:  Class 35: Pharmacy retail services

Class 44: Pharmacy advice; Pharmacy advisory services; Pharmacy dispensary services

Trade Mark:  

  1. I will refer to the above services and trade marks as ‘the Services’ and ‘the Trade Marks’.

  2. The Applications were examined as is mandated by section 31 of the Act and the Trade Marks were advertised as accepted for possible registration in the Australian Official Journal of Trade Marks on 9 January 2014.

  3. On 7 March 2014 Jack Gance and Mario Verrocchi (‘the Opponents’) filed Notices of Intention to Oppose, followed by Statements of Grounds and Particulars (‘SGP’) on 7 April 2014. The grounds stated are under section 60 and subparagraph 42(b) of the Act as follows:

    Trade mark is similar to a trade mark which has acquired a reputation in Australia - Section 60

    Trade Mark No. 1197039 (Registered 4 September 2007)

    Trade Mark No. 1277739 (Registered 17 December 2008)

    Trade mark is scandalous or contrary to law - Section 42

    The use of the Applicant's Trade Mark in the colours designated would cause a not-insignificant proportion of the public to be misled into believing that the Applicant is or was associated with the Opponents or associated with the Opponents being the owners of the Chemist Warehouse chain of pharmacies and use of the Trade Mark by the Applicant will breach section 18 of Schedule 2 of the Australian Consumer Law.

  4. On 22 May 2014 the Applicant filed Notices of Intention to Defend.

  5. Thereafter, the parties have filed their evidence (which I further discuss below) as allowed by the Trade Mark Regulations 1995 (‘the Regulations’).

  6. Both parties requested to be heard and the matters came before me as a delegate of the Registrar…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Jack Gance and Mario Verrocchi v Ian Tauman and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] ATMO 118
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned oppositions to trade mark applications brought by Ian Tauman (the Applicant) against Jack Gance and Mario Verrocchi (the Opponents). The court was required to determine whether the grounds on which the Opponents opposed the registration of the Applicant's trade marks had been established. The evidence filed included declarations from the parties, with one declaration from the Applicant being excluded as it concerned an appeal to the Full Bench of the Federal Court.

The central legal issue was whether the Opponents had successfully established any grounds for opposing the registration of the Applicant's trade marks. This involved assessing the extent to which the grounds of opposition, as provided for under section 55 of the relevant Act, had been proven by the evidence. The court considered the extensive use and advertising of the Opponents' "Chemist Warehouse" trade mark and associated get-up, particularly through catalogues, in its decision-making process.

The court found that the oppositions had not been established in relation to the trade marks. Consequently, the Registrar was directed to register the trade marks, subject to certain conditions. The trade mark applications were to proceed to registration one month from the date of the decision, unless notice of appeal had been served, in which case registration would be deferred pending the outcome of any appeal. The Applicant was awarded costs against the Opponents, with the costs in two of the oppositions to be taxed at 20% of scale.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The evidence filed by the parties in these matters comprises the following declarations:Evidence relied on by OpponentsMario Verrocchi made on 28 August 2014.Hamish Rostein made on 13 March 2015.Evidence relied on by ApplicantIan Tauman made on 1 December 2014 Emma Kate Mitchell made on 10 November 2015. The latter declaration is one under regulation 21.19 and concerns the appeal to the Full Bench of the Federal Court, a matter about which I had already informed myself. I therefore do not admit the latter declaration into evidence. Mario Verrocchi is one of the Opponents and his declaration goes to the development or evolution of the Opponents’ Chemist Warehouse trade mark in 2002 (‘the Warehouse trade mark’) via prior use and registration of the trade mark ‘Chemistop’ (which is only of incidental interest in these decisions). This business has grown considerably and at the relevant date there were some 259 Chemist Warehouse retail outlets in Australia. There are now several registrations in Australia of the Warehouse trade marks as is detailed below: The Opponents have also extensively advertised through catalogues – “hundreds of millions” in the words of Mr Creighton-Selvay have been distributed as fold-ins with newspapers, directly placed into letterboxes or thrown at driveways. It is worth noting the use of the Warehouse trade mark and associated get-up in those catalogues at this juncture as this feeds into my decision in relation to subparagraph 42(b): The above are, in my assessment, representative of the ways in which the Opponents use its Warehouse trade mark and the surrounding get-up in its catalogues. Mr Verrocchi also particularises the appearance of the Warehouse trade mark on, and get-up of, the Opponents’ shopfronts:[4][4] These examples are from Verrocchi. Mr Verrocchi states of the catalogue advertising by the Opponents:Catalogues are the main form of external marketing used by the Chemist Warehouse Network.Since about September 2002, the Chemist Warehouse Network has distributed catalogues every four (4) to six (6) weeks which feature the Chemist Warehouse Colour Scheme (Chemist Warehouse Catalogues) in areas where Chemist Warehouse stores are located. Exhibit MV-14 contains samples of Chemist Warehouse Catalogues distributed nationally across each Australian state and territory each month or so, for each year from 2003 to 2014 inclusive.In addition to the usual Chemist Warehouse Catalogues which are distributed nationally each four to six weeks or so, whenever a new Chemist Warehouse store is opened, the new store catalogues are distributed to between 50,000 and 100,000 households in and around the surrounding suburbs nearest to the new Chemist Warehouse store (Store Opening Catalogues). Exhibit MV-15 contains samples of Store Opening Catalogues for each of the years 2003 to 2014, which each predominantly feature the Chemist Warehouse Colour Scheme.Between September and December 2002, every four (4) to six (6) weeks a total of approximately 100,000 Chemist Warehouse Catalogues displaying the Chemist Warehouse Colour Scheme were distributed on behalf of the Chemist Warehouse Network.In 2003, every four (4) to six (6) weeks, a total of approximately 200,000 Chemist Warehouse Catalogues displaying the Chemist Warehouse Colour Scheme were distributed on behalf of the Chemist Warehouse Network.In 2004, every four (4) to six (6) weeks, a total of approximately 400,000 Chemist Warehouse Catalogues displaying the Chemist Warehouse Colour Scheme were distributed on behalf of the Chemist Warehouse Network.In 2005, every four (4) to six (6) weeks, a total of approximately 1,200,000 Chemist Warehouse Catalogues displaying the Chemist Warehouse Colour Scheme were distributed on behalf of the Chemist Warehouse Group.In 2006, every four (4) to six (6) weeks, a total of approximately 2,000,000 Chemist Warehouse Catalogues displaying the Chemist Warehouse Colour Scheme were distributed by the Chemist Warehouse Network.In 2007, every four (4) to six (6) weeks, a total of approximately 2,500,000 Chemist Warehouse Catalogues displaying the Chemist Warehouse Colour Scheme were distributed by the Chemist Warehouse Group NetworkIn 2008, every four (4) to six (6) weeks, a total of approximately 4,000,000 Chemist Warehouse Catalogues displaying the Chemist Warehouse Colour Scheme were distributed by the Chemist Warehouse Network.In 2009, every four (4) to six (6) weeks, a total of approximately 5,000,000 Chemist Warehouse catalogues displaying the Chemist Warehouse Colour Scheme were distributed by the Chemist Warehouse Network.In 2010, every four (4) to six (6) weeks, a total of approximately 5,000,000 Chemist Warehouse catalogues displaying the Chemist Warehouse Colour Scheme were distributed by the Chemist Warehouse Network.In 2011, every four (4) to six (6) weeks, a total of approximately 5,500,000 Chemist Warehouse catalogues displaying the Chemist Warehouse Colour Scheme were distributed by the Chemist Warehouse Network.In 2012, every four (4) to six (6) weeks, a total of approximately 6,000,000 Chemist Warehouse catalogues displaying the Chemist Warehouse Colour Scheme were distributed by the Chemist Warehouse Network.In 2013, every four (4) to six (6) weeks, a total of approximately 7,000,000 Chemist Warehouse catalogues displaying the Chemist Warehouse Colour Scheme were distributed by the Chemist Warehouse Network.The current distribution of Catalogues means that we effectively cover nearly every household in urban areas and all major regional towns throughout Australia on a very regular basis.The Chemist Warehouse Network has since 2002 spent tens of millions of dollars on printing the Chemist Warehouse Catalogues for distribution in each Australian state and territory.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Section 55 of the Act relevantly provides:55Decision(1)Unless subsection (3) applies to the proceedings, the Registrar must, at the end, decide:(a)to refuse to register the trade mark; or(b)to register the trade mark (with or without conditions or limitations) in respect of the goods and/or services then specified in the application;having regard to the extent (if any) to which any ground on which the application was opposed has been established.Note:For limitations see section 6. The oppositions have not been established in relation to the Trade Marks. Trade mark applications 1572995, 1572997, and 1572998 may then proceed to registration one month from the date of this decision. If the Registrar has been served with notice(s) of appeal before that time, I direct that the registration(s) shall not occur until the appeal(s) has/have been decided or discontinued and that the disposition of the applications should be in accordance with the Court’s order or direction. The Applicant requested its full costs in relation to these matters on the basis that it has been most unlikely that the opposition could prevent registration of the Trade Marks. However, I see no reason to depart from the costs as specified in Schedule 8 of the Regulations. Having been successful, the Applicant is entitled to those costs which I award against the Opponents with the costs in the second and third oppositions to be taxed at 20% of scale (per Hume Industries (Malaysia) Berhard v James Hardie & Coy Pty Ltd[10]).[10] (2001) 53 IPR 591.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.