Italiano v The Water Corporation [No 2]

Link copied
Case Copied 92 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

IN CIVIL

CITATION:   ITALIANO -v- THE WATER CORPORATION [No 2] [2020] WASC 112

CORAM:   KENNETH MARTIN J

HEARD:   25 - 28 NOVEMBER 2019

DELIVERED          :   6 APRIL 2020

FILE NO/S:   CIV 1976 of 2016

BETWEEN:   ANTONIO ROCCO ITALIANO

ANGELINA ITALIANO

Plaintiffs

AND

THE WATER CORPORATION

Defendant


Catchwords:

Land resumption - Compensation dispute - Public work - Speculative premium sought above highest and best use value for resumed portion of land - Adjoining land issue - Town planners - Valuers - Disagreement over speculative component premium based on possibility of relaxation of zoning regime to permit multiple smaller sized hobby farms

Legislation:

Land Administration Act 1997 (WA)
Water Agencies (Powers) Act 1984 (WA)

Result:

Compensation awarded in the sum of $160,380

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Plaintiffs : Mr P Lochore
Defendant : Mr K de Kerloy & Mr C Hicks

Solicitors:

Plaintiffs : JNC Legal
Defendant : Herbert Smith Freehills

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

Arcus Shopfitters Pty Ltd v Western Australian Planning Commissioner [2002] WASC 174; (2002) 125 LGERA 180

Beard v Director of Housing (Tasmania) [1961] Tas SR 141

Boland v Yates Property Corporation Pty Ltd [1999] HCA 64; (1999) 167 ALE 575

C A MacDonald v South Australian Railways Commissioner (1911) 12 CLR 221

Commissioner of Succession Duties (South Australia) v Executor Trustee & Agency Company of South Australia Ltd (1947) 74 CLR 358

Cook & Edwards v City of Stirling (1991) 4 WAR 469

Davis Properties Pty Ltd v Roads and Traffic Authority of New South Wales [1995] NSWLEC 172 (18 December 1995)

De Ieso v Commissioner of Highways South Australia (1981) 27 SASR 248

Housing Commission of New South Wales v San Sebastian Pty Ltd (1978) 140 CLR 196

Kelliher v Commissioner for Main Roads [No 2] [2015] WASC 478

Kirela Pty Ltd v Minister administering the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979 [2003] NSWLEC 135

Marshall v Director-General, Department of Transport [2001] HCA 37; (2001) 205 CLR 603

Marshall v Metropolitan Region Redevelopment Authority [2015] WASC 226

McKay v Commissioner of Main Roads [2013] WASCA 135

McKay v Commissioner of Main Roads [No 7] [2011] WASC 223

McKenna v Municipality of Burnie [1970] Tas SR 279

Merrick Tyler Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Main Roads [2015] WASCA 82

Merrick Tyler Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Main Roads [2019] WASC 166

Mount Lawley Pty Ltd v Western Australian Planning Commission [2004] WASCA 149; (2004) 29 WAR 273

Mount Lawley Pty Ltd v Western Australian Planning Commission [2007] WASCA 226; (2007) 34 WAR 449

Pointe Gourde Quarrying and Transport Co v Sub Intendent of Crown Lands (Trinidad) [1947] AC 565

Port Stephens Shire Council v Tellamist Pty Ltd [2004] NSWCA 353; (2004) 135 LGERA 98

Queensland v Murphy [1990] HCA 42; (1990) 95 ALJR 493

R v Compensation Court of Western Australia (1990) 2 WAR 242

Spencer v The Commonwealth (1907) 5 CLR 418

Trandos v Western Australian Planning Commission [2001] WASCA 346

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Italiano v The Water Corporation [No 2] and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] WASC 112
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Italiano v The Water Corporation [No 2] involved a dispute over the compensation for land resumed for a public work. The plaintiffs, who had previously received an advance payment of compensation, sought additional compensation on the basis of a speculative component. This component was predicated on the possibility that the zoning regime would be relaxed to permit multiple smaller sized hobby farms on the resumed land. The court was required to decide the issue of whether the plaintiffs' lots met the statutory criteria of adjoining land, and whether the speculative premium sought by the plaintiffs exceeded the highest and best use value for the resumed portion of the land.

