Administrative Appeals Tribunal
DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2012] AATA 374
ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL )
) No 2012/0196
GENERAL APPEALS DIVISION ) Re BYRON ISSA Applicant
And
AUSTRALIAN COMMUNITY PHARMACY AUTHORITY
Respondent
And
SARAH DEAS, JOHN FORSYTH & ROBERT WOOD
Other Party
DECISION
Tribunal The Honourable Justice Logan RFD, Presidential Member
Date8 June 2012
PlaceBrisbane
Decision The Tribunal decides the following as a preliminary question:
Question : The preliminary question is whether the Tribunal may, when conducting the review, receive from the Applicant material which was not lodged with the approval application or later requested by the Authority?
Answer: The Tribunal may receive further material from the Applicant, but only if the Tribunal so requests. Whether the Tribunal makes such a request will depend on the circumstances of the particular case.
..............................................
Presidential Member
4. Mr Issa has sought the review by the Tribunal of the Authority’s recommendation decision pursuant to s 105AD(2)(a), of the Act. Section 105AD provides materially:
Application for review by Tribunal of decisions of the Australian Community Pharmacy Authority
(1) In this section:
“Authority” means the Australian Community Pharmacy Authority.
“reviewable recommendation” means a recommendation of the Authority referred to paragraph (2)(a) or (aa).(2)An application may be made to the Tribunal for review of the following recommendations of the Authority:
(a)a recommendation made under subparagraph 99K(1)(b)(i) that an applicant under section 90 not be approved under that section in respect of particular premises;
(aa)a recommendation made under subparagraph 99K(1)(b)(ii) as to the conditions (if any) to which an approval under section 90 should be subject.
5. The Determination includes a provision, s 9, in these terms:
Information to be considered by Authority
The Authority may consider information provided by an applicant only if:
(a) the information as given at the time the application was made; or
(b) the Authority requested the information.
6. Section 9 has not hitherto been the subject of consideration, either by the Tribunal or for that matter the Federal Court, as to its meaning. The question as to what is the true meaning of s 9 is one which has an importance, not just in this case but also, having regard to the pervasive application of s 9, in other cases. For these reasons the applicant, Mr Issa, the Authority, and Messrs and Ms Deas, Forsyth, and Wood, who are other interested parties to the review application, have requested the Tribunal to determine, as a preliminary issue on the review application, the question as to whether, having regard to s 9 in the Determination, the Tribunal can receive from the applicant and consider on the review evidence that was not before the Authority at the time when the Authority made the decision under review?
7. Such is the potential impact of the true construction of s 9 of the Determination on this review application, as well as having regard to the wider importance of the construction question, I am persuaded that it is appropriate to…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Issa and Australian Community Pharmacy Authority and Anor and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2012] AATA 374
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the Tribunal revolved around the scope and flexibility of the review process, specifically whether the Tribunal could consider additional material from the applicant that was not initially provided. This involved interpreting the relevant statutory provisions and case law to establish the parameters within which the Tribunal could operate. The core issue was whether the Tribunal had the authority to request and accept additional material from the applicant and what criteria should guide such a decision.
The Tribunal concluded that it had the discretion to request and receive additional material from the applicant but only if it explicitly made such a request. The decision on whether to make a request would depend on the specific circumstances of each case. This approach balanced the need for a thorough review with the importance of maintaining procedural fairness and consistency. The Tribunal's decision provided clarity on the scope of its powers and set out a practical framework for handling supplementary submissions during the review process.
The Tribunal's final orders were that it may receive additional material from the applicant if it explicitly requested it, with the decision to make such a request being guided by the particular circumstances of the case. This ruling provided a clear guideline for future proceedings, ensuring that the review process could be both comprehensive and fair.
Orders
Orders of the court
The Tribunal decides the following as a preliminary question:
Question : The preliminary question is whether the Tribunal may, when conducting the review, receive from the Applicant material which was not lodged with the approval application or later requested by the Authority?
Answer: The Tribunal may receive further material from the Applicant, but only if the Tribunal so requests. Whether the Tribunal makes such a request will depend on the circumstances of the particular case.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter was brought before the Tribunal to determine a preliminary question regarding the scope of material that could be received during the review of Issa's application for approval to supply pharmaceutical benefits. The Tribunal was asked to decide whether it could accept additional material from Issa that was not part of the original approval application or subsequently requested by the Authority. This decision arose in the context of the ongoing review process initiated by the Authority.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the Tribunal may, when conducting the review, receive from the Applicant material which was not lodged with the approval application or later requested by the Authority?
2. If so, under what conditions may the Tribunal receive such material?
Held
1. The Tribunal may receive further material from the Applicant only if the Tribunal so requests.
2. Whether the Tribunal makes such a request will depend on the circumstances of the particular case.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In addressing the preliminary question of whether the Tribunal may receive from the Applicant material which was not lodged with the approval application or later requested by the Authority, the Tribunal first considered the statutory framework governing the review process. The relevant legislation did not explicitly preclude the Tribunal from receiving additional material from the Applicant during the review process. Therefore, the Tribunal concluded that it has the discretion to request further material if necessary, but this decision is contingent on the specific circumstances of each case. The Tribunal noted that while it is not bound to request additional material, it may do so if it deems it necessary to fully understand the issues at hand.
The Tribunal then examined case law and precedent to ascertain how similar tribunals have approached this issue. It found that there was no binding authority directly addressing whether a tribunal may request additional material from an applicant in the context of a pharmaceutical benefits approval application. Consequently, the Tribunal had to determine the appropriate approach based on general principles of fairness and procedural justice.
In doing so, the Tribunal underscored the importance of ensuring that all relevant information is considered to make an informed decision. It reasoned that fairness to the Applicant, as well as the need for a comprehensive understanding of the application, may necessitate the request for additional material. However, the Tribunal emphasised that such requests should not be made lightly and must be justified by the circumstances of the particular case. This balanced approach ensures that the review process is both thorough and fair.
The Tribunal also considered the potential impact of requesting additional material on the timeliness and efficiency of the review process. While it acknowledged the importance of timely decisions, it concluded that fairness to the Applicant and the need for a comprehensive assessment could, in some cases, justify a request for additional material. The Tribunal thus established that it may request further material from the Applicant if the circumstances warrant it, but such requests will be made on a case-by-case basis.
In summary, the Tribunal found that it has the discretion to request additional material from the Applicant, but this power must be exercised judiciously and in accordance with the specific circumstances of each case. This decision ensures a fair and comprehensive review process while maintaining the efficiency of the tribunal's operations.