Hala Phcy Pty Ltd and Australian Community Pharmacy Authority

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

Hala Phcy Pty Ltd and Australian Community Pharmacy Authority [2022] AATA 2155 (7 July 2022)

AppID:  Hala Phcy Pty Ltd and Australian Community Pharmacy Authority

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2021/8092

Re:Hala Phcy Pty Ltd  

APPLICANT

AndAustralian Community Pharmacy Authority 

RESPONDENT

AndBourke O’Brien Pharmacies Pty Ltd

OTHER PARTY

DECISION

Tribunal:Deputy President J W Constance 

Date:7 July 2022  

Place:Sydney

The decision under review, being the decision of the Australian Community Pharmacy Authority made 3 September 2021, is affirmed.

................................[SGD].................................

Deputy President J W Constance

CATCHWORDS

HEALTH – PHARMACISTS – application for approval to supply pharmaceutical benefits – whether there is a supermarket with gross leasable area of 1,000 square metres within prescribed distance of proposed premises – consideration of Pharmacy Authority Rules – construction of the definition of supermarket as defined by the Rules – meaning of "range” of foods, beverages, groceries and other domestic goods – context and purpose of Rules – decision affirmed

LEGISLATION

National Health Act 1953 (Cth)

National Health (Australian Community Pharmacy Authority Rules) Determination 2018 (Cth)

National Health (Australian Community Pharmacy Authority Rules) Determination 2006 (Cth)

CASES

Independent Commission Against Corruption and Cunneen and Others (2015) 256 CLR 1

Issa and Australian Community Pharmacy Authority and Others [2012] AATA 374

Project Blue Sky v Australian Broadcasting Authority (1998) 194 CLR 355

Stonehealth Pty Ltd and ZAA Ventures Pty Ltd as Trustee for ZAA Investment Trust and Australian Community Pharmacy Authority [2020] FCAFC 188

Vincentia MC Pharmacy Pty Ltd v Australian Community Authority [2020] FCAFC 16

Walkerden v Wodonga Pharmacy Pty Ltd [2015] FCA 273

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President J W Constance

7 July 2022

INTRODUCTION

  1. In July 2021 the Applicant lodged an application under the National Health Act 1953 (Cth) for approval to supply pharmaceutical benefits from premises in a shopping centre in Warners Bay, New South Wales.[1] 

    [1] Exhibit R1 at 173.

  2. In accordance with procedures set out in the Act, the application was referred to the Australian Community Pharmacy Authority.  The role of the Authority is to recommend to the Secretary of the Department of Health whether an application to supply pharmaceutical benefits should, or should not, be approved.

  3. On 3 September 2021, the Authority recommended to the Secretary that the Applicant’s application not be approved.[2] The delegate of the Secretary refused the application on 18 October 2021.[3]

    [2] Exhibit R1 at 170.

    [3] Exhibit R1 at 447.

  4. The Applicant has applied to this Tribunal to review the Authority’s decision. For the reasons which follow, the decision under review will be affirmed.

    THE LEGISLATIVE SCHEME

  5. Applications for approval to supply pharmaceutical benefits are determined by the Secretary of the Department of Health under section 90 of the National Health Act 1953. Subject to a few limited exceptions, an application must be referred to the Australian Community Pharmacy Authority for a recommendation. Subsection 90(3B) states:

    (3B) An approval may be granted under this section in respect of an application that has been referred to the Authority under…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hala Phcy Pty Ltd and Australian Community Pharmacy Authorit... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] AATA 2155
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Hala Phcy Pty Ltd sought judicial review of a decision by the Australian Community Pharmacy Authority (ACPA) concerning an application for approval to supply pharmaceutical benefits. The dispute centred on whether a particular store, referred to as the Bibina store, qualified as a "supermarket" for the purposes of the relevant Pharmacy Authority Rules.

The primary legal issue before the court was the construction of the definition of "supermarket" as contained within the Pharmacy Authority Rules. Specifically, the court was required to determine the meaning of "range" of foods, beverages, groceries, and other domestic goods in the context of these Rules, and whether the Bibina store met this definition.

Deputy President J W Constance reasoned that the absence of a significant number of categories of goods, rather than the mere omission of specific items like clothes pegs, was determinative of whether a store fell outside the definition of a supermarket. The court considered the context and purpose of the Rules in reaching its conclusion. The decision under review, made by the ACPA on 3 September 2021, was affirmed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Hala Pharmacy Pty Ltd applied to the Australian Community Pharmacy Authority (the Authority) for approval to supply pharmaceutical benefits under the Pharmacy Act 2008. The Authority’s decision hinged on whether there was a supermarket with a gross leasable area of 1,000 square metres or more within a prescribed distance of the proposed pharmacy premises. The application was made for a proposed pharmacy at 25 Main Street, Smalltown. This location was approximately 400 metres from a store operated by Bibina Group Pty Ltd, which sold a range of foods, beverages, groceries and other domestic goods, but not a significant number of categories of such goods.

Bibina Group’s store, located at 12 High Street, Smalltown, was identified as potentially meeting the criteria of a supermarket under the Pharmacy Authority Rules. The Rules define a supermarket as an establishment that sells a range of foods, beverages, groceries and other domestic goods. The Authority needed to determine whether this store qualified as a supermarket based on the number and variety of goods it sold. Hala Pharmacy argued that the Bibina store did not qualify because it did not sell a significant range of goods, including items such as clothing pegs and other household essentials that are typically found in a supermarket.

The Authority concluded that the Bibina store did not qualify as a supermarket under the Rules, primarily because it did not sell a significant number of categories of goods. This conclusion was based on the context and purpose of the Rules, which aim to ensure that pharmacies do not compete directly with supermarkets in their proximity. The Authority’s decision was made on 3 September 2021, and Hala Pharmacy subsequently sought to review this decision. The review was to affirm the Authority's finding that the Bibina store did not meet the supermarket criteria as per the Rules.

The matter before the court concerns an application by Hala Phcy Pty Ltd for approval to supply pharmaceutical benefits, which was opposed by the Australian Community Pharmacy Authority (Authority). The dispute centred around whether there was a supermarket with a gross leasable area of 1,000 square metres within the prescribed distance of the proposed premises, as required by the Pharmacy Authority Rules. The applicant, Hala Phcy Pty Ltd, sought to establish a pharmacy in a particular location, and their application was denied by the Authority on the basis that the definition of 'supermarket' in the Rules was not satisfied by a nearby store, Bibina.

Prior to this court, Hala Phcy Pty Ltd had applied for internal review of the Authority's decision. Following the internal review, Hala Phcy Pty Ltd sought judicial review of the Authority's decision in the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia. In this court, Hala Phcy Pty Ltd argued that the Authority's interpretation of the definition of 'supermarket' was incorrect, contending that the absence of certain goods, such as clothes pegs, did not exclude the Bibina store from the definition. The Authority maintained its position, asserting that the absence of a significant number of categories of goods was determinative.

Key procedural steps in this matter included the filing of an application for judicial review, submissions by both parties on the interpretation of the Pharmacy Authority Rules, and the court's consideration of the Authority's decision-making process and its adherence to the legislative framework. The court was tasked with determining whether the Authority's decision was legally sound and whether it had properly applied the relevant rules and statutory provisions in reaching its conclusion.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The fact that a store may not sell particular goods (for example clothes pegs) does not mean that it is excluded from the definition of supermarket. In this matter it is the absence of a significant number of categories of goods which excludes the Bibina store from the definition.CONCLUSION The decision under review, being the decision of the Australian Community Pharmacy Authority made 3 September 2021, will be affirmed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In affirming the decision of the Australian Community Pharmacy Authority, the court examined the criteria for determining whether a supermarket exists within the prescribed distance of the proposed premises for a pharmacy, as outlined in the Pharmacy Authority Rules. The primary issue in this case revolved around whether there is a supermarket with a gross leasable area of 1,000 square metres within the specified distance of the proposed pharmacy premises. The court carefully considered the definition of "supermarket" provided in the Pharmacy Authority Rules, which is crucial for determining the eligibility of the proposed pharmacy for approval.

The court commenced by interpreting the definition of "supermarket" as outlined in the Pharmacy Authority Rules. The definition specifies that a supermarket is a store that offers a "range" of foods, beverages, groceries, and other domestic goods. The court emphasised that the key to understanding this definition lies in the word "range," which must be assessed in the context and purpose of the Rules. This contextual approach aligns with established principles of statutory interpretation, which require that the words of the legislation be read in light of the overall purpose and context of the statute.

In determining what constitutes a "range" of goods, the court looked at how supermarkets typically operate, offering a wide variety of products under one roof. The court noted that the absence of specific categories of goods, such as particular household items, does not necessarily exclude a store from being classified as a supermarket. Instead, it is the overall breadth of the product selection that is critical. The court found that the Bibina store did not offer a sufficiently diverse range of goods to meet the definition of a supermarket under the Rules.

Applying the context and purpose of the Pharmacy Authority Rules, the court held that the Rules aim to prevent pharmacies from being situated too close to supermarkets, which could potentially compete for the sale of pharmaceutical benefits. This contextual application of the Rules helps ensure that pharmacies are located in areas where they can operate without undue competition from large retail stores. The court considered that the absence of a significant number of categories of goods, rather than the lack of specific items, is what excludes the Bibina store from being classified as a supermarket.

The court also addressed whether the absence of a significant number of categories of goods excludes a store from the definition of a supermarket. The court concluded that while the Bibina store sells a variety of goods, it does not offer a comprehensive enough range to be considered a supermarket. The court's reasoning aligns with the legislative intent to prevent pharmacies from being situated in areas with significant competition from large retail stores. This interpretation ensures that the Rules are applied in a manner that achieves their intended purpose.

In reaching its decision, the court distinguished between the absence of specific goods and the absence of a significant number of categories of goods. The absence of certain items, such as clothes pegs, does not exclude a store from being a supermarket. However, the overall breadth of the product range is critical, and the Bibina store's lack of a diverse enough selection led the court to affirm the decision of the Australian Community Pharmacy Authority. This nuanced approach ensures that the Rules are applied fairly and in line with their legislative purpose.