The legal issues before the court were primarily focused on the interpretation of the statutory provisions under the Land Administration Act 1977 (WA) and the valuation of the speculative component of the compensation. The court had to determine whether the plaintiffs' lots were adjoining land, and if so, what the appropriate compensation should be for such land. Additionally, the court had to consider the expert evidence presented by the parties' rival expert planners and valuers, and decide whether the speculative premium claimed by the plaintiffs was justified.

In resolving these issues, the court found that two of the plaintiffs' lots, namely lot 553 and lot 3120, did meet the statutory criteria of adjoining land, while lot 997 did not. The court accepted the plaintiffs' arguments that the Water Corporation's valuation of the speculative component was insufficient, and awarded the plaintiffs an additional $160,380 in compensation. This award was based on the court's conclusion that the speculative premium sought by the plaintiffs did not exceed the highest and best use value for the resumed portion of the land.

In summary, the court found in favour of the plaintiffs, awarding them an additional $160,380 in compensation for the adjoining land issue and rejecting the speculative premium claim. This decision was based on the court's interpretation of the statutory provisions and its consideration of the expert evidence presented by the parties.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the wake of my reasons delivered 6 April 2020 I found for the plaintiffs in the additional amount of $160,380: see Italiano v The Water Corporation [No 2] [2020] WASC 112 (primary reasons). That conclusion essentially followed from my conclusions resolving the parties' disagreement over whether three of the plaintiffs' lots met the description of 'adjoining land' for the purposes of engaging with the compensatory criteria under s 241(7)(b) of the Land Administration Act 1977 (WA) (the LAA). The trial was conducted on the basis of the parties' quantitative agreement in respect of all potential contingent outcomes upon the substantive issues between them under the Compensation Table - being exhibit 16 (Annexure A to the primary reasons). Because of that agreement the $160,380 outcome essentially reflected the conclusions resulting from a resolution of the adjoining land issue - which I described at various places within the reasons as a 'secondary issue'. Overwhelmingly, however, the primary and substantial issue at the trial concerned the plaintiffs' failed pursuit of what it sought as additional compensation on the basis of its claim for a 'speculative component' of extra compensation. It will be remembered that the plaintiffs had already received $1,017,500 as compensation paid over by the defendant (Water Corporation) in April 2012, under the regime for that advance payment to be received as provided by s 248 of the LAA. Including interest, that sum now sits at $1,185,262. As the primary reasons display, the plaintiffs' claim for that extra speculative component compensation amount (which, had I accepted the plaintiffs' arguments, would have been quantitatively agreed at the amount of $1,156,453) was, overwhelmingly, the economically significant and substantively complex issue (both as to fact, law and by all the disputed expert evidence submitted between the parties' rival expert planners and valuers) at the four-day trial. In the end result, the secondary issue came to be determined in relatively straightforward fashion - seen at between [58] - [72] of the primary reasons. In short, the plaintiffs were successful in establishing, contrary to the Water Corporation's argument, that two of the three lots then in dispute, namely lot 553 and lot 3120, did meet the statutory threshold of characterisation as adjoining land. By reference to the agreed Compensation Table, success for the plaintiffs in respect of that adjoining land determination carried with it an as agreed economic worth of $200,000 (being agreed amounts of $100,000 each as regards lot 553 and lot 3120). However, as regards this secondary aspect of the trial, I did not accept the plaintiffs' arguments that their lot 997 met the statutory criteria of adjoining land. The economic end consequence of that conclusion was agreed at resulting in the plaintiffs not being entitled to an additional $30,000 (again see the Compensation Table). As can be expressly discerned from [58] - [72] of the primary reasons, the arguments and conclusions upon the adjoining land issue, were in the context of the trial as a whole, a relatively minor aspect of the parties' trial disagreements. There had been no dispute at trial that the plaintiffs' other three lots, making up its (six lots in all) escarpment dairy farm (namely, other lots 500, 502 and 265), all met the description of adjoining land.