Bakota v City of Wanneroo

Link copied
Case Copied 78 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

CITATION:   BAKOTA -v- CITY OF WANNEROO [2022] WASC 462

CORAM:   CURTHOYS J

HEARD:   22 - 25 AUGUST 2022, 5 - 7, 13 SEPTEMBER 2022

DELIVERED          :   23 DECEMBER 2022

FILE NO/S:   CIV 1145 of 2015

BETWEEN:   IVAN BAKOTA

RUZICA BAKOTA

Plaintiffs

AND

CITY OF WANNEROO

Defendant


Catchwords:

Resumption and acquisition of land - Compensation under s 241 of the Land Administration Act 1997 (WA) - Valuation of land - Knowledge of the hypothetical Spencer parties - Highest and best use of land

Resumption and acquisition of land - Injurious affection - Proper construction of s 241(7) of the Act - Whether damage to remaining land caused by the carrying out of the public work or the proposal to carry out the public work

Legislation:

Land Administration Act 1997 (WA), s 241

Result:

Compensation awarded plus interest

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Plaintiffs : P G McGowan & L E Rowley
Defendant : P D Lochore

Solicitors:

Plaintiffs : Rowley Legal
Defendant : Castledine Gregory

Cases referred to in decision:

Bombara [2021] WASAT 141

Cairns City Council v CMB No 1 Pty Ltd (1997) 96 LGERA 306

Cerini v Minister for Transport [2001] WASC 309

Coastal Estates v Bass Shire Council [1993] 2 VR 566

Commissioner of Highways v Shipp Bros Pty Ltd (1978) 19 SASR 215

De Ieso v Commissioner of Highways (1981) 27 SASR 248

Greenslade v Hiew [2022] WASCA 47

Italiano v Water Corporation [No 2] [2020] WASC 112

Kelliher v Commissioner for Main Roads [No 2] [2015] WASC 478

Kelly v Western Australian Planning Commission [2006] WASC 208

Lenz v Commissioner of Main Roads [2012] WASC 6

Longford v Commissioner of Stamp Duties (1953) SR 53 (NSW) 342

McKay v Commissioner of Main Roads [No 7] [2011] WASC 223

Mir Bros Unit Constructions Pty Ltd v Roads and Traffic Authority of NSW [2005] NSWLEC 467

Mir Bros v RTA NSW [2006] NSWCA 314

Mount Lawley Pty Ltd v Western Australian Planning Commission [2006] WASC 82

Parramatta City Council v Valuer-General (1965) 10 LGRA 160

Pollock v Wellington (1996) 15 WAR 1

Pownal v Conlan Management Pty Ltd (1995) 12 WAR 370

Pringle v Minister [1968] 1 NSWR 509; (1967) 14 LGRA 280

Roads and Traffic Authority of NSW v Hurstville City Council [2001] NSWCA 11; (2001) 112 LGERA 223

Royal Sydney Golf Club v Federal Commissioner of Taxation [1955] HCA 13; (1955) 91 CLR 610

Spencer v The Commonwealth [1907] HCA 82; (1907) 5 CLR 418

Transport for NSW v Eureka Operations Pty Ltd [2022] NSWCA 56

Western Australian Planning Commission v Arcus Shopfitters Pty Ltd [2003] WASCA 295

Western Australian Planning Commission v Kelly [2007] WASCA 160

CURTHOYS J:

Introduction

  1. This case concerns a claim by the plaintiffs, Ivan and Ruzica Bakota, for a claim for compensation under s 241 of the Land Administration Act 1997 (WA) (LAA). The claim concerns the taking of an area of 5,847 sqm of the Bakotas' land at 185 Mary…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bakota v City of Wanneroo and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] WASC 462
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Ivan and Ruzica Bakota commenced proceedings against the City of Wanneroo seeking compensation for the taking of an area of 5,847 sqm of their land by the City. The City counterclaimed that it had overpaid the amount of compensation and sought a return of the excess amount. The City admitted that it had taken the land but contested the amount of compensation payable. The City accepted the Bakotas' submissions that the highest and best use of the land was potential for residential subdivision. The City also accepted that the Bakotas had sustained loss by reason of the taking. The City contested the amount of compensation payable and the City's counterclaim was dismissed. The court found primarily for the Bakotas and ordered that the City pay the Bakotas' costs of the action to be taxed if not agreed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Ivan and Ruzica Bakota, the plaintiffs, brought a claim for compensation under s 241 of the Land Administration Act 1997 (WA) against the City of Wanneroo, the defendant. The claim concerns the taking of an area of 5,847 square meters of the Bakotas' land at 185 Mary Street, Wanneroo, by the City for the purpose of extending Lenore Road. The land taken was a roughly triangular portion on the south-west corner of the plaintiffs' land, effectively landlocked the remaining land, and reduced its access to Mary Street. This significantly impacted the future sub-divisibility of the remaining land, which had been used as a market garden since 1985. The City made an advance payment of compensation to the Bakotas of $1,156,850.07 on 4 September 2012, but now asserts that it has overpaid and counterclaims for the alleged overpaid amount. The Bakotas also claim compensation for the demolition of their residence in a shed on the land, which was used without proper council approval for residential purposes.

The case was heard by Curthoys J in the Supreme Court of Western Australia. The hearings took place from 22 to 25 August 2022, and from 5 to 7 and 13 September 2022. The decision was delivered on 23 December 2022. The matter was filed under the number CIV 1145 of 2015. The plaintiffs were represented by counsel P G McGowan and L E Rowley, and solicitors Rowley Legal. The defendant was represented by counsel P D Lochore, and solicitors Castledine Gregory.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. What is the value of the land taken by the City of Wanneroo, and how should it be determined under s 241(2) of the Land Administration Act 1997 (WA)?
2. Are the plaintiffs entitled to compensation for the loss of their residence in the shed on the taken land, and if so, how much?
3. Are the plaintiffs entitled to compensation for the disruption and reinstatement of their business due to the taking of the land under s 241(6)(b) of the Act?
4. Are the plaintiffs entitled to compensation for severance and injurious affection under s 241(7) of the Act?
5. What amount of solatium, if any, should be awarded to the plaintiffs under s 241(8) and (9) of the Act?
6. Are the plaintiffs entitled to interest on the compensation awarded under s 241(11) and (12) of the Act?

Held
1. The value of the land taken by the City of Wanneroo is determined to be $643,170, assessed as on the date of the taking.
2. The plaintiffs are not entitled to compensation for the loss of their residence in the shed on the taken land.
3. The plaintiffs are entitled to compensation for the disruption and reinstatement of their business in the amount of $239,708.
4. The plaintiffs are entitled to compensation for severance and injurious affection in the amount of $2,851,402.
5. The plaintiffs are entitled to solatium in the amount of $373,427.67.
6. The plaintiffs are entitled to interest on the compensation awarded from the date of the taking until the part payment by the City and on the balance from the date of payment until judgment at 6% per annum.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the value of the land taken under s 241(2) of the Land Administration Act 1997 (WA), applying the Spencer hypothetical to assess the value as if a prudent, well-informed, and willing purchaser and vendor would have agreed on the price on the taking date. The court found the evidence of the plaintiffs' expert, Mr Hajigabriel, more reliable than that of the defendant's expert, Ms Butterworth, in determining the highest and best use of the land and the time frame for rezoning and subdivision. The court accepted Mr Hajigabriel's opinion that the land had potential for residential subdivision and that it would take five to seven years to achieve this, rather than the twelve to fourteen years proposed by Ms Butterworth.

Regarding the severance and injurious affection claim under s 241(7) of the Act, the court found that the taking of the land effectively landlocked the remaining land, making its highest and best use rural rather than urban. The court accepted the evidence of the plaintiffs' expert, Mr Chapman, over that of the defendant's expert, Mr Zucal, in valuing the land and determining the extent of the damage caused by the taking.

The court found that the plaintiffs were not entitled to compensation for the loss of their residence in the shed on the taken land, as their occupation of the shed for residential purposes was illegal and contrary to the Health Act. The court also rejected the plaintiffs' claim for removal expenses related to the demolition of the shed.

In determining the amount of solatium under s 241(8) and (9) of the Act, the court considered the exceptional circumstances of the case and awarded 10% of the total compensation amount.

Lastly, the court awarded interest on the compensation from the date of the taking until the part payment by the City and on the balance from the date of payment until judgment at 6% per annum, as provided for in s 241(11) and (12) of the Act